Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: CM(M) No. 281/2024,
CM Nos. 2085/2025, 2659/2026,
7490/2024 & 502/2025
Reserved on : 08.09.2026
Pronounced on :18.09.2026
Uploaded on 18 .09.2026
1. Modern
Hotel
Shakuntla
Complex
Private
Limited
through
Romesh
Chander
Mahajan, age 85 years, son of
late Lala Ram Chand Mahajan,
R/O 72 A/D Gandhi Nagar,
Jammu.
2. Rahul Mahajan, aged 50 years,
S/O Shri Ramesh Chander
Mahajan,
R/O 72, A/D Gandhi Nagar,
Jammu.
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Anil Sethi, Advocate
Vs.
Sudhir Gandotra
S/O Late Radha Krishan,
R/O H.No. 28, Karan Nagar,
Jammu.
…. Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Ayushman Kotwal, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioners, through the medium of the present petition, have
challenged order dated 22.07.2024 passed by Assistant Labour
Commissioner, Jammu, in his capacity as Controlling Authority
CM(M) No. 281/2024
(under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972) (hereinafter referred to as
“the authority”).
2. Vide the impugned order, the authority has refused to set aside the
exparte order dated 13.11.2023 passed by the said authority whereby
the petitioners have been asked to deposit an amount of Rs. 9,26,024/on account of claim of the respondent under the provisions of
Payment of Wages Act.
3. According to the petitioners, the respondent was their employee w.e.f.
1984 to June, 2011 and in June, 2011 he voluntarily resigned from the
office of the petitioners. It has been submitted that the respondent,
while withholding the aforesaid crucial information of his voluntary
abandonment of service, obtained an ex parte order from the authority
on 13.11.2023, whereby the petitioners were asked to make a payment
of Rs. 7,78,846/- along with interest of Rs. 1,47,178/- to the
respondent.
4. It has been submitted that the authority has not found any logic in the
plea of the petitioners that the respondent had voluntarily left the
service, regarding which a certificate was produced before the
authority. It has been submitted that the petitioners have approached
the Deputy Labour Commissioner, Jammu, with an appeal, but the
said authority has refused to entertain the appeal in the absence of the
deposit of 100% of the awarded amount, as required under Section
7(7) of the Payment of Gratuity Act. It has been submitted that
insistence upon the deposit of 100% of the amount with the appellate
authority is operating harshly against the petitioners, who have a valid
right to present their stand and establish the same before the Court. It
CM(M) No. 281/2024
has been submitted that in the light of the certificate issued by the
Provident Fund Organization, Jammu, the respondent ceased to be an
employee of the petitioners from June, 2011, the period for which he
claims gratuity and its arrears. It has been further submitted that even
an application for setting aside the ex parte order was not properly
entertained by the authority.
5. The respondent has raised a preliminary objection to the
maintainability of the present petition on two counts:(i)
That the order of the authority whereby the claims of the
respondent against the petitioners have been allowed, as also
the impugned order dated 22.07.2024 whereby the authority has
refused to set aside the ex parte order dated 13.11.2023, are
appealable in nature in terms of Section 7(7) of the Payment of
Gratuity Act and, therefore, the petition is not maintainable. It
has been contended that the petitioners, in order to circumvent
the requirement of depositing the awarded amount at the time of
filing of the appeal, have invoked the writ jurisdiction, which is
impermissible in law.
(ii)
That the petitioners have filed two writ petitions previously on
the same cause of action, and both these writ petitions have
been dismissed as withdrawn by the petitioners without
obtaining liberty to file a fresh writ petition. It has been
submitted that, without bringing these facts to the notice of this
Court, the petitioners have again invoked the writ jurisdiction,
which is not permissible under law.
CM(M) No. 281/2024
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused record of the
case.
7. Without going into the question as to whether the impugned order
dated 22.07.2024 passed by the authority refusing to set aside the ex
parte award dated 13.11.2023 is appealable in nature, this Court
would like to deal with the second contention raised by the respondent
in the first instance.
8. In the above context, the respondent has placed on record a copy of
the petition bearing CM(M) No. 183/2024 filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution, challenging order dated 22.07.2024, which is also
the subject matter of the present writ petition. It appears that the said
petition was withdrawn by the petitioners as is clear from order dated
09.08.2024 passed by this Court. However, liberty was given to the
petitioners to seek an appropriate remedy available under law.
Thereafter, the petitioners filed another writ petition under Article 226
of the Constitution, bearing WP(C) No. 2195/2024, before this Court,
challenging the same order dated 22.07.2024 passed by the authority.
The said writ petition was also dismissed as withdrawn in terms of
order dated 09.09.2024 passed by this Court. This time, no liberty was
granted to the petitioners to avail of any kind of remedy.
9. After making two attempts to challenge order dated 22.07.2024, first
by filing a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution and second
by filing a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, the
petitioners have filed the present petition again under Article 227 of
the Constitution, challenging the same order. It is significant to
mention here that, in the present petition, the petitioners have not even
CM(M) No. 281/2024
made a whisper about the previous two petitions filed by them. In fact,
in para No. 8 of the petition, it has been mentioned that the petitioners
have not filed any other writ, suit or appeal on the same cause of
action before any legal forum, including Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10.In the face of the aforesaid facts, the question arises as to whether the
present petition is maintainable.
11.It is a well-settled principle of law that a subsequent writ petition on
the same cause of action, after withdrawing the initial writ petition
without liberty to file a fresh petition from the Court, is barred on the
ground of public policy. In this context the Supreme Court, in the case
of Sarguja Transport Service Vs. State Transport Appellate
Tribunal, M.P., Gwalior and others, 1987 (1) SCC 5, has observed
as under:“ 9. The point for consideration is whether a petitioner after
with-drawing a writ petition filed by him in the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India without the
permission to institute a fresh petition can file a fresh writ
petition in the High Court under that Article. On this point the
decision in Daryao's case (supra) is of no assistance. But we
are of the view that the principle underlying Rule 1 of Order
XXIII of the Code should be extended in the interests of
administration of justice to cases of withdrawal of writ petition
also, not on the ground of res judicata but on the ground of
public policy as explained above. It would also discourage the
litigant from indulging in bench-hunting tactics. In any event
there is no justifiable reason in such a case to permit a
petitioner to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution once again. While
the withdrawal of a writ petition filed in a High Court without
permission to file a fresh writ petition may not bar other
CM(M) No. 281/2024
remedies like a suit or a petition under Article 32 of the
Constitution of India since such withdrawal does not amount to
res judicata, the remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India should be deemed to have been abandoned by the
petitioner in respect of the cause of action relied on in the writ
petition when he withdraws it without such permission. In the
instant case the High Court was right in holding that a fresh
writ petition was not maintainable before it in respect of the
same subject-matter since the earlier writ petition had been
withdrawn without permission to file a fresh petition. We,
however, make it clear that whatever we have stated in this
order may not be considered as being applicable to a writ
petition involving the personal liberty of an individual in which
the petitioner prays for the issue of a writ in the nature of
habeas corpus or seeks to enforce the fundamental right
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution since such a
case stands on a different footing altogether. We, however leave
this question open.”
12.From the aforesaid observations of the Supreme Court, it is clear that
the public policy prevents a litigant from filing repeated petitions for
the same grievance and estops a litigant from resorting to the practice
of bench hunting. In fact, resorting to such practice amounts to an
abuse of judicial process. A litigant can approach the Court again only
if a completely distinct and subsequent event creating a new brand of
cause of action after withdrawal of the writ petition arises.
Withdrawing a writ petition without liberty from the Court means that
the litigant has legally abandoned his extraordinary remedy under
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution for that specific issue.
13.In the present case, the petitioners have challenged the impugned
order on two previous occasions and, on both occasions, they have
CM(M) No. 281/2024
withdrawn the petitions. On the first occasion, the petitioners were
given liberty to avail of an appropriate remedy, but on the second
occasion, the petitioners withdrew the writ petition without any
liberty. To top it all, the petitioners did not think it even appropriate to
make reference to the previous attempts made by them to challenge
the impugned order by way of two previous petitions and had the
courage to specifically plead in the present petition that they have not
filed any other writ, suit or appeal on the same cause of action. Thus,
on the ground of public policy, the present petition is not
maintainable.
14.Petitioner No. 2 has sworn an affidavit in support of the petition, and
in the petition, it has been stated that the petitioners have not filed any
other writ, suit or appeal on the same cause of action. This statement,
on the face of it, appears to be false. Therefore, petitioner No. 2
deserves to be proceeded against for having made a false statement in
the present petition. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed, and it is
further directed that a show cause notice be issued to petitioner No. 2,
asking him as to why he should not be proceeded against for having
committed perjury by filing a false affidavit.
15.The Registry shall post this matter on 21.10.2026 for the limited
purpose of considering appropriate action against petitioner No. 2.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Jammu
18.09.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.09.18 14:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM(M) No. 281/2024
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review