Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
#
#
$
$
$
$
%
!!
&!
')
!!
*
'
)
Digitally signed
by SACHIN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
! ""
#
"
$
&
'
%
#
%
'
(
# %
&
'
' )
"
# %
'
'!
(
-2-
*
$
' &
+
+
*#
%
#
'%
&
*
+
'
, -
-#
, -
-%
'
+
#
-
- %
)
'
,
- *
&
-
'
""
$
+
"
.
"
))
+
$
/
+$+
$
+
'
/
$
+
'
"
-
"
/
-3-
"
"
" 0 $
$ "
/
!
#
"
$ )
+
# %
))
# %1
" +
*/
)
)
"
$ )
-/
%
$
,-
)
)
$
"
-
"
$
) 2
)
*'
)
"
"
"
"
$
$"
"
/
""
#
"
+
&
$
%
'
'
(
# %
&
*
'
""
-4-
"
# %
'
*
$
' &
+
+
*#
%
#
'%
&
*
+
'
, '
-#
, -
-%
+
#
%
)
,
'
- *
&
-
'
""
$
.
"
))
/
+$ +
$
$
+
'
+
'
+
"
-5-
"
#
)
$
+
*
# %/
# %1
$
)
))
%
)
)
)
$
,-
$
-
'
"
)
"
'
)
""
-
$
) 3
"
'
)
""
)
'
)
$
$
-6-
$
#"
#
%
5676 89: ;<<6;=7 ;>6 ?@=6A BC A6?6DA;D8
>67<6E8@F6=C @D
AA@8@:D;=
:
6D@:>
@F@=
:7
;DA
:D 856 ?@=6 :? 856
GAH6 ;DA
)
;8
E5;==6DH@DH 856 IGAHJ6D8 ;DA A6E>66 A;86A
;@E5G>
-
BC 95@E5 856 7G@8 9;7 A6E>66A
56 <;>8@67 ;>6 56DE6?:>85 >6?6>>6A 8: ;7 856C
96>6 ;>>;C6A B6?:>6 856 8>@;=
*
7G@8
:G>8
@D
:
9;7
?@=6A
?:>
<;>8@8@:D ;DA 76<;>;86 <:77677@:D :? 856 <=;@D8@??(7 75;>6 @D
856 7G@847 7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@67
56 <=;@D8@?? E=;@J6A 85;8
756 ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8
;DA * ;>6 856 E5@=A>6D :?
5;@K5
;I@ ;DA
:7
;5B::B
6HGJ
56 E=;@J6A 85;8 756
5;A ?;@85 @D 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * 85;8 856C 9:G=A
J;D;H6 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67
:96F6> 856 7;@A A6?6DA;D87
5;A ;=@6D;86A ;DA 6DEGJB6>6A <:>8@:D7 :? 856 7G@8
<>:<6>8@67 @D ?;F:G> :? 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
-
;DA
-7-
56 856>6?:>6 A6J;DA6A ; 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67
95@E5 956D >6?G76A E:J<6==6A 56> 8: 7G6 ?:> <;>8@8@:D
#@%
56 A6?6DA;D8
:7
;DA * B6@DH 856 7@B=@DH7
:? 856 <=;@D8@??
E:D86786A 856 7G@8
;AJ@886A 85;8
J8
*
,
65B::B
56 A6?6DA;D8
:
6HGJ 856 J:856> A@6A :D
BG8 E=;@J6A 85;8 756 5;A :>;==C H@?86A 6;786>D
<:>8@:D :?
C
:*
J6;7G>@DH * ;E>67 8: 56> ;DA 85;8
756 8::K :F6> <:77677@:D :? 856 7;J6
J8
65B::B
B6;>@DH
C
6HGJ 5;A ;=7: H@?86A 856 6D8@>6 =;DA
:
;DA 856 >6J;@D@DH <:>8@:D :?
8: 856 A6?6DA;D8
<:77677@:D
56 E=;@J6A 85;8
: * @D 856 C6;>
56>6;?86>
;EE:>A@DH=C JG8;86A
,,
C
:*
;DA 5;A A6=@F6>6A
>6F6DG6
>6E:>A7
96>6
56>6?:>6 @8 9;7 E:D86DA6A 85;8 856
<=;@D8@?? E;DD:8 7G6 ?:> <;>8@8@:D :? 56> 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8
<>:<6>8@67 ;7 @8 5;A B6E:J6 856 ;B7:=G86 <>:<6>8@67 :? 856
A6?6DA;D8
#@@%
65B::B
:7
;DA *
A6?6DA;D8
:*
6HGJ A@6A :D *
E:D86DA6A
,
85;8
J8
;DA AG>@DH 56>
-8-
=@?68@J6 756 5;A :>;==C B6LG6;856A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 @D
5@7 ?;F:G> @D 856 C6;>
,,
;DA ?>:J 856D 56 9;7 856 ?G==
;DA ;B7:=G86 :9D6> :? 856 <>:<6>8C 7: B6LG6;856A ;DA
85;8 5@7 D;J6 9;7 6D86>6A @D 856 >6F6DG6 >6E:>A7 @D 856
C6;> ,,
6 E=;@J6A 85;8 56 7:=A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8C 8: 856
A6?6DA;D8
: - :D
:7
;DA
,
@K69@76
856 A6?6DA;D8
;=7: 7:=A 856@> 75;>67 8: 856 A6?6DA;D8
:-
9>@886D
A6?6DA;D8
:
;=7:
?@=6A
;
78;86J6D8 :D 7@J@=;> =@D67 ;7 856 9>@886D 78;86J6D8 ?@=6A BC
856 A6?6DA;D8
: * ;DA E=;@J6A 85;8 56 5;A <G>E5;76A -
;E>67 *- HGD8;7 :? =;DA @D
: * :D
-
C
:*
?>:J 856 A6?6DA;D8
56 A6?6DA;D8
:
A6D@6A 856
;F6>J6D87 :? 856 <=;@D8 ;DA E:D86DA6A 85;8 856 <=;@D8@??
;DA A6?6DA;D87
:7
;DA
:? 856 7G@8 =;DA B6;>@DH
C
96>6 D6F6> @D I:@D8 <:77677@:D
:
6 E=;@J6A 85;8 <=;@D8@??
5;A KD:9=6AH6 :? 856 ?;E8 85;8 56> J:856> 5;A H@?86A 856
7G@8 =;DA @D
C
:
8: 856 A6?6DA;D8
: * ;DA 856>6?:>6
56 9;7 856 ?G== ;DA ;B7:=G86 :9D6> :? 856 7;@A <>:<6>8C
5G7 @8 @7 E:D86DA6A 85;8 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D87
-9-
:7
;DA
B6;>@DH
5;F6 D: >@H58
C
:
8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 @D =;DA
;DA 56DE6 856 7G@8 ?:> <;>8@8@:D 9;7 D:8
J;@D8;@D;B=6
-
56 A6?6DA;D87
:7 - ;DA
B6@DH <G>E5;76>7
;=7: ?@=6A 856 9>@886D 78;86J6D8 E:D86DA@DH 85;8 856 7G@8 @7
?@=6A 9@85 ;
@D86D8@:D 8: 6M<=:@8 856 7@8G;8@:D ;DA
6M8>;E8 ?>:J 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7 - ;DA
56C E=;@J6A 85;8
856C 5;A <G>E5;76A 856 <>:<6>8@67 ?:> F;=@A E:D7@A6>;8@:D
;DA 856>6?:>6 856 <=;@D8@?? @7 D:8 6D8@8=6A 8: ;DC 75;>6 @D
856 <>:<6>8C
;76A :D 85676 E:D86D8@:D7 8>@;=
:G>8 ?>;J6A
856 ?:==:9@DH @77G67
N
'56856> 856 <=;@D8@?? <>:F67 85;8 856 7G@8
7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@67 ;>6 856 <>:<6>8@67 :?
J8
65B::B 6HGJO
'56856> 856 <=;@D8@?? ?G>856> <>:F67 85;8
756 @7 @D I:@D8 <:77677@:D ;DA 6DI:CJ6D8 :?
7G@8
7E56AG=6
<>:<6>8C
;=:DH
9@85
A6?6DA;D87 : 8: *O
*
'56856> 856 <=;@D8@?? @7 6D8@8=6A ?:>
75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@67O
-85
- 10 -
'56856> 856 A6?6DA;D8 : * <>:F67 856
:>;= H@?8 7;@A 8: 5;F6 B66D 6M6EG86A BC =;86
;56B::B
6HGJ
@D
5@7
?;F:G>
B6LG6;85@DH <>:<6>8C B6;>@DH
C :*
J6;7G>@DH
, ;E>67
HGD8;7 ;DA
C :
J6;7G>@DH ;E>6 , HGD8;7O
'56856> 856 A6?6DA;D87 :7 ;DA - <>:F6
85;8 856C ;>6 856 B:D;?@A6 <G>E5;76>7 :?
856 <>:<6>8@67 ?>:J 856 *>A A6?6DA;D8 ?:> ;
F;=G;B=6 E:D7@A6>;8@:DO
-
'56856> 856 7G@8 @7 D:8 <>:<6>=C F;=G6A ?:>
856 <G><:76 :? :G>8 ?66 ;DA IG>@7A@E8@:D
;DA :G>8 ?66 <;@A @7 @D7G??@E@6D8O
'5;8 A6E>66 :> :>A6>O
AA=
77G6
'56856> 856 A6?6DA;D8 :
<>:F67 85;8
56 @7 856 B:D;?@A6 <G>E5;76> :? 7G@8
<>:<6>8C ?>:J A6?6DA;D8 : * ?:> F;=G;B=6
E:D7@A6>;8@:DOP
56 <=;@D8@?? 9;7 6M;J@D6A ;7 "'
J;>K6A
96>6
M7 "
8: "*
6M;J@D6A
A:EGJ6D87 ;7
56 A6?6DA;D8
;7
'7
M7
8:
A:EGJ6D8;>C 6F@A6DE6
8:
856 8>@;=
:7 *
;DA
856C
;DA 756
;DA
J;>K6A
;76A :D 856 :>;= ;DA
:G>8 56=A 85;8 856
<=;@D8@?? 5;A <>:F6A 85;8 756 9;7 6D8@8=6A 8: ; 75;>6 @D 856
7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 ;DA @8 ;=7: 56=A 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8:
- 11 -
* 96>6 D:8 ;B=6 8: 678;B=@75 856 :>;= H@?8 768 G< BC 856J
;==6H6A=C 6M6EG86A BC 856@> J:856> @D >67<6E8 :?
;DA
C
:7 *
8 856>6?:>6 A6E>66A 856 7G@8 ;DA A6E=;>6A 85;8 856
-85 75;>6 :G8 @D 856 7G@8 7E56AG=6
<=;@D8@?? @7 6D8@8=6A 8:
<>:<6>8@67
8 ;=7: 56=A 85;8 856 7;=6 A66A 6M6EG86A BC 856
A6?6DA;D8
:7
8:
@D ?;F:G> :? A6?6DA;D8
D:8 B@DA@DH :D 856 <=;@D8@??47
7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@67
:7
8:
;>6
-85 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8
6@DH ;HH>@6F6A BC 856 7;@A IGAHJ6D8
;DA A6E>66 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
;DA
;>6 B6?:>6 85@7
:G>8 @D 85676 89: ;<<6;=7
,
;DA
56 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
7GBJ@886A 85;8 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 96>6 =;9?G==C
<G>E5;76A BC 856J BC <;C@DH F;=@A E:D7@A6>;8@:D 8: 856
A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: *
6 856>6?:>6 E:D86DA6A 85;8 856
<=;@D8@?? E;DD:8 D:9 ;776>8 56> >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 8:
856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67
:7
6 ;=7: E:D86DA 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8
8: * 5;A 7<6E@?@E;==C E=;@J6A 85;8 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67
96>6 :>;==C B6LG6;856A BC 856@> J:856> @D ?;F:G> :? 856
A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * ;DA 856>6?:>6 856 8>@;=
:G>8 E:G=A
- 12 -
D:8
5;F6
=@H58=C
A6?6DA;D87
E:D7@A6>6A
6F@A6DE6
:?
6 E:D86DA7 85;8 856>6 @7 D: >6LG@>6J6D8 :?
=;9 8: H68 ;D :>;= H@?8 >6H@786>6A ;DA 5;F@DH >6H;>A 8: 856
>6F6DG6 >6E:>A7 @8 75:G=A B6 <>67GJ6A 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * 5;A B6E:J6 856 ?G== ;DA ;B7:=G86 :9D6>7 :? 856
7G@8 <>:<6>8C
856 A6?6DA;D8
56 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?G>856> 7GBJ@886A 85;8
:7
;DA
<>:<6>8@67 @D 856 C6;>
5;F6 <G>E5;76A 856 7G@8
-
<G>E5;76A @D 856 C6;>
95@=6 856 A6?6DA;D8
:
6 856>6?:>6 E:D86DA7 85;8
856 7G@8 ?@=6A @D 856 C6;>
@7 5@H5=C B6=;86A
856 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 =6H;=
>6<>676D8;8@F67 :? <=;@D8@?? E:D86DA7 85;8 856 <=;@D8@?? @7
6D8@8=6A 8: ;D GDA@F@A6A 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 ;?86>
856 A6;85 :? 56> ?;856> ;DA J:856>
6 ;=7: E:D86DA7 85;8
856>6 @7 D: <;>8@8@:D B68966D 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856
A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * ;>6
E=;@J@DH >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 @D 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8C B;76A
:D ;D ;==6H6A :>;= H@?8 6M6EG86A BC 856@> J:856>
E:D86DA7 85;8 ;?86> 856 A6;85 :? 856 ?;856> 856 J:856>
- 13 -
9;7 6D8@8=6A 8: ;D GDA@F@A6A 75;>6 ;DA 756 856>6?:>6 E:G=A
D:8 5;F6 B6LG6;856A :> H@?86A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67
856>6?:>6 E:D86DA7 85;8 856 @J<GHD6A IGAHJ6D8 ;DA
A6E>66 <;776A BC 856 8>@;=
A6?6DA;D8
:7
:G>8 @7 IG78 ;DA <>:<6> ;7 856
8: * 96>6 D:8 ;B=6 8: 678;B=@75 856
;==6H6A H@?8 ;DA ;77GJ@DH @? 856C 678;B=@756A 856 6M6EG8@:D
:? 856 :>;= H@?8 856 >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 :? 856 <=;@D8@??
9;7 D:8 ;??6E86A
'6
5;F6 E:D7@A6>6A
7GBJ@77@:D7 J;A6
BC
=6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 <=;@D8@?? ;7 96== ;7 856 =6;>D6A
E:GD76= ?:> 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
;DA
56 :D=C <:@D8 85;8 ;>@767 ?:> E:D7@A6>;8@:D @D
85@7 ;<<6;= @7
'56856> 856 8>@;=
:G>8 9;7 >@H58 @D A6E>66@DH 856
7G@8 :? 856 <=;@D8@?? ?:> <;>8@8@:DO
*
56 ?;E8 85;8 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 96>6 :9D6A
;DA <:776776A BC 856 <;>6D87 :? 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856
A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * @7 D:8 @D A@7<G86
8 @7 ;=7: D:8 @D
- 14 -
A@7<G86 85;8 856 ?;856> :? 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * A@6A @D8678;86
56 E=;@J :? 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * @7 85;8 856@> J:856> 5;A B6LG6;856A 856 7G@8
<>:<6>8@67 @D 86>J7 :? ; :>;=
7 >@H58=C E:D86DA6A BC
856 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 <=;@D8@??
856 J:856> :? 856
<=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8
8: * 5;A :D=C ;D
GDA@F@A6A
75;>6
;DA
:7
856>6?:>6
B6LG6;856A 856 6D8@>6 <>:<6>8C
E:G=A
56 8>@;=
856>6?:>6 >@H58 @D 5:=A@DH 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8
D:8
5;F6
:G>8 9;7
:7
8: *
96>6 GD;B=6 8: 678;B=@75 856 =;9?G= 6M6EG8@:D :? 856 :>;=
;7 E:D86DA6A BC 856J @D 856@> 9>@886D 78;86J6D8
;F@DH >6H;>A 8: 856 ;B:F6 ?;E87 856 8>@;=
:G>8
5;A D: :856> ;=86>D;8@F6 85;D 8: A6E>66 856 7G@8 ?@=6A BC
856 <=;@D8@??
56 A6?6DA;D8
:7
;DA
;>6 ;== <G>E5;76>7
:? 856 <:>8@:D7 :? 856 <>:<6>8C ?>:J 856 A6?6DA;D8
8: *
:7
56@> @D86>678 E;DD:8 B6 B6C:DA 856 @D86>678 :? 856
A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: *
;F@DH >6H;>A 8: 856 ?;E8 85;8 856
<=;@D8@?? 5;A ;D GDA@F@A6A >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 @D 856
7G@8 <>:<6>8C 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
;DA
E;DD:8 E=;@J 85;8
- 15 -
856 7;@A 7;=6 A66A 6M6EG86A BC 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * @D
856@> ?;F:G> B@DA7 856 <=;@D8@?? ;=7:
56 8>@;=
:G>8 5;7
E:D7@A6>6A
;DA
>@H58=C
85676
?;E87
J68@EG=:G7=C
5;7
>68G>D6A 856 ?@DA@DH 5:=A@DH 856 <=;@D8@?? @7 6D8@8=6A 8:
-85
75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67
'6 A: D:8 766 ;DC 6>>:> @D 856 @J<GHD6A
IGAHJ6D8 ;DA A6E>66 <;776A BC 856 8>@;=
:G>8
6DE6 856
;<<6;= @7
-
'6 J;K6 @8 E=6;> 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
;DA
5;F@DH <G>E5;76A 856 <:>8@:D7 :? 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8C ?>:J
856 A6?6DA;D8
:7
8: * ;>6 6D8@8=6A 8: 9:>K :G8 856@>
>6J6AC B6?:>6 856 ?@D;= A6E>66
:G>8 ;7 56=A BC 856
<6M
:G>8 @D 856 E;76 :?
!
@D
'
"
"
#
$ !%
&!
>6<:>86A
()
+'
&
$(
$
+'
&
@78
:
=
:
$
$
%
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review