Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.271 of 2025
Mita Deb Saha
W/O Goutam Saha, R/O Subhash Palli, AD Nagar,
P.O & P.S:A.D. Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura.
------ Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, PWD(R & B),
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
New Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
New Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Chief Engineer (R&B),
Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
New Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
------ Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Aradhita Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Pradyumna Gautam, Sr. G.A.,
Date of hearing
:
25.02.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
03.03.2026
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the following
reliefs:
a) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
regularize the Petitioner with all incidental and consequential
benefit in the post of Group-C, w.e.f. 01.01.2008, the date the
Petitioner’s service was regularized as Peon, Group-D after
completion of 10 years as Casual Worker since her initial
engagement on 12.03.1992.
b) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders
shall not be issued whereby quashing and cancelling the letter,
dated, 16.04.2025, issued by the Engineering Officer, to the Chief
Engineer, PWD(R&B).
c) Make the rules absolute.
d) Call for records.
e) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble High Court
considered fit and proper.
And
For this act of kindness, your humble Petitioner as in duty bound
shall ever pray.
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Aradhita Debbarma appearing on
behalf of the petitioner and also heard Learned Sr. G.A., Mr.
Pradyumna Gautam appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
3.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner drawn the attention of this Court by a memorandum dated
12.03.1992, the petitioner was engaged as a Casual Worker under the
establishment of Executive Engineer, Agartala, Division-IV (Annexure1). Thereafter, she completed her Madhyamik Pariksha(Secondary
Examination) from TBSE in the year 1997(Annexure-2). After that,
the Engineering Officer to the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B) forwarded
one
communication
(Annexure-3)
to
informing
Time/Contingent/Casual
Joint
Secretary,
the
list
Workers
Finance
of
against
the
Department
DRW/Part
memorandum
No.20.10.2003 wherein the name of the petitioner was reflected in
serial No.141. After that, the Under Secretary, Finance Department
forwarded one letter to Treasury Officer, Agartala Treasury No.I &
II/Udaipur/Kailashahar/Ambassa
on
15.06.2004(Annexure-4)
informing the list of DRW/Contingent/Part Time employees wherein
the name of the petitioner was shown to be in serial No.2590 as a
Casual Worker. After that, on 01.09.2008 the Government of Tripura
issued one memorandum regarding regularization of services of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent workers. For the sake of convenience, the
same is mentioned herein below:
No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part)
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated, Agartala, the 1st September, 2008
MEMORANDUM
Subject:
Regularization of services of DRWs/Casual/
Contingent Workers on completion of 10 years
of service as on 31-03-2008
The undersigned is directed to inform that the Government
has taken a policy decision to regularize services of fulltime
DRWs/Casual/Contingent
Workers
who
have
completed 10 (ten) years of service as on 31-03-2008 and
fulfill the following criterion as per Department-wise names
and particulars attached herewith:
i)
DRW/Casual/Contingent
workers
who
were
engaged on a full time basis in different Departments
with or without concurrence of Finance Department
and have completed 10 years of service as on 31-32008 other than Permanent Labourers, Part-time
workers, Anganwadi Workers and Helpers, Home
Guards, Teachers and Workers engaged under SSA and
other Schemes/programmes, may be considered for
regularization as per names attached.
ii) Requirement of age as per Recruitment Rules will
be deemed to be relaxed for the purpose of this
regularization.
iii) Requirement of educational qualification as per
Recruitment Rules will be deemed as relaxed for
regularization under Group D only. In case of
DRW/and Contingent Workers who were appointed
under Group category, educational qualification as
required under concerned R.R. must be ensured while
entertaining their cases for regularization.
iv) Except age and educational qualification mentioned
in point (iii) all other criterion as per relevant
Recruitment Rules including reservation roster will
have to be followed strictly for this process of
regularization.
vi) Subject to fulfillment of above conditions, the
eligible workers will be provided pay scale in the
relevant grade for their regularization which will take
effect from 1st July 2008.
2. To facilitate quick action for implementation of the above
decision, appropriate authorities of the concerned
Administrative Departments of the State Government are
authorized to take following actions:
i) The Departments will scrutinize the records and
particulars of the workers whose names and
particulars are included in the annexure attached
herewith
to
ascertain
their
eligibility
for
regularization. Only those workers out of the attached
annexure who fulfills all the above criterion are to be
regularized.
ii) While ascertaining eligibility, other than relaxation
made in respect of educational qualification and age,
other requirements like nationality. reservation quota
are to be followed strictly.
iii) After ascertaining the number of eligible cases, the
department will take steps for creation of required
number of posts in the appropriate category including
creation for post for SC and ST as per 100 point roster
for accommodating them in the concerned pay scale
for regularization. The computation is to be done to
ensure 31% reservation for ST & 17% reservation for
SC against the member of UR candidates as per list
enclosed without bringing any previous backlog.
Formal appointment orders are to be issued by
concerned appropriate authority accordingly. After
taking this step department will send proposal to the
Finance Department for ex-post-facco concurrence for
creation of posts.
iv) Following regularization of the eligible cases out of
list attached herewith, the Departments are required
to take action to ensure recruitment of shortfall of
candidates under ST & SC category to fulfill the roster.
In respect of such shortfall under Group D category,
the Tribal Welfare Department would act as the Nodal
Department for selection of required number of
candidates and sponsoring them to the respective
Department. The Departments are requested to send a
report within one month to the Finance Department
indicating
action
taken
as
per
the
instant
Memorandum and details of posts filled up/lying
vacant on completion of the process.
3. The undersigned is directed to request all concerned to
ensure strict implementation of the above decisions.
Joint Secretary to the
Government of Tripura
To
Secretary In-charge of_______________Department
Copy to:
1. Principal Secretary to the Governor, Tripura
2. Principal Secretary to Chief Minister, Govt. of Tripura
3. The Chief Secretary, Tripura, Agartala.
4. PS/PA to all Ministers, Govt. of Tripura
5. AG, Tripura, Agartala.
6. All T.O./S.T.O.
Learned Counsel after that submitted that the respondentauthority by a office order dated 10.10.2008 appointed the petitioner
in the post of peon with effect from 01.01.2008 under PWD
Department(Annexure-6) and accordingly she joined and started
discharging
her
duties.
Thereafter,
by
office
order
dated
16.10.2008(Annexure-7), the then SDO(PWD), Amtali Sub-Division,
Badharghat released the petitioner to join in the office of SDO(PWD)
Amtali
Sub-Division
immediately.
Thereafter,
on
16.09.2013,
Engineering Officer to the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B) issued one Final
Seniority List of Group-D employees (Annexure-8) wherein the name
of the petitioner was shown in serial No.783 as a permanent worker
with effect from 01.01.2008 as Madhyamik passed. Learned Counsel
thereafter candidly submitted that the Superintendent Engineer, 4th
Circle, PWD(R&B) on 16.08.2021 forwarded a proposal to the
Engineer-in-Chief, PWD Department, requiring for promotion to the
post
of
LDC
from
various
categories
of
Group-D
employees
(Annexure-9). The petitioner accordingly submitted her representation
on 27.01.2025 to the Department for regularization in Group-C post
(Annexure-10).
The
said
representation
of
the
petitioner
was
forwarded by the office of SDO, Amtali sub-Division, PWD(R&B) to the
office of Executive Engineer, Bishalgarh Division, PWD(R&B) on
27.01.2025 (Annexure-11).
According to Learned Senior Counsel, another employee Sibu
Deb who was also engaged as a Casual Worker was regularized to the
post of Work Assistant(Group-C) on regular basis with effect from the
date of regularization in the earlier Group-D post i.e. 01.01.2007 but
the respondent-authority did not consider the case of the petitioner.
In this regard, information was sought for through RTI and in the
reply, it was mentioned that said Sibu Deb who was joined as DRW
was engaged on 08.08.1988 and on completion of 15 years of service,
he was regularized with effect from 01.01.2007. However, according
to Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner although the present
petitioner was in the similarly situated position but her representation
was not considered by the authority. Thereafter, one Anima Debnath
and Aparajita Bhowmik filed two separate writ petitions (Annexure-14
and Annexure-15) and this High Court directed the respondentauthority to consider their appointment as a Group-C in accordance
with the recruitment rules and accordingly, those employees were
regularized as Group-C employees. Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner thereafter submitted that the petitioner submitted one
representation to the authority to get her regularized in Group-C post
but her representation was not considered. Hence, the petitioner filed
the writ petition.
4.
The State-respondents have contested the writ petition by
filing counter affidavit. In para Nos.9 and 10, they have asserted as
under:
“9. That, in response to the contents of paragraphs-3 to 12
of this writ petition, I humbly submit that the petitioner
was engaged as a Casual Worker vide Memorandum
No.F.6(100)-PWD(E-II)/70(pt-90)dated 12/03/1992 of
the Chief Engineer, PWD (Annexure-1 to the Writ Petition)
& accordingly assumed her duties on 12/03/1992 under
the control of Executive Engineer, Agartala Division No-IV,
Agartala in Public Works Department, Government of
Tripura. At the time of engagement being a Casual Worker
the educational qualification of the Petitioner was
Madhyamik plucked. Later on the petitioner had passed the
Madhyamik Examination from Tripura Board of Secondary
Education in the year 1997 being an external candidate.
The Petitioner didn't take any No Objection from her
employer i.e., Public Works Department, Government of
Tripura prior to appearing before Madhyamik Examination
conducted by Tripura Board of Secondary Education.
Subsequently the Government had taken a policy Vide
Memorandum
No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)
/2008(Part),
dtd.
01/09/2008 of the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, Finance Department (Annexure-5
to the Writ Petition) to regularize services of full time
DRWs/Casual/Contingent Workers who have completed 10
(ten) years of service as on 31-03-2008 after observing the
following criteria:I) DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who were engaged on
a full time basis in different Department with or without
concurrence of Finance Department and have completed 10
(ten) years of service as on 31-03-2008 other than
Permanent Labourers, Part-time Workers, Anganwadi
Workers and Helpers, Home Guards, Teachers and Workers
engaged under SSA other Schemes/programmes, may be
considered for regularisation.
II) Requirement of age as per Recruitment Rules will be
treated as relaxed for this purpose of this regularisation.
III) Requirement of educational qualification as per
Recruitment Rules will be treated as relaxed for
regularisation of Group-D only. In case of DRW/and
Contingent Workers who were appointed under Group-C
category, educational qualification as required under
concerned Recruitment Rules must be ensured while
entertaining their cases for regularisation.
IV) Except age and educational qualification mentioned in
point (III) all other criteria as per relevant Recruitment
Rules including reservation roster will have to be followed
strictly for this process of regularisation.
V) Subject to fulfillment of above conditions, the eligible
workers will be provided pay scale in the relevant grade for
their regularisation which will take effect from 1st July
2008.
But, in the instant case service of the petitioner was
regularized as a Peon, Group- D temporarily for a period of
01 (one) year on regular basis w.e.f 01/01/2008 Office
Order No.F.6(29)PWD(E-II)/07(P-VI) dtd. 10/10/2008 of
the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B) (Annexure-6 to the Writ
Petition) due to the following reason:1. Finance Department Vide Memorandum No.F.10(2)FIN(G)/2008(Part), dt.01/09/2008 (Annexure-8 to the
Writ Petition) had recommended the name of the Petitioner
being a Group-D as his educational qualification at the time
of joining in this Department being a casual worker was
Madhyamik fail (plucked).
2. Further in the same memorandum dated 01/09/2008 it
was directed by the Finance Department at Para 1 (iii) that
"Requirement
of
educational
qualification
as
per
Recruitment Rules will be treated as relaxed for
regularisation under Group-D only. In case of DRW/and
Contingent Workers who were appointed under Group-C
category, educational qualification as required under
concerned Recruitment Rules must be ensured while
entertaining their cases for regularisation".
3. Prior to appear before the Madhyamik Examination the
petitioner didn't take No Objection Certificate from her
present employer i.e., Public Works Department.
And, for this aforesaid reasons, the Administrative
Department Vide Office Order No.F.6(29)PWD(E-II)/07(PVI) dt. 10/10/2008 of the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B)
(Annexure-6 to the Writ Petition) had regularized the
service of the petitioner being a Peon, Group-D temporarily
for a period of 01 (one) year on regular basis w.e.f
01/01/2008.
10. That, in response to the contents of paragraphs-13 to
17 of this writ petition, I humbly submit that one Shri
Shibu Deb was engaged as DRW on 08-08-1988. At the
time of his engagement being a DRW his qualification was
Madhyamik failed. Later on he qualified Madhyamik
Examination from Tripura Board of Secondary Education in
the year 1989. Subsequently the Government had taken a
policy Vide Memorandum No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2005, dated
22/02/2007 of the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, Finance Department to regularize
services of full time DRWs/ Casual/Contingent Workers
who have completed 15 (fifteen) years of service as on 3103-2006 after observing the following criteria :-
a) DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who were engaged on
a full time basis in different Department with or without
concurrence of Finance Department and have completed 15
years of service as on 31/03/2006 other than Permanent
Labourers, Part-time Workers, Anganwadi Workers and
Helpers, Home Guards, Teachers and Workers engaged
under SSA other Schemes/programmes, may be considered
for regularisation.
b) Requirement of age as per Recruitment Rules will deem
to be relaxed for the purpose of this regularisation.
c) Requirement of educational qualification as per
Recruitment Rules will be deemed as relaxed for
regularisation of under Group-D only. In case of DRW/and
Contingent Workers who were appointed under Group-C
category, educational qualification as required under
concerned Recruitment Rules must be ensured while
entertaining their cases for regularisation.
d) Except age and educational qualification mentioned in
point (C) all other criteria as per relevant Recruitment
Rules including reservation roster will have to be followed
strictly for this process of regularisation.
e) Subject to fulfillment of above conditions, the eligible
workers will be provided pay scale in the relevant grade for
their
regularisation
which
will
take
effect
from
01/01/2007.
Likewise the petitioner, Shri Shibu Deb was also appointed
as a Peon, Group D employee temporarily for a period of
01(one) year in the post of peon on regular basis w.e.f
01/01/2007 Vide Office Order No.F.6(29)-PWD(E-II)/2007
dated 10/01/2008 of the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B) as his
educational qualification at the time of joining in the
Department being a DRW was Madhyamik fail.
Further Finance Department directed the Administrative
Department that "the Candidate has passed Madhyamik
(Class-X) examination and has also received the wages as
DRW (Group-C). So, there may not be sufficient ground to
deny him regularization as Group-C.
The department is requested to re-examine their existing
stand and if the findings are found in consonance with RR
of Group-C Post, then the benefit of movement to Group-C
Post may be allowed to person prospectively to avoid
litigation".
Further, after careful examination of records it is found
that Shri Shibu Deb has requisite qualification along with
other criteria as proposed by the Finance Department for
DRW/Contingent Workers etc. for regularization to Group C
Post being a Work Assistant. As per verified roster there
was no vacancy of LDC, Group C post against UR Category
at that time. So, his service was regularized being a Work
Assistant, Group C post against UR category and his pay
scale was fixed in the relevant grade for regularisation with
prospective effect after notional fixation of pay with effect
from 01/01/2007 as per condition laid down in the
Memorandum No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2005, dated 22/02/2007
of the Commissioner & Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Finance Department & subject to fulfillment of
other conditions of service.
From the above discussion it is crystal clear that the both
cases are completely different. The service of Shri Shibu
Deb was regularized from DRW to Work Assistant instead
of from Peon. Whereas the Service of the petitioner was
regularized from Casual Worker to Peon and re-fixation of
pay notionally without promotion in upper post i.e., Group-
C Post with all consequential benefits is not possible before
the eye of law.”
Further, in para Nos.11 and 12, they have observed as under:
“11. That, in response to the contents of paragraphs-18 to
26 of this writ petition, I humbly submit that of late
Finance
Department,
Government
of
Tripura
vide
Memorandum
No.
10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part)
dated
31/07/2018 has reviewed Policy decision on regularization
of services of DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc. Workers
in Government Establishments and State PSUs and
Autonomous bodies including AMC/ NPs. And, according to
that Memo. "Finance Department has issued instructions
from time to time as given for regularization of services of
DRWs/ Casual /Contingent / PTW etc. Workers on the next
date of completion of 17 years / 15 years / 10 years of
services. The memorandum are as follows:Sl.
Memo no.
No.
F.10(2)Fin(G)/05, dated 0403-2006
No.
F.10(2)Fin(G)/05, dated 2202-2007
No.
F.10(2)Fin(G)/08
(Part),
dated 01-09-2008
No.
F.10(2)Fin(G)/08
(Part),
dated 21-01-2009
No.F.34(3)Fin(G)/2012
04-09-2012
dated
No.F.10(12)FIN(G)/07(Part-1),
dated, 07-11-2012
Issues
Regularization
of
DRWs/Contingent
etc.
Workers on completion of 17
years
of
service
as
on
31.03.2005
allowing
effect
from 01.02.2006.
Regularization
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc.
Workers on completion of 15
years
of
service
as
on
31.03.2006 allowing effect as
on 01.01.2007.
Regularization
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc.
workers on completion of 10
years of service as on 31-032008 allowing effect from
01.07.2008.
Regularization
of
DRWs/
Casual/Contingent
etc.
workers from the next date of
completion of 10 years of
service.
Regularization
of
etc.
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc.
workers working in State PSUs
and
Autonomous
bodies
including
AMC/NPs
on
completion of 10 years of
service.
Engagement of PTWs etc. as
DRWS (Group-D) working in
different departments of the
Government for 2/3/4 hours
who were engaged on or prior
to
31.03.2003
and
have
completed 10 years of services
w.e.f. 01.12.2012.
2. Recently, the matter has been further reviewed. It has
been observed that there are some shortcomings in these
instructions for
regularization
of the services
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent
staff
affecting
institutional
efficiency and individual productivity due to different
reasons.
3. With a view to ensure transparent public employment
policy for engagement of staff for such services, all the
memorandums as mentioned above are repealed"
At
present
there
are
good
numbers
of
DRW/Casual/Contingent workers etc. are engaged by the
Government. On account of financial constraints, the State
Government has not been in a position to provide them
with regular service. Henceforth, there is no scope of
regularisation of DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who are
engaged with this Department more than 10 years w.e.f
01/12/2012.
From the above discussion, it can be said that after
publication of the Memorandum dated 31/07/2018, further
operation on any either of the either Memorandum dated
04-03-2006, dated 22-02-2007, dated 01-09-2008, dated
21-01-2009, dated 04-09-2012, & dated 07-11-2012 has
been ceased.
Copy
of
the
Memorandum
No.10(2)FIN(G)/2008(Part)
dated 31/07/2018 is
annexed hereto & marked as Annexure- R/1.
In the instant case the petitioners have not approached the
Court within time. The writ petition was filed in the year
2025, 7 years after the repeal of the regularization scheme.
Therefore, it is barred on grounds of delay and laches.
It is further submitted that since regularization scheme has
been repealed on 01.08.2018, no relief should be granted
in favour of the petitioners, otherwise it may open
floodgates for all those persons who have been sleeping
over their rights and did not approach the Court within
time. Delay defeats rights and remedies both.
It is further submitted that, Department has complied with
the Judgment dated 13/09/2024 delivered in WP(C) 410 of
2024 & WP(C) 411 of 2024 respectively without challenge
the same before the Double Bench of the Hon'ble High
Court. But, it doesn't mean Department should did the
mistake repeatedly.
In Kerala State Electricity Board Vs. Sharat Chandran P.
(2009), the Supreme Court held that Article 14 is a positive
concept. It applies only where the parties are similarly
situated. No equality can be climbed on the basis of an
illegality.
Further, in Basawaraj Vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer,
(2013), the Supreme Court has made it clear that "It is
settled legal proposition that Article 14 of the Constitution
is not meant to perpetuate illegality or fraud, even by
extending the wrong decisions made in other cases. The
said provision does not envisage negative equality but has
only a positive aspect. Thus, if some other similarly
situated persons have been granted some relief/benefit
inadvertently or by mistake, such an order does not confer
any legal right on others to bet the same relief as well. If a
wrong has been committed in an earlier case, it cannot be
perpetuated. Equality is a trite, which cannot be claimed in
illegality and therefore, cannot be enforced by a citizen or
court in a negative manner……… Even otherwise, Article 14
cannot be stretched too far otherwise it would make
functioning of the administration impossible."
Further, in a more recent case in State of Odisha Vs. Anup
Kumar Senapati (2019), it was observed after relying upon
Basawaraj (supra) that there is no concept of negative
equality under Article 14 of the Constitution. In case the
person has a right, he has to be treated equally, but where
right is not available, person cannot claim rights to be
treated equally as the right does not exist, negative
equality when the right does not exist, cannot be claimed.
Above mentioned information was not incorporated by the
Department earlier in the Counter Affidavit filed in WP(C)
410 of 2024 & WP(C) 411 of 2024 respectively for which
Hon'ble High Court of Tripura has delivered its Judgment
without consideration of the above facts & resulting
Department has also abide by the decision of the Hon'ble
High Court without challenge.
12. That, in response to the contents of paragraphs-27 to
29 of this writ petition, I humbly submit that this instant
writ petition is devoid of any merits and the same to be
dismissed in limine.”
Finally, Learned Senior G.A. urged for dismissal of the
writ petition. However, at the time of hearing, Learned Senior G.A.
drawn the attention of the Court that the present petitioner is not in
similarly situated condition like that Sibu Deb and as such, his service
cannot
be
regularized
in
the
Group-C
post
with
effect
from
01.01.2008.
4.
I have heard both the sides and perused with the writ petition
and the documents annexed with the writ petition as well as the
counter affidavit and the documents annexed with the counter
affidavit. It appears that in the year 2018 the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura by a memorandum (Annexure-R/1) cancelled
all the previous notification regarding regularization of services of
DRW/Casual/Contingent workers in the Government establishments
and State PSUs and by the said memorandum, the prospective was
given for giving effect of the said memorandum. Prior to that, as
already stated, the Government of Tripura by a memorandum dated
01.09.2008 (Annexure-5 supra) framed some guideline regarding
services of DRW/Contingent/Casual Workers on completion of 10
years of service as on 31.03.2008. Here in the case at hand, the
present petitioner was appointed to the post of Peon with effect from
01.01.2008, having 40% disability and said Sibu Deb was regularized
with effect from 01.01.2007 in the promotional post of the Work
Assistant but the case of the petitioner was not considered. In the
similar manner, other similarly situated two employees namely Anima
Debnath and Aparajita Bhowmik were given the same benefit.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the present petitioner at the time of appearing in
Madhyamik examination did not obtain any ‘No Objection Certificate’
but since the petitioner was a Casual Worker almost daily rated basis,
so, as per law she was not under legal obligation to obtain any ‘No
Objection Certificate’ in this regard from the Department. So, the
stand taken by the respondent-Department bears no legal basis and
accordingly, the same stands discarded.
Even Annexure-R/1 also does not create any embargo to the
case of the petitioner for her regularization and appointment to the
post of Group-C with effect from the date of her initial engagement
i.e. on 01.01.2008.
5.
Thus, after hearing both the sides, it appears that the case of
the present petitioner cannot be differentiated from the case of said
Sibu Deb, Anima Debnath [WP(C)/410/2024] and Aparajita Bhowmik
[WP(C)/411/2024]. In view of the above, it appears to this Court that
this is a fit case to grant relief in favour of the petitoner. Accordingly,
the writ petition filed by the present petitioner is hereby allowed.
The respondent-authority be asked to consider the case of the
petitioner for her appointment as a Group-C employee in accordance
with the existing rules for the post of Group-C within a period of
3(three) months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
With the above observation, this writ petition stands disposed
of.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
DATTA
Date: 2026.03.05 16:18:10 -08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review