Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP(C) No. 2811/2021
CM No.8704/2021
Reserved on: 17.09.2026
Pronounced on: 25.09.2026
Uploaded on: _______________
Operative part or full judgment - Full
Mohammad Yousuf Dar
S/O Late Ali Mohammad Dar,
R/O Beebrda, Parigam Check,
District Kulgam.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Sr.Adv. N.A.Beigh with
Adv. Sofi Manzoor.
Vs.
1. Food Corporation of India
through General Manager,
North Noida, New Delhi.
2. Assistant General Manager, CPF,
Food Corporation of India,
Zonal Office, North Noida, New Delhi.
3. Divisional Manager,
Food Corporation of India,
Sanant-Nagar, Srinagar.
…Respondent(s)
Through: Adv. Omais Kawoos.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A.CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The
petitioner,
retired
employee
of
the
respondent-
Corporation, has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking inter
alia, a writ of mandamus directing the respondentCorporation to produce the record pertaining to his
retirement case and further directing the respondent-
Page |2
Corporation to pay to him the balance amount of
Rs.2,74,349/-,
alleged
unjustifiably
to
have
been
withheld/deducted
illegally
and
from
his
retiral/pensionary benefits.
2. The case set up by the petitioner is that he retired from the
services of the respondent-Corporation on 01.07.2021
while working as an Ancillary Worker; that although the
retiral benefits were released in his favour, the amount
actually paid to him was less than what was due to him on
the basis of the calculation made by the respondentCorporation; that the petitioner and one Muzaffar Ahmad
Magloo, CPF No.6388, who is also stated to be an
Ancillary
Worker,
had
joined
the
services
of
the
Corporation on the same date i.e. 01.01.1994; that
despite the similarity in their date of joining and status,
the CPF amount standing to his credit was substantially
less than that reflected in the payroll record of the said
similarly situated employee; that the respondents itself
calculated his CPF (Contributory Provident Fund) up to the
year 2021-2022 at Rs.9,23,188/-, whereas an amount of
Rs.8,74,918/-
only
was
released
to
him
without
furnishing any justification for the difference; that the
difference
comes
to
Rs.48,270/-
under
the
said
calculation, whereas the overall grievance raised in the
writ petition relates to the amount of Rs.2,74,349/allegedly withheld from his retiral benefits.
Page |3
3. The
respondents,
in
their
counter
Affidavit
dated
15.12.2025, have pleaded that the petitioner has been
paid all the retirement benefits to which he was entitled;
that the allegation regarding payment of lesser CPF than
that payable to his colleague namely Muzaffar Ahmad
Magloo has been denied; that no parity can be claimed
with Muzaffar Ahmad Magloo since the said employee has
not yet retired from service; that the CPF of the said
employee has been calculated on the basis of the number
of days actually worked by him and, therefore, the figures
reflected in his account cannot be made the basis for
determining the entitlement of the petitioner.
4. While arguing the matter, learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner states that the payroll particulars of similarly
situated employee-Muzaffar Ahmad Magloo reflect his CPF
balance up to the year 2021-2022 as Rs.11,11,467/-; that
the petitioner claims that he has been discriminated and
has not been paid the CPF/retiral benefits actually due to
him; that before approaching this Court the petitioner
submitted several representations to the respondents
seeking clarification and release of the amount allegedly
withheld from his retiral benefits, however, none of those
representations have been considered or decided by the
respondents.
5. Learned counsel for the respondents, ex-adverso, contends
that pursuant to the directions of this Court, respondents
Page |4
filed counter Affidavit dated 16.12.2025 and states that a
meeting was convened with the petitioner who was
apprised of the computation of his CPF contribution; that
after being satisfied with the calculation, the petitioner
submitted a representation expressing his intention to
withdraw the writ petition; that the said representation
bears thumb impression of the petitioner and is annexed
with the counter Affidavit; that this fact was brought to the
notice of the Court on 07.04.2025 by learned counsel
appearing for the respondents, however, on 02.09.2025,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner made a
statement before the Court that the petitioner denied
having submitted any such representation.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the material
available on record and considered the matter.
7. At the outset, it needs to be noticed that the grievance of
the petitioner essentially relates to the correctness of the
computation of his CPF/retiral dues. The respondents
assert that the petitioner has been paid all the amounts
due
to
him,
whereas
the
petitioner
disputes
the
computation and alleges that the amount has been
wrongly withheld from his retiral benefits.
8. There can be no dispute with the proposition that retiral
benefits payable to an employee upon his retirement
constitute an important service entitlement and that the
employer is required to make a correct and transparent
Page |5
computation thereof. At the same time, a writ Court
cannot direct payment of a particular amount merely on
the basis of an assertion of the employee unless the
entitlement to such amount is established from the
relevant service and financial record. The Supreme Court
in ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee
Corporation of India Ltd., reported as (2004) 3 SCC
553, while considering the scope of Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, has held that the mere existence of a
disputed question of fact does not constitute an absolute
bar to the exercise of writ jurisdiction. The Court has also
reiterated that the question is essentially one of judicial
discretion depending upon the facts and circumstances of
each case.
9. In the present case, the relevant record relating to the
petitioner's
CPF
account,
contribution,
deductions,
adjustment, and final settlement assumes considerable
importance. The respondents have asserted that the
petitioner has received all the amounts due to him, but the
petitioner
disputes
the
computation.
In
such
circumstances, the respondents cannot merely rely upon a
general assertion that all retiral benefits have been paid.
The computation must be capable of verification from the
official record.
10.
The comparison sought to be made by the petitioner
with the similarly situated employee Muzaffar Ahmad
Page |6
Magloo, however, cannot by itself establish the petitioner's
entitlement to the amount claimed. The respondents have
specifically stated that the said employee has not retired
and that his CPF balance has been calculated on the basis
of the actual period/days worked. Therefore, the mere fact
that the payroll statement of the said employee reflects a
higher CPF balance cannot, without examination of the
respective
contribution
records,
establish
that
the
petitioner has been wrongly paid.
11.
The Court, therefore, finds that the claim of parity
with the said employee cannot, in the present state of the
record, furnish a sufficient basis for issuing a positive
direction for payment of the amount claimed by the
petitioner. There is, however, another aspect of the matter
which requires consideration. The respondents have relied
upon
a
representation
allegedly
submitted
by
the
petitioner expressing his intention to withdraw the writ
petition after being satisfied with the CPF calculation. The
petitioner, through his counsel, has specifically denied
having submitted such representation. Once the petitioner
has denied the very submission of the representation,
particularly when the respondents seek to rely upon the
same for bringing the proceedings to an end, this Court
would not be justified in treating the said document as
conclusive proof of withdrawal of the petition. The disputed
question regarding the alleged representation need not be
Page |7
adjudicated in the present proceedings, particularly when
the
respondents
can
independently
demonstrate
the
correctness of the CPF calculation from their official
record.
12.
The petitioner, admittedly, had approached the
respondents through representations before filing the writ
petition. If such representations remained undecided, the
respondents
were
expected
to
communicate
to
the
petitioner the basis on which his claim for the alleged
difference in retiral benefits had been rejected or adjusted.
13.
The Court is, therefore, of the considered view that
instead of directing immediate payment of the amount of
Rs.2,74,349/-, the respondents are directed to undertake
a fresh verification of the petitioner's CPF/retiral benefit
account
on
the
basis
of
the
original
record
and
communicate a reasoned decision to him. The exercise
shall necessarily include examination of the petitioner's
service
record,
CPF
ledger/account,
monthly
contributions, employer's contributions, interest credited
from time to time, withdrawals/adjustments, if any, and
the basis on which the final amount payable to the
petitioner was arrived at. The respondents shall also
specifically
indicate
the
basis
for
the
figure
of
Rs.9,23,188/-, stated by the petitioner to have been
calculated as his CPF entitlement, as against the amount
of Rs.8,74,918/- actually released to him. It is, however,
Page |8
clarified that this Court has not expressed any final
opinion on the correctness of either party's calculation.
The respondents shall undertake the exercise strictly on
the basis of the official record and the applicable rules
governing CPF/retiral benefits.
14.
Such a course would also safeguard the interest of
the respondent-Corporation, while ensuring that the
petitioner is not deprived of any legitimate retiral benefit
on account of an unexplained or unverifiable calculation. If
upon such verification it is found that any amount was
due to the petitioner but was not paid to him, the same
shall be released in his favour within the time stipulated.
Conversely, if the respondents find that no further amount
is payable, a detailed and reasoned communication shall
be furnished to the petitioner setting out the calculation
and the basis thereof.
15.
In the event of the afore-stated exercise, if the
petitioner is not satisfied, he shall be at liberty to work out
his legal remedy.
16.
Petition is disposed of in terms of the above along-
with pending application(s).
( M. A. CHOWDHARY )
JUDGE
Srinagar
25.09.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review