Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/25
GAHC010191412024
2026:GAU-AS:441
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.A./313/2024
MOKSEDUL HOQUE
S/O. LATE HAMIDUR RAHMAN, R/O. VILL- CHAGOLIA PART 2, P/S.
GOLAKGANJ, DIST.- DHUBRI, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR
REP. BY THE PP, ASSAM.
2:S.I. JITUMONI BAISHYA
P/S. CHAGOLIYA
DIST.- DHUBRI
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. SURAJIT DAS,
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. R.J. Baruah, Addl.PP, ASSAM,
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 18.11.2025
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 09.01.2026
Page No.# 2/25
Whether the pronouncement is of the : No.
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, J)
Heard Mr. Surajit Das, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. R J
Baruah, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor for the State of Assam.
2.
This is an appeal under Section 415 of the BNSS, 2023 against the
impugned judgment and order dated 30.07.2024 passed by the learned Special
Judge, (Addl.) Dhubri in Special (NDPS) Case No. 179 of 2023 arising out of
Golokganj P.S Case No. 193 of 2023 convicting the accused/appellant U/S 22(C)
of NDPS Act, 1985 and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10
(ten) years along with a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh) only, and in
default of payment of fine, another rigorous imprisonment for another 1 (one)
year.
3.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that the informant S.I Jitumani Baishya
Page No.# 3/25
lodged an FIR with the O/C of Golakganj P.S on 12.04.2023 stating that I/c of
Chagolia O.P had received information from reliable source that a huge quantity
of contraband was being kept stored at the house of Moksedul Hoque (A-1) of
Chagolia Part-2, backside of Pundibari L.P School and was being sold in the
locality. Accordingly, GDE No. 194 dated 11.04.2023 was entered and O/C of
Golakganj P.S along with other senior officers, were informed, and he was
ordered to take necessary action. Written authorization was issued to him by
DSP(HQ) as empowered by Govt. of Assam vide Notification No. Ex. 145/85/301
dated 15.05.1995 under Section 41(2) of NDPS Act. Thereafter, he along with
other staff rushed to the spot and arrived at the house of A-1 and met the
independent witnesses namely Sankar Sarkar, Patano Adhikary, Manobindu
Sarkar and Sofidul Miah. Thereafter, the police team thoroughly searched the
house of A-1 and recovered 18 numbers of Eskuf cough syrup of 100 ML each,
suspected to have codeine phosphate from the drain kept concealed near the
stored bamboo firewood from his possession and seized the same in presence of
witnesses following the formalities. The accused person was apprehended and
then, the police team returned to the police station along with the accused and
the seized articles. Accordingly, the instant FIR was lodged.
4.
On completion of investigation, charge-sheet bearing CS No. 234/2023
Page No.# 4/25
dated 25.06.2023 was submitted against A-1 under Section 21(c) of NDPS Act.
5.
Charge under Section 22(c) of NDPS Act was framed against the accused
who pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. In course of trial, prosecution
side examined 6 (six) PWs and 2 (two) CWs. Further, learned counsel on behalf
of the accused filed a petition bearing No. 670 dated 25.06.2024 stating that
examination of FSL Expert is not vital and contents of the same were accepted
by him. Moreover, PW- Nurul Islam and Rofiqul Alom were struck off vide order
dated 03.02.2024 and 30.03.2024, respectively.
6.
PW-1 S.I Jitumani Baishya in his evidence has stated that the I/C Chagolia
Out Post under Golakganj P.S received secret information that one person
namely Moksedul Hoque of village Chagolia Part-II had kept concealed
suspected contrabands in his house and he was selling those drugs to the
nearby area. Accordingly, GDE No. 194 dated 11.04.2023 was made. He
informed his superior authorities over phone regarding the matter. He was
issued authorization letter for conducting search and seizure by DSP(HQ).
Thereafter, he along with other police personnel went to the residence of the
accused and found him near Pundibari L.P School located near his house. He
informed the VDP Secretary along with his team to witness in their search and
seizure operation. Witnesses reached the place of occurrence and along with
Page No.# 5/25
them, police team went to the residence of accused. They got their body
searched by the witnesses before entering into the premises of residence of
accused. They recovered 18 nos. of Eskuf cough syrup from the premises of
accused in presence of independent witnesses. He sealed and packed those
cartons and then, he along with the accused and the suspected contrabands,
returned back to Chagolia Out Post. In the Police Out Post, he recorded the
statement of accused and the witnesses and handed over the accused and the
seized contrabands to the O/C of Golakganj P.S. The suspected contrabands
were deposited to Malkhana of Golakganj P.S and he duly received the Malkhana
receipt against the deposit of suspected contrabands. Then, he lodged the
instant FIR.
7.
During cross-examination, the I.O stated that the MCD which he submitted
is neither paginated nor certified. He also admitted that no search warrant was
obtained from the Magistrate. In the FIR lodged by him or in the GDE made by
him, nothing has been mentioned regarding the urgency of the search. He
further admitted that the content of the GDE were not communicated to his
superior authority in writing, but vide Exbt. P-4/PW-1 he communicated to his
superior authority regarding the compliance of Section 42 of the NDPS Act. He
further admitted that there is no memo number mentioned in the authorization
Page No.# 6/25
letter which he received from DSP(HQ) through special messenger UBC/368 one
D. Sangma. The dak book regarding the receipt of the authorization letter was
not seized by him and neither he sent the serial No. of the dak book against
which he received the authorization letter. PW-1 further stated during crossexamination that no other neighbors were associated with the search and
seizure operation except for the VDP people. He went on to state that he
returned to Chagolia Out Post at 03:30 AM and handed over the contraband to
the O/C of Golakganj P.S on the same day at about 12:10 PM and during that
time, the seized contraband was in their office Malkhana at Chagolia Out Post
and no register is maintained at the said Out Post regarding deposition of the
articles in the Malkhana. He also admitted that he did not mention anything
about the compliance with the provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS Act in his
FIR or GDE or in his statement recorded under 161 Cr.P.C. The I/O also stated
that he did not seize any ownership document nor did he make any
investigation from the concerned Government Officials regarding the ownership
of the residence from where the suspected contraband were recovered and that
he never visited the house of the accused before the incident. PW-1 denied the
other suggestions put to him by the defence including the proposition that the
authorization letter was procured subsequently from the concerned authority,
and that he did not comply with the provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS Act.
Page No.# 7/25
8.
PW-2 Shankar Sarkar in his evidence has stated that he is a member of
VDP of Chagolia Part-II. The informant called him to the police station to
accompany them as they were going to apprehend an accused person. 18
numbers of cough syrups were recovered from the residence of the accused by
the police. He put his signature in the seizure-list.
9.
In cross-examination, PW-2 has admitted that he does not know the
number and names of the inhabitants of the residence from where the
suspected contrabands were recovered. He did not know the brand name of the
cough syrup. His body was not searched by any of the independent witnesses
before entering into the residential premises of accused person. A-1 was not
found near the school which was located near his residence. He did not read the
contents of the seizure-list but, police read over the contents of the same. He
only put his signature on a paper in which police told him that 18 numbers of
cough syrup were seized. The seizure-list was handwritten by the police and
nothing was printed on the seizure-list. PW-2 has denied the other suggestions
put to him by the defence.
10. PW-3 Patano Adhikary in his evidence has stated that the police took him
to the residence of the accused person. In his presence, the police recovered 18
numbers of cough syrup from below the bed of the accused from his residence.
Page No.# 8/25
He put his signature in the seizure-list.
11. In cross-examination, PW-3 has stated that he knows the accused person
by face, but he does not know his name and his residential address. He is a
member of VDP of village Chagolia Part- II. He also knows other VDP members,
i.e. seizure witnesses. Police did not call any nearby person to witness the
search and seizure operation. He works under Superintendent of (Addl.) Police
as VDP member. He does not know the contents of the seizure-list and police
also did not read over the contents of the seizure-list to him. PW-3 has denied
the other suggestions put to him by the defence.
12. PW-4 Sofidul Miah has stated in his evidence that one day, the police took
him to the residence of the accused along with them. He saw the police recover
about 18 bottles of cough syrup from the residence of the accused and he put
his signature on the seizure-list.
13. In cross-examination, PW-4 has stated that at the relevant time, only the
accused and his wife were present. He is the VDP Secretary of Chagolia Part-II
village. Other seizure witnesses are the members of the VDP. Nobody searched
their bodies before entering into the residence of accused. Some police
personnel entered into the residence of the accused and others remained
Page No.# 9/25
outside of the said house. They (VDP members) did not search the bodies of the
police personnel, who entered into the residence of the accused person. He did
not see the neighboring people called by the police. The police did not read over
the contents of the seizure-list. PW-4 has denied the other suggestions put to
him by the defence.
14.
PW-5 S.I. Nirmal Chanda has stated in his (Addl.) evidence that on the
date of occurrence, O/C of Golakganj P.S. entrusted the instant case for
investigation to him. He recorded the statement of the informant, independent
witnesses and accused person. He prepared a sketch map, produced the
inventory before the Hon'ble Magistrate and also took steps for sending the
samples of suspected contraband to FSL through S.P. Office, Dhubri.
15. In cross-examination, PW-5 has admitted that in the FIR as well as in the
statement of the informant recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., there is no
mention about the communication to the superior authority about the contents
of GDE. The authority letter was not issued to the informant on 12.04.23. He
started the investigation at 10.10 a.m on 12.04.2023. He was informed over
phone to initiate the investigation by the O/C, Golakganj P.S. He did not seize
the seal used in the instant case. After preparing the inventory, the suspected
contraband was in his custody from 13.04.23 till 18.04.23 at Chotogoma Out
Page No.# 10/25
Post. He did not record the statement of DSP(HQ), O/C of Golakganj P.S.,
Sheristadar of Golakganj P.S. and one D. Sangma. He did not find any role of D.
Sangma. PW-5 has denied the other suggestions put to him by the defence.
16. PW-6 SI(P) Mehbub Ali has stated in his evidence that he submitted the
charge-sheet against the accused Moksedul Hoque under Section 21(c) of NDPS
Act.
17. In cross-examination, PW-6 has admitted that there is no pagination and
certification in the case diary. PW-6 has denied the other suggestions put to him
by the defence.
18. CW-1 UBC/293 Mishak Sangma in his evidence has stated that he went to
serve the summons to witness Nurul Islam in his address, however, he failed to
find any person with that name in the village, after making inquiry from the VDP
secretary and BLO. Therefore, the summons could not be served to the said
witness.
19. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that this is a
case of total non-compliance of Section 42(2) of the NDPS Act.
20.
Referring to the aforesaid provision, it is submitted that the first part
Page No.# 11/25
thereof pertains to recording the information in writing and the second part
concerns recording of grounds of belief necessitating the search operation
between sunset and before sunrise. The learned counsel has laid much stress
on the requirement of recording the grounds of belief, in the event the search is
carried out after sunset and before sunrise and also the necessity of
communicating the same to the superior officer. In this regard, the learned
counsel has referred to the decision of the Apex Court in Karnail Singh vs.
State of Haryana, (2009) 8 SCC 539 , wherein it had been held that delayed
compliance of the provisions of Section 42(2) of the NDPS Act with satisfactory
explanation may be acceptable, but total non-compliance with the requirement
of Sub-Sections 1 & 2 of Section 42 of the NDPS Act is impermissible. The
learned counsel has also cited the decision of the Apex Court in State of
Rajasthan vs. Jagaraj Singh, (2016) 11 SCC 687.
21. It is further submitted that in the present case, the seizure was made at
around 02:05 AM on 12.04.2023 and the contraband was handed over to the
O/C only at 12:10 PM and during this long period the contraband was with the
informant, whereafter the same was produced before the Magistrate on
18.04.2023 after a delay of 6 (six) days for which there is no sufficient
explanation.
Page No.# 12/25
22. The learned counsel has referred to the decision of the Supreme Court in
Kailash vs. State of Maharashtra, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1977 , wherein it
has been held as follows:“ In the light of the discussion above, in our view, mere non-
production of the seized contraband during trial may not be fatal if
there is reliable evidence in respect of its seizure, drawing of
samples therefrom, and FSL report relating to the sample drawn
from the seized material. However, to ensure that no adverse
inference is drawn against the prosecution for non-production of the
seized contraband, documents prepared in terms of the provisions
of Section 52-A, inter alia, evidencing preparation of inventory of
seized contraband and drawing of samples therefrom, would have
to be brought on record. Likewise, evidence should be there that
the sample drawn from the inventory was sent to FSL in a sealed
container/envelop, as per guidelines, and that the seal was found
intact at the end of FSL. This is to obviate any doubt regarding
sample being tampered in transit. Similarly, FSL’s report along with
the sample tested by it is to be placed on record so that there
remains no doubt regarding the sample tested.”
Page No.# 13/25
23. It is submitted that in the present case, there is no evidence as to how the
inventory was prepared and samples were drawn or whether the samples were
sent to the FSL in the sealed container and that in the FSL the seal was found
intact. Not only was the seized contraband not exhibited during the trial, even
the FSL report along with the tested sample was never brought on record and
therefore it is not known if the sample that was tested was actually the same as
that which was drawn from the seized contraband.
24.
Further, with regard to the non-examination of the Scientific Officer and
the failure to bring on record the FSL report, learned counsel has referred to the
decision of the Delhi High Court in Crl. A. No. 331/2017, wherein it has been
held as follows:“It is true that in view of Section 293 of the Criminal Procedure
Code, the report in question need not have been proved by
summoning the author thereof, but that does not mean, that
during trial nobody had to tender the same in evidence and have
the same exhibited by deposing that either he himself went to
the FSL Laboratory and collected the report in question or
deposing that during investigation he obtained the report in
question and that the same pertains to the investigation
Page No.# 14/25
conducted in the case which was being tried. It must be
deposed that the report in question pertains to the case at
hand.”
25. It is also submitted that in view of the admission of the I/O that he had
never previously visited the house of the accused nor seized any ownership
documents, and the fact that the accused was not found inside the house at the
time of search, prosecution could not prove that the house from where the
contraband was allegedly seized belonged to the accused, and therefore, no
liability can be fastened on the accused/appellant. It is lastly submitted that
Section 52(A) of NDPS Act requires that the inventory, the samples drawn, list of
samples and the photographs are to be certified by the Magistrates and will be
considered as primary evidence. But here in this case not only the samples
drawn were not exhibited, the photograph of the seized substance was not
certified and exhibited.
26. In view of the multiple infirmities and lapses in the investigation pointed
out, the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside, submits learned counsel
for the appellant.
27.
Mr. R J Baruah, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor submitted that upon
Page No.# 15/25
perusal of the evidence of the seizure witnesses i.e. PW Nos. 2, 3 & 4, the
recovery of the contraband has been duly proved inasmuch as, PW-2 stated that
the contents of the seizure list were read over to him before he signed the
same, and therefore, the same was within the knowledge of PW-2. Although PW
Nos. 3 & 4 did not know about the contents of the seizure list, they
subsequently deposed to having seen the police recover the contraband from
the house of the accused. It is further submitted that on many occasions
independent witnesses and neighbors are reluctant to participate in such search
and seizures operations for various reasons, and there is no hard and fast rule
that the evidence of VDPs is to be discarded unless supported by other
independent witnesses, especially in view of absence of any evidence regarding
any enmity between the VDP personnel and the accused.
28.
Learned Addl. Public Prosecutor further submitted that there was
substantial compliance with the provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS inasmuch
as, in view of PW-4/Exbt. P-4/PW-1 by which, the PW-1 communicated in
writing to superior authority regarding compliance of Section 42 of the NDPS Act
and upon perusal of the GDE, it appears that all the relevant details about the
secret information received by the PW-1 was informed over phone to various
authorities including S.P to brief him. Upon such instructions, an authorization
Page No.# 16/25
letter was issued by Dy. S.P (HQ), Dhubri. Further, prosecution by exhibiting the
Malkhana receipt as exhibit Exbt-5/PW-1 has also proved the chain of custody.
29.
It is finally submitted that in view of the aforesaid evidence, the
prosecution proved the recovery of the contraband form the possession of the
accused/appellant and thereby, the presumption under Section 54 of the NDPS
Act was rightly raised by the learned Trial Court, which the accused appellant
failed to rebut and therefore, there is no infirmity in the impugned judgment or
sentence.
30. I have given my anxious consideration to the rival submissions as well as
to the material on record. Section 42 of the NDPS Act provides as follows:“Section 42. Power of entry, search, seizure and arrest
without warrant or authorisation.—
(1) Any such officer (being an officer superior in rank to a peon,
sepoy or constable) of the departments of central excise, narcotics,
customs, revenue intelligence or any other department of the
Central Government including paramilitary forces or armed forces as
is empowered in this behalf by general or special order by the
Central Government, or any such officer (being an officer superior in
Page No.# 17/25
rank to a peon, sepoy or constable) of the revenue, drugs control,
excise, police or any other department of a State Government as is
empowered in this behalf by general or special order of the State
Government, if he has reason to believe from personal knowledge
or information given by any person and taken down in writing that
any narcotic drug, psychotropic substance, or controlled substance
in respect of which an offence punishable under this Act has been
committed, or any document or other article which may furnish
evidence of the commission of such offence, or any illegally
acquired property or any document or other article which may
furnish evidence of holding any illegally acquired property which is
liable for seizure or freezing or forfeiture under Chapter V-A of this
Act is kept or concealed in any building, conveyance or enclosed
place,
may,
between
sunrise
and
sunset—
(a) enter into and search any such building, conveyance or place;
(b) in case of resistance, break open any door and remove any
obstacle
to
such
entry;
(c) seize such drug or substance and all materials used in the
manufacture thereof and any other article and any animal or
conveyance which he has reason to believe to be liable to
Page No.# 18/25
confiscation under this Act and any document or other article which
he has reason to believe may furnish evidence of the commission of
any offence punishable under this Act or furnish evidence of holding
any illegally acquired property which is liable for seizure or freezing
or
forfeiture
under
Chapter
V-A
of
this
Act;
and
(d) detain and search, and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person
whom he has reason to believe to have committed any offence
punishable under this Act:
Provided that in respect of the holder of a license for manufacture
of manufactured drugs or psychotropic substances or controlled
substances granted under this Act or any rule or order made
thereunder, such power shall be exercised by an officer not below
the rank of sub-inspector.
Provided further that, if such officer has reason to believe that a
search warrant or authorization cannot be obtained without
affording an opportunity for the concealment of evidence or facility
for the escape of an offender, he may enter and search such
building, conveyance or enclosed place at any time between sunset
and sunrise after recording the grounds of his belief.
Page No.# 19/25
(2) Where an officer takes down any information in writing under
sub-section (1) or records grounds for his belief under the proviso
thereto, he shall within seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to
his immediate official superior.”
31.
From the above, it is abundantly clear that the concerned officers who
receive the information are required to take down the same at any rate in
writing which has been done in the present case by way of GDE No. 194 dated
11.04.2023 (Exbt – 1/PW 1). Sub-section 2 of Section 42, thereafter, requires
that such information taken down in writing shall be communicated to his
immediate official superior within 72 hours.
32. The I/O in his evidence has clearly admitted during cross-examination that
the contents of the GDE were not communicated to his superior authority in
writing, which would imply that the information reduced to writing under Subsection (1) of Section 42 NDPS Act, was never communicated to his immediate
superior whether before or after 72 hours. PW-1 has sought to explain this by
way of Exbt. P-4/PW-1 which is as follows:-
Page No.# 20/25
Dated 11/04/23
”
To,
The Deputy Superintendent of Police, (HQ)
Dist Dhubri
Ref-
Chagolia OP GDE No 194 Dtd 11/04/23
Sub- Compliance of Sec 42 of NDPS Act
Sir,
With respectfully I have the honour to inform you that I have
received the information in connection with above noted reference
regarding Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substance and report
before you under the provision of Sec 42 NDPS Act seeking
authorization from your end.
Submitted for favour of your kind perusal.”
33. As submitted, the said communication does not disclose the nature of the
information or any details thereof and although the reference to Chagolia O.P
GDE No. 194 dated 11.04.2023 is made in the aforesaid communication, the I/O
has clearly admitted that the contents of the said GDE were not communicated
to his immediate superior officer in writing. The aforesaid communication itself
does not show that a copy of the information taken down in writing i.e. the
Page No.# 21/25
aforesaid GDE was enclosed along with the said communication.
34.
Under the aforesaid circumstances, there appears to be force in the
contention of the appellant that the Exbt.P-3/PW-1 authority Letter dated
11.04.2023, containing no memo number permitting the PW-1 to proceed to the
house of the accused Md. Moksedul Hoque and to search the said house as per
the secret information received appears to be a made-up document. Since the
Exbt. P-4/PW-1 communication dated 11.04.2023 does not contain any
particulars of the information received and a copy of GDE was also not
communicated in writing, the information regarding the accused and his address
could not have been known to the issuing authority of the authority letter i.e.
the Dy. S.P(HQ), Dhubri. It is also noticed that the date mentioned on top of
Exbt. P-4/PW-1 communication was initially written as 12.04.2023 and so was
the date below the signature of the PW-1, which has been corrected by hand as
11.04.2023 at both places, thereby raising doubts about the time or date on
which the said communication was made.
35.
Coming to the second proviso to Sub-section 1 of the Section 42 of the
NDPS Act, it being an admitted position that the search and seizure was carried
out during the night, the concerned police officer was required to record the
grounds of his belief regarding the urgency of the matter because of which he
Page No.# 22/25
could not wait for a search warrant or authorization, without affording the
opportunity for the concealment of evidence or facilitating for the escape an
offender. In the instant case, although PW-1 claims to have obtained the
authorization letter from the Dy. S.P(HQ), Dhubri i.e. Exbt P-3/PW-1, because of
which it may well be argued that recording of such grounds of belief was not
necessary. But, since it has been found that the authority letter itself is a
doubtful one, the recording of the grounds of belief as referred to in the second
proviso to Sub-section 1 to Section 42 of the NDPS Act must be insisted upon.
But no such ground is available in the Exbt. P-4/PW-1. In fact, even in the GDE,
recording the secret information, no such ground requiring search and seizure
operation to be carried out without authorization after sunset and before sunrise
has been mentioned and therefore, the communication thereof to the immediate
official superior within 72 hours as required by Sub-section 2 of Section 42
NDPS Act, or even thereafter, is not of any consequence.
36.
Furthermore, there is a gap of about 10 hours from the time of alleged
seizure till its deposition at the Malkhana, Golakganj P.S during which time it
was lying in the custody of PW-1 at Chagolia Out Post and admittedly, no
Malkhana register was maintained at the said Out Post, although the I/O has
stated that upon seizure of the contraband he had sealed the same, no such
Page No.# 23/25
seal/fascimile has been exhibited. In a matter involving such serious
consequences for the appellant, the mere word of the I/O of the PW-1 that he
had sealed the contraband is, in the view of this Court, not sufficient.
Furthermore, the FSL report has not been brought on record by the prosecution
through the I/O as an exhibit and although in view of Section 293 Cr.P.C, it was
not necessary to prove the FSL report by summoning the author thereof, I am
complete agreement with the decision of the Delhi High Court referred to by the
learned counsel for the petitioner that it was necessary for the same to have
been tendered the evidence by the I/O, or the person who collected the same
from the FSL, in order to show that the report pertains to the case in hand.
37.
The learned Trial Court has therefore fallen into error in taking into
consideration the said FSL report, notwithstanding the fact that defence had
filed a petition stating that examination of the FSL expert is not vital. It is stated
in the aforesaid petition No. 670 dated 25.06.2024 that the accused is in
custody for a long time and it is not so vital to examine the Forensic expert, who
is an official witness and that the report of the forensic expert was accepted.
That by itself, however, does not obviate the need to bring the FSL report,
perhaps the most vital document of the case on record. As held by the Apex
Court in Kailash (supra), the FSL report along with the sample tested by it is to
Page No.# 24/25
be placed on record so that there remains no doubt regarding the sample tested
and admittedly, in the instant case, neither has been brought on record.
38. It is surprising to note that the PW-6 who submitted the charge- sheet in
the instant case deposed that he collected the FSL report in connection with the
instant case and yet the prosecution did not get the said FSL report exhibited
through PW-6 for reasons best known to it.
39.
PW-5 S.I Nirmal Chandra, who produced the seized articles before the
Magistrate, got the inventory certified and exhibited the said inventory as Exbt.
P -9/PW-5 and the list of samples as Exbt. P-10/PW-5, but did not depose to
anything regarding taking any photographs in the presence of the Magistrate
and getting them certified as true and this is despite the fact that the said
photographs are found tagged within the records of the case. This is also
another indicator of the casual attitude of the prosecution.
40. In view of the aforesaid infirmities for the prosecution case as discussed
above, more particularly the total non-compliance with Section 42 of the NDPS
Act, the trial has been vitiated and the consequent judgment and sentence
therefore cannot be sustained and the same are accordingly set aside. The
appeal stands allowed.
Page No.# 25/25
41. The appellant be set at liberty forthwith. Send back the TCR.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review