Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 60
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Bail App No.60/ 2026
Reserved on: 08.07.2026
Pronounced on:.16. 07.2026
Uploaded on: 16.07.2026
Whether the part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Mohd. Nadeem Samyal (30 Years)
S/O Mohd. Sharif
R/O Lower Mada Gujad Mada,
Udhampur
.....Applicant
Through :- Mr. M. A. Goni, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Tanzeel Illahi, Adv.
V/S
Union Territory of J&K through
Station House Officer,
P.S. Udhampur
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Sumeet Bhatia, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner, through the medium of present petition has invoked
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 483 of BNSS for grant of bail in a case
arising out of FIR No.167/2023 dated 28.11.2026 for offences under Sections
8/15/25 of NDPS Act registered with Police Station Chenani, Udhampur,
asserting that his earlier bail plea had been rejected vide order dated 31.03.2026
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Udhampur, (‘Trial Court’).
2.
Being aggrieved of the order dated 31.03.2026 passed by the learned
Trial Court in Bail Application titled ‘Mohd. Nadeem Samyal V. UT of J&K’,
whereby the bail application of the petitioner came to be rejected, the petitioner
has preferred the present bail application seeking enlargement on bail on the
grounds that:
(i)
That the impugned order is arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the
settled principles of law, and therefore, liable to be set aside;
(ii)
That the trial court has applied rigor of Section 37 of NDPS Act
for grant of interim bail but Supreme Court has held that the
rigor of these special provisions does not apply to the chronic
and lifelong disease;
(iii)
That the trial court has failed to appreciate that the applicant is
not the owner of the alleged vehicle at the time of occurrence,
as the vehicle is question was sold by the petitioner vide sale
deed dated 25.04.2021, thereby negating the essential
ingredients of Section 25 NDPS Act;
(iv)
That the petitioner has been falsely implicated in the case
merely on the allegation that the petitioner is the owner of the
vehicle;
(v)
That the son of the driver who had purchased the vehicle
despite repeated requests did not get the RC entries changed
from the concerned RTO;
(vi)
That the basic requirement of Section 25 NDPS Act i.e.
conscious knowledge and permission by the owner for use of
the vehicle in commission of offence, is completely absent in
the present case;
(vii) That the petitioner was not named in the initial challan and was
subsequently arrayed as an accused after an unexplained delay
of several months;
(viii) That despite lapse of considerable time after framing of
charges, the prosecution has failed to examine material
witnesses till date, which shows inordinate delay, violating the
petitioner’s fundamental right to speedy trial under Article 21 of
the Constitution of India;
Bail App No.60/2026
(ix)
That the trial court has ignored the settled law that prolonged
incarceration without progress of trial is a valid ground for
grant of bail;
(x)
That the petitioner is suffering from multiple serious and life
threatening medical conditions, including acute renal failure
and acute epididymo-orchitis, requiring specialized and
continuous medical treatment which cannot be adequately
provided in custody;
(xi)
That during the period of interim bail petitioner has not jumped
over the conditions imposed by the court nor prosecution has
even whispered a word about misuse of bail in any manner.
3.
The respondent/UT, through its detailed objections has, vehemently,
opposed the bail application on the grounds that the petitioner along with his
driver was intentionally engaged in the illegal trade of smuggling/transportation
of poppy straw in a well planned and organized manner for earning the
monetary gains and the petitioner intentionally allowed his vehicle to be used for
the purpose of transportation of poppy straw from Kashmir towards the other
parts of the country thus destroying the future of the youth of nation; that perusal
of CDR and IMEI record clearly shows that petitioner with Mohd Baber visited
Anantnag for the illegal purchase of narcotic drugs, to be sold in different parts
of the country; that the investigation of the case was completed and
supplementary challan as per the provisions of Section 173(8) CrPC of the
above said case was produced against the petitioner, in the court of law on
12.11.2024; and that rigor of Section 37 NDPS Act is attracted in the instant
case, hence the petition for grant of bail, be dismissed.
4.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner argued that the
petitioner was falsely implicated in the case; that charges against the accused
Bail App No.60/2026
were framed by the trial court on 11.11.2024 and since then, prosecution has
deliberately failed to examine its witnesses as only one prosecution witness,
namely, Nasreen Begum has been examined, who did not support the
prosecution case; that the petitioner is entitled to absolute bail in view of
suffering from life threatening diseases; that the trial court has applied rigor of
Section 37 of NDPS Act for grant of interim bail but Supreme Court has held
that the rigor of these special provisions does not apply in case of chronic and
life threatening disease; that prolonged incarceration without progress in trial is
a valid ground for grant of bail; that the petitioner is suffering from multiple
serious and life-threatening medical conditions, including acute renal failure and
acute epididymo-orchitis, requiring specialized and continuous medical
treatment which cannot be adequately provided in custody; that the petitioner
has not jumped any of the bail conditions imposed by this court while admitting
the petitioner to interim bail. Lastly, it is prayed that the interim bail granted to
him be made absolute.
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent, ex adverso, vehemently, opposed
the grant of bail to the petitioner for the reasons that delay in examination of
witnesses cannot, in any manner, be an automatic ground for grant of bail in
favour of the petitioner; that in view of bar created under Section 37 of the
NDPS Act, the petitioner cannot be enlarged on bail as this stage particularly
when there is material on record to suggest that he is involved in the alleged
crime; that the petitioner has not been able to satisfy the trial court that his truck
was not being used for any illegal activity; that as per the statement of specialist
doctor, treatment to the petitioner can be provided on need basis in the OPD,
Bail App No.60/2026
whenever required. Lastly, it is prayed that the bail application be dismissed and
the interim bail granted to the petitioner be revoked.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the material on the file
and considered.
7.
As per the prosecution story, on 28.11.2023 at about 08:45 hours, a
police party, while performing traffic checking duty at Naka Point Motor Shed
NHW Chenani, signaled a Truck No. JK14G-1818, coming from Srinagar, to
stop for checking and driver of the above Truck Mohd. Baber was questioned
about the load in the Truck; that on not giving satisfactory reply, SPO Raj Singh
searched the Truck and found 09 nos. of plastic bags containing poppy strawlike substance, loaded in the body of the said truck; thus, the driver by keeping
poppy straw bags, in his possession has committed offences U/S 8/15 of the
NDPS Act.
8.
Based on this factual background, a case was registered vide FIR
No.167/2023 U/S 8/15 NDPS Act, vehicle used for commission of crime was
seized and investigation of the case was entrusted to PSI Bua Ditta Bhagat of
Police Station Chenani; that during the course of investigation, it was
established that the owner of the vehicle though executed an agreement for sale
of his Truck No. JK14G1818 to driver of the Truck, but did not transfer the
ownership of the said vehicle, so that all the affairs of Truck got managed by
him and he was knowingly engaged in the illegal trade and smuggling of
Narcotics (Poppy straw) with criminal intention through accused driver; that
offence under Section 25 NDPS Act got established against the petitioner, who
was arrested on 24.03.2024, for further investigation.
Bail App No.60/2026
9.
A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, vide order dated 06.04.2026, while
issuing notice, admitted the petitioner to interim bail subject to following
conditions:
(i)
That the petitioner shall not absent himself from causing
personal appearance in the case before the court below on the
date/s fixed;
(ii)
That the petitioner shall not leave the UT of J&K without prior
permission of the trial court even for the sake of seeking
medical treatment;
(iii)
That the petitioner shall not in any manner attempt to influence
prosecution witnesses, whether examined in the case or yet to
be examined; and
(iv)
That the petitioner to furnish personal as well as surety bond of
an amount of Rs. 1.00 Lac each before the Registrar Judicial,
Jammu.
10.
The petitioner is seeking bail on the ground that he is suffering from
multiple serious and life threatening medical conditions, including acute renal
failure and acute epididymo-orchitis, requiring specialized and continuous
medical treatment, which cannot be adequately provided in custody; that he has
not jumped any of the bail conditions imposed while granting him interim bail.
Petitioner has also claimed that the vehicle wherefrom contraband was allegedly
recovered, had been sold by him to the son of the driver, before the date of
occurrence, however, registered certificate had not been transferred in the name
of the purchaser, as such, RC continued in his name but he had no control over
the vehicle, having been sold by him to the son of the driver of the vehicle.
Bail App No.60/2026
11.
Of course, there was no recovery of any contraband/narcotic from the
petitioner and he has been connected with the commission of offence, on the
basis of Call Detail Report (CDR) indicating that he was in touch with the main
accused, who had used the vehicle registered in the name of the petitioner, with
his consent. In view of the shaky and circumstantial evidence, petitioner has
raised rebuttable grounds.
The Supreme Court in SLA (Crl.) No.11376/2024 titled ‘Amar
12.
Sadhuram Mulchandani V. Directorate of Enforcement & Anr.’ held that the
proviso to Section 45(1) of PMLA specifically contemplates that a person who
is ‘sick or infirm’ may be released on bail if the Special Court so directs. The
Delhi High Court in Bail App No.2040/2024 titled ‘Dheeraj Wadhawan V. CBI’
decided on 09.09.2024 in a case wherein the applicant claimed to be suffering
from multiple co-morbidities and chronic ailments including ischemic heart
disease,
chronic
kidney disease,
fluctuating
serum creatinine
levels,
hypertension, observed in paragraph no. 23 as follows:
“23.The arguments advanced on behalf of the applicant and the
respondents are considered in right perspective. The applicant is
suffering from various ailments as detailed herein above and is falling
under category of sick person. The applicant at present may not
require hospitalisation and can be treated as outdoor patient but the
applicant needs regular and periodical medical attention and
treatment under direct supervision of expert and specialist doctors. If
the ailments of the applicant are not properly addressed then these
ailments may prove to be life threatening. The applicant is required to
be treated by the suitable doctors may be at private hospitals. The
applicant is entitled for grant of bail as per proviso to section 437 (1)
of the Code”.
Bail App No.60/2026
13.
The issue as to whether a statement made by an accused before NCB
officials under Section 67 of the NDPS Act is admissible in evidence is no
longer res integra. The Supreme Court has in a three Judge Bench judgment
delivered in the case of Tofan Singh V. State of Tamil Nadu reported as (2021)
4 SCC 1 held that the confessional statement recorded under Section 67 of the
NDPS Act by NCB officials will remain inadmissible in the trial of an offence
under the NDPS Act. Therefore, any statement made by accused under Section
67 of the NDPS Act implicating the petitioner or any statement made by the
petitioner implicating himself before the officials of NCB in terms of Section 67
of the NDPS Act is not admissible in evidence. It has been clearly held by the
Supreme Court that the confessional statement made by the accused/co-accused
before the NCB official is inadmissible evidence. Thus, the statement of the coaccused cannot be considered while determining the issue relating to
involvement of the petitioner in the alleged crime.
14.
The only material that connects the petitioner to the alleged crime that is
left is the CDR which has been collected by the investigating agency during the
investigation of the case. As per analysis of the CDR, it appears that the
petitioner was in touch with the co-accused during the relevant period. The
question arises as to whether the same would be sufficient to ‘prima facie’ hold
that the petitioner guilty of having committed the offence for which he has been
arrested. In the opinion of this court, CDR details showing contact between the
petitioner and co-accused, without there being any voice recording relating to
conversation between them, may not be sufficient to convict the petitioner for
the offence for which he has been booked. In this factual background of the
case, it is to be considered as to whether petitioner who has renal failure and life
Bail App No.60/2026
threatening disease, if not treated on a regular basis, even without requirement of
hospitalization, can be admitted to bail in a case where rigor of Section 37 of the
NDPS Act is applicable.
15.
The Delhi High Court while granting bail to the applicants in Bail App.
No.900/2025 titled Vinay Dua v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi c/w Bail App
No.982/2025 titled ‘Raj Kumar Agarwal V. State of NCT Delhi & Anr’ in
paras 20, 21 and 25 held as under:
“20. While the veracity of the disclosure statement against the
applicants will be tested during the course of the trial, however, at
this stage, it cannot be ignored that no recovery was ever effected
from the applicants.
21. It is argued that there are certain financial transactions and CDR
connectivity between the applicants and co-accused persons. It is
also argued that there are certain WhatsApp chats between the
applicants and co-accused persons.
16.
It has been pleaded by the petitioner that he was arrested on 24.03.2024
after a period of four months of the registration of the FIR, supplementary
charge sheet was laid against him on 12.11.2024, and the charges were framed
against him on 30.04.2025; that he fell severely sick in the jail and has been
suffering of serious disease diagnosed as acute right epididymo-architis; that in
absence of proper medical remedy, the same will result in a life threatening
disease, as such, he had been admitted to interim bail by this court on
06.06.2025. However, the trial Court, on expiry of the interim bail, rejected his
bail, which compelled the petitioner to approach this Court again. He further
submitted that the petitioner has now been diagnosed as a case of acute renal
failure as his creatinine has increased to 4.3, which is a very alarming medical
Bail App No.60/2026
condition; that both the ailments i.e. acute renal failure (CKD Stage-V) and
acute right epididymo-architis are life threatening diseases; that he is also
suffering from Gastroenterology and deranged coagulogram; that he was
advised by Dr. Raju K. Bhandari and Dr. Abdul Majeed, Assistant Professor in
Government Super Specialty Hospital, Jammu to undergo kidney Biospy in
view of unexplained renal failure; and that he had remained admitted in
Government Medical College Jammu; that the Consultant Dr. Raju K Bhandari
on 10.02.2026 had reported that ‘the petitioner has been suffering from renal
disfunction for more than three years, it has now progressed to chronic kidney
disease, a life-long disease, that the patient can be brought from custody to OPD
for examination and treatment’.
17.
The petitioner has placed on record the medical record of Government
Medical College and Hospital, Jammu in support of his contentions, which
reveals that the petitioner has been suffering from the aforestated diseases,
which require treatment. In view of serious ailments, the treatment of the
aforesaid diseases, in the considered opinion of this court, is not possible to the
petitioner as an accused under trial facing incarceration in jail and for that
matter, since the disease is life threatening, he is required to be admitted to bail
for getting him treated at his own. In view of the judgments referred, the rigor of
the Section 37 of NDPS Act applicable to the bails shall not be an impediment
for grant of bail on such a serious medical condition of which the petitioner has
been suffering.
18.
Having regard to the law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court and the
Delhi High Courts in the cases referred above, the allegations and objections
filed by the Investigating Agency, and considering the nature of the offences
Bail App No.60/2026
with which the applicant has been charged, and especially the medical
conditions of the petitioner that in case he does not get the treatment which is
not provided in custody, it can be life threatening, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the applicant is entitled to be admitted to bail. It will be in the
interest of justice if the interim bail granted to the applicant is made absolute,
until completion of the trial.
19.
In the aforesaid backdrop of the matter, the law cited hereinabove, in view
of the facts and circumstances of the case on hand, the bail application is
allowed and the interim bail granted to the petitioner/applicant vide order dated
06.04.2026 is made absolute, subject to all the conditions therein.
20.
The bail application is, allowed, along with connected application(s)
(M A Chowdhary)
Judge
JAMMU
16 .07.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
Raj Kumar
2026.07.16 18:04
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Bail App No.60/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review