Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
……
WP(C) no.2434/2025
CM no.6459/2025
Reserved on: 02.07.2026
Pronounced on: 23.07.2026
Uploaded on: 23.07.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full
1. Mohd Hazzak Lohar, aged about 23 years S/o Sh Gulam Mohd R/o Tukson
Tehsil Reasi, J&K
2. Dheeraj Gupta Authorized signatory of JMC Transport Company aged
about 39 years S/o Sh. Satish Kumar R/o H.No.30, SEC 1-A South Extn.
Trikuta Nagar, J&K
…….Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. M. Tufail, Advocate
Versus
1. Commissioner State Tax, Excise & Taxation Complex, Kashmir, J&K
2. State Taxes Officer, Enforcement South, H.Q. Lower Munda, South
Kashmir, J&K
……Respondent(s)
Through: Mr Mohsin Qadri, Sr. AAG with
Ms. Maha Majeed, assisting counsel
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
1. Petitioners have invoked extraordinary writ jurisdiction vested in this
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, to throw challenge
to the following orders issued by the State Taxes Officer – respondent
no.2: Notice in Form GST MOV-02 dated 11th September 2025
(Annexure I);
(ii) Notice in Form GST MOV-06 dated 11th September 2025
(Annexure II);
(i)
Page 1
WP(C) no.2434/2025
(iii) Notice in Form GST DRC – 01 dated 11th September 2025 –
Summary of Show Cause Notice (Annexure III);
(iv) Summary of Order issued under Section 129 (3) dated 22nd
September 2025 (Annexure IV).
2. The impugned notices, which are purportedly issued under Section 129
of the J&K Goods and Services Tax, 2017 [“Act of 2017”], particularly
the Order dated 22nd September 2025, have been assailed by petitioners
primarily on the ground that the order dated 22nd September 2025 has
been passed by respondent no.2 after expiry of seven days stipulated in
Section 129(3) of the Act of 2017 for passing the order of payment of
penalty in terms of clause (a) or clause (b) of Subsection (1) of Section
129 of the Act.
3. Briefly put, the facts leading to filing of this petition are that on 11 th
September 2025, vehicle bearing registration no.JK02CS-0580,
belonging to petitioners was intercepted at Heerpora, Shopian by
respondent no.2. One, Mohammad Shafi, claiming to be representative
of the transporter and owner of goods carried in the vehicle, appeared
before respondent no.2, but failed to provide any document relating to
consignment loaded in the vehicle. A show cause notice in terms of
Section 129(3) of the Act of 2017 was issued on 11th September 2025,
proposing penalty to the tune of Rs.15,05,746/-. The notice was aimed
at affording an opportunity to petitioner no.1, the tax payer, to furnish
the reasons as to why penalty under Section 129(3) of the Act of 2017
may not be imposed on him for transporting the goods without proper
documents.
4. On 14th September 2025, petitioner no.1 filed his reply and agreed to
furnish bank guarantee equivalent to the amount of penalty under
Page 2
WP(C) no.2434/2025
Section 129(1) (c) of the Act of 2017, and requested for providing him
the details of authority in whose favour bank guarantee was to be
executed. The petitioner no.1 was provided the requisite but instead of
furnishing the bank guarantee as offered by him in his reply dated 14 th
September 2025, he along with Mohammad Shafi appeared before
respondent no.2 on 15th September 2025, disputing valuation of goods
seized and asked for revaluation of the cost of the goods and for redetermining the amount of penalty. On the request of petitioners, the
revaluation team was constituted on 17th September 2025. The team
verified the prevalent market rate of the commodities and submitted its
report.
5. On 18th September 2025, the officials from J&K Pollution Control
Board [“JKPCB”] intervened and after conducting inspection, declared
the polythene seized as contraband item and requested to defer issuance
of final order till a formal communication of clearance from JKPCB.
The State Taxes Department’s jurisdiction over the seized goods
became the subject to the JKPCB’s action.
6. It seems that a formal communication from JKPCB was received on
20th September 2025, declaring the seized goods as contraband under
the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016 with a request to hand over
the goods along with carrying vehicle.
7. In the backdrop of aforesaid development, respondent no.2 came to the
conclusion that the contraband goods could not be taxed as it cannot be
sold in the open market. The State Taxes Officer, thus, gave a go-by to
the penal proceedings in respect of contraband and, accordingly, issued
final order of penalty on 22nd September 2025 and excluded the penalty
Page 3
WP(C) no.2434/2025
relating to the contraband carry bags. The penalty in respect of the rest
of the goods was imposed.
8. Obviously, the order of penalty as envisaged under Section 129(3) of
the Act of 2017 could not be passed by respondent no.2 within seven
days from the date of service of notice of proposed penalty.
Indisputably, the notice of show cause for imposing penalty in terms of
Section 129 (3) of the Act of 2017 was served upon petitioner on 14th
September 2025, on which date the petitioner not only appeared before
respondent no.2 but also filed his reply. Going strictly by provisions of
Section 129(3) of the Act of 2017, the final order for payment of penalty
was to be passed by respondent no.2 within a period of seven days from
the date of service of such notice.
9. If we take service of notice upon petitioner no.1 on 14 th September
2025, the last date by or before which the order for payment of penalty
under Section 129(1) of the Act, could have been passed, was 21st
September 2025. However, in the instant case, the order imposing
penalty was passed on 22nd September 2025, i.e., after expiry of
statutory period stipulated under Section 129 (3) of the Act of 2017.
10. It is in the backdrop of aforesaid admitted factual position that the
learned counsel for petitioner contends that the notice impugned dated
22nd September 20-25 is not sustainable in law. He places reliance upon
the judgement of the Gujarat High Court in the case of Allcargo
Logistics Limited through its Distribution Manager Vijay Kumar v.
State of Gujarat and others, 2025 SCC OnLine Guj 5875, and couple of
other judgements rendered by the High Court of Madras and Patna, to
contend that the timeline prescribed under Section 129(3) of the Act of
Page 4
WP(C) no.2434/2025
2017 is mandatory in nature and failure to adhere thereto vitiates the
order for payment of penalty whether passed under clause (a) or clause
(b) of Subsection (1) of Section 129 of the Act of 2017.
11.Per contra, Mr. Mohsin Qadri, learned Sr. AAG, appearing for
respondents, would contend that the delay in issuing the order for
payment of penalty under Section 129 of the Act was occasioned due
to reasons beyond the control of respondent no.2 and, therefore, the
petitioner cannot be permitted to take the benefit of events which were
not foreseen and encountered during the course of proceedings.
12.Having heard learned counsel for parties and perused the record, we are
of the considered opinion that the timelines for issuance of show cause
notice and imposition of penalty under Section 129(3) of the Act of
2017, are mandatory in character.
13.Before we proceed to elaborate, we deem it appropriate to set out
Section 129 of the Act of 2017 in extenso:
“129. Detention, seizure and release of goods and conveyances in
transit. ––
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, where any
person transports any goods or stores any goods while they are in transit
in contravention of the provisions of this Act or the rules made
thereunder, all such goods and conveyance used as a means of transport
for carrying the said goods and documents relating to such goods and
conveyance shall be liable to detention or seizure and after detention or
seizure, shall be released, ––
(a) on payment of penalty equal to two hundred per cent of the
tax payable on such goods and, in case of exempted goods, on
payment of an amount equal to two per cent. of the value of
goods or twenty-five thousand rupees, whichever is less, where
the owner of the goods comes forward for payment of such
penalty;
(b) on payment of penalty equal to fifty per cent of the value of
the goods or two hundred per cent of the tax payable on such
goods, whichever is higher, and in case of exempted goods, on
payment of an amount equal to five per cent. of the value of
goods or twenty-five thousand rupees, whichever is less, where
the owner of the goods does not come forward for payment of
such penalty;
Page 5
WP(C) no.2434/2025
(c) upon furnishing a security equivalent to the amount payable
under clause (a) or clause (b) in such form and manner as may
be prescribed :
Provided that no such goods or conveyance shall be detained or
seized without serving an order of detention or seizure on the person
transporting the goods.
[***]
(3) The proper officer detaining or seizing goods or conveyance
shall issue a notice within seven days of such detention or seizure,
specifying the penalty payable, and thereafter, pass an order within a
period of seven days from the date of service of such notice, for payment
of penalty under clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1).
(4) No penalty shall be determined under sub-section (3) without
giving the person concerned an opportunity of being heard.
(5) On payment of amount referred in sub-section (1), all
proceedings in respect of the notice specified in sub-section (3) shall be
deemed to be concluded.
(6) Where the person transporting any goods or the owner of
such goods fails to pay the amount of penalty under sub-section (1)
within fifteen days from the date of receipt of the copy of the order
passed under sub-section (3), the goods or conveyance so detained or
seized shall be liable to be sold or disposed of otherwise, in such manner
and within such time as may be prescribed, to recover the penalty
payable under sub-section (3):
Provided that the conveyance shall be released on payment by
the transporter of penalty under sub-section (3) or one lakh rupees,
whichever is less:
Provided further that where the detained or seized goods are
perishable or hazardous in nature or are likely to depreciate in value with
passage of time, the said period of fifteen days may be reduced by the
proper officer.”
14.As is evident, Section 129 deals with detention, seizure and release of
goods and conveyances in transit. It provides that if any person
transports any goods or stores any goods while they are in transit in
contravention of the provisions of the Act of 2017 or rules made
thereunder, all such goods and conveyance used as a means of transport
as also documents relating to such goods and conveyance shall be liable
to detention or seizure. The Section further provides that goods,
conveyance or documents so seized shall be released only on payment
of penalty equivalent to two hundred percent of the tax payable on such
goods and in case of exempted goods, on payment of an amount equal
to two percent of the value of goods or Rs.25,000/- whichever is less,
where owner of the goods comes forward for payment of such penalty.
Page 6
WP(C) no.2434/2025
However, where the owner of goods does not come forward for
payment of penalty, he shall be liable to pay penalty equal to fifty
percent of the value of goods or two hundred percent of the tax payable
on such goods whichever is higher, and in case of exempted goods, on
payment of an amount equal to five percent of the value of goods or
Rs.25,000/- whichever is less and it is only payment of such penalty
that the goods, conveyance or the documents as the case may be shall
be released.
15.Subsection 3, which is relevant for the purpose of our discussion, lays
down that the proper officer, who detains or seizes goods or
conveyance, shall issue a notice within seven days of such detention or
seizure, specifying the penalty payable and thereafter pass an order
within a period of seven days form the date of service of such notice for
payment under clause (a) or clause (b) of Subsection (1) of Section 129
of the Act of 2017.
16.From the plain reading of Subsection (3) of Section 129 of the Act of
2017, it is abundantly clear that the legislature by using the expression
“shall” in respect of show cause notice as well as notice for payment of
penalty has signified its intent that adherence to timeline is mandatory.
Otherwise also, the Act of 2017 is a fiscal statute and, therefore,
required to be construed strictly. It is true that Subsection (3) of Section
129 of the Act of 2017 does not provide for consequence of nonadhering to the timelines but that alone cannot be a determining factor
to come to a conclusion that seven days’ period stipulated in Subsection
(3) of Section 129, is not mandatory in nature.
Page 7
WP(C) no.2434/2025
17.We are, thus, inclined to concur with a view taken by various High
Courts and the High Court of Gujarat that the timelines under Section
123 of the Act are mandatory. This is so primary for the following
reasons:
(i)
The provision regulates exercise of coercive statutory power;
(ii)
It protects valuable primary rights;
(iii)
The legislature has prescribed timelines using the word “shall”;
(iv)
Treating timelines in Section 129(3) as directory would defeat
the legislative purpose of preventing prolonged detention and
seizure of goods, conveyance or documents of the transporter or
the assesee;
(v)
The absence of express consequences of a mandatory provision
is not always decisive.
(vi)
The legislative intent, object of provision and the nature of right
affected are governing tests.
(vii) Whenever the statute authorizes coercive action, like seizure or
detention, the Courts insist on strict compliance with the
statutory procedure.
18.It is, thus, beyond any pale of discussion that whether the provision is
mandatory or not, depends upon the legislative intent, context, object
and the consequences of non-compliance.
19.From the perusal of the provision in question in the context of the
scheme of the Act of 2017, it is axiomatic that the timelines have been
introduced to prevent arbitrary detention, prolonged seizure and
harassment to the trader. It is in keeping with the aforesaid intention
that the legislature has used the expression “shall” at two places in
Section 129 (3) of the Act.
20.The view, which we have taken on the interpretation of Section 129(3)
finds support from the judgements rendered on the point by various
Page 8
WP(C) no.2434/2025
High Courts. The High Court of Gujarat in Allcargo Logistics Limited
(supra) and couple of other judgements, has held the provisions of
Section 129(3) mandatory and held that failure to adhere to the
timelines prescribed therein would vitiate order of detention.
21.We are aware that in the instant case there is only delay of one day in
passing the order of penalty by respondent no.2 and that there were
some intervening circumstances contributing to such delay, yet in view
of the clear provisions of Section 129 (3) of the Act, respondent no.2
was under an obligation to pass the order of payment of penalty within
a period of seven days from the date of service of show cause notice of
proposed penalty and this the respondent no.2 could have done with
respect to the goods other than the banned contraband, i.e., polythene.
22.In view of the aforesaid, we are left with no option but to accept this
petition. Accordingly, writ petition is allowed and impugned
notice/order dated 22nd September 2025, issued to petitioner for
payment of penalty, having been issued beyond the period of seven
days, is quashed.
23.We, however, make it clear that notwithstanding the quashing of the
notice dated 22nd September 2025, the proceedings, if any, permissible
under the other provisions of the Act of 2017 can still be pursued by
respondents.
24.Disposed of.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Chief Justice (Acting)
Srinagar
23.07.2026
Ajaz Ahmad, Secy
Whether approved for reporting? Yes/No
Page 9
WP(C) no.2434/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review