Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CRA No. 06/2004
Reserved on: 26.12.2025
Pronounced on: 27.01.2026
Uploaded on: 27.01.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced
Muhammad Shaban Wani
S/o Ghulam Qadir Wani
R/o Kurshoo Nowgam, Padshahi
Bagh
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Through: - Mr. Nisar Ahmad Bhat, Advocate and
Mr. A. Hanan, Advocate
V/s
State of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through Senior Superintendent of
Police, Vigilance Organization
Kashmir, Old Secretariat,
Srinagar
…..Respondent(s)
Through: - Mr. Mohsin Qadri, Sr. AAG with
Mr. Waseem Gul, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
This appeal is directed against the judgment of conviction and
sentence dated 29.09.2004 passed by the Court of Special Judge, AntiCorruption Srinagar, Kashmir, whereby the appellant was prosecuted in
FIR No. 40/1986 under Section 5/2 of the Jammu and Kashmir Prevention
of Corruption Act (for short, P.C. Act). Vide the impugned judgment, the
appellant was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of
two years and to pay a fine of ₹20,000/- for the offence under Section 5/2
of the P.C. Act. Besides, the appellant was also held guilty of the offence
under Section 161 RPC and was sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for one year with a fine of ₹10,000/-.
02.
Briefly stated, FIR No. 40/1986 was registered on 15.09.1986 by
the Vigilance Organization Kashmir (hereinafter referred to as VOK) on
the basis of a complaint lodged by the complainant. It was alleged that the
appellant was approached by the complainant for issuance of a revenue
extract, as the complainant intended to transfer 1½ kanals of land. It is
alleged that for issuance of the said revenue extract, the appellant
demanded a bribe of ₹1,000/-, which was ultimately scaled down to
₹800/-. On the strength of the said complaint, a trap was laid and, in the
presence of shadow witnesses, the VOK alleged that the appellant
demanded the bribe amount, which the complainant handed over to him.
During the trap proceedings, ₹700/- was recovered from the person of the
appellant, whereas ₹100/- was recovered from a fellow Patwari, namely
Karan Singh, to whom the appellant is alleged to have handed over the
said amount towards satisfaction of some past liability.
03.
Consequently,
during
the
trap
proceedings
conducted
on
15.09.1986, the alleged recovery was effected, leading to the arrest of the
appellant. Subsequently, the offence under Section 5/2 of the P.C. Act was
stated to have been proved against him, on the basis of which, the Trial
Court held the appellant guilty and sentenced him as aforesaid. The said
findings are assailed in the present appeal on the ground that the learned
Trial Court failed to correctly appreciate the settled legal position. It is
contended that neither the demand of bribe was proved nor was there any
clinching evidence to establish recovery from the person of the appellant.
The complainant did not support the alleged demand, and even the
presence of the shadow witness (PW-6) is doubtful, as the said witness
nowhere deposed that he had seen the complainant handing over the bribe
amount to the appellant. In the absence of proof of demand and recovery,
the conviction and sentence recorded against the appellant are manifestly
erroneous. It is further contended that the charge-sheet was not proved
beyond reasonable doubt and that the Trial Court, without indicating any
cogent basis, proceeded merely on surmises and speculation. The
mandatory requirements of law were not fulfilled and, therefore, the
impugned judgment is unsustainable.
04.
The respondent, while supporting the judgment rendered by the
Trial Court, argued that not only was the presence of the shadow witness
duly proved, but even the complainant, during cross-examination,
materially stated that the demand for payment of bribe was made through
a broker, namely Habibullah Alaei of Rawalpora. The said broker
appeared in the witness box and deposed that the accused had made a
specific demand. It was further contended that the appellant had prepared
a defective revenue extract, on account of which the complainant faced
difficulty in selling his land. Thereafter, on 15.09.1986, the complainant
himself approached the appellant and requested issuance of a fresh
revenue extract, for which the appellant demanded illegal gratification,
initially amounting to ₹1,000/-, which was later scaled down to ₹800/-.
The said amount was recovered during the trap proceedings. It was also
argued that there is no contradiction in the testimony of the trap witnesses,
as not only was the tainted money recovered, but during the hand-wash
proceedings as well, the appellant failed to point out any lacuna.
Consequently, it was submitted that the trap proceedings do not suffer
from any infirmity. It was further contended that the appellant failed to
tender any plausible explanation as to how the tainted money landed in his
pocket, particularly when the pocket wash gave positive results of
phenolphthalein powder.
05.
Per contra, counsel for the appellant placing reliance on 2014 (13)
SCC 55, argued that the prosecution was required to prove beyond
reasonable doubt that the appellant had voluntarily accepted the bribe
amount, and that in the absence of proof of demand for illegal
gratification, the offence under the Act does not stand proved. Learned
counsel further relied upon 2015 (10) SCC 230 to submit that once the
complainant turned hostile, and his evidence during cross-examination
failed to elucidate any incriminating circumstance, it cannot be said that
the demand was proved. It was argued that allegations of bribery must be
examined in the light of all surrounding circumstances and, in the present
case, even the shadow witness failed to disclose the actual transfer of
money from the complainant to the pocket of the appellant.
06.
Learned counsel for the appellant further drew the attention of this
Court to a similar case wherein conviction recorded by the learned Trial
Court of CBI, Jammu, was set aside by this Court in Criminal Appeal No.
13-A/2004 decided on 21.07.2008, holding that there was no sufficient
material to sustain the conviction. It was pointed out that in the said case
also, the statement of the complainant was not corroborated by any
independent witness, and once acceptance pursuant to demand was not
proved by the shadow witness, the same was sufficient to create a doubt in
the prosecution case.
07.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the
case.
08.
The Trial Court, though having taken the view that the complainant
had turned hostile, held that the recovery of tainted money stood proved
beyond shadow of doubt and that the appellant had failed to explain as to
how the money had landed in his pocket. The Trial Court further found
that the allegation of false implication was without any basis, as the
independent witnesses had corroborated the transaction of money between
the complainant and the appellant. Though the complainant did not fully
support the prosecution case, the Trial Court rejected the defence
contention that the shadow witness had not witnessed the transaction. On
the contrary, the shadow witness categorically deposed that a transaction
of money had taken place between the complainant and the appellant.
There was no contradiction with regard to the fact as to who had smeared
phenolphthalein powder on the currency notes. The defence argument that
the police had smeared powder on the hands of the appellant after his
arrest and thereafter conducted the hand-wash proceedings was found to
be devoid of any legal substance, as no such inference was suggested
during the cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses. The allegation
that members of the Sikh community had hatched a conspiracy to falsely
implicate and trap the appellant was also found to be without any
evidentiary support. Trial Court further observed that though certain
discrepancies had emerged in the testimony of the complainant, the same
were attributable to the long delay in recording the evidence, as most of
the witnesses had candidly admitted that due to lapse of time their
memory had faded.
09.
Trial Court, therefore, observed that “when the prosecution
evidence is considered as a whole, a picture emerges which favours the
prosecution story and not the defence version. The criticism of the defence
counsel to the evidence of PW-6, the shadow witness, is not fully justified.
It cannot be said with certainty that the said PW was not present during
the proceedings merely because he has not been made to sign the
documents prepared in this case, which does not necessarily point to his
absence. His statement, when read as a whole, is convincing. Therefore, I
am not in a position to agree with the defence counsel and to hold that
PW-6 Abdul Gani Head SG Constable was not associated with the team
for conducting the trap.”
10.
The Trial Court further observed that “however, the accused
Mohammad Shaban alleges that the said money was thrusted into his
pocket by one of the members of the team. I am not convinced with this
defence of the accused. In view of his defence, the prosecution case that
the bribe money was taken out from the pocket of the shirt of the accused
gets corroborated. Had it been a case of conspiracy and concoction, and
had it been proved that Patwari Mohammad Shaban was falsely
implicated in the manner projected by him, he would not have remained
silent and would have agitated the matter along with the members of the
Patwari Organization.”
11.
The plea put forth by the appellant that accused No.2, Karan Singh,
was involved to get the appellant implicated with the active assistance of
the Vigilance Organization Kashmir, was also found to be unsupported by
evidence. The learned Trial Court, therefore, concluded that the appellant
had made a demand for bribe, accepted the money, and that the same was
recovered from his possession. Though the complainant, Rahim Khan, did
not fully support the prosecution case, it was observed that he might have
been won over. The witnesses categorically deposed that the complainant
had met the accused-Patwari and requested issuance of the necessary
revenue extract, for which the accused demanded money that was paid by
the complainant. The learned Trial Court relied upon the testimonies of
PW-Abdul Gani Lone, the complainant, PW-6 PW-Opinderjeet Singh,
Accounts Officer (shadow witness).
12.
Since the appellant had taken exception to the appreciation of
prosecution evidence, it was found necessary to re-examine the evidence
on record. According to the prosecution, the complainant PW-Rahim
Khan owned land at Rawalpora, out of which he intended to sell 1½
kanals and, for that purpose, required the revenue extract and map.
Initially, he attempted to procure the same through a property dealer;
however, the concerned Patwari, the appellant herein, did not issue the
proper extract. Thereafter, the complainant personally approached the
appellant, who allegedly demanded a bribe of ₹1,000/- for issuance of the
requisite record. On insistence of the complainant, the amount was scaled
down to ₹800/-, which was allegedly demanded to be paid on 15.09.1986.
The complainant approached the Vigilance Organization and narrated the
incident, pursuant to which a case was registered and investigation
commenced. A trap was arranged by associating PW-6 Opinderjeet Singh,
Accounts Officer, as the shadow witness. In the presence of PWs-2, 4, 5,
6 and 11, the vigilance team proceeded to the spot, where the appellant
was residing in a rented room. The complainant entered the room and,
upon demand, paid ₹800/-, which had already been treated with
phenolphthalein powder in the VOK office. Thereafter, the appellant
allegedly issued the revenue extract and map. Upon receipt of the prearranged signal, the raiding party entered the room and questioned the
appellant regarding the money received by him. During the search, ₹700/was recovered from the pocket of the shirt worn by the appellant, while
₹100/- was recovered from co-accused No.2. The appellant was arrested
on the spot and, after completion of necessary formalities, the
investigation was concluded. Upon obtaining sanction under Section 6 of
the J&K Prevention of Corruption Act, the appellant was charged for
offences under Section 5(2) of the P.C. Act read with Sections 161 and
120-B RPC. At the stage of charge, it was found that though ₹100/- had
been recovered from co-accused No.2, the complainant had alleged that
only the appellant had demanded and received the bribe. The co-accused
had explained that the amount of Rs 100/- was paid to him by the
appellant towards satisfaction of a past liability, which explanation stood
corroborated by independent witnesses. Although the revenue extract was
prepared by the co-accused, it was signed by the appellant in his capacity
as Patwari. The Trial Court, therefore, held that no act of conspiracy was
made out between the appellant and co-accused No.2 and, consequently,
the charge under Section 120-B RPC was dropped against the co-accused.
The appellant alone was tried for the offences under Section 5(2) of the
P.C. Act read with Section 161 RPC.
13.
For a just decision of the appeal, the statements of the complainant
and the shadow witness, being the most material evidence, deserve close
scrutiny and are, therefore, reproduced and discussed. PW-Rahim Khan,
the complainant, stated that he never went to meet the appellant for
obtaining the revenue extract and that it was only the mediators who had
approached the appellant for the said purpose. He categorically denied
having lodged any complaint against the appellant alleging demand of
₹800/- as bribe. Upon being declared hostile, he deposed that he intended
to sell 1½ kanals of land and for that purpose had engaged PW-Habibullah
Alaei, who alone had obtained the revenue extract from the appellant. He
further stated that he neither knew the appellant nor had ever met him. He
admitted that he was taken to the Vigilance Organization, where he was
handed over ₹800/-, which was later taken back by the Vigilance officials,
and his signatures were obtained on a receipt. According to him, the said
amount of ₹800/- was adjusted towards the final sale consideration of the
land. He reiterated that he neither met the appellant nor paid any money to
him and denied having any knowledge of the alleged occurrence, though
he claimed to have later learnt about the arrest of the appellant. On being
examined by the Court, he stated that after the sale of land, the mediators
did not return ₹800/- to him and that the said amount was included in the
sale price. He further stated that he was told to issue a receipt for ₹800/and was assured that the remaining sale consideration would be paid after
the Patwari issued the revenue extract. He also stated that he was told that
₹800/- had to be paid to the Patwari.
14.
PW-Habibullah Alaei stated that he knew both the complainant and
the appellant but denied having paid any money to the appellant. He was
declared hostile and, during cross-examination, denied the suggestion that
he was sent by the complainant to obtain the revenue extract from the
appellant.
15.
PW-Abdul Gani Lone stated that he was posted as SG Constable in
the Vigilance Organization and that in the year 1986 a complaint was
lodged alleging that the Patwari was demanding money for issuance of a
revenue extract, initially ₹1,000/-, later settled at ₹800/-. He stated that he
participated in the raid and that on the basis of the complaint, a trap was
laid. According to him, the complainant asked the appellant whether his
work had been done, to which the appellant replied in the affirmative,
whereafter the complainant handed over ₹800/- to the appellant in the
presence of witnesses. Thereafter, the complainant went outside and
informed the raiding team, which then entered the premises and recovered
the amount.
16.
PW-Opinderjeet Singh, Accounts Officer in the Divisional Fund
Office, Srinagar, deposed that he was called to the Vigilance Organization
where a demonstration was given prior to laying the trap. He stated that he
had no knowledge whether the complainant had accompanied the
Vigilance party to the raiding spot. He did not admit the preparation of a
demonstration memo, though his signatures appear on record. He stated
that when he reached the premises of the appellant, one of the persons
present was a Sikh, and ₹700/- were recovered from the appellant while
₹100/- were recovered from another Patwari. The recovery memo, marked
EXPW-3, bears his signatures. He confirmed that the recovered currency
notes bore the same numbers as noted during the demonstration. In crossexamination, he stated that though he does not read or write Urdu, he
understands it and had signed documents written in Urdu. He stated that
when the raiding party entered the room, the complainant and co-accused
Karan Singh were also present. He further stated that the appellant
informed the team that ₹100/- were with Karan Singh. He could not recall
who actually recovered the amount from Karan Singh and admitted that
the statement of the appellant regarding handing over of ₹100/- to the coaccused was not recorded. He stated that one Inspector recovered ₹700/from the shirt pocket of the appellant. He further deposed that he and two
Inspectors had stayed about 300 meters away from the spot and that it was
the complainant who came out and gave the pre-arranged signal, upon
which they rushed to the place of occurrence.
17.
From the testimony of the shadow witness, it emerges that it was
only the complainant who had gone inside the house where the appellant
and the co-accused were present. It is pertinent to note that the trap was
not laid in the office premises of the appellant but in a private house. The
owner of the said house denied that the appellant was his tenant at the
relevant time and also denied that any such incident had occurred in his
house. From the evidence of the shadow witness, it is evident that he
neither witnessed any demand being made by the appellant nor saw the
complainant handing over any bribe amount to the appellant. The shadow
witness, who is otherwise an independent witness having no affiliation
with the Vigilance Organization, expressed ignorance as to whether the
complainant had accompanied the raiding party, though at one point he
stated that the complainant came out of the house and gave the signal to
the raiding party. The presence of the complainant at the scene of crime
has been completely denied by the complainant himself, who has pleaded
ignorance of the entire incident. The Trial Court presumed that the
complainant had been won over by the appellant, though such
presumption is not supported by any tangible evidence. The complainant
consistently stated, both in examination-in-chief and cross-examination,
that he had no contact or proximity with the appellant. His only reliance
was that he was called to the Vigilance Organization by a mediator, whom
he identified as PW-Habibullah Alaei, on the assertion that the appellant
was demanding money. However, the evidence of the said mediator does
not support the prosecution case. The complainant further stated on oath
that he neither accompanied the raiding party nor was present at the time
of recovery. His testimony is thus in direct contradiction to that of the
shadow witness, who himself was uncertain as to whether it was the
complainant or some other person who gave the signal.
18.
PW-Abdul Gani Lone, being an official of the Vigilance
Organization, described the presence of the complainant and the shadow
witness at the time of laying the trap, yet he too was not specific regarding
the presence of the complainant at the scene of crime. The prosecution
sought to rely upon the testimony of PW-Mohd. Shaban Tan tray to
establish that the complainant had approached the appellant through him
for obtaining the revenue extract and that the appellant deliberately
avoided issuing the extract in order to demand bribe. However, this
witness stated on oath that when he approached the appellant, he was told
that the appellant was unwell and would deputize his fellow Patwari to
prepare the sketch and get it signed. This version finds support from the
statement of the appellant recorded under Section 342 Cr.P.C., wherein he
stated that due to illness he had deputed co-accused Karan Singh to
prepare the extract, which he later signed in good faith, and that there was
no transaction of money. Thus, the testimony of PW-Mohd. Shaban
Tantray does not advance the prosecution case.
19.
The learned Trial Court proceeded on the premise that once the
money was recovered from the pocket of the appellant and there was no
contradiction in the recovery evidence, it must be presumed that the same
was in pursuance of demand. Such conclusion is contrary to the settled
legal position. For proving a trap case, four essential ingredients are
required: (i) demand of illegal gratification, both initial and at the time of
trap; (ii) acceptance of money pursuant to such demand; (iii) recovery of
tainted money; and (iv) motive or consideration for demanding such
money.
20.
Insofar as the alleged initial demand of ₹1,000/- is concerned, the
same is not supported by the complainant, who merely stated that he was
asked to issue a receipt for ₹800/-, which amount was arranged by a
middleman and adjusted towards the sale consideration. What transpired
between the complainant and the appellant is not discernible from the
record. The testimony of the complainant clearly indicates absence of any
direct nexus between him and the appellant regarding demand of bribe.
The prosecution itself alleges that the demand was routed through a
middleman, yet the identity of such middleman is not established. Neither
PW-Habibullah Alaei nor PW-Mohd. Shaban Tantray admits to being
such intermediary. As regards post-trap demand and acceptance, though
the presence of PW-Abdul Gani Lone and PW-6 Opinderjeet Singh is
shown, the shadow witness categorically stated that he did not witness any
exchange of money between the complainant and the appellant. Thus,
neither demand nor acceptance has been proved by any prosecution
witness.
21.
A learned Single Judge of this Court in P. N. Dogra v. C.B.I.,
Jammu in Criminal Appeal No. 13-A/2004 decided on 21.07.2008, held
that where the prosecution itself relies upon the statement of an
independent witness to prove demand and acceptance of illegal
gratification by the accused, and such witness denies having witnessed
any such act, the burden squarely shifts upon the prosecution to establish
demand and acceptance through some other independent evidence. It was
further held that when, according to the prosecution case, independent
witnesses were available and could have been examined in this regard,
failure to do so casts a serious doubt on the prosecution version. The
officials of the department of the accused, who were examined as
witnesses to the Panchnama, were the most reliable and independent
witnesses and could have deposed with regard to demand and acceptance.
The omission to examine such witnesses creates a shadow of doubt over
the prosecution story concerning demand and acceptance of bribe by the
accused.
22.
In B. Jayaraj v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2014 (13) SCC 55, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, while dealing with a similar fact situation where
the complainant did not support the prosecution case insofar as demand of
bribe was concerned, held as under:
“8.
In the present case, the complainant did not support the prosecution
case insofar as demand by the accused is concerned. The prosecution has not
examined any other witness present at the time when the money was allegedly
handed over to the accused by the complainant to prove that the same was
pursuant to any demand made by the accused. When the complainant himself
had disowned what he had stated in the initial complaint (Ext. P-11) before
LW-9, and there is no other evidence to prove that the accused had made any
demand, the evidence of PW-1 and the contents of Ext. P-11 cannot be relied
upon to come to the conclusion that the above material furnishes proof of the
demand allegedly made by the accused. We are, therefore, inclined to hold that
the learned Trial Court as well as the High Court were not correct in holding
the demand alleged to be made by the accused as proved. The only other
material available is the recovery of the tainted currency notes from the
possession of the accused. Mere possession and recovery of the currency notes
from the accused without proof of demand will not bring home the offence
under Section 7. The above also will be conclusive insofar as the offence under
Sections 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) is concerned…”
“9.
Insofar as the presumption under Section 20 of the Act is concerned,
such presumption can be drawn only on proof of acceptance of illegal
gratification, which necessarily presupposes proof of demand. In the absence
thereof, the foundational facts for raising such presumption are wholly absent.”
23.
In Selvaraj v. State of Karnataka2015 (10) SCC 230, the Hon’ble
Apex Court, reiterating the settled legal position, held as under:
“17. In A. Subair v. State of Kerala, this Court laid down that illegal
gratification has to be proved like any other criminal offence and where the
evidence produced by the prosecution lacks quality and credibility, it would be
unsafe to base a conviction thereon.”
“31. When the evidence produced by the prosecution has neither quality nor
credibility, it would be unsafe to rest conviction upon such evidence… The
evidence on record is not sufficient to bring home the guilt of the appellant.
The appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt.”
“18. In State of Kerala v. C.P. Rao, it has been held that mere recovery of
tainted money is not sufficient to convict the accused. There must be
corroboration of the complainant’s testimony regarding demand of bribe and
the charge must be proved beyond reasonable doubt.”
The Court further reiterated the settled principles governing
interference with orders of acquittal, as laid down in Sanwat Singh v. State of
Rajasthan, emphasizing that proof of demand and acceptance is the sine qua
non for conviction in bribery cases.
23.
The consistent legal position that emerges from the aforesaid
judgments is that the prosecution must prove the charge beyond
reasonable doubt, like any other criminal offence, and the accused is
presumed innocent until proven otherwise by cogent evidence of demand
and acceptance of illegal gratification, which constitutes the most vital
ingredient for securing conviction in bribery cases. Allegations of bribery
must be examined in the backdrop of all attendant circumstances and
demand must be established by clear and clinching evidence.
24.
Applying the settled law to the facts of the present case, the
appellant has been convicted for offences under Section 5(2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act read with Section 161 RPC, despite the fact
that neither the demand of bribe in discharge of official duty nor its
acceptance has been proved from the evidence on record. Even the
recovery itself is rendered doubtful, as PW-Opinderjeet Singh
categorically stated that he was not present when the alleged exchange of
money took place between the complainant and the appellant. The trap
was not laid in the office premises of the appellant but in a private house,
the owner whereof has not supported the prosecution case. Considerable
emphasis has been placed on the alleged recovery of ₹700/- from the
appellant and ₹100/- from the co-accused, though the co-accused already
stands discharged, which has not been questioned. The prosecution case
throughout was that the appellant acted in conspiracy with the co-accused,
yet such conspiracy has failed to be established. Above all, the
complainant has completely negated the prosecution case, having neither
supported the alleged demand of bribe nor the recovery thereof.
25.
Much reliance has been placed by the prosecution on the hand-wash
and pocket-wash proceedings to contend that the exchange of money
stood proved, particularly because the sodium carbonate solution turned
pink and the shirt pocket of the appellant also showed phenolphthalein
residue. However, the law is well-settled that mere recovery of tainted
currency or positive phenolphthalein test is not sufficient to sustain
conviction unless the demand for illegal gratification is proved beyond
reasonable doubt. In B. Jayaraj v. State of A.P., 2014 (13) SCC 55, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has categorically held that proof of demand is
sine qua non for constituting an offence under the Prevention of
Corruption Act and that recovery by itself cannot give rise to a
presumption under law.
26.
In the present case, even the recovery itself is rendered doubtful.
PW-Opinderjeet Singh clearly deposed that when the raiding party rushed
to the spot, the appellant was already being restrained by a Vigilance
Inspector with both hands tied behind his back. This version has been
corroborated by PW-Abdul Gani Lone, an official of the Vigilance
Organization. In such circumstances, the possibility of phenolphthalein
powder being transferred to the hands or clothing of the appellant during
apprehension cannot be ruled out. The Supreme Court in B. Jayaraj
(supra) has cautioned that phenolphthalein test is only corroborative in
nature and cannot substitute proof of demand.
27.
Significantly, the prosecution has not disputed or questioned the
discharge of the co-accused. The testimony of Mohd. Shaban Tantray
establishes that the appellant was ill and had deputed Patwari Karan Singh
to prepare the revenue extract and obtain signatures. This explanation
stands reinforced by the appellant’s own version that he has been falsely
implicated. In the absence of independent corroboration showing
voluntary acceptance of money by the appellant, the benefit of doubt must
necessarily follow.
28.
Once the demand itself becomes doubtful or improbable, the
alleged recovery loses its legal significance. Although it is stated that the
tainted money was recovered from the right pocket of the appellant’s
shirt, there is no direct evidence showing transfer of money from the
complainant to the appellant. Even the shadow witness has failed to
clearly depose as to the actual act of acceptance. In Selvaraj (supra), the
Supreme Court has reiterated that acceptance must be proved as a
conscious and voluntary act, failing which the presumption under Section
20 of the Act cannot be invoked.
29.
The prosecution case further suffers from serious infirmities
inasmuch as it is nowhere stated as to who actually recovered the money
from the pocket of the appellant. All materials such as the tainted notes,
phenolphthalein powder, and test solutions remained within the exclusive
control of the trap-laying agency. Given that the appellant was
apprehended with both hands restrained, the possibility of manipulation or
planting of recovery cannot be ruled out. The explanation offered by the
appellant regarding his illness and deputation of the Patwari appears
plausible and finds support from the prosecution evidence itself.
30.
At the cost of repetition, though the presence of the complainant at
the pre-trap demonstration stands established, his presence thereafter is
neither discernible nor proved. Insofar as the payment of the alleged bribe
amount is concerned, the complainant has categorically denied having
produced the same before the VOK and, on the contrary, has stated that its
payment might have been made by a middleman, an assertion which does
not form part of the prosecution case. The finding recorded by the learned
Trial Court that the complainant may have been won over is purely
conjectural and is not supported by any cogent evidence. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Selvaraj (supra) has categorically held that courts
cannot draw adverse inferences against the accused on mere assumptions,
particularly when the prosecution itself has failed to establish the
foundational facts of demand and acceptance.
31.
Even the members of the raiding party, including the so-called
independent witness, have not been consistent in their testimonies, thereby
weakening the prosecution case. The learned Trial Court proceeded on
assumptions rather than legally admissible proof, which is impermissible
in criminal jurisprudence. As held in B. Jayaraj (supra), suspicion,
however strong, cannot take the place of proof.
32.
In view of the above discussion, it is evident that neither demand
nor voluntary acceptance of illegal gratification by the appellant has been
proved beyond reasonable doubt. The prosecution case is riddled with
inconsistencies and shrouded in suspicion. Consequently, the conviction
and sentence recorded by the Trial Court cannot be sustained in law and
are hereby set aside. The appellant is acquitted and shall stands discharged
of his bail bonds and the file is ordered to be consigned to records. Trial
court record in original if called for, shall be sent back with copy of the
judgement.
33.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
Judge
JAMMU
RAM MURTI
27.01.2026
Ram Murti
2026.01.27 15:15
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review