Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30107
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 462 OF 2019
AGAINST JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 28.01.2019 IN OS NO.6 OF 2014 OF
SUB COURT, VADAKARA
----APPELLANT/DEFENDANT:
MOHANDAS KARANDOTE PARAMBATH,
S/O. KANNAN KARANDOTE PARAMBATH, AGED 52 YEARS, RESIDING AT
KARANDOTE PARAMBATH HOSUE, MOKERI.P.O., MOKERI AMSOM,
KARANDOTE DESOM, VATAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
U.K.DEVIDAS
SRI.K.K.ANILRAJ
RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
JAMAL PAIKKATT
S/O. KUNHAMMAD, PAIKKAT, AGED 46 YEARS,
RESIDING AT PAIKKAT, KUMMANKODE AMSOM, NADAPURAM DESOM,
P.O. NADAPURAM, VATAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 504.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.B.KRISHNAN
SRI.P.B.SUBRAMANYAN
SRI.SABU GEORGE
SMT.B.ANUSREE
SRI.MANU VYASAN PETER
SMT.MEERA P.
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON 08.04.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:30107
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 8th day of April, 2025
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
The decree in a suit for money due under four
cheques (Exts.A1 to A4), was decreed by the trial court.
The defendant is in appeal.
2. According to the plaintiff, both the plaintiff
and the defendant were businessmen in Manama, Bahrain.
The
plaintiff
invested
money
in
the
gold
jewellery
business of the defendant at Manama. In August, 2013 the
plaintiff decided to withdraw his investment. It was
agreed to settle the account when the parties reach
India. In November 2013 when the parties were in India,
the accounts were settled and Exts.A1 to A4 cheques were
issued for ₹ 48 lakhs towards full and final settlement.
Exts.A1 to A2 cheques when presented, were dishonoured
for
the
reason
“account
blocked”
and
“funds
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 2 :-
insufficient”.
Ext.A3
cheque
was
returned
with
the
endorsement “funds insufficient”. It is thereupon that
the suit has been filed for realisation of ₹ 48 lakhs
with interest.
3. The defendant denied the plaint allegation that
he was doing business at Manama. He contended that he
did not have business. He was a gold smith and was an
employee
in
a
jewellery
shop.
The
plaintiff
never
invested any amount with the defendant. The plaintiff
was conducting chitty business without the sanction of
the Government. The defendant had joined in such Kuries
from the year 2006. Repayments of the chitty amounts
were noted down by the plaintiff in a paper maintained
by the defendant. The plaintiff used to obtain signed
cheques of the defendant as security for repayment of
the amounts due under the chitty transactions. Though
the chitty accounts were closed and the defendant sought
return of the cheques, the plaintiff informed that the
same were destroyed. Such cheques have been misused by
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 3 :-
the plaintiff, is the contention. The defendant denied
the issuance of the cheques and contended that they are
not supported by consideration.
4. The suit was originally dismissed by the trial
court.
The
plaintiff
challenged
the
same
in
appeal
before this Court, in RFA 422/2017. This Court held that
the defendant has admitted the issuance of the cheque,
more particularly the signatures in the cheque and hence
he is entitled for the presumption under Section 118(a)
of the Negotiable Instruments Act (for short, “N.I.
Act”). It was held that the burden is on the defendant
to rebut the presumption. Holding that the trial court
failed to draw the presumption, the decree and judgment
of the trial court were set aside and the suit was
remanded for fresh disposal.
5. After remand no further evidence was adduced by
either side. On appreciation of the evidence, the trial
court held that the defendant has failed to rebut the
presumption under Section 118(a) of the N.I. Act, and
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 4 :-
accordingly decreed the suit.
6. We have heard learned counsel on either side.
7. The points that arise for determination in this
appeal are:(i) Was the trial court right in having held that the defendant
failed to rebut the presumption under Section 118(a) of the N.I. Act?
(ii) Do the decree and judgment of the trial court warrant
any interference?
8. At paragraph 8 of the written statement it is
contended that, towards security for repayment of the
amount
due
under
cheques
of
the
the
Kuri
defendant
transaction,
were
entrusted
the
signed
with
the
plaintiff. It was also pleaded that the said cheques
given as security were misused by the plaintiff. The
relevant sentences in the said paragraph reads thus :“When bidding the kuries the plaintiff used to collect signed cheques of
this defendant as security for due payment of the balance amount. … Now
after getting summons in the case this defendant could learn that the
cheques, earlier given as security were misused by the plaintiff without
the knowledge and consent and concurrence of this defendant with sole
intention to make illegal gain. This defendant has not executed and issued
those cheques.”
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 5 :-
PW1 the plaintiff, when cross-examined, it has been
suggested to him that the blank cheques entrusted during
the period 2006-2010 for the Kuri transactions were
misutilised by him. The relevant sentence reads thus :“കറ ഇടപ ടൽ സ ക രറയ യ 2006 മതൽ 2010 കടയ ക ലത പത എനക
നൽക യ ബ ങ സ കകള ൽ പതയസട അറവ#
വക ളങള' Fill സ യ
മതവ% ഇല സത
'ഖ)യ' എസ* വപര'
present സ യത ണ. Ext.A1 മതൽ A4 കടയ
സ കകൾ എന പറഞ ൽ ശരയല.”
Similar is his stand as DW1. The signatures on Exts.A1
to A4 are admitted to be that of his. In the light of
the
judgments
of
the
Apex
Court
in
Bharat Barrel and
Manufacturing Company v. Amin Chand Payrelal (AIR 1999 SC 1008), Mallavarapu
Kasivisweswara Rao v. Thadikonda Ramulu Firm (2008 (7) SCC 655), when the
signature on the cheque is admitted, the plaintiff is
entitled for the presumption under Section 118(a) of the
N.I. Act. In matters under Section 139 of the N.I. Act,
the Apex Court in Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar (2019 (4) SCC 197) and
Dattatraya v. Sharanappa (2024 (8) SCC 573) held the same view. This
Court in the remand order in RFA 422/2017 also held that
the plaintiff is entitled for the presumption under
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 6 :-
Section 118(a) of the NI Act. Therefore, it is for the
defendant to rebut the presumption.
9. The presumption can be rebutted by the defendant
even relying on the evidence adduced by the plaintiff,
by disproving his case. It is not necessary that the
defendant should adduce evidence and rely upon the same
alone to rebut the presumption. In Regi Isac v. Philomina Pious
[MANU/KE/1840/2010] a Division Bench of this Court, after
referring to the judgments in Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. v.
Amin Chand Payrelal (1999 (3) SCC 35), Joseph v. Gladis Sasi 2010 (3) KLT 379,
Mallavarapu Kasivisweswara Rao v. Thadikonda Ramulu Firm (2008 (7) SCC 655),
M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala (2006 (6) SCC 39) held:“..... At the risk of repetition, one may notice that it may not be necessary
for the defendant to adduce evidence to show that the document is not
supported by consideration. He can rely on the evidence of the plaintiff
himself to show that the document is not supported by consideration.
Once that burden is discharged by the defendant, the onus of proof shifts
to the plaintiff.”
Once both sides have let in evidence, it is for the
Court
to
appreciate
the
same
and
find
if
the
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 7 :-
presumption has been rebutted, and if so, whether the
plaintiff has established his case entitling him for a
decree.
10. According to the plaintiff, he had invested
amounts with the defendant in his jewellery business.
In the year 2013, since the plaintiff did not intend to
proceed with the arrangement further, the accounts were
settled and Exts.A1 to A4 cheques were issued to him by
the defendant. The defendant denied that he had any
such business as claimed by the plaintiff. He contended
that he was only a
goldsmith in a jewellery shop.
Though the plaintiff as PW1 claimed that the defendant
was
the
owner
of
a
jewellery
shop,
in
the
latter
portion of his cross-examination he admitted that the
defendant was only an employee. He also stated that he
has
not
defendant.
seen
any
Ext.B1
business
or
shop
owned
by
the
is
evidence
given
by
the
the
plaintiff in the proceeding under Section 138 of N.I
Act relating to the cheques in question. Therein also
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 8 :-
he has admitted that the defendant is only an employee.
Therefore, the very contention of the plaintiff that
the defendant is doing business in gold and that the
plaintiff
invested
money
in
such
business
of
the
defendant, is disproved.
11. While appreciating the rival evidence, Ext.B2
series documents are of significance. Ext.B2 series are
certain
paper
slips
wherein
entered.
The
defendant
filed
certain
an
figures
application
as
are
IA
518/2015, delivering interrogatories to the plaintiff.
The interrogatories read thus:“1) Whether you are admitting your handwriting in the paper slips
produced along with the written statement as document No.1 to 4, 6 and
7?
2) According to you for what purpose you made such entries
against the receipt of money?
3) Have you seen any document showing that defendant is doing
or having any jewelry business elsewhere including Bahrain?”
To the same, the plaintiff replied admitting that Ext.B2
series is in his handwriting. He also stated that such
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 9 :-
entries were made towards the payment of share of profit
on his investment in the business with the defendant. As
PW1, in his cross-examination he has sated that the
profits
of
his
investment
with
the
business
of
the
defendant
was
being
gold
paid
jewellery
by
the
defendant once in a month or bimonthly or quarterly. In
Ext.B1 deposition he deposed that the payment of profits
was not on daily basis or not even on alternate days. He
deposed
“ദ #വ നവയ അവത ഒവന രവ6 ദ # ' ഇട#വ7 ഞ ൻ പതയൽ നന' ഞ ൻ പണ'
കകപറ റല.” However,
a perusal of Ext.B2 series reveal that
the entries therein are made almost on a daily basis.
This cuts at the very root of the plaintiff's case that,
the entries in Ext.B2 represents the payment of profits
towards his investment.
12. When the plaintiff admits that Ext.B2 is in his
own handwriting and that it represents the payment of
share of profits, the burden was heavy on him to explain
the inconsistency noted above. However, the plaintiff
has not attempted to do so. The trial court has found
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 10 :-
fault with the defendant for not having elicited from
the
plaintiff
the
purpose
behind
Ext.B2
and
the
inconsistencies in the entries in Ext.B2 series with the
case set up by the plaintiff. It was not something for
the defendant to question and elicit, but was for the
plaintiff to explain the incongruity. But he did not
even attempt the same. We are unable to agree with the
view adopted by the trial court. All that the defendant
had to do was to bring out materials to demonstrate the
irreconcilability of the plaintiff’s case. The plaintiff
ought to have explained away the same, if he had any
explanation.
13. It is the plaintiff's case that, in August 2013
he decided to withdraw his investment and the defendant
informed him that the accounts can be settled while they
are
in
India,
since
his
investments
are
in
India.
Apparently the said reason is difficult to be accepted
when the parties had transactions abroad and according
to the plaintiff the defendant is a business man there
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 11 :-
at Manama.
14. The plaintiff claimed that the accounts were
settled in November, 2013 while both parties were in
India. According to him, on settlement of accounts it
was found that ₹ 50 lakhs is payable by the defendant to
the plaintiff. However, he accepted the defendants offer
to pay ₹ 48 lakhs in full and final settlement. The
relevant pleading in the plaint reads thus :“3. The Defendant arrived in India on 20.11.2013. The matter had been
talked over between the Plaintiff and the Defendant in the last week of
November, 2013. Eventually, it was fund that Rs.50,00,000.00 (Rupees
Fifty Lacs Only) in Indian Rupees is payable by the Defendnat to the
Plaintiff on account of the said business. On 28.11.2013 the Defendant
had offered to pay Rs.48,00,000.00 (Rupees Forty Eight Lacs Only) to the
Plaintiff in full and final settlement, in Indian Rupees. The Defendant had
also offered to make payment in four installments and had agreed that he
would issue and deliver post dated cheques in respect of the four
installments at once. Since the Defendant had agreed to issue such post
dated cheques at once, the Plaintiff had accepted the offer. …..”
As PW1 he would claim that the entire accounts for the
period from 2007-13 were settled between them and the
cheques were issued. However, in his cross-examination
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 12 :-
he would depose that the entire profits payable were
paid
by
the
principal
defendant
amount
earlier
remained
and
that
outstanding.
He
only
the
has
also
deposed that, there were no accounts to be settled. The
relevant portion of his deposition reads thus :“പത എനക തര നള ബ
നസലള മഴ#ൻ profit ഉ' പത എനക മമ തസന തന
തEർതരന. എനക മതൽ % തവ% ക7 ന6 യരനള. അന) യതല'
Eഫല' പറഞ
പക ര' എനക പതയ% യ settle സ യ ൻ അകKസ6 ന' ഉ6 യരന ല. അകK6
സ റൽ സ യ ൻ ഞ ൻ പതവയ ട ആ#ശ)സപ77ല. പതക ഞ ൻ അവങ 7 സക ടക ൻ ഒര
തകയ' ഉ6 യ7ല.”
Similar was his deposition in Ext.B1. He deposed
തര നള profit മഴ#ന യ' എല %
there
were
no
വ' അയ ൾ തന രന.”
accounts
to
be
“എനക
If that be so, then
settled
between
the
parties, and all that remained was, repayment of the
principal amount paid by the plaintiff to the defendant.
Therefore,
the
plaintiff's
case
that
the
defendant
wanted the accounts to be settled while he is in India
seem improbable.
15. So also, going by the plaintiff's case as is
evident
from
the
pleading
at
paragraph
of
the
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 13 :-
plaint(extracted
supra),
on
settlement
of
accounts
though it was found that the total amount payable by the
defendant
to
the
plaintiff
is
₹
lakhs,
as
a
concession, he agreed for a full and final settlement at
₹ 48 lakhs. However, in his further cross-examination he
would state that 2 lakhs was the amount to be given by
him to the defendant towards adjustment of profit. The
relevant deposition reads thus :“പതക ഞൻ
അവങ 7 സക ടക ൻ ഉ6 യരന തക സക ടക ന6 യത profit
adjustment വലക ര6 ലക' രപയ ണ, ര6 ലക' രപ സക ടക ൻ ഉ6 എനളത' 48
ലക' രപ ക 7 ന6 എന പരസര' കണക കഴച ണ %നസല കയത.”
This is apparently at variance from the pleading in the
plaint.
In
Ext.B1
deposition
also
at
page
the
plaintiff has deposed that, “പതക ഞ ൻ അവങ 7 സക ടക ൻ ഉ6 യരന തക
സക ടക ന6 യത profit
adjustment
വലക ര6 ലക' രപയ ണ.”
Therefore,
evidently the plaint case and the evidence does not
tally. The case of concession vanishes.
16. In the plaint it has not been pleaded as to how
much
amount
was
invested
by
the
plaintiff
in
the
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 14 :-
defendant's
business
and
also
as
to
when
such
investments were made. PW1 admitted that there is no
document evidencing the investment. He admitted that
there is no evidence with regard to the source of the
funds. He has also admitted that there is no document
evidencing
the
liability
of
the
defendant
to
the
plaintiff under the alleged investment. Similar was his
deposition in Ext.B1 also. It is to be noted that, the
amount claimed to have been paid to the defendant is not
too
small,
to
be
advanced
without
any
document
evidencing the same.
17.
witnessed
The
evidence
of
PW2,
who
claims
the
issuance
of
the
cheque
is
to
have
apparently
artificial. He claims to be a chance witness who went to
the house of the plaintiff for some other purpose and
happened
to
witness
the
issuance
of
the
cheques.
According to him, the plaintiff explained to him of the
transactions between the plaintiff and the defendant and
the plaintiff had asked him to keep memory of the
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 15 :-
transaction in case necessity occurs. The evidence is
not at all reliable.
18. In the light of the irreconcilability in the
evidence of the plaintiff as above, we are of the
opinion that the defendant was able to dislodge the
presumption available to the plaintiff under Section
118(a)
of
rebutted,
the
it
N.I.Act.
was
for
Once
the
the
presumption
plaintiff
to
stands
prove
the
transaction as pleaded by him. The plaintiff failed in
the said regard. We are unable to agree with the finding
of the trial court that the defendant failed to rebut
the presumption. The evidence on record is overwhelming
to hold otherwise. The finding of the trial court to the
contrary is liable to be set aside and we do so.
19. On the findings as above, the suit is bound to
fail.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. The decree and
judgment of the trial court are set aside. The suit will
stand dismissed. The appellant shall be entitled for the
R.F.A. No.462 of 2019
2025:KER:30107
-: 16 :-
costs in the appeal.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review