Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 1887 of 2025
Mithuya Roy (Sarkar) & Ors.
VERSUS
Union of India
For the appellants/claimants:
Mr. Sujay Sinha, Adv.
For the respondent/Union of India:
Mr. Asis Mukherjee, Adv.
Last Heard on: September 15, 2026
Judgment on: October 01, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury, J:
The appellants before this Court were applicants in a case under Section
124A of the Railways Act 1988 and are aggrieved by the Judgment and Award
dated 25-05-2023 passed by Learned Railway Claims Tribunal Kolkata Bench
in OA(IIu)/Kol/25/2022.
The case of the appellants before the Learned Tribunal may be summed
up thus:-
The accident took place on 27/11/2021 at night at about 23.30 to 23.45
hours. The victim who was a resident of Shimurali Nadia on 27/11/2021 early
morning came to Palpara Station nearest and convenient rail head along with
his wife Mithuya Roy Sarkar after purchasing a return Journey ticket for both
of them from Palpara to Dumdum Cantonment Both of them boarded a local
train from Palpara Station. He was on his way to Dum-Dum Cantonment to his
relative’s house and also for some personal work purpose at Dum-Dum area.
On their way they alight at Dum-Dum Junction Station to catch a train for
Dum-Dum Cant. as there is no direct train service available on that particular
route from Palpara. After completion of his work and brief stay at his relative’s
house at Dum-Dum Cant. they again came to Dum-Dum Junction Station at
late night and boarded an up Ranaghat bound local train from that station to
return back to their house. During the course of journey when the train arrived
at Barrackpore station victim came near the door of the said train
compartment with an intention to see his brother Basudev Roy who came to
Barrackpore for his work and was supposed to board that train from that
station but unable to see his brother Basudev Roy who came to Barrackpore
for his work he stood near the door and in the process when the train reached
at Naihati end of Platform no. 1 at Km Past no. 25/4-25/6 in between Palta
and Ichapore Station due to sudden jerk the victim lost his balance and fell
down from the running train. The victim’s wife who was inside, the
compartment after listening the hue and cry of other passengers that some
person had fallen down from the compartment she became sure that her
husband had fallen down. Instantly she tried to call her brother in Law, who
was supposed to board the same train. When the train reached next station at
Ichapore she alighted from the train waited for her brother in law who also
after knowing such incident alighted at Ichapore Station and met with the
victim’s wife and came back to Palta; In the meantime on being officially
informed by the booking superior of Palta railway station through a memo
which was treated as first information report investigating officer of Naihati
GRPS reached the accident spot at about 1.00 AM midnight and prepared.
Inquest report in the presence of available witness. During inquest two journey
tickets were recovered from the body of the victim which were seizedThe respondent Railway Authority contested the case by filing written
statement. ISSUES were framed and evidence was adduced. Learned Tribunal
upon considering the evidence adduced and upon hearing the Learned
Advocates was pleased to dismiss the claim case by observing as follows:‘The applicant could not succeed to prove by adducing cogent evidence
that the deceased was travelling in the train on the date of incident and that
his death was caused by injury due to fall from a running train Besides the
ticket did not belong to the deceased.’
The appellants/applicants being aggrieved by the Judgment passed by
the Learned Tribunal has come up with the instant appeal.
Heard Learned Advocate for the appellant and Learned Advocate for the
respondent. Perused the materials on record.
Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that the Learned Tribunal
has rejected the claim solely on conjunctures and surmise without considering
the entire chain of documentary evidence. Learned Advocate further submits
that, FIR, Investigation Report Final Police Report, post Mortem Report certified
copy of Railway Tickets, and seizure list were exhibited without objection thus
the said documents cannot be discarded merely on speculative reasoning.
Learned Advocate also submits that the Railway has never disputed time
of occurrence place of occurrence, and recovery of dead body from railway
track. It is submitted by the Learned Advocate that the Inquest Report reveals
that the deceased travelled with his wife, and he accidentally fell between Palta
and Ichapore Station. Wife cum co-passenger and relatives subsequently
identified the body. Learned Advocate submits that the tribunal relied upon the
decision in Jetty Naga Lakshmi Parvathi and ors. VS Union of India and
proceeded on the basis that the initial burden was upon the claimants.
However the said principle does not mean that the claimant must produce an
eyewitness or an undisputed railway ticket in every case.
Learned Advocate further submits that the Tribunal proceeded upon its
perception that the conduct attributed to the wife was contrary to ‘common
sense’ and ‘normal human behavior.’ However human behavior following a
sudden railway accident cannot be reduced to one predetermined pattern of
conduct. A person witnessing a sudden fall of a close family member from a
moving train may react with shock confusion fear, helplessness or panic.
Learned Advocate also submits that minor variations regarding the wifes
subsequent destination could not destroy the core of her evidence.
Learned Advocate relies upon the following Judicial decision:Rajni and Anr. VS Union of India.
Reported in 2025 INSC. 1201.
Rumpa Mallick and ors VS Union of India.
FMA-1315 of 2015.
(High Court at Calcutta).
Sulata Kanji and Anr. VS Union of India.
FMA-1886 of 2025.
(High Court at Calcutta)
Kharka Bahadur Chetri VS Union of India.
FMA-1134 of 2024.
(High Court at Calcutta).
Smt. Yellamma VS Union of India.
FMA-No.-6117/2016.
(High Court at Karnataka)
Ram Sudha Devi VS Union of India.
MA-229 of 2009.
(High Court at Patna).
Learned Advocate for the respondent Railway Authority submits that the
appellant failed to prove that the death of the victim was an untoward incident.
Learned Advocate further submits that no independent co-passenger railway
employee, guard, station official or local eyewitnesses was examined to
establish that the deceased had boarded the alleged train or was travelling
therein or fell from it. Learned Advocate also submits that the post mortem
report states that death was due to the effect of head injury, and it does not
state that the head injury arose from accidental fall from running train.
It is submitted by the Learned Advocate that the version of AW-1 is
contradictory and the versions do not concern a minor discrepancy. The three
versions place her at, Ichapur Palpara and Ranaghat after the same alleged
occurrence. It is further submitted that the alleged ticket recovery is not proved
and the alleged seizure does not establish that tickets were recovered from the
deceased or that he was a bona-fide passenger. It is also submitted that AW-1
a signatory to the seizure list was not present at the spot when body was
searched. The other witness Amit Roy was a GRPS constable and was not an
independent recovery witness. It is submitted that the appeal be dismissed.
Before proceeding to decide on the issue it is to be remembered that it is
an admitted fact that body of the victim was recovered from railway track and
there is no direct evidence that the victim was run over by any train or that the
victim’s house is near the place where the accident took place, and it is quite
far from the place where the body was recovered. Thus there is no scope to
presume that the victim was crossing the Railway Track. In the case of Kharka
Bahadur Chettri VS Union of India (supra) it was observed as follows:‘The Railway Authority in the absence of identification of the body came
to the finding that it is a case of knocking down by running train but when the
body is identified and the place of residence of the victim is ascertained there is
no scope to accept the findings of running down by train in absence of direct
evidence when the victim is not residing in the area where incident took place
nor has any place of business or employment in the nearby area but resides in
a place about more than 1000 Kilometres from the place of incident.’
Similarly in the instant case considering the place of residence of victim
and place of recovery of body at night there is no scope to presume that the
victim came to the railway track.
Although the post mortem report mentions only about head injury and
not about falling from train but the recovery of body, the head injury and post
mortem report taken together will be the ground to arrive at a conclusion about
death due to fall from train.
Upon perusal of the evidence of AW-1 it appears that AW-1 specified in
details about the incidents which took place on the date of accident, as well as
the place and time of accident.
In cross-examination also the witness stated about the date of accident
and that she was with her husband on the said date and that they boarded the
train from Dum-Dum cantonment. She further stated that her Bhasur was to
board the same train and so her husband was watching whether he boarded
the train or not. Thus nothing could be shaken in cross-examination of AW-1
that she along with her husband boarded the train from Dum-DumCantonment on the date of accident and that her Bhasur was to board the
same train and so her husband was watching whether he boarded the train or
not.
The statement of AW-1 is corroborated by the statement of Basudev Roy
before RPF. Basudev Roy in the statement before RPF contended that on 2711-2021 he was at Palta area for his work and by night he had to pick up the
UP train from Palta Station and in that train his deceased brother and his wife
Mithuya Roy also returned from Dum-Dum-Cantonment. But on the said day
he tried to call his deceased brother and there was no response. In the morning
he got information from GRP/Naihati that his brother died in Rail accident.
The Inquest Report and Final Report under Section 174 CrPC submitted
by Police Authority further strengthens the case of the Appellants about victim
Somnath Roy dying due to fall from the train.
Although there is discrepancy in statement of AW-1 with regard to place
she went after accident but the fact she boarded the train along with her
husband being established the discrepancy with regard to places she went after
accident is not fatal. As AW-1 faced a tragic incident in her life, confusion in
making statement’s and discrepancy recorded is not unnatural.
Now with regard to recovery of journey ticket although it is held in
different Judicial pronouncements that mere non-recovery of Railway ticket is
not fatal but in the instant case Police Authority has recovered two railway
tickets by preparing seizure list. As general people are not always available to
sign seizure list near railway track where body is found the signature of Police
person cannot be a ground to disbelieve the seizure list.
When Police Authority has conducted investigation in accordance with
law and submitted report the said report should not be discarded on the
ground that investigation is perfunctory without examining the investigating
officer. In the facts and circumstances discussed above this Court is of the view
that the death of the victim Somnath Roy was an untoward incident. Thus the
appellants are entitled to compensation.
Hence this Appeal FMA-1887 of 2025 stands allowed. The Judgment and
Award dated 25/05/2023 passed by the Learned Railway Claims Tribunal
Kolkata in Claim Case No. OA(IIu)/Kol/25/2022 is set aside. The appellants
are entitled to compensation of Rs. 8,00,000/-. The respondent Railway
Authority shall deposit Rs. 8,00,000/- along with interest @6% per annum
from date by filing claim case till today. Such deposit shall be made within 8
weeks from the date of communication of this Order. The appellant are entitled
to withdraw the compensation upon compliance of necessary formalities.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review