The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Further, the learned counsel appearing for the applicants would submit that during the last occasion also, the Hon’ble retired Judge of this court was appointed as an Election Officer and therefore, this time also another retired Judge of High Court may be appointed as an Election Officer. In this context, merely because, on earlier occasion, this Court appointed another retired Judge of High Court to conduct the election, as a matter of right, the applicants cannot claim to appoint another Election Officer. As the election process is also started, voter’s list has also been finalised and the date of election is also fixed, it is not appropriate to appoint any other Election Officer and the applicants are not entitled to any relief through these applications and therefore, these applications have no merits and deserve to be dismissed.
10. Accordingly, the Original Application No.1184 of 2025 and the Application No.6333 of 2025 are dismissed. 10-02-2026 Page12 of 13 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis OA No. 1184 of 2025 and A. No.6333 of 2025
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 10-02-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and A No. 6333 OF 2025
in CS NO. 304 OF 2025,
1. Mr. G. Srinivasan AND 4 OTHERS
Membership No.3400,S/O.Gnanaprakasam
No.16/49, Valluvan Salai,
Arumbakkam, Ch-600106
2. I.John Max
Membership No.2857
S/o.Isthappan,
No.108/11, 2nd Floor,
Mahadev Nivas, AVM Avenue, 5th Street,
Virugambakkam, Chennai-600092
3. Ranjith Kumar.P
Membership No.4254
S/o.Parijatham,
No.104-D, First Floor,
Rajavelan Homes , Neru Street,
Near Royal Hospital
Alwarthirunagar, Chennai-600087
4. A.K.Michael
Membership No.2372
__________
Page1 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
S/. Aindhukayan
No.G 78, Subiksham Flats
12th street, Anna Nagar East
Chennai-600102
5. S.D.Youvakandha Rao
Membership No.3445,
S/o.Devapriyam,
No.37/19, TVK Ngar, 2nd Street, Pulianthope,
Chennai-600012
..Applicant(s) common
in both applications.
Vs
1. Tamil Film Producers Council and another
Rep by its Secretary
South Indian Film Chambers Compound,
No.606, Anna Salai, Chennai-600006
2. Justice.Mr.S.Rajeshwaran(Retd.)
Election Officer,
Tamil Film Producers Council
South Indian Film Chambers Compound,
No.606, Anna Salai , Ch-6
3. Mrs. T.Rajeswari Vendan
Proprietrix, M/s.Thaaiman Thiraiyagam,
Residing at No.E 12/3, Taisha Apartments,
Natesan Nagar, Virugambakkam,
Chennai-600092
__________
Page2 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
(3rd Respondent impleaded as per order dated
03.02.2026 in A.No.503/2026)
..Respondent(s) common
in both applications.
PRAYER in OA No. 1184 of 2025: This Original Application has been filed
under Order XIV Rule 8 of Original Side Rules read with Order XXXIV Rule 1
and 2 of Code of Civil Procedure praying to grant an Interim Injunction
restraining the Respondents Association from in any manner whatsoever to
conduct the election for the year 2026 to 2029 slated to be held on 22/02/2026
or any other subsequent dates, pending disposal of the above suit.
PRAYER in A No. 6333 of 2025: This application has been filed Order XIV
Rule 8 of Original Side Rules read with Section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure
praying to appoint a Retired High Court Judge as Election Officer to conduct
the election for the office bearers and Executive Committee Members of the 1st
Respondent Association for the year 2026 to 2029 afresh after scrutinizing and
declare the final voters list in accordance with the bye-law of the 1st
Respondent Association.
For Applicant(s):
T.Thiageswaran for M/S.Waraon And Sai Rams
For Respondent(s):
Mr Krishna Ravindran [for R1 and R2]
Ms. Dakshayani Reddy, Senior Counsel
__________
Page3 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
for Mr. T.R. Prabhakarn [for R3]
COMMON ORDER
The Original Application in O.A. No.1184 of 2025 has been filed to grant
an Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents Association from in any
manner whatsoever to conduct the election for the year 2026 to 2029 slated to
be held on 22/02/2026 or any other subsequent dates, pending disposal of the
above suit.
The application in A. No.6333 of 2025 has been filed to appoint a Retired
High Court Judge as Election Officer to conduct the election for the office
bearers and Executive Committee Members of the 1st Respondent Association
for the year 2026 to 2029 afresh after scrutinizing and declare the final voters
list in accordance with the bye-law of the 1st Respondent Association.
2. According to the applicants, they are the Plaintiffs in the main Suit,
which is filed for the reliefs of declaration declaring that the Resolution passed
by the General Body dated 09.11.2025 of the 1st defendant Association by fixing
the election and appointing the 2nd defendant as the Election Officer and the
Election Notice dated 04.12.2025 are null and void and non-est in the eye of
law, for a permanent injunction restraining the 1st defendant from in any manner
whatsoever conducting the election for the Office bearers and executive
Committee Members of the 1st Defendant Association for the year 2026 to 2029
as contemplated in the Election notice dated 4.12.2025 slated to be held on
__________
Page4 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
22.02.2026 or any other date and to appoint an independent Retired Judge of the
High Court as Election Officer to conduct the election of the Office Bearers and
the Executive Committee Members of the 1st Def association for the year 2026
to 2029 afresh after scrutinizing and declare the final Voters List as per the rules
and regulations of the Bye-Law of the 1st defendant Association and for cost of
the Suit. The applicants are the members of the 1 st respondent Association. The
1st respondent Association is administered by an Executive Committee duly
elected once in three years and the Executive Committee consists of one
President, two Vice Presidents, two Secretaries, one Joint Secretary, one
Treasurer and 26 Executive Committee members.
The members of the
Executive Committee shall hold their respective office for three years and the
entire Executive Committee shall retire at the General Body Meeting, wherein
election of the Office Bearers and Executive Committee Members are held and
shall continue till the new Officer Bearers / Committee Members is duly
elected.
The election for the Officer Bearers and Executive Committee
Members of the Association shall be conducted and announced at the General
Body once in three years.
2.1. As per Clause 16 of the by-law, the Secretaries shall give notice to
the members of the Council after fixing up the date of the General Body
Meeting in the Executive Committee Meeting for the election of the Office
Bearers and Executive Committee Members. The 1st respondent Association
__________
Page5 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
conducted its Annual General Body meeting on 09.11.2025 whereunder it was
decided to conduct the election of the Office bearers and its Executive
Committee members for the 1st respondent Association for the years 2026-2029.
As per Clause 17 of the by-law, the Executive Committee when assembled to
deliberate the fixation of General Body Meeting date, wherein the election of
Office Bearers and Executive Committee members are held, after fixing the date
of General Body, shall appoint a Senior Producer member from the Council as
an Election Officer to conduct the elections. As per the norms and regulations
prescribed by the Executive Committee such Officer should not be a candidate
for any office.
2.2. However, contrary to the by-law of the Association, the General
Body has appointed the Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Rajeshwaran, Former Judge of
High Court, Madras as an Election Officer, which is arbitrary and non-est in the
eye of law. The Election Officer, had issued a notice containing the date and
details of election on 04.12.2025. The Election Notice contains the date for
issuance of nomination on 08.12.2025 to 15.12.2025 and the submission of the
filled nomination from 11.12.2025 to 20.12.2025.
The Election notice
containing the table of dates has not been sent to all the members.
The
approach of the 1st respondent Association and the Election Officer indicate that
to conclude the election without any contest from the table of dates announced
by the Election Officer stating that the final list of candidates will be released on
30.12.2025 and the election will be convened on 22.02.2026. The Election
__________
Page6 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
Notice issued on 04.12.2025 without giving sufficient time to reach the
members and the date of issuance of nomination is fixed on 08.12.2025 within
four days. The period for the present Office Bearers will come to an end on
30.04.2026. While so, in a hurried manner, the Election schedule has been
announced.
2.3. Therefore, the Election announced by the 1 st respondent Association
much before the completion of period of the present Office bearers for the year
2023-2026. In the earlier occasion, various commotions happened during the
election and therefore, it is absolutely necessary to appoint an independent
retired High Court Judge as an Election Officer to conduct the election of the
Office Bearers and the Executive Committee Members of the 1 st respondent
Association in a free and fair manner as per the by-laws of the Association after
scrutinizing the Voters’ list and finalise the same in accordance with rules and
regulations of the by-laws of the Association. Therefore, the Plaintiff filed the
Suit and now filed these applications to appoint a retired High Court Judge as an
Election Officer to conduct the election and to grant interim injunction
restraining the respondents from conducting the election for the year 2026 to
2029 slated to be held on 22/02/2026.
3. The respondents filed a common counter denying the averments made
in the affidavit of the applications. The present Office Bearers and Executive
Committee members were elected in the election held on 02.05.2023 and their
__________
Page7 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
term is valid till 01.05.2026. While so, the Annual General Body Meeting was
held on 09.11.2025 at Fayas Mahalin, where unanimous resolution was passed
to conduct elections for the office bearers and the Executive Committee
members in the 1st respondent Association for the years 2026 – 2029 and the
same was done in compliance with Clause 16 of the By-laws. There is no
violation as alleged in the Plaint. In the said Annual General Body Meeting
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Rajeshwaran, a retired Judge of High Court was
nominated as an Election Officer and the applicants, who were also present in
the said Annual General Body Meeting, did not raise any objections regarding
the nomination of the said Election Officer. In fact, the same Election Officer
had been acted as an Election Officer for the previous election conducted in the
year 2017. Therefore, the General Body unanimously appointed the said retired
High Court judge as an Election Officer.
3.1. The Election Officer had called for a meeting with the members of
the Association on 15.11.2025 and all the members were duly informed about
the proposed meeting and all the members had duly participated in the meeting,
wherein the date of election was fixed on 22.02.2026, after due consultation
with the members, who were present in the said meeting. It was further decided
that a draft voter list would be prepared and the same would be put in notice
board from 17.11.2025 to 27.11.2025 for raising any objections. The applicants
were present in the said meeting, where they had not raised any objection. The
__________
Page8 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
Election Officer had once again called for meeting with the Members of the
Association on 28.11.2025, where final draft of the voters list was produced and
accepted by the members and date for election was decided to be held on
22.02.2026 and accepted by all the members and the date of election was fixed
on 22.02.2026. On 04.12.2025, the Schedule for the said election was released.
The applicants, who are very well aware of the conduct of the above said
election and who have participated in the Annual General Body meeting and
other meetings conducted by the Election Officer, neither raised any objection
nor sent any communication / representation regarding their objections to the
Association or the Election Officer till date.
3.2. The applicants 1, 2, 3 and 5 filed their nominations for the post of
Executive Committee members before the Election Officer and their
nominations have been accepted and published in the notice board in the list of
accepted candidates. All the above four applicants have participated in all the
meetings and had never raise any objection. The Election Officer has already
started the election process and therefore the Suit has been filed with an ulterior
ill-motive. The applicants have failed to take into consideration the prayer
sought by them to appoint a retired High Court Judge, is by violating the Clause
17 of by-law which says that the Election Officer shall be a Senior Producer
member from the council, but they have failed to take into consideration and
prayed to appoint a retired High Court judge as an Election Officer. Therefore,
__________
Page9 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
the prayer sought for by the applicants have no merits and deserves to be
dismissed.
4. Heard both sides and perused the entire materials available on record.
5. In this case, it is an admitted fact that the Annual General Body
Meeting was convened on 09.11.2025 and in the said meeting, the Election
Officer was appointed unanimously.
Thereafter, the election process was
commenced and the Election Officer finalised the voters list and announced the
date of election. These applicants have also participated in the said Annual
General Body Meeting and all other meetings and they have not submitted any
objections either orally or in writing. Even after the appointment of the Election
Officer, the applicants have not sent any communication either to the 1 st
respondent Association or to the Election Officer in respect of violations and
without raising any objections and without any communication to the
defendants, the Plaintiffs straight away filed the Suit.
6. It is pertinent to note that even the applicants 1, 2, 3 and 5 have
applied for the post of Executive Committee members and they have
participated in the election process, once they participate in the election process,
they cannot object the same later. It is also an admitted fact that now the
General Body nominated the Hon’ble retired Judge of High Court as an Election
__________
Page10 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
Officer. There is no any personal allegation as against the Election Officer and
the said Officer on earlier occasion also conducted the election. Therefore, once
the applicants filed nominations accepting the appointment of Election Officer,
later they cannot deny the same, without any valid grounds. There are no
grounds urged by the applicants to allow these applications.
7. As far as the prayer in respect of interim injunction is concerned, the
applicants have to prove the prima facie case, the balance of convenience and
irreparable loss. There is no prima facie case made out and the applicants have
participated in the General Body Meeting and it is also admitted by the
applicants. But there is no any objection raised by them for the appointment of
Election Officer. After admitting the appointment of Election Officer, they
filed their nominations and voters list also finalised and the election date was
also fixed. At this stage, the applicants cannot claim any injunction against the
election process. If any violations, then they have to prove the same through
trial. Therefore, there is no prima facie case made out and the applicants are not
entitled to the relief of interim injunction.
8. As far as the appointment of the Election Officer is concerned, the
prayer sought for in the application is to appoint a retired Judge of High Court.
Already the General Body also nominated the Hon’ble retired Judge of this
Court as an Election Officer and there is no any allegation as against the
__________
Page11 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
Election Officer.
Without sending any representation either to the 1 st
respondent or the 2nd respondent in respect of violations, the contention of the
applicants cannot be accepted and even if any violations, then they can be
challenged in the manner know to law. The Suit is in respect of the resolutions
made in the General Body Meeting. Therefore, the contention of the applicants
for the appointment of Election Officer is unnecessary one.
9. Further, the learned counsel appearing for the applicants would submit
that during the last occasion also, the Hon’ble retired Judge of this court was
appointed as an Election Officer and therefore, this time also another retired
Judge of High Court may be appointed as an Election Officer. In this context,
merely because, on earlier occasion, this Court appointed another retired Judge
of High Court to conduct the election, as a matter of right, the applicants cannot
claim to appoint another Election Officer. As the election process is also
started, voter’s list has also been finalised and the date of election is also fixed,
it is not appropriate to appoint any other Election Officer and the applicants are
not entitled to any relief through these applications and therefore, these
applications have no merits and deserve to be dismissed.
10. Accordingly, the Original Application No.1184 of 2025 and the
Application No.6333 of 2025 are dismissed.
10-02-2026
MJS
__________
Page12 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OA No. 1184 of 2025 and
A. No.6333 of 2025
P.DHANABAL J.
MJS
OA No. 1184 of 2025
and A No. 6333 OF 2025
in CS NO. 304 OF 2025
10-02-2026
__________
Page13 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review