The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
06. In view of the aforesaid facts and the subsequent developments that have taken place during the pendency of the present petition, the instant writ petition is dismissed as withdrawn, with liberty to the petitioners to challenge the order dated 06.11.2023 by availing such remedy as may be available to them in law. Consequently, all connected application(s) shall also stand disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 76
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
SWP No.1628/2011
CM No.1386/2025
1. Mohinder Singh, Age 43 years
Const. No.890160203 ITBP
S/o Sh. Ajit Singh E/o H.No.57
Mangwal Colony Tehsil and District
Sangroor (Punjab)
.....Petitioner (s)
2. Kulwant Singh, Age 43 years Const.
No.890195221 ITBP S/o Sh. Ranga
Singh R/o Bhura Karimpura Patti Tehsil
Tarantaran (Punjab)
3. Gurnam Singh, Age 43 years Const.
No.890194438 ITBP S/o Sh. Sawroop
Singh R/o Barmal Jattan, P.O. Narota
Jaimal Singh (Punjab).
4. Pardeep Kumar, Age 43 years Const.
No.890195239 ITBP S/o Sh. Shanker
Dass R/o Vill. Bamial, P.O. Bamial
Tehsil Pathankot (Punjab).
Through :- Mr. K. S. Johal, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Supreet R. S. Johal, Advocate
v/s
1. Union of India through Ministry of
Home Affairs, New Delhi.
2. Inspector General Indian Tibtan
Boarder Police New Delhi.
3. Dy. Inspector General SHQ (LDK),
ITBPF MHA (Govt. of India) C/o56
APO.
4. Commandant 24th Bn. ITBP
Choglamsar, Leh.
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Karan Sharma, CGSC
SWP No.1628/2011
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
ORDER
23.07.2026
CM No.1386/2025
01.
This is an application filed by the petitioners/applicants for placing on
record, the requisite documents which are necessary to clinch the
controversy in question.
02.
For the reasons stated in the application coupled with the submissions
made at Bar, the same is allowed and the documents accompanying the
said application are taken on record with all just exceptions.
03.
The application is disposed of
SWP No.1628/2011
01.
Through the medium of the instant petition, the petitioners have prayed
for the following reliefs:i)
A writ of Mandamus for commanding the respondents to conclude the
de-novo inquiry initiated in terms of the order passed by this Court vide
a common judgment dated 22.07.2000 and upheld by the Hon‟ble
Division Bench in a common judgment dated 03.09.2009;
ii)
In the alternative, a writ commanding the respondents to withdraw the
proceedings initiated for holding the denovo inquiry and treat the
petitioner exonerated of the charges;
iii)
A writ directing the respondents to reinstate the petitioners and give all
consequential benefits w.e.f. the date they were suspended including
emoluments, promotions, seniority and other benefits permissible to
the petitioners in ITBP.
02.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners fairly
submits that the reliefs sought in the present writ petition have
substantially been granted by the respondents. It is submitted that the
petitioners have been reinstated and have also been extended
consequential service benefits with effect from the dates of their
SWP No.1628/2011
suspensions, including emoluments, promotions, seniority and other
service benefits admissible under the applicable rules governing the ITBP.
Learned senior counsel further submits that during the pendency of the
present petition, the respondents passed a detailed order dated 06.11.2023,
which has been brought on record along with the the instant application as
Annexure-I.
03.
A perusal of order dated 06.11.2023, annexed as Annexure-I to the instant
application, reveals that the competent authority has decided the case of
the petitioners in the following terms:“It is apparent that there is an inordinate delay in completion of
disciplinary proceedings against the above Constable, which has
caused mental agony, stress etc. to him and has also made a
stigma on his character. Hence, the de-novo enquiry ordered
against above person is liable to be stopped. Accordingly, the denovo enquiry which was ordered against him vide order No.76371 dated 07.12.2012 is hereby closed.
The question regarding the back wages for the period of
suspension above Constable yet to be decided. As already
discussed that the above personnel have faced lot of mental agony
and financial crisis as is mentioned in reinstatement order of
suspension also. Furthermore, as discussed above, in CA No.958
of 2010 titled Prem Nath Bali versus Registrar, High Court of
Delhi & anr., by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court “….. it should be
concluded within six months as an outer limit. Where it is not
possible for the employer to conclude due to certain unavoidable
causes the time frame then efforts should be made to conclude
within reasonably extended period depending upon the cause and
the nature of inquiry but not more than a year.”
The de-novo enquiry ordered on 22.09.2011, should have been
reasonably concluded within a period of one year from the date of
its order, given the nature of enquiry and the articles of charges
to be enquired. However, looking into the nature and
SWP No.1628/2011
technicalities of the case, the enquiry should have been
reasonably concluded within a period of two years. Therefore, the
continuous suspension of above Constable beyond the period of
two years from the date of order of de-novo enquiry does not seem
to be justified. Hence, to deny the back wages of suspension
period beyond the period of two years from the date of order of
de-novo/fresh enquiry doe not appears to be just and appropriate
in the present circumstances.
The period of suspension of above Constable w.e.f. 22.11.1993 to
26.07.2018 shall be treated as „duty‟ for all purposes. However, he
be paid full pay and allowances, only for the period of 23.09.2013
to 26.07.2018. For the period of 22.11.1993 to 22.09.2013, the
above Constable be paid an amount being „Subsistence
Allowance‟ @50% of his basic pay and other allowance(s), if not
already paid, for which he is entitled as per F.R. 53. However, the
amount already drawn, if any, by above Constable being
„Subsistence Allowance‟ shall be adjusted against the amount to
be drawn for the aforementioned period.
During the period of suspension, the above Constable has also
availed
permission
leave
and
same
is
ordered
regularized/adjusted as mentioned below:Sr. No.
Period
From
10.05.2010
31.10.2010
20.03.2011
05.05.2011
22.07.2011
24.11.2011
09.12.2011
03.07.2013
09.10.2013
12.04.2024
27.04.2014
14.10.2014
25.06.2015
01.09.2015
29.09.2015
To
24.05.2010
14.11.2010
03.04.2011
03.06.2011
05.08.2011
08.12.2011
22.01.2012
22.07.2013
07.11.2013
26.04.2024
16.05.2014
12.11.2014
09.07.2015
08.09.2015
28.10.2015
Regularized as
15 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
45 days as E.L
20 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
20 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
08 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
to
be
04.
01.02.2016
26.03.2016
18.05.2016
11.07.2016
10.10.2016
10.11.2016
15.01.2017
22.02.2017
23.03.2017
20.04.2017
06.06.2017
04.08.2017
19.09.2017
28.03.2018
03.05.2018
28.01.2019
28.03.2019
18.04.2019
18.11.2019
01.02.2020
23.11.2020
16.01.2021
05.11.2021
06.01.2022
25.10.2022
08.12.2022
23.01.2023
06.11.2023
15.02.2016
04.04.2016
06.06.2016
25.07.2016
08.11.2016
29.11.2016
13.02.2017
08.03.2017
06.04.2017
04.05.2017
20.06.2017
13.08.2017
28.09.2017
26.04.2018
12.05.2018
06.02.2019
30.03.2019
27.04.2019
24.12.2019
01.03.2020
22.12.2020
14.02.2021
04.12.2021
25.01.2022
26.10.2022
14.01.2023
21.02.2023
05.12.2023
SWP No.1628/2011
15 days as E.L
10 days as E.L
20 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
20 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
15 days as E.L
10 days as E.L
10 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
10 days as E.L
10 days as E.L
03 days as E.L
10 days as E.L
37 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
20 days as E.L
02 days as E.L
38 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
30 days as E.L
Upon perusal of the detailed order passed by the respondents during the
pendency of the instant writ petition, learned senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioners submits that the said order gives rise to a fresh
cause of action. He, accordingly, seeks permission of this Court to
withdraw the present petition with liberty to challenge the aforesaid order
by way of appropriate proceedings, as the reliefs claimed in the instant
petition were confined only to the prayers reproduced hereinabove and did
not encompass a challenge to the subsequent order dated 06.11.2023.
05.
SWP No.1628/2011
It is submitted that since the aforesaid order has been passed by the
respondents during the pendency of the present writ petition, the
petitioners seek leave of this Court to withdraw the instant petition with
liberty to assail the said order by instituting appropriate proceedings in
accordance with law.
06.
In view of the aforesaid facts and the subsequent developments that have
taken place during the pendency of the present petition, the instant writ
petition is dismissed as withdrawn, with liberty to the petitioners to
challenge the order dated 06.11.2023 by availing such remedy as may be
available to them in law. Consequently, all connected application(s) shall
also stand disposed of.
07.
It is made clear that the order dated 06.11.2023 came to be passed by the
respondents during the pendency of the present writ petition. Immediately
thereafter, without any undue delay, the petitioners filed the instant
application placing on record the said order and other relevant documents,
while simultaneously seeking liberty to challenge the same by way of
appropriate proceedings. Accordingly, it is made clear that in the event the
petitioners institute such proceedings, the period during which the present
writ petition remained pending, including the time spent in seeking
appropriate liberty from this Court, shall not operate to their prejudice on
the question of limitation. It shall be open to the petitioners to seek
exclusion of the said period before the competent forum, which shall
consider the issue in accordance with law.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
JAMMU
23.07.2026
Shammi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review