Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.01.30 17:31:18 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
1. Shri Moirangthem Rajen Singh, aged about 50
years, S/O M. Mani Singh, resident of New
Chekon, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat and District
Imphal East, Manipur-795001.
2. Shri Bashaspatimayum Kumar Sharma, aged
about 51 years, S/O (L) B. Kulachandra Sharma,
resident of Porompat Kshetri Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, and District Imphal East, Manipur795005.
3. Smt. Salam Sanahanbi, aged about 57 years,
D/O (L) S. Lakhichan Singh, resident of Kha Jiri
Mamang Leikai, P.O. Bishnupur, P.S. Nambol
and District Bishnupur, Manipur-795134.
4. Shri R.K. Ranjan Singh, aged about 55 years,
S/O (L) R.K. Muktasana Singh, resident of
Thoubal Achouba, P.O., P.S. and District
Thoubal, Manipur-795138.
5. Shri Khadangbam Subol Singh, aged about 56
years, S/O K. Kanhai Singh, resident of
Mongshangei Awang Leikai School Leirak, P.O.
Canchipur, P.S. Singjamei and District Imphal
West, Manipur-795003.
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |2
6. Smt. Sapam Parva Devi, aged about 55 years,
D/O S. Kumar, resident of Sagolband Shayang
Kuraou Makhong, P.O., P.S. and District Imphal,
Manipur-795001.
7. Shri Maimom Maipak Singh, aged about 59
years, S/O (L) M. Mangi Singh, resident of
Thoubal Haokha Mamang Leikai, P.O., P.S. and
District Thoubal, Manipur-795138.
8. Mr. Phamitphang Ningshen , aged about 58
years, S/O Masahung Ningshen, resident of
Ningchou Village, P.O. Chassao Kamjong, P.S.
Chassao and District Ukhrul, Manipur.
9. Smt. Akoijam Memcha Devi, aged about 38
years, D/O Ak. Pishak Singh, resident of Thoubal,
P.O., P.S. and District Thoubal, Manipur-795138.
10. Shri Konsam Indrajit Singh, aged about 51 years,
S/O (L) K. Babudhon Singh, resident of
Maniyaiskul, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Lamlai and
District Imphal East, Manipur-795010.
11. Shri Laishram Herojit, aged about 51 years, S/O
L. Chaoba Singh, resident of Khurai Kongpal
Ningthoubung Leikai, P.O.& P.S. Porompat and
District Imphal East, Manipur-795005.
12. Laitonjam Nabadip Singh, aged about 53 years,
S/O L. Tomba Singh, resident of Charangpat
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |3
Mayai Leikai, P.O., P.S. and District Thoubal,
Manipur-795138.
13. Smt. Khoisnam Peto Devi, aged about 58 years,
D/O Kh. Manao Singh, resident of Ngingom
Thongjao, P.O. Canchipur, P.S. Singjamei and
District Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
14. Smt. Wahengbam Manglembi Devi, aged about
57 years, D/O (L) W. Iboton Singh, resident of
Mana Inkhol, P.O. Swombung, P.S. Lamlai and
District Imphal East, Manipur-795010.
…Petitioners
-Versus1. The State of Manipur, through the Principal
Secretary/ Commissioner/ Secretary, Textiles,
Commerce and Industries, Govt. of Manipur,
Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director, Commerce and Industries, Govt. of
Manipur, Office of the Directorate of Trade,
Commerce & Industries, Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S.
Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur-795004.
…. Respondents
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |4
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. BP Sahu, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
10.01.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
30.01.2023
::
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, GA
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners
to quash the impugned order dated 10.1.2019 passed by the
second respondent and to regularize/absorb the services of the
petitioners within a time frame.
2.
The case of the petitioners is that they were initially
engaged as skilled Artisans of various categories/trades,
sweeper and demonstrator of the Department of Industries
since the year 1981 up to the year 1994 and since then they
have been serving in the same capacities, however, their wages
have been revised from time to time. The petitioners have been
drawing meager wages/pay and allowances with a legitimate
expectation that their services shall be regularized by the
respondent authorities. While so, on 14.7.2016, the Principal
Secretary, Commerce and Industries, Government of Manipur,
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |5
addressed a communication to the Additional Director,
Directorate of Employment Exchange requesting candidates for
appointment of various categories of posts, including the posts
in which the petitioners have been serving for decades together.
Being aggrieved, the petitioners have filed W.P.(C) No.626 of
2016 to quash the said letter dated 14.7.2016 and to direct the
respondents to regularize their services through a Screening
Committee constituted exclusively for them. By the order dated
10.5.2018, this Court disposed of the writ petition with certain
directions. Since the respondents failed to take action as per
the order of this Court, the petitioners have filed Contempt Case
(Civil) No.88 of 2019 and the same was closed on 20.8.2019 by
recording the issuance of the impugned proceedings dated
10.1.2019. Challenging the same, the petitioners have filed this
writ petition.
3.
The
respondents
filed
affidavit-in-opposition
stating that the Finance Department, Government of Manipur
issued an Office Memorandum dated 19.2.2005 prescribing a
standard agreement for engagement on contract basis.
Accordingly, the engagement of the petitioners on contract
basis was made. There are sanctioned post of SA/Dem (D&T),
SA/Dem
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
(T&C),
SA/Dem
(Foundry),
SA/Dem
(Carpet
Page |6
Weaving), SA/Dem (Weaving), SA/Dem (Carpentry) and
SA/Dem
(Blacksmithy)
in
the
Department
of
Textiles,
Commerce and Industries. However, the petitioners were not
engaged against those sanctioned posts and they were
engaged
on
daily
wage
basis.
Further,
no
post
creation/sanction orders was indicated in the engagement
order. Besides, there is no sanctioned post of SA (Winder),
Attendant (P/L) and SA (B&BM) in the Department in which
petitioners 1, 7 and 14 were engaged respectively. Therefore,
there is no question of the post held by the petitioners in the
requisition letter dated 14.7.2016.
4.
It is stated that pursuant to the order dated
10.5.2018 passed in W.P.(C) No.626 of 2016, the Director of
Trade, Commerce and Industries, Manipur issued an order
dated 10.1.2019 rejecting the claim of the petitioners, as they
failed to fulfill the conditions. It is stated that framing of scheme
for regularization of adhoc/officiating/substitute employees is
within the wisdom and domain of the State Government. Only
after thorough examination, the claim of the petitioners was
rejected as they do not fulfill the conditions stipulated by this
Court in the order dated 10.5.2018. Therefore, the petitioners
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |7
have no right to file the present writ petition and the same is
liable to be dismissed.
5.
Assailing the impugned order, Mr. Anjan Prasad,
the learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that while
rejecting the case of the petitioners, the second respondent has
failed to consider the direction of this Court passed in the earlier
writ petition. He would submit that the act of the second
respondent
rejecting
the
claim
of
the
petitioners
for
regularization to their respective posts is unacceptable, as the
petitioners have been engaged in the said posts for 2-3 decades
together and in spite of being fulfilled the conditions set forth by
this Court.
6.
Explaining further, the learned counsel for the
petitioners further submitted that the order dated 10.5.2018
passed in W.P.(C) No.626 of 2016 lays down two alternative
conditions for
regularization
i.e.
qualified/affirmative
for
condition (a), (b) and (c) or affirmative for condition (d) which
also contains two parts. Thus, the impugned order is not in
consonance with the direction of this Court.
7.
The learned counsel added that one K.Birjit Singh,
who was serving as skill Artisan (Bamboo and Cave) on
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |8
contract basis, was regularized to the said post on skill Artisan
(Bamboo and Cave) in the time scale of pay with usual
allowances with effect from the date of issuing duty against the
post created vide order dated 3.3.1978.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioners urged that
they were initially engaged to their respective posts between the
month of September, 1981 and August, 1996. As such, they
have been continuously discharging their duties to their
respective posts on engagement basis decades together by
getting meager wages with the hope and trust that their services
will be absorbed by the respondent authorities in due course.
Therefore, the petitioners are entitled to be regularized for being
a regular employee of the Department of Commerce and
Industries, Government of Manipur prior to their attaining the
age of superannuation. In support, the learned counsel placed
reliance upon the order dated 18.7.2022 passed by this Court
in W.P.(C) No.289 of 2021.
9.
Per contra, Mrs. Ch. Sundari, the learned
Government Advocate submitted that the contract engagement
of the petitioners was made with the second respondent after
obtaining approval of the Committee of officers for such
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
Page |9
engagement. When the petitioners entered into their services,
an agreement was entered between the petitioners and the
State Government on which it is clearly mentioned that the
petitioners cannot claim for regularization of their services.
10.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that the regularization of K.Birjit Sigh and 8 others
were done in compliance with the orders of the High Court,
whereas the prayer of the petitioners for regularization of their
casual/contract basis could not be considered by the
respondent authorities as stated in the impugned order dated
10.1.2019.
In fact, the case of the petitioners has been
examined very carefully as per the direction of this Court in
W.P.(C) No.626 of 2016 and therefore, there is no illegality in it.
Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ petition.
11.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
12.
Before dealing with the issue involved, it is to be
mentioned that the petitioners 6 and 12 herein have earlier filed
W.P.(C) No.289 of 2021 challenging the very same impugned
order dated 10.1.2019. Therefore, challenging the impugned
order dated 10.1.2019 again by the said petitioners in the
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 10
instant writ petition is not permissible. The learned counsel for
the petitioners has also agreed for the dismissal of the writ
petitions as far as petitioners 6 and 12 are concerned. In view
of the above, the writ petition in respect of the petitioners 6 and
12 is dismissed. Thus, the writ petition remains to be decided
in respect of the petitioners 1 to 5, 7 to 11, 13 and 14.
13.
The grievance of the petitioners is that the first
petitioner was initially engaged as Skill Artisan (Brass and Bell
Metal) vide order dated 23.9.1993; the second petitioner was
engaged as Demonstrator/Skill Artisan (Blacksmithy) vide order
dated 24.6.1993; the third petitioner was engaged as
Demonstrator (Weaving) vide order dated 22.2.1994; the fourth
petitioner was engaged as Casual Demonstrator (Blacksmith)
for a period of 3 months at the approved rate vide order dated
23.9.1991; the fifth petitioner was engaged as Skill Artisan (Doll
& Toys) for a period of three months with effect from 8.9.1982
with the permission to pay the paid holiday on the Sunday for
working of 6 consecutive days in a week of the month vide order
dated 1.9.198; the seventh petitioner was initially engaged as
Sweeper vide order dated 21.8.1982; the eighth petitioner was
engaged to the post of Demonstrator (Tailoring) on payment of
Rs.350/- per month for a period of 3 months vide order dated
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 11
21.8.1984; the ninth petitioner was engaged as Demonstrator
(Weaving) on consolidated scale of pay; the tenth petitioner was
engaged as Skill Artisan (Carpentry) vide order dated 9.8.1996;
the eleventh petitioner was engaged as Skill Artisan (Carpet) on
payment of Rs.13.40 per day vide order dated 20.7.1988; the
thirteenth petitioner was engaged as Skill Artisan at the rate of
9.50 per day for a period of three months with effect from
8.9.1981 with permission to pay the paid holiday on Sunday for
the working of 6 consecutive days in a week of the month vide
order dated 1.9.1981 and the fourteenth petitioner was engaged
as Skill Artisan (Winder) at the rate of Rs.8/- per working day for
a period of three months with effect from the date of joining his
duties with the permission to pay the paid holiday for working of
6 days continuously in a week of the month vide order dated
15.5.1982.
According to the petitioners, pursuant to the
issuance of the said appointment/engagement orders, the
petitioners 1 to 5, 7 to 11, 13 and 14 have joined their duties to
their respective places of postings and started to discharge their
duties to the fullest satisfaction of their superior officers and
there has been no adverse remark to the services rendered by
them from any quarters. The respondent authorities extended
the terms of contract engagement of the petitioners from time to
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 12
time by issuing orders and wages of the petitioners have also
been revised by the authorities from time to time.
14.
The further grievance of the petitioners is that one
K.Birjit Singh who was serving as Skill Artisan (Bamboo and
Cave) on contract basis was appointed/regularized to the said
post in the time scale of pay with usual allowances vide order
dated 28.7.1998 by the Director of Commerce and Industries,
Government of Manipur. Similarly, as many as 8 persons who
were serving as Muster Roll/Casual basis of the Department of
Commerce and Industries were also regularized to the post of
Demonstrator/Skill Artisan (PINA) in the time scale of pay.
However, the petitioners have not been considered for
regularization/absorption till date. The petitioners have been
continuously discharging their duties with the hope that their
services would be regularized in due course.
15.
It is to be noted that earlier when the Director of
Commerce and Industries requested for requisition of
candidates for appointment to various posts from open market,
including the posts in which the petitioners have been engaging
for decades together, the petitioners herein have filed W.P.(C)
No.626 of 2016 for quashing the said letter dated 14.7.2016 and
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 13
also for issuing a mandamus to direct the respondents to
regularize their services through a Screening Committee.
16.
By the order dated 10.5.2018, this Court disposed
of the said writ petition. The operative portion of the order reads
thus:
“[11] In view of the above, the instant writ
petition is disposed of with the following
directions:
(a) The Respondents and in particular, the
respondent No.2 shall verify as to whether the
petitioners
were
engaged
against
the
sanctioned posts;
(b) The respondents and in particular, the
respondent No. 2 shall verify a to whether the
petitioners were eligible for appointment as
per the then existing recruitment rules at the
time when they were initially engaged against
the posts being held by them;
(c) The respondents and in particular, the
respondent No. 2 shall verify as to whether the
petitioners have served by now, for more than
ten years without the benefit or protection of
the interim order or any court or tribunal;
(d) The respondents and in particular, the
respondent No. 2 shall verify as to whether the
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 14
petitioners are similarly situated with Shri K.
Birjit Singh who has been appointed as Skill
Artisan (Bamboo & Cane) vide Order dated
03.03.1978 or with the said eight persons who
have
been
appointed
to
the
posts
of
Demonstrator/Skill Artisan (PINA) vide Order
dated 25.06.2010 issued by the Principal
Secretary
(Commerce
&
Industries).
Government of Manipur:
The aforesaid exercise shall be done within a
period of thirty days from the date of receipt of
a copy of this judgment and order and in case
the answers to the directions (a) to (c) above
are in the affirmative, the petitioners shall be
regularised by the State Government within
two months thereafter or alternatively, in case
the answer to the direction (d) is in affirmative,
the petitioners shall be regularised by the
State
Government
within
two
months
thereafter."
17.
As rightly argued by learned counsel for the
petitioners, the order dated 10.5.2018 speaks about two
alternative conditions for regularization i.e. qualified/affirmation
for condition (a), (b) and (c) or affirmative for condition (d), which
also contains two parts., which reads thus:
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 15
“(a) Whether the petitioners were engaged
against the sanctioned post, or
(b)
Whether
they
were
eligible
for
appointment as per the then recruitment
rules at the time when they were initially
engaged against the posts being held by
them, or
(c)
Whether the petitioners have served, by
now, for more than ten years without the
benefit or protection of the interim order
of any Court or Tribunal and
(d)
Whether the petitioners are similarly
situated with Shri K.Birjit Singh who has
been
appointed
as
Skill
Artisan
(Bamboo & Cane) vide order dated
3.3.1978 or with the said eight persons
who have been appointed to the posts
of Demonstrator/Skill Artisan (PINA)
vide order dated 25.6.2020.”
18.
Pursuant to the directions of this Court, the
Director, Trade, Commerce and Industries, Government of
Manipur passed the impugned order dated 10.1.2019 and in
paragraphs 4 and 5, it has been stated as under:
“4. Whereas none of the petitioners fulfil the
condition at (a) of the directions of the High
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 16
Court
even
though
there
were
some
candidates who satisfy condition at (b) & (c).
As such, the answer to the directions (a) & (c)
is not affirmative and there will be no question
of issue of regularization order on account of
the first condition of the directive of the Hon’ble
High Court.
5. Whereas, the present petitioners were
engaged and their terms of engagement were
extended from time to time with one day gap
in
a
year.
Therefore,
technically,
their
engagement were not extended but reengaged for another year, each after the lapse
of previous engagement and as such, they
were last engaged for 1 (one) year only
against the continuous engagement for 20
years in respect of 8 (right) persons. before
their regularization. Similarly, Shri K. Birjit
Singh was engaged as Skilled Artisan
(Bamboo & Cane) against sanction post and
had been working continuously for twelve
years without any break and he was not
lacking requisite qualification prescribed under
the RR. Therefore, engagement of the
petitioners is not similarly situated with that of
the 8 (eight) persons under consideration nor
with Shri K. Birjit Singh. In this regard, the 2nd
part of the second condition as stated at Para
1(d) mentioned above is not affirmative and
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 17
the petitioner does not satisfy the condition of
the directive of the Hon'ble High Court."
19.
Two conditions emanate from the above order,
namely (1) whether the petitioners qualify conditions (a), (b) and
(c); and, (2) whether the petitioners are similarly situated with
K.Birjit Singh who has been appointed as Skill Artisan (B&C)
vide order dated 3.3.1978 or with the said eight persons who
have been appointed to the posts of Demonstrator/Skill Artisan
(Pina) vide order dated 25.6.2010.
20.
Insofar as condition (a) is concerned, it appears
that the petitioners herein as well as the position of K.Birjit Singh
and eight other incumbents regularized is similar, inasmuch as
they were initially engaged in similar manner and under similar
terms and conditions and they were not engaged against any
sanctioned post and subsequently, the posts were created.
21.
If we consider condition (b), the petitioners were
eligible as per the then existing Recruitment Rules and that is
why in the impugned order the second respondent stated that
“as such, the answer to the directions (a) & (c) is not affirmative
and there will be no question of issuance of regularization order
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 18
on account of the first condition of the directive of the Hon’ble
High Court.”
22.
As far as condition (c) is concerned, the petitioners
have served for more than 10 years. The petitioners were
appointed between 1981 and 1994 respectively and they have
also completed 10 years of service.
23.
Coming to the comparison of the petitioners with
K.Birjit Singh, K.Birjit Singh was engaged as Skilled Artisan
(B&C) on 18.6.1986 for a period of one month and his
engagement was extended from time to time. K.Birjit Singh
approached the Gauhati High Court by filing Civil Rule No.179
of 1995, inter alia, praying for regularization of his service as
Skilled Artisan. By the order dated 5.2.1998, the Gauhati High
Court disposed of the case. The operative portion of the order
reads thus:
“6. By now, the petitioner has been working as
Skilled Artisan (Bamboo & Cane) for almost 12
years. He is entitled to be regularized in the
post. The respondents are therefore, directed
to regularize the service of the petitioner
immediately if there is any post in existence
and in the event there is no post in existence,
he shall be regularized in the immediate future
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 19
vacancy that may arise. Till regularization of
his service, petitioner shall not be ousted from
the post that he is holding.”
24.
It is seen that vide order dated 20.7.1998, the
Directorate of Commerce and Industries, appointed K.Birjit
Singh to the post of Skilled Artisan (B&C) by creating the said
post as Md. Kumar Jaman, Skilled Artisan (B&C) retired on
31.1.1994.
25.
Insofar as 8 other incumbents whose services
have been regularized vide order dated 25.6.2010 is
concerned, they were initially engaged in the year 1972-75-7677 in the similar manner as that of the petitioners. They have
also approached the Gauhati High Court by filing Civil Rule
No.778 of 1993 and by the order dated 17.8.1995, the said case
was disposed of. The operative portion of the order is extracted
hereunder:
“Accordingly, this writ application is allowed.
The respondent No.2 and 3 are directed to
regularize the services of the petitioners within
a period of three months from the date of
receipt of this order. Regularisation shall be
done by the authority in such manner so that
the petitioner at the end of their service is
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 20
entitled to have something as pensionary
benefit or retiral benefits otherwise if they are
regularized simply, they will have nothing in
the end of their service carrier. So the
authorities shall regularize the services of the
petitioner from back date by giving them only
retirement benefit so that they get pensionary
benefits.
None of the petitioners shall be
thrown out from the service in the meantime.”
26.
The learned Government Advocate argued that
there was a gap in the engagement of the petitioners, whereas
K.Birjit Singh and 8 other incumbents who were regularized
were engaged against the sanctioned posts and there was no
gap in their service records and also the Recruitment Rules
were also fulfilled by K.Birjit Singh and 8 others. Therefore, the
petitioners cannot compare the case of K.Birjit Singh. Nothing
has been produced by the respondents to show that the
engagement of K.Birjit Singh and 8 others was against the
sanctioned posts.
27.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
petitioners submitted that the artificial break of one day in the
continuous service is arbitrary. He also pointed out that the one
day gap only came into existence only after implementation of
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 21
the Office Memorandum dated 19.2.2005, wherein it has been
directed that engagement of person on contract basis by
various Department should be done on the prescribed standard
agreement format and no other engagement orders, letters etc.
shall be issued by any authority.
28.
In All Manipur Government Arts & Culture
Departmentv. State of Manipur and others, (2011) 4 GLT 864,
the Guahati High Court held thus:
“7. For the foregoing decision, this Court is of
the considered view that artificial break of one
day in the continuous service of the members
of the petitioner Union as casual/contract
employees in the Arts & Culture Department,
Govt. of Manipur, is arbitrary. Accordingly, this
Court has no alternative except to direct the
State respondents not to create artificial one
day's break i.e. 01.11.2003 in extending the
term of the services of the members of the
petitioner Union as casual/contract employees
while issuing the impugned order dated
30.8.2005 and necessary extension order
should be issued by the respondents for not
creating
artificial
one
day's
break
i.e.
01.11.2003 in extending the term of the
services of the members of the petitioner
Union as casual/contract employees within a
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 22
period of three months from the date of receipt
of a certified copy of the judgment and order of
this Court, which is being furnished by the
petitioner Union within a period of 10(ten) days
from today to the Director of Arts & Culture
Department, Govt. of Manipur. 8. To the extent
indicated above, this writ petition is allowed.”
From the above, it is clear that there should not be artificial
break of one day.
29.
It is to be mentioned that K.Brijit Singh, was
engaged for one month in the year 1986, whereas some of the
petitioners herein were engaged during 1981. As stated supra
and as could be seen from the records, the petitioners herein
are serving since the year 1981 to the posts in which they were
engaged.
30.
At this juncture, the learned Government Advocate
submitted
that
that
the
Court/Tribunal
cannot
direct
regularization of temporary appointees’ dehors the rules.
31.
It is not the case of the respondents that the very
engagement/appointment of the petitioners is illegal. In the
case on hand, the appointment/initial engagement of the
petitioners is not under challenge and there is also no illegality
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 23
in the initial appointment. That apart, when similar challenge
was made in W.P.(C) No.289 of 2021, this Court, by the order
dated 7.6.2022, quashed the impugned order dated 10.1.2019.
The operative portion of the order is extracted hereunder:
“39. In the result, the writ petition is allowed.
(a)
The impugned order dated 10.1.2019
declining
regularization
of
the
petitioners is set aside.
(b)
The respondents are directed to
regularise
the
services
of
the
petitioners and extend the similar
service benefits received by K.Birjit
Singh and 8 other incumbents.
(c)
The said exercise is directed to be
completed within a period of four
months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order. No costs.”
32.
It is seen that as against the order dated 7.6.2022
passed in W.P.(C) No.289 of 2021, no appeal has been filed by
the respondents and nothing has been produced by the
respondents to show that the said order has been stayed by the
appellate Court. In the absence of any appeal and/or stay
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 24
order, the judicial discipline warrants this Court to follow the
order dated 7.6.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.289 of 2021.
33.
At
this
juncture,
the
learned
Government
Advocate, by placing reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Union of India and others v.
Ramesh Gandhi, (2012) 1 SCC 476, submitted that the said
order dated 7.6.2022 has been obtained by playing fraud on
Court and, therefore, the same cannot be taken into account.
34.
It is trite law that a judgment obtained by playing
fraud on the Court is a nullity and is to be treated as non-est by
every Court. Further, the judgment obtained by non-disclosure
of all necessary facts tantamounts to a judgment obtained by
fraud.
35.
In the instant case, nothing has been produced by
the respondents to show that by playing fraud, the petitioners in
W.P.(C) No.289 of 2021 have obtained orders in their favour.
On the other hand, this Court, after a detailed discussion and
upon considering the arguments put forth by the respective
counsel, passed the order dated 7.6.2022. Therefore, it cannot
be contended by the learned Government Advocate that the
order dated 7.6.2022 was obtained by playing fraud. That apart,
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 25
in the facts and circumstances of the case involved herein, the
decision in the case of Ramesh Gandhi, supra, relied upon by
the learned Government Advocate is not applicable to the case
on hand.
36.
It is apposite to mention at this juncture that the
initial engagement of K.Birjit Singh was not against any
sanctioned post and after completion of 12 years continuous
service and in compliance with the order dated 5.2.1995, his
service was regularized on 20.7.1998.
In the counter, the
second respondent admitted that regularization of K.Birjit Singh
and 8 casual workers by the Department were done in
compliance of the Court orders.
The petitioners who were
appointed between the year 1981 and 1994 have already
completed 10 years of service respectively. With respect to the
8 other incumbents who were engaged in the year 1972-75-7677, the impugned order dated 10.1.2019 states that they have
been engaged for continuous period of 20 years.
37.
It is seen that the petitioners have also completed
20 years of continuous engagement. Therefore, the impugned
order stating that engagement of the petitioners is not similar to
that of K.Birjit Singh is erroneous and is liable to the set aside.
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 26
It is also seen from the records that in the span of 12 years from
the date of initial date of engagement, there has not been any
one day break in service.
38.
The petitioners have legitimate expectation for
being regular employees of the Department prior to their
attaining the age of superannuation and therefore, the
respondents
are
bound
to
consider
their
cases
for
regularization/absorption to their respective posts. Many adhoc/officiating/substitute employees have been regularized to
their respective posts by the State Government by formulating
various schemes in respect thereof including the one relating to
conversion from the work-charged to regular establishment and
the
fact
that
the
petitioners
have
not
yet
been
regularized/absorbed had shown that they were being
discriminated. As stated supra, there is also no dispute that the
petitioners were engaged as Skill Artisans etc. and their
engagements were extended from time to time. As a result of
which, they have been continuing in that capacity till date.
39.
When similarly situated persons have been
granted the benefit of regularization, the petitioners were
discriminated. Therefore, this Court finds merit in the writ
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 27
petition. That apart, while passing the impugned order dated
10.1.2019, the second respondent ignored the said aspects of
the matter and had passed a mechanical order. On the other
hand, the petitioners have fulfilled the conditions for
regularisation. Therefore, there are grounds to interfere with
the impugned order. Since the impugned order cannot be
sustained in the eye of law, the same is liable to be quashed.
40.
In the result,
(i)
The writ petition is allowed in respect
of the petitioners No. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7,
8, 9, 10 & 11 and dismissed against
the petitioners No. 6 and 12.
(ii)
The
impugned
order
dated
10.1.2019 declining regularization
of the services of the petitioners No.
1,2,3,4,5,7,8,9,10 and 11 is set
aside.
(iii)
The respondent authorities are
directed to regularise the services
of
the
petitioners
1,2,3,4,5,7,8,9,10
and
No.
and
extend to them similar service
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
P a g e | 28
benefits received by K.Birjit Singh
and 8 other incumbents.
(iv)
The said exercise is directed to be
completed within a period of four
months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
(v)
There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 930 of 2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review