Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
Reserved On: 15th of September, 2026.
Pronounced On: 26th of September, 2026.
Uploaded On: 26th of September, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced:
Full.
Mohammad Sultan Bhat, (74 Years)
S/O Late Abdul Ahad Bhat
R/O Dangerpora, Teilbal,
Srinagar, Kashmir.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Sajad Ahmad Sofi, Advocate.
V/S
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through Commissioner/ Secretary to Government,
Revenue Department, Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar/ Jammu.
2. Divisional Commissioner,
Kashmir, Srinagar.
3. Tehsildar North, Hazratbal,
Srinagar, Kashmir,
4. Naib Tehsildar, Nandpora,
Srinagar, Kashmir.
… Official Respondents
5. Shabir Ahmad Bhat
S/O Late Ali Mohammad Bhat
R/O Dangerpora Teilbal, Srinagar, Kashmir.
6. Wahid Ahmed Bhat
S/O Abdul Samad Bhat
R/O Dangerpora Teilbal, Srinagar, Kashmir.
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
7. Manzoor Ahmad Bhat
S/O Late Nabla Bhat
R/O Dangerpora Teilbal, Srinagar
(Legal Heir of Nabla Bhat).
… Private Respondents
Through: Ms Nadiya Abdullah, Assisting Counsel vice
Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG for R-1 & 2;
Mr Waseem Gul, Government Advocate for R-3 & 4; and
Mr Z. A. Qurashi, Senior Advocate with
M/S F. A. Bhat and Anurag Verma, Advocates for R-5 to 7.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The Petitioner, through the medium of this Petition filed under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, has challenged Order dated 3rd of
March, 2025 passed by the Court of learned 3rd Civil Subordinate Judge
(Forest Magistrate), Srinagar in the Suit titled “Mohammad Sultan Bhat
V. Shabir Ahmad Bhat & Ors.”, whereby the Trial Court has struck out
the names of Defendants No. 1 to 3/ Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein from the
array of Defendants by invoking the provisions of Order I Rule 10 (2) of the
Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).
02.
The Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein claims to have filed a Suit for
declaration and perpetual injunction against
all the Defendants/
Respondents herein; that, pursuant to notice, the Defendants No. 1 to 3/
Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein caused their appearance and filed two
applications; one by Defendants No. 1 and 3 and the other by Defendant
No.2, separately, under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, seeking rejection of the
Plaint, on the ground that the jurisdiction of the Trial Court was barred and
that the Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein has disclosed cause of action in the
Plaint few days prior to filing of the Suit, when the Naib Tehsildar
concerned had issued notice to the Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein and his
nephew to part with possession over the Suit property, as such, the cause to
file the present Suit was against the Naib Tehsildar only.
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
03.
It is alleged by the Petitioner that, although both the
applications moved by the Defendants No. 1 to 3 in terms of Order VII Rule
11 of the CPC were not granted by the Trial Court, however, the Trial
Court, at its own, while invoking Order I Rule 10 (2) of the CPC, vide the
Order impugned, ordered to delete them from the array of Defendants,
holding that no cause of action is disclosed in the Plaint against them, nor
has even accrued to them and also no relief has been sought against
Defendants No. 1 to 3.
04.
The impugned Order has been assailed by the Plaintiff/
Petitioner herein on the ground that the Trial Court has non-suited him
against the private Defendants in the Suit, at whose behest the official
Defendants had initiated proceedings against the Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein
with regard to the Suit land; that the Trail Court has erred in holding that
the Defendants No. 1 to 3 in the Plaint have been wrongly joined as
Defendants, when no cause of action had arisen against them in favour of
the Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein, inasmuch as, the Trial Court has not
appreciated the material facts disclosing the cause of action in Paragraphs
No. 18 to 20 of the Plaint as regards the Defendants No. 1 to 3; that the
Trial Court has wrongly applied the provisions of Order I Rule 10 (2) CPC,
without appreciating first the provisions of Order I Rules 3, 4, 5 and 7,
which deal with the persons who may be joined as Defendants to a Suit;
that the Trial Court has mis-judged the pleadings of the Plaintiff/ Petitioner
herein in relation to cause of action which has arisen against the persons
arrayed as Defendants in the Suit, in view of the fact that the official
Defendants had acted against the interests of the Plaintiff, at the behest of
private Defendants.
05.
Heard learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the parties,
perused the pleadings available on record and considered the matter.
06.
From the perusal of the pleadings available on record, it
transpires that the Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein filed a Suit for declaration and
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
injunction, arraying as many as seven Defendants, including the private
Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein. On notice having been issued by the Trial
Court, the private Defendants (Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein) filed two
separate applications under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC for rejection of
the Plaint. The Trial Court, while dealing with the aforesaid applications,
was of the view that since the Applicants/ Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein
have sought rejection of the Plaint in part, to their extent only, as such, the
said relief cannot be granted in view of the Judgments rendered by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Maqsud Ahmad V. Mathra Dutt & Co.,
1936 SCC Online LAH 337” and “(2018) 11 SCC 780”. At the same time,
the Trial Court observed that the Court, however, is not powerless or that
the Suit can be continued against the Defendants No. 1 to 3 (Respondents
No. 5 to 7 herein) , when cause of action is neither disclosed in the Plaint
against them, nor has even accrued to the Plaintiff (Petitioner herein)
against them and also no relief in the Plaint is sought against the Defendants
No. 1 to 3 (Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein), as such, the Defendants No. 1 to
3 (Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein) have been improperly joined in the Plaint
as Defendants. On the basis of these observations, the Trial Court, while
resorting to Order I Rule 10 (2) of the CPC, struck out the names of the
Defendants No. 1 to 3 (Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein) from the array of
Defendants.
07.
Keeping in view the aforesaid factual backdrop, it becomes
necessary to go through the mandate of Rule 10 (2) to Order I of the CPC,
which reads as under:
“10 (2): Court may strike out or add parties – The
Court may, at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or
without the application of either party, and on such terms as
may appear to the Court to be just, order that the name of any
party improperly joined, whether as plaintiff or defendant, be
struck out, and that the name of any person who ought to
have been joined, whether as plaintiff or defendant, or whose
presence before the Court may be necessary in order to
enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit, be
added.”
08.
From a bare perusal of sub-rule (2) of Order I Rule 10 of the
CPC, it is clearly evident that the power has been conferred upon the Court
to strike out the name of any party improperly joined, whether as Plaintiff
or Defendant, and also when the name of any person ought to have been
joined as Plaintiff or Defendant or in a case where a person whose presence
before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court, effectually
and completely, to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in
the Suit. In the present case, since this Court is concerned with the Order of
the Trial Court striking out the name of Defendants No. 1 to 3 (Respondents
No. 5 to 7 herein), having been improperly joined in the Suit as per the Trial
Court, therefore, let us consider the said part of sub-rule (2) of Rule 10 of
Order I of the CPC, in the light of the facts and circumstances of the case.
09.
The primary meaning of a party is a litigant who has a part to
play in the proceedings. A “necessary party” is one without whom no
order can be effectively made. The object of Rule 10 (2) to Order I of the
CPC is not to prevent multiplicity of actions, tough it may incidentally have
that effect, but that is a desirable consequence of the Rule, rather than its
main objective. The only reason which makes it necessary to array a person
as a party to an action is, so that, he should be bound by the result of the
action and the question to be settled, therefore, must be a question in the
action which cannot be effectually and completely settled, unless he is a
party.
10.
It is trite in law that a person may be added as a party-
Defendant to the Suit, though no specific relief may be claimed against him/
her, provided his/ her presence is necessary for a complete and final
decision on the question involved in the Suit. Such a person is only a proper
party, as distinguished from a necessary party.
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
11.
The Petitioner has pleaded that, after the death of his father-
Ahad Bhat in the year 1965, the demised estate devolved upon his two sons,
namely, Ghulam Qadir Bhat and Mohammad Sultan Bhat (Petitioner
herein), by virtue of Mutation No. 964 entered into the revenue records on
12th of July, 1967 to the exclusion of two sisters, namely, Ateeqa and Nabla,
who were married outside their parental home and had not staked any claim
at the time of inheritance mutation having been entered in the revenue
records; that, subsequently, after the death of Ghulam Qadir Bhat in the
year 2003, his demised estate devolved upon his widow, namely, Habla and
one son, namely, Ghulam Ahmad Bhat, and daughter, namely, Nuzhat by
virtue of inheritance Mutation No. 3061.
12.
It is alleged that the Petitioner and his sisters had no dispute
inter se over the inheritance rights till the year 2015, when greed prevailed
upon one of his sisters, namely, Mst. Ateeqa, as a result of which, she filed
a Revision Petition before the Joint Financial Commissioner to challenge
the inheritance Mutation No. 964 entered into revenue records on 4th of
July, 1967, on the basis of which the Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein and his
deceased brother had acquired exclusive rights of ownership and possession
over the demised estate of their father; that the inheritance Mutation No.
964 was ordered to be set aside by the learned Financial Commissioner,
vide Order dated 26th of December, 2017, directing the Respondent No.3Tehsildar North (Hazratbal), Srinagar to attest fresh mutation in accordance
with Muslim Personal Law, after following proper procedure; that the Order
passed by the learned Financial Commissioner was assailed by the
Petitioner and his co-owners before this Court in OWP No. 118/2018,
wherein Mst. Nabla was also arrayed as a party proforma Respondent; that
Mst. Nabla and her sister-Mst. Ateeqa, arrayed as Respondents No. 3 and 4
in the aforesaid Writ Petition, filed their Response before this Court, taking
the plea that the parties to the Writ Petition had already entered into a
compromise which was reduced into writing and, under the terms of the
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
said compromise, Mst. Ateeqa has received her share in the form of cash,
whileas Respondent-Nabla had been given land measuring 01 Kanal and 01
Marla under Khasra No. 745 in estate Teilbal, Srinagar and, on the basis of
the said compromise, the said OWP No. 118/2018 was disposed of as
settled by this Court on 20th of March, 2018; that, pursuant to the
compromise bonafidely entered into between them, the Tehsildar, North
(Hazratbal) recorded the statements of the sisters of the Petitioner, namely,
Mst. Ateeqa and Mst. Nabla on 12th of May, 2018, so as to ascertain the
factum of valid and binding compromise.
13.
The Petitioner further contends that the Tehsildar, North
(Hazratbal) did not close the proceedings for attesting fresh mutation in
view of the compromise and kept the proceedings on board, generating
doubts in the minds of the Plaintiff/Petitioner herein and his co-owners visà-vis the Suit property, as a result of which, the Plaintiff and the legal heirs
of the deceased brother of the Plaintiff-Mst. Nabla-sister of the Petitioner,
filed a civil Suit for declaration and injunction before the Court of learned
Forest Magistrate, Srinagar, however, despite the knowledge about the
institution of the said Suit on 27th of February, 2020 and in utter disregard
of the civil proceedings, to which Tehsildar, North (Hazratbal) had been
arrayed as a party, he passed a prejudicial Order on 5th of March, 2020,
brushing aside the legal effectiveness and impact of the statements made by
the sister of the Plaintiff-Mst. Ateeqa, wherein it had been stated that the
inheritance Mutation No. 964 should be kept intact, inasmuch as, the
inheritance claims of both the sisters had been satisfied by the Petitioner
and his other co-owners, and that the Tehsildar could not sit in judgment
over the compromise entered by the parties voluntarily before this Court in
OWP No. 118/2018; that the Order passed by the Tehsildar was, thus,
challenged through the medium of a Civil Original Suit for declaration and
injunction before the Court of learned Forest Magistrate, Srinagar, who was
pleased to pass an Order on interim injunction application.
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
14.
The Petitioner further contends that the Respondent No.5-
Shabir Ahmad Bhat, who has been arrayed as Defendant No.1 in the Suit,
had exercised undue influence upon his mother, i.e., Defendant No.3 and
filed a frivolous application before the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir,
misrepresenting the facts that her share in her father’s demised property was
not being given to her and the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir referred
the said application to Tehsildar, North (Hazratbal), who, in turn, endorsed
the same to Naib Tehsildar, Natipora for necessary action as warranted
under law, who has arrogated himself the powers of the Court to compel the
Plaintiff/ Petitioner herein and his nephew to part with the possession of
their landed property and give more land to Defendants No. 1 to 3/
Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein, which is illegal and unwarranted in view of
the compromise entered between the parties.
15.
The Petitioner, faced with the aforesaid circumstances, thus,
claims to have filed a fresh Suit before the Trial Court, to declare that the
Tehsildar and Naib Tehsildar had no authority or power to pressurize the
Petitioner to part with his possession and ownership of the Suit property in
view of the pendency of civil litigation before the Court of learned Forest
Magistrate, Srinagar in their earlier Suit titled “Mohammad Sultan Bhat
& Ors. V. Mst. Ateeqa & Ors.”, and the Revision Petition filed against
Mutation No. 4378 pending disposal before the Joint Financial
Commissioner, Srinagar and for permanent prohibitory injunction. The
aforesaid Suit, besides official Defendants, was filed against the private
Defendants/ Respondents No. 5 to 7 herein, as well.
16.
The Respondents No. 5 to 7 moved two separate applications
for rejection of the Plaint, on the ground that neither any cause of action is
disclosed against them in the Plaint nor any relief has been sought against
them. The Court below, however, declined their applications, but ordered to
delete them from the array of Defendants for the reason that they were not
necessary or proper party to the Suit.
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
17.
It is an admitted fact, as borne out from the Plaint, that neither
any cause of action has been disclosed against any of the private
Respondents nor any relief has been claimed against them, in the Suit,
though in an earlier Suit filed by the Petitioner and his co-sharers, they are
stated to be party. As per the assertions made in the Plaint by the Petitioner
before the Court below, as Plaintiff, the Tehsildar and Naib Tehsildar
concerned have been proceeding in the matter as per the orders of the
Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir. Instead of contesting the matter by the
Petitioner and his co-sharers before the Tehsildar and Naib Tehsildar, the
Petitioner has filed another Suit against the official Respondents, including
the Tehsildar and Naib Tehsildar and also implicated the private
Respondents as Defendants No. 1 to 3.
18.
From the perusal of the aforesaid Plaint, there is neither any
cause of action pleaded against them nor any relief has been sought against
the private Respondents. Besides, it is also a fact that the proceedings
before the aforesaid revenue officers can be effectually decided in absence
of the private Respondents, who, otherwise, do not wish to join
proceedings, which may be at their own peril. Therefore, the private
Respondents cannot be forced to be made as party in a Suit, wherein there is
neither any cause of action accrued to the Plaintiff against them nor any
relief has been sought against them.
19.
Having regard to the foregoing reasons and observations made
hereinabove, this Court is of the considered opinion that the Trial Court has
rightly decided to delete the private Respondents from the array of
Defendants, as Defendants No. 1 to 3 in the Suit, before it and there is no
perversity or illegality in the Order impugned passed by the Trial Court, so
as to warrant any interference by this Court, while invoking supervisory
jurisdiction. The impugned Order passed by the Trial Court is, thus, upheld.
CM (M) No. 363/2025
CM No. 5485/2025
20.
Viewed thus, the present Petition is found to be bereft of any
merit and substance. Accordingly, the same is hereby dismissed, along with
the connected CM. Interim direction(s), if any subsisting as on date, shall
stand vacated.
21.
Registry to forward a copy of this Judgment to the Trial Court,
for information.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 26th, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review