Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 19
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.101/2022
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Mohd. Bashir age 72 years
S/o Abdul Rehman.
Tobia Akhtar age 20 years.
Sadia Akhtar age 17 years.
Muskan Akhtar age 15 years
Daughters of Ltd. Mohd
Ramzan through her sister
Tobia Akhtar petitioner No.2
Mohd. Imran age 13 years
S/o ltd. Mohd Ramzan
(petitioners No.3,4 and 5
through their sister Tobia
Akhtar petitioner no.2)
Jamila Akhtar age 55 years
w/o Ltd. Mohd. Kabir
All residents of village
Badakana Tehsil
Thannamandi District
Rajouri.
…..Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Sahil Sharma, Advocate
Vs
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Union Territory of J&K, through
Commissioner/Secretary
Department of Rural Development
Department, J&K Government,
Civil Secretariat,
Jammu/Srinagar.
Commissioner/Secretary R&B
Department, J&K Government,
Civil Secretariat,
Jammu/Srinagar.
Chief Engineer, R&B Department,
Jammu.
Director, Rural Development
Department, Jammu.
District Development
Commissioner (Deputy
Commissioner), Rajouri.
Assistant Commissioner
Development, Rajouri.
Block Development Officer,
Palanger, Tehsil Thanamandi,
Rajouri.
8.
9.
10.
WP(C) No.101/2022
Executive Engineer, R&B,
Rajouri.
S.H.O. Police Station,
Thanamandi, Rajouri (now
deleted)
Custodian Evacuee Property,
Jammu.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Ms. Jagmeet Kour, Advocate vice
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG for R-1, 4, 6 & 7.
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG for R-2, 3 & 8.
Ms. Priyanka Bhat, Assisting Counsel to
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG for R-5.
None for others.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
13.07.2026
1.
As per the note of the Registry, notices issued to the respondent Nos.12 to 15
through registered post on 23.04.2025 have not been received back served or unserved. Statutory period is over. No one has caused appearance on their behalf.
They are, accordingly, set ex-parte.
2.
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, learned AAG appearing on behalf of the respondent
Nos.2, 3 & 8 fairly submits that the said respondents have been inadvertently
arrayed as party respondents in the present petition. He, therefore, prays that
respondent Nos.2, 3 & 8 be struck off from the array of the respondents.
His statement is taken on record, which is not objected by the learned counsel for
the petitioners. Accordingly, respondent Nos.2, 3 & 8 are struck off from the array
of respondents as they are not necessary parties.
3.
The instant writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, whereby the petitioners seek issuance of the following reliefs:-
WP(C) No.101/2022
a. A writ of Mandamus directing the respondent Nos.1 to 8 not to
construct road without adopting the due course of law and
acquiring the land bearing Khasra No.352 measuring 27 Kanals
18 Marlas situated at village Badakana Tehsil Thannamandi
Rajouri on the instance of private respondents.
b. A writ of Mandamus directing the official respondents to protect
the land bearing Khasra No.352 measuring 27 Kanals 18 Marlas
situated at village Badakana tehsil Thannamandi in its original
shape and not to convert for any other purpose than agriculture,
land being Brayal Abal and also not to damage in any manner
the house of the petitioners.
4.
The facts, which emerge from the filing of this petition are that the
petitioners are in continuous cultivating possession of land bearing Khasra No.352
measuring 27 Kanals and 18 marlas, at village BadaKana, Tehsil Thannamandi,
District Rajouri. It is averred that prior to the petitioners, their ancestors have
remained in possession and cultivation of the aforesaid land since time
immemorial. According to the petitioners, the land is recorded as Shamlat Deh and
was initially entered in the revenue records in the name of one Nabu as a
cultivating share-holder, who migrated to Pakistan in the year 1965. Upon his
migration, a portion of the land was allotted to Shah Mohd and Mohd Alam, sons
of Roshan Din, residents of Panjgrain. However, upon the government discovering
that the said land allottees were suspects and had been sent back to the border area,
the allotment was withdrawn.
5.
It is further averred that, under the Depopulation Scheme, the aforesaid land
was restored in favour of Abdul Rehman, S/o Sunju Kashmiri (the
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners) by way of symbolic delivery of
possession through proclamation, digging and ploughing, which was duly recorded
vide Order No. 171/AC dated 7-6-1968 passed by the Tehsildar, Rajouri, in respect
WP(C) No.101/2022
of khasra No. 352 measuring 27 kanal 18 marlas. Although the ownership column
of the revenue record reflects the land as Shamlat Deh, yet the petitioners claim that
being the legal heirs and successors of Abdul Rehman, they have stepped into his
shoes and are entitled to all rights flowing from such possession. It is further
pleaded that Abdul Rehman was the father of petitioner No.1, the father-in-law of
petitioner No.6 and the grandfather of petitioner Nos.2 to 5. The petitioners assert
that they have remained in uninterrupted possession and cultivation of the land as
well as the residential house situated thereon, which is reflected in the revenue
records including the latest Khasra Girdawari for kharif 2021.
6.
It is the specific case of the petitioners that respondent Nos.2 & 3 had
constructed a road through a portion of their land approximately ten years ago by
assuring them that they would be duly compensated and that appropriate
arrangements would be made for the flow of water from the road towards their
agricultural land. According to the petitioners, the said construction resulted in the
utilization of approximately 2 kanal of their agricultural land for the purpose of a
link road, leading to mohalla Javed Ahmed.
7.
The petitioners further allege that the private respondents, in connivance
with the respondents Nos. 6 and 7 and at the behest of respondent no. 11, who was
formerly the Sarpanch and is presently a member of the Panchyat, subsequently
constructed another road connecting the main road to Thannamndi through the land
of the petitioners, thereby occupying more than 01 Kanal of land without following
the due process of law or acquiring the same in accordance with law. It is pleaded
that the petitioners brought the matter to the notice of respondent No. 10 by way of
an application dated 04-11-2020. It is further alleged that, during construction of
the said road, debris was dumped upon the petitioners’ land and no retaining wall,
WP(C) No.101/2022
cross-drainage or other protective measures were provided, resulting in damage to
their agricultural land.
8.
In support of their case, the petitioners have placed reliance upon a
communication dated 04.11.2020 issued by respondent No.10, namely, the Deputy
Custodian Evacuee Property, Jammu, whereby the Tehsildar, Thannamandi, was
directed to prevent encroachment and trespass over the land in question and to take
appropriate action against the persons responsible. It has also been pleaded that
respondent No. 10 vide communication dated 18-02-2021, requested respondent
No.9-SHO, Police Station, Thanamandi Rajouri to register an FIR against the
private respondents. However, as no action was allegedly taken pursuant thereto,
the petitioners were constrained to institute the present writ petition. The record
further reveals that respondent No.9 has since been deleted from the array of
respondents. It has also been alleged that private respondent No.12 and the father of
respondent Nos.13 & 14 are attempting to encroach upon the petitioners’ land.
In this regard, the petitioners claim to have approached the Custodian General, who
is stated to have directed that the un-authorized occupation of the land be
regularized by granting a lease in favour of the petitioners for a period of 40 years.
9.
The petitioners further contend that the respondents have no authority in law
to interfere with their possession or make use of the land in question without
following the due process of law including acquisition of the land, wherever so
required, in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions.
10.
Reply has been filed on behalf of the respondent Nos. 2, 3 & 8, wherein a
specific objection has been taken by the respondents, controverting the averments
made by the petitioners. The stand taken by the said respondents, particularly in
WP(C) No.101/2022
Paragraph No. 2 of the objections, substantially refutes the case set up by the
petitioners. The said Paragraph No. 2 of the objections is reproduced hereunder:“That in response to the relevant Para’s sought for by the petitioners
and related contentions/assertions made in Para’s of the writ
petition. It is respectfully submitted that as per the record of the
office of Executive Engineer, PWD (R&B) Division Rajouri, no
such, road was/is being constructed by Public Work Department and
the road mentioned in the writ petition pertains to REW i.e., Rural
Development Department. The petitioners have wrongly arrayed the
answering respondents as party respondents in the writ petition and
no cause of action has accrued against the answering respondents.”
11.
In addition to the above, a separate reply has been filed on behalf of the
respondent No.5. In paragraph 6 of the said reply, respondent No.5 has taken the
following stand, which is reproduced hereunder:“That a detailed report in the matter was sought from Tehsildar
Thannamandi who vide his office No. PS/TMD/94 dated 25.08.2023
reported that he along with revenue filed staff visited the spot and
found that a road constructed by Public Works Department is
Thannamandi who vide his office No. PS/TMD/94 dated 25.08.2023
reported that he along with revenue filed staff visited the spot and
found that a road constructed by Public Works Department is
passing through the aforementioned Khasra Number which as
stated by the petitioner in this Para has been constructed more than
10 years back and the land occupied by the said road is measuring
01 Kanal and 07 Marlas. Further, a tractor road measuring 09
Marlas has been found constructed by private persons and not by
the governmental agencies and also, a third road measuring 08
Marlas has been found to be constructed by the private persons and
not by the Government department (s). Rest of the area is under the
possession of Mohammad Bashir Shawl, Mohammad Ramzan
Shawl sons of Abdul Rehman and Mst Jamila Begum Wd/o Mohd
WP(C) No.101/2022
Kabir. The report of Tehsildar Thannamandi dated 25.08.2023
along with Sketch depicting the roads and rest of the area.”
12.
A detailed reply has also been filed on behalf of respondent Nos. 1, 4, 6 & 7,
wherein the said respondents have controverted the averments made by the
petitioners. It has been specifically pleaded that the allegation of the petitioners that
the said respondents are in the process of constructing another road connecting the
main road to Thannamandi through the land of the petitioners, is factually incorrect
and misconceived. It has been stated that neither any such road has been
constructed by the said respondents nor there is any proposal for undertaking
construction of any road through the land belonging to the petitioners.
13.
The aforesaid stand has further been substantiated by the report of the
Village Level Worker (VLW), wherein it has been reported that no such
construction has been carried out by the said respondents over the land of the
petitioners. The said respondents have also categorically denied the allegations of
interference with or encroachment upon the land of the petitioners, as alleged in the
present writ petition.
14.
The record further reveals that a separate reply has been filed on behalf of
respondent Nos. 10 and 11, wherein the said respondents have taken a specific
stand that the land in question measuring 27 Kanals and 18 Marlas, falling under
Khasra No. 352 situated at Village Badakana, Tehsil Thannamandi, District
Rajouri, was found to be under unauthorized possession of the petitioners. It has
been pleaded that after following the due process of law, the said land was allotted
in favour of the petitioners by the Custodian General, Evacuee Property, J&K
Government vide order dated 01.01.2015 for agricultural purposes, subject to
payment of the requisite premium and rent.
15.
WP(C) No.101/2022
It has further been submitted that the alleged illegal interference by certain
persons over a portion of the aforesaid evacuee land including the alleged
construction of a road without following due process of law, was brought to the
notice of the Deputy Custodian concerned, who, in turn, took up the matter with the
Revenue and Police authorities for ensuring protection of the said evacuee land. It
has been further stated that insofar as the Evacuee Property Department is
concerned, it has no role to play in respect of the issues raised in the present writ
petition.
16.
The said respondents have also categorically denied the averments and
allegations made by the petitioners and have asserted that the case projected by the
petitioners in the present writ petition is factually incorrect and devoid of merit.
17.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioners as well as learned
counsel representing the respondents and perused the record of the case with due
consideration. With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the instant
petition is taken up for disposal.
18.
A perusal of the pleadings on record reveals that the petitioners, through the
medium of the present writ petition, have raised disputed questions of fact, which
cannot be adjudicated upon while exercising the extraordinary writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Consequently, the present writ
petition, being devoid of merit, is liable to be dismissed at the threshold.
19.
Even otherwise also, on merits, the assertions made by the petitioners stand
controverted by the consistent stand taken by the official respondents in their
respective replies. The respondents have categorically maintained that no road has
been constructed by the Government authorities over the land in question, and
WP(C) No.101/2022
therefore, the question of payment of any compensation or seeking consent of the
petitioners does not arise.
20.
This Court finds it appropriate to refer to the stand taken by respondent
No. 5, who has placed reliance upon the report submitted by the Tehsildar,
Thannamandi, dated 25.08.2023. As per the said report, the Tehsildar, along with
the revenue officials inspected the spot and found that a tractor road measuring 09
Marlas had been constructed by private persons and not by any Government
agency. It was further reported that another road measuring 08 Marlas had also
been constructed by private persons and not by any Government department(s).
21.
The aforesaid report dated 25.08.2023 alongwith the sketch depicting the
roads and the remaining area, has been placed on record by respondent No. 5 along
with the detailed reply. The said material on record supports the stand taken by the
respondents and does not substantiate the allegations levelled by the petitioners in
the present writ petition.
22.
In addition to the above, the stand taken by respondent Nos. 1, 4, 6 and 7
also negates the case set up by the petitioners. The stand of the said respondents is
in consonance with the position projected by the other respondents, wherein it has
been specifically stated that neither the said respondents have constructed any road
over the land of the petitioners nor there is any proposal for construction of any
such road through the said land.
23.
In view of the aforesaid stand taken by the respondents vis-à-vis the
allegations levelled by the petitioners, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the averments made in the writ petition are not supported by any cogent or
convincing documentary evidence. The relief sought by the petitioners is based on
the apprehension that the respondents may construct a road over the land in
WP(C) No.101/2022
question without following the due process of law; however, the respondents have
categorically denied the existence of any such proposal or construction activity
over the land of the petitioners. Thus no alleged cause of action has accrued to the
petitioners to file the instant petition which is premature and based on mere
apprehension is not maintainable.
24.
Thus, upon a careful consideration of the pleadings and the material
available on record, coupled with the consistent stand taken by the respondents, this
Court finds that the present writ petition is not maintainable and the same is
premature being devoid of merit, and not supported by any substantive evidence to
substantiate the allegations made therein. Accordingly, the same is dismissed along
with all connected application(s), if any, without any order as to costs.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
Jammu
13.07.2026
Shammi
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review