Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No. 33/2026
CM No. 3958/2026
CM No. 2924/2026
Reserved on:
11.08.2026
Pronounced on:
20.08.2026
20.08.2026
Uploaded on:
Operative part or full judgment:
Mohd. Asgar @ Tola,
S/O Bashir Ahmed,
Through his wife, Naseem Choudhary,
R/O Ward No. 3, Der Chowadi,
Tehsil Bahu, District Jammu.
Full
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Pranav Kohli, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Aftab Malik, Adv.
Vs.
1. UT of Jammu & Kashmir through
Principal Secretary to Govt., Home Deptt.
Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2. District Magistrate, Jammu.
3. Senior Superintendent of Police, Jammu.
Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Pawan Dev Singh, Dy. AG
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Petitioner-Mohd. Asgar @ Tola earlier challenged his
detention order No. PSA 32 of 2023 dated 24.11.2023
issued by respondent No. 2-District Magistrate, Jammu, at
pre-execution stage, by filing a petition HCP No. 130/2024,
which was dismissed by this Court vide order dated
HCP No. 33/2026
07.03.2025. Against the said dismissal order, the petitioner
preferred LPA before the Division Bench of this Court
which, vide order dated 20.05.2026, also dismissed the
appeal for non-prosecution.
02.
Through the medium of the instant Habeas Corpus
Petition, filed through his wife Naseem Choudhary, the
petitioner-Mohd. Asgar @ Tola (hereinafter called ‘detenue’)
seeks quashment of Order No. PSA 32 of 2023 dated
24.11.2023 (hereinafter called ‘detention order’) passed by
the
respondent
No.
2-District
Magistrate,
Jammu
(hereinafter called ‘detaining authority’) whereby and
whereunder in terms of Section 8(1)(a) of the Jammu and
Kashmir Public Safety Act (for short, PSA), he had been
ordered to be detained under preventive detention, in order
to prevent him from acting in any manner, prejudicial to
the ‘maintenance of public order’.
03.
The impugned detention order has been challenged mainly
on the grounds, firstly that the grounds of detention are
vague, mechanical and based merely upon registration of
FIRs which do not disclose any activity prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order; secondly that there is no
proximate link between the prejudicial activities and the
detention order and the same was based on stale reference
of FIRs, thirdly that the detenue has not been informed
HCP No. 33/2026
about his right to make effective representation to the
Government as well as to the detaining authority.
04.
Pursuant to notice, the respondents have filed the counter
affidavit, asserting therein that upon receipt of the dossier
and the relevant material, the detaining authority, after
examining the record and being satisfied that the activities
were prejudicial to the maintenance of public order, passed
the impugned detention order; that as many as eight
criminal cases have been registered against the petitioner,
which clearly belie and negate the claim of the petitioner,
enjoying a good reputation in society; that the impugned
detention order has been passed strictly in accordance with
the provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety
Act, 1978; that all the constitutional and statutory
safeguards have been observed in letter and spirit; that the
detenue was a threat to the maintenance of public order
due to his involvement in various cases, enumerated in the
Police dossier, which have been based as grounds for his
detention. Lastly, it is prayed that the impugned detention
order be upheld and the petition filed by the detenue, being
devoid of any merit and substance, be rejected.
05.
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
argued
that
the
impugned detention order was issued on 24.11.2023 and
the same was executed on 23.04.2026, as such, the
HCP No. 33/2026
impugned detention is liable to be quashed; that four FIRs
registered before 2014 wherein detenue was also one of the
accused being stale having no proximate link with the
detention order and the three FIRs registered in the year
2021, 2022 and 2023 regarding property disputes within
the family /close relatives where the complainants were the
cousins of the detenue have also been quashed on the basis
of the compromise settled between the parties outside the
court
and
the
said
fact
has
not
been
taken
into
consideration by the detaining authority while issuing the
detention order, which shows non-application of mind on
the part of the detaining authority; that the representation
filed by the petitioner on 23.04.2026 has been rejected by
the authorities without application of mind.
Lastly, it is
prayed that the impugned detention order be quashed.
06.
Learned counsel for the respondents ex adverso argued that
the detention order, which was challenged by the detenue
at pre-execution stage, has been rejected by this court vide
order dated 07.03.2025; that against the said dismissal
order, the petitioner preferred LPA before the Division
Bench of this Court which, vide order dated 20.05.2026,
also dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution; that the
detenue had been absconding and evading arrest, as such,
proceedings under the relevant provisions of law were
HCP No. 33/2026
initiated against the detenue and only after his arrest,
detention warrant was executed on the detenue, therefore,
the delay in the execution of the detention order was solely
attributable to the conduct of the petitioner in absconding
and evading arrest and not to any inaction or lapse on the
part of the respondents; that no safeguards have been
violated while issuing the detention order; that the
detaining authority after drawing subjective satisfaction
that the detenue poses a serious threat to society and is
prejudicial to the maintenance of public order, detention
order was passed. Lastly, it is prayed that the petition be
dismissed.
07.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the detention
record and considered.
08.
Detenue was ordered to be detained in preventive custody
vide impugned order, conveyed to him vide communication
dated 24.11.2023, informing him that he can make a
representation
against
the
detention
order
to
the
Government, if he so desired.
09.
The impugned detention order was passed by District
Magistrate to prevent the detenue from acting in any
manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order,
while making reference to his earlier involvement in as
many as eight criminal cases registered vide FIR No.
HCP No. 33/2026
259/2002, FIR No. 119/2011, FIR No. 105/2012, FIR No.
39/2014, FIR No. 45/2021, FIR No. 182/2021, FIR No.
120/2022, FIR No. 174/2023, at Police Stations Trikuta
Nagar, and Channi Himmat from the year 2002 to 2022.
10.
So far as the first ground of challenge that the grounds of
detention are vague, mechanical and based merely upon
registration of the FIRs, which do not disclose any activity
prejudicial to the maintenance of public order is concerned,
in this regard, it is to be noted that in the grounds of
detention, reference is made to as many as eight FIRs viz.,
FIR No. 259/2002, FIR No. 119/2011, FIR No. 105/2012,
FIR No. 39/2014, FIR No. 45/2021, FIR No. 182/2021, FIR
No. 120/2022, FIR No. 174/2023 with the accusation that
the activities of the petitioner are prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order.
11.
It
has
been contended
by
learned counsel for
the
respondents that the petitioner poses a serious threat and
he has no respect for the law and his continuous
criminal/anti-social
activities
are
prejudicial
to
the
maintenance of public order in the area and his repeated
involvement in such offences clearly demonstrates his
criminal propensity and disregard for the law.
12.
It would be useful to refer all the cases alleged to have been
registered against the detenue over a period of two decades
HCP No. 33/2026
from the year 2002 to 2022. First FIR No. 259/2002 related
to a murder of one Noor Ahmad, wherein he alongwith
some other accused was named as accused. This case
resulted into acquittal vide judgment dated 31.10.2007 of
all the seven accused including detenue by Sessions Court,
Jammu. Second FIR No. 119/2011 related to theft etc. and
finding no substance during investigation, his name was
cleared, as was evident from its Final Report No. 16/2014
against sole accused Mohd. Aziz. Third FIR No. 105/2012
related to attempt of murder by an unlawful assembly and
again his name was cleared during investigation, finding
his no involvement. In fourth FIR No. 39/2014, the detenue
was named as an accused for the commission of offences
punishable under Sections 429/342/382/147/148/506
RPC, however, investigation of the case was stayed by this
Court vide order dated 12.05.2014.
Fifth case was
registered vide FIR No. 45/2021 at Police Station Channi
Himmat regarding a land dispute on a complaint by his
cousin against the detenue and his close relatives of the
family. Sixth case was registered at the same Police Station
vide FIR No. 182/2021 for missing Latha and Masavi of the
revenue record, whose investigation was transferred to
Crime Branch of Police, however, petitioner had no role in
it, as he was not a revenue official, having custody of
record; that all the FIR Nos. 45/2021, 120/2022 and
HCP No. 33/2026
174/2023 filed by the cousin of the detenue were settled
amicably and quashed by this Court vide orders dated
01.07.2025, 19.11.2025 and 22.07.2025 respectively.
13.
Though all the FIRs registered from the year 2002 to 2022,
over a period of twenty years can’t be made basis to order
preventive detention, as all the cases even do not disclose
any instance of laws and order, much short of public order.
Detention on the apprehension of ‘public order’ can be
ordered, in view of the past track record of the detenue, but
in last twenty years, there was not a single instance of
throwing the tempo of public life out of gear to attract such
a stringent order.
14.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in K.K. Saravana Babu v. State
of Tamil Nadu & Anr., (2008) 9 SCC 89, while delineating
the distinction between “law and order” and “public order”,
observed in paragraph 31 as under:
“31. We have tried to deal with the important cases
dealing with the question of "law and order" and "public
order" right from the case of Romesh Thappar (supra) to
the latest case of R. Kalavathi (supra). This court has
been consistent in its approach while deciding the
distinction between `law and order' and `public order'.
According to the crystallized legal position, cases
affecting the public order are those which have great
potentiality to disturb peace and tranquillity of a
particular locality or in the words of Hidayatullah, J.
disturb the even tempo of the life of the community of
that specified locality.”
HCP No. 33/2026
15.
So far as second ground of challenge that there is no
proximate link between the prejudicial activities and the
detention order and the same was based on stale
reference of FIRs of 2002, 2011, 2012, 2014, 2021, 2022
and 2023 is concerned, the detaining authority, ought to
have considered this aspect of the matter, while passing
the
impugned
detention
order,
inasmuch
as,
the
detenue’s involvement has been shown in the aforesaid
FIRs, which ex facie shows that out of these FIRs
registered upto the year 2014, by all stretch of reference,
are too remote to be a live link to consider a case of
preventive detention of a person to be passed in the year
2023, and stale reference to have any nexus with the
grounds of detention, forming basis for subjecting the
detenue to preventive detention custody.
16.
In the case of “Sama Aruna Vs State of Telangana & Ors.,”
reported in (2018) 12 SCC 150 against a detention
order dated 23.11.2016 upheld by the High Court, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in an appeal came to
consider the relevance of 9 to 14 years’ old incidents
resulting in FIRs, through a grossly belated order of
detention. Paragraphs No. 16 & 17, being relevant are
extracted as under:-
HCP No. 33/2026
“16.
Obviously, therefore, the power to detain, under
the Act of 1986, can be exercised only for preventing a
person from engaging in, or pursuing or taking some
action which adversely affects or is likely to affect
adversely the maintenance of public order; or for
preventing him from making preparations for engaging in
such activities. There is little doubt that the conduct or
activities of the detenu in the past must be taken into
account for coming to the conclusion that he is going to
engage in or make preparations for engaging in such
activities, for many such persons follow a pattern of
criminal activities. But the question is how far back?
There is no doubt that only activities so far back can be
considered as furnish a cause for preventive detention in
the present. That is, only those activities so far back in
the past which lead to the conclusion that he is likely to
engage in or prepare to engage in such activities in the
immediate future can be taken into account. In Golam
Hussain alias Gama v. Commissioner of Police, Calcutta
and Ors. (1974)4 SCC 530, this Court observed as follows:
“5. No authority, acting rationally, can be satisfied,
subjectively or otherwise, of future mischief merely
because long ago the detenu had done something evil To
Rule otherwise is to sanction a simulacrum of a
statutory requirement. But no mechanical test by
counting the months of the interval is sound. It all
depends on the nature of the acts relied on, grave and
determined or less serious and corrigible, on the length
of the gap, short or long, on the reason for the delay in
taking
preventive
action,
like
information
of
participation being available only in the course of an
investigation. We have to investigate whether the causal
connection has been broken in the circumstances of
each case.
Suffice it to say that in any case, incidents which are
said to have taken place nine to fourteen years earlier,
cannot form the basis for being satisfied in the present
that the detenu is going to engage in, or make
preparation for engaging in such activities.
17.
We are, therefore, satisfied that the aforesaid
detention order was passed on grounds which are stale and
which could not have been considered as relevant for arriving
at the subjective satisfaction that the detenu must be
detained. The detention order must be based on a reasonable
prognosis of the future behavior of a person based on his
past conduct in light of the surrounding circumstances. The
live and proximate link that must exist between the past
conduct of a person and the imperative need to detain him
must be taken to have been snapped in this case. A
detention order which is founded on stale incidents,
must be regarded as an order of punishment for a crime,
HCP No. 33/2026
passed without a trial, though purporting to be an order
of preventive detention. The essential concept of
preventive detention is that the detention of a person is
not to punish him for something he has done but to
prevent him from doing it. See G. Reddeiah v.
Government of Andhra Pradesh and Anr. (2012) 2 SCC
389, and P.U. Iqbal v. Union of India and Ors. (1992) 1
SCC 434.”
17.
In the case of “Khaja Bilal Ahmed Vs State of Telangana &
Ors.,” (2020) 13 SCC 632 the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India again came up dealing with the case of preventive
detention based upon stale grounds. In this case, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India making reference to its
judgment in the case of Sama Aruna Vs State of
Telangana & Ors. (supra), held in paragraph No. 23,
which is beneficially extracted as follows:“………………….The satisfaction to be arrived at by the
detaining authority must not be based on irrelevant or
invalid grounds. It must be arrived at on the basis of
relevant material; material which is not stale and has a
live link with the satisfaction of the detaining authority.
The order of detention may refer to the previous criminal
antecedents only if they have a direct nexus or link with
the immediate need to detain an individual. If the
previous
criminal
activities
of
the
appellant
could
indicate his tendency or inclination to act in a manner
prejudicial to the maintenance of public order, then it
may have a bearing on the subjective satisfaction of the
detaining authority. However, in the absence of a clear
indication of a causal connection, a mere reference to the
pending
criminal
cases
cannot
account
for
the
requirements of Section 3. It is not open to the detaining
authority to simply refer to stale incidents and hold
them as the basis of an order of detention. Such stale
HCP No. 33/2026
material will have no bearing on the probability of the
detenu engaging in prejudicial activities in the future.”
18.
So far as third ground of challenge that the detenue has
not been informed about his right to make effective
representation to the Government as well as to the
detaining authority, it is established from the perusal of
record that detaining authority vide communication
dated 24.11.2023, had informed the detenue that he may
make representation to the detaining authority, and such
a representation can be made to the Government. The
same does not constitute a violation of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution. The constitutional guarantee of making a
representation is meaningful only when the detenue is
clearly informed of the authorities before whom such
representation can be made and the earliest opportunity
to
exercise
that
right.
Non-communication
of
this
valuable constitutional right deprives the detenue of an
effective opportunity to challenge the detention at the
earliest stage, thereby vitiating the detention order. Since
the procedural safeguards governing preventive detention
are mandatory and must be strictly complied with, such
observance does not vitiate the detention order illegal.
Therefore, this ground taken by the petitioner fails and is
rejected.
HCP No. 33/2026
19.
From the foregoing analysis of legal position, it is clear that
merely because the petitioner is alleged to be involved in as
many as eight FIRs is not a sufficient ground to invoke the
remedy of preventive detention, particularly, in a case
where the detaining authority has not recorded any
subjective satisfaction that such activities of the detenue
have either resulted or have the potential to lead to public
outrage.
The four FIRs registered before 2014 wherein
detenue was also one of the accused being stale having no
proximate link with the detention order and the three FIRs
registered in the year 2021, 2022 and 2023 regarding
property disputes within the family /close relatives where
the complainants were the cousins of the detenue and
those case emanated from the civil property dispute within
the family which have also been quashed on the basis of
the compromise settled between the parties outside the
court and there being no propensity of all the cases wherein
detenue was one of the accused to cause any public order,
the
impugned
order
of
detention
is,
therefore,
unsustainable in law on these grounds.
20.
As a sequel to the aforementioned discussion and
observations made hereinabove, the present petition is
allowed. Consequently, impugned detention order is
quashed. The detenue is directed to be released forthwith
HCP No. 33/2026
if not required in any other case(s). The detention record
be returned to the learned counsel for the respondents.
21.
Disposed of, accordingly.
(M A CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
JAMMU
20.08.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether order is speaking: Yes
Whether order is reportable: Yes
Raj Kumar
2026.08.20 16:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
HCP No. 33/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review