The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the appeal deserves to be partly allowed by modifying the impugned Judgment and Award. Hence, the following order: (i) The First Appeal is partly allowed. (ii) The Judgment and Award dated 29.06.2011 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Gangakhed in Land Acquisition Reference No.837 of 1997 is modified. (iii) The market value of the acquired land admeasuring 4 Hectares 41 R from Survey No.132 is determined at Rs.1,85,000/- (Rupees One Lakh Eighty-Five Thousand only) per Hectare. (iv) The claimants shall be entitled to all consequential statutory benefits on the enhanced compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. 905-FA-2244-2011.odt (v) The claimants shall be entitled to interest under Section 34 of the Act, strictly in accordance with the Full Bench decision in State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari, 2016 (3) Mh.L.J. 457. (vi) The remaining part of the Judgment and Award passed by the learned Reference Court shall remain unaltered. (vii) The modified award be drawn accordingly. (viii) The appellants-claimants shall pay the deficit Court fees, if any, on the enhanced compensation. (ix) S P Rane Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed of. [ SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE ]
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:41851
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
905 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2244 OF 2011
Mohd Ahmeduddin Faroqui S/o Mohd Afzaluddin Faroqui (died)
Through L.Rs. Mohd. Aliuddin Faroqui S/o. Mohd. Afzaluddin FaroquiAnd
Others
VERSUS
The State Of Mahrashtra And Others
……
Mr. M.P. Kale, Advocate for Appellants-Claimants
Mr. B.A. Shinde, AGP for Respondents No.1 and 2
Mr. S.G. Bhalerao, Advocate for Respondent No.3-Acquiring Body
……
CORAM : SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.
DATE
: 04 SEPTEMBER, 2026
PER COURT :
1.
Heard the learned counsel for the respective parties.
2.
By this appeal, the appellants-original claimants challenge the
Judgment and Award dated 29.06.2011 passed by the learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Gangakhed in Land Acquisition Reference No.837 of 1997.
By the impugned Judgment and Award, the learned Reference Court
enhanced the compensation by 50% over and above the amount mentioned
in Column No.13 of the 'E' Statement. The claimants seek further
enhancement.
3.
The land belonging to the claimants, admeasuring 4 Hectares 41 R,
from Survey No.132, was acquired for the purpose of construction of
Government offices and quarters. The notification under Section 4 of the
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was published on 18.05.1989. The Special Land
Acquisition Officer passed the award under Section 11 of the Act on
14.12.1993 and awarded total compensation of Rs.2,12,297/-, including
solatium and interest. The claimants received the said amount under protest
and reserved their right to seek enhancement. Accordingly, the claimants
sought a reference under Section 18 of the Act.
4.
Before the learned Reference Court, the claimants relied upon the
sale instance at Exhibit 29. The said sale instance relates to 600 sq. ft. of
land from Survey No.128/1, which was sold for a consideration of
Rs.3,000/-. The claimants also relied upon the 7/12 extract at Exhibit 28,
map at Exhibit 52, the award passed by the Special Land Acquisition Officer
at Exhibit 95 and the 'E' Statement at Exhibit 96.
5.
Before the learned Reference Court, the case of the claimants was
that Survey No.128 and Survey No.132 are adjoining lands. It was
contended that, though the acquired land continued to be recorded as
agricultural land, the adjoining area had already been developed and the
acquired land had non-agricultural potentiality. The claimants therefore
contended that the market value ought to be assessed on the basis of the
sale instance at Exhibit 29.
6.
The learned Reference Court, however, did not determine the market
value on the basis of the sale instance at Exhibit 29 and instead enhanced
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
the compensation by 50% over and above the amount awarded by the
Special Land Acquisition Officer. Being dissatisfied with the quantum of
compensation so awarded, the claimants have preferred the present appeal.
7.
Learned counsel Mr. M.P. Kale, appearing for the appellants-
claimants, submits that the learned Reference Court has failed to properly
appreciate the sale instance at Exhibit 29. He submits that the sale instance
relates to Survey No.128/1, which is adjoining the acquired Survey No.132,
and the map at Exhibit 52 clearly demonstrates the proximity of the two
lands. He further submits that the acquired land was situated in a developed
area and was acquired for construction of Government offices and quarters.
Merely because the land was not formally converted into non-agricultural
use, its non-agricultural potentiality could not have been ignored. According
to him, the surrounding area was already developed and, therefore, the
market value of the acquired land ought to have been assessed with
reference to the comparable sale instance.
8.
Learned counsel fairly submits that, considering the large extent of
the acquired land and its agricultural character, appropriate deductions may
be made from the rate reflected in the sale instance. However, according to
him, even after such deductions, the appellants would be entitled to a
substantially higher rate than that determined by the learned Reference
Court. He therefore prays for further enhancement.
9.
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
Per contra, learned AGP appearing for Respondents No.1 and 2-State
and learned counsel Mr. S.G. Bhalerao appearing for Respondent No.3Acquiring Body support the impugned Judgment and Award. Learned
counsel for the Acquiring Body submits that the acquired land was
agricultural land on the date of publication of the Section 4 notification and,
therefore, its future development cannot be taken into consideration for
determining the market value. He relies upon Section 24 of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 in support of his submission.
10.
He further submits that the sale instance at Exhibit 29 cannot be
treated as a genuine and comparable sale instance. The transaction relates
only to a small plot admeasuring 600 sq. ft., whereas the acquired land
admeasures 4 Hectares 41 R. He submits that the small plot covered by the
sale instance was situated in a developed area and had the advantage of
road frontage, and therefore, the price fetched by it could not be equated
with the rate applicable to a large extent of agricultural land. According to
learned counsel, merely because Survey Nos.128 and 132 are adjoining, the
rate reflected in the sale instance cannot be mechanically applied to the
acquired land. He therefore submits that the enhancement already granted
by the learned Reference Court is reasonable and no further enhancement is
warranted.
11.
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
I have considered the submissions advanced by the learned counsel
for the respective parties and have gone through the Record and
Proceedings as well as the impugned Judgment and Award.
12.
There is no dispute that the land from Survey No.132 was acquired
for construction of Government offices and quarters. The relevant date for
determination of market value is the date of publication of the notification
under Section 4 of the Act.
13.
The claimants relied upon the sale instance at Exhibit 29 relating to
Survey No.128/1. The map at Exhibit 52 shows that Survey No.128 and
Survey No.132 are adjoining lands. Thus, the sale instance cannot be
discarded merely because it relates to a different Survey Number. Its
comparability, however, has to be examined having regard to the nature,
location and extent of the lands involved.
14.
The sale instance at Exhibit 29 relates to only 600 sq. ft. of land,
whereas the acquired land admeasures 4 Hectares 41 R. There is, therefore,
a substantial difference in the size of the land covered by the sale instance
and the acquired tract. At the same time, the location of the acquired land
and the material placed on record indicate that the adjoining area was
already developed. The acquired land, though agricultural on the relevant
date, had development potential having regard to its location and the
purpose for which it was acquired. Therefore, the sale instance at Exhibit 29
cannot be completely ignored. Appropriate deductions, however, are
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
necessary before applying the rate reflected therein to the large extent of
agricultural land.
15.
The learned counsel for the appellants-claimants had only submitted
that appropriate deductions could be made. The actual extent of deductions
is required to be determined on the facts and circumstances of the present
case. Having regard to the development required for utilization of the
acquired land, a deduction of 35% towards development charges is justified.
Further, considering that the sale instance relates to a very small plot of only
600 sq. ft., whereas the acquired land is a large tract admeasuring 4
Hectares 41 R, a further deduction of 30% on account of the small size of
the sale instance is warranted. Thus, the total deduction comes to 65%. The
calculation is as under:
Particulars
Calculation
Result
Area of sale instance
—
600 Sq. Ft.
Sale consideration
—
Rs.3,000/-
Rate per Sq. Ft.
Area of 1 Hectare
Rs.3,000 ÷ 600
—
Rs.5/107,639.10 Sq. Ft.
Deduction of 65%
Rs.5.00 × 65%
Rs.3.25 per sq. ft.
Balance rate after deduction
Rs.5.00 - Rs.3.25
Rs.1.75 per sq. ft.
1 Hectare
107,639.10 sq. ft.
—
Rate per Hectare
Rs.1.75 × 107,639.10
Rs.1,88,368.42
16.
Thus, on applying the aforesaid deductions to the rate of Rs.5/- per
sq. ft., the market value works out to approximately Rs.1,88,368/- per
Hectare. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, the same
is rounded off to Rs.1,85,000/- per Hectare.
17.
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
In my view, the learned Reference Court erred in not considering the
sale instance at Exhibit 29 for determination of the market value and in
restricting the enhancement merely to 50% over the compensation awarded
by the Special Land Acquisition Officer. The claimants are entitled to the
market value of the acquired land at Rs.1,85,000/- per Hectare.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the appeal deserves to be partly
allowed by modifying the impugned Judgment and Award. Hence, the
following order:
ORDER
(i)
The First Appeal is partly allowed.
(ii)
The Judgment and Award dated 29.06.2011 passed by the learned
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Gangakhed in Land Acquisition Reference
No.837 of 1997 is modified.
(iii)
The market value of the acquired land admeasuring 4 Hectares 41 R
from Survey No.132 is determined at Rs.1,85,000/- (Rupees One Lakh
Eighty-Five Thousand only) per Hectare.
(iv)
The claimants shall be entitled to all consequential statutory benefits
on the enhanced compensation in accordance with the provisions of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
905-FA-2244-2011.odt
(v)
The claimants shall be entitled to interest under Section 34 of the
Act, strictly in accordance with the Full Bench decision in State of
Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari, 2016 (3) Mh.L.J. 457.
(vi)
The remaining part of the Judgment and Award passed by the
learned Reference Court shall remain unaltered.
(vii)
The modified award be drawn accordingly.
(viii)
The appellants-claimants shall pay the deficit Court fees, if any, on
the enhanced compensation.
(ix)
S P Rane
Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed of.
[ SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE ]
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review