Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1810 OF 2024
OS NO.1 OF 2022 OF II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS COURT,THODUPUZHA
PETITIONER/S:
MISTY MOUNTAIN PLANTATION RESORT, KUTTIKKANAM P.O.,
PEERMEDU, IDUKKI DISTRICT , REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING
PARTNER, MR. MICHAEL JOSEPH KALLIVAYALIL,AGED 32 YEARS, SON
OF JOSEPH MICHAEL KALLIVAYALIL, RESIDING AT KONDUPARAMBIL
HOUSE, MALLIKASSERY P.O,ELIKKULAM,KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686577
BY ADVS.BENOY K.KADAVAN
A.B.MANJU
CELINE JOHN
RESPONDENT/S:
M/S SURYA HOTEL AND PROPERTIES
44/1256, ASRA, ACSRA COLONY , KALOOR, KOCHI, KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, P.SURESH,S/O
R.PRABHAKARAN PILLAI,AGED 60 YEARS, PIN - 682017
BY ADVS.PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE(K/000516/1995)
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM(K/001758/1999)
V.T.LITHA(K/278/2006)
K.R.MONISHA(K/915/2013)
JIJO PAUL(K/1009/2023)
HAFNITHA MOL K.H.(K/002571/2024)
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV. SAIKRISHNA RAJAGOPAL
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 6.3.2025, THE COURT
ON 26.3.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 26th day of March 2025)
The petitioner is the plaintiff in O.S. No.1 of 2022 on the files
of the II Additional District and Sessions Court, Thodupuzha, and
the respondent is the defendant therein.
2. The petitioner is a partnership firm running a resort
named ‘Misty Mountain Plantation Resort’. The trade mark
‘Misty Mountain’ was adopted as the trade name by the plaintiff's
predecessor in 1999. An application for registration of trade mark
was filed for the word ‘Misty Mountain’ under application
No.2441920 in class 43 on 6.6.2019 in respect of services of
‘providing of food and drinks and temporary accommodation’ and
the petitioner was assigned with the trade mark ‘Misty Mountain’.
3. By virtue of the assignment deed dated 13.9.2019, the
same has been duly submitted before the Trade Mark Registry. In
2016, the petitioner came to know about the respondent's use of
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
the said trademark with respect to a resort in Munnar. On enquiry,
the petitioner came to know that the respondent secured a
registration for the same mark with the application No.1969012.
The petitioner immediately filed a rectification application for
cancellation of the registration issued, and it was allowed, holding
that the petitioner is the prior user of the trade mark. Despite the
cancellation order, the respondent used the trade mark, violating
the right of the petitioner and therefore, O.S.No.1 of 2022 was
filed for a decree of declaration and for a permanent prohibitory
injunction restraining the defendant from using in any manner the
trade mark ‘Misty Mountain Resort’ or any other mark similar or
deceptively similar to the registered trade mark of the plaintiff
‘Misty Mountain’. Along with the suit, an application for a
temporary injunction under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 read with
Section 151 CPC was also filed. The learned District Judge
passed an interim injunction order on 19.3.2022. The respondent
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
filed I.A.No.2 of 2022 for vacating the said interim injunction
order. After hearing both sides and marking Ext.Nos.A1 to A27
and Ext.Nos.B1 to B7, the learned District Judge, allowed
I.A.No.2 of 2022 and vacated the interim injunction order passed.
Aggrieved by order in I.A.No.2 of 2022, the petitioner filed
I.A.No.8 of 2022 to review the order, along with a petition to
condone the delay of 92 days, as I.A.No.6 of 2022. Another I.A.,
as I.A.No.7 of 2022, was also filed to receive additional
documents. Objections were filed to all the applications by the
petitioner. The District Judge, by a common order dated
13.2.2024, allowed I.A.No.6 of 2022 as well as I.A.No.7 of 2022,
but dismissed I.A.No.8 of 2022, which was filed for reviewing
the order in I.A.No.2 of 2022. It is challenging the said order in
I.A.No.8 of 2022, this O.P. is filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
4. A counter affidavit is filed by the respondent, wherein it
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
was contended that this Original Petition is not maintainable as it
has been filed by the petitioner, who is not the lawful proprietor
of the trade mark. He has also approached this court with unclean
hands and has concealed the material facts and documents. The
plaintiff obtained the order in I.A.No.1 of 2022, by active
concealment and suppression of facts and by filing I.A. No.2 of
2022 by the respondent, the ex-parte interim injunction order was
vacated. I.A.No.8 of 2022 is an afterthought, as it is filed only
with a delay of 92 days.
5. As per the order dated 24.12.2021 by the Assistant
Registrar of Trade Mark, Chennai, in the certificate of
registration, the registration in respect to word Misty mountain
bearing application No.2441920 in class 43 stood cancelled and
in the database, it was changed from registered to ‘review filed’.
The respondent’s firm adopted the composite mark on
18.04.2009, and it has been used exclusively and uninterruptedly,
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
since the said date. Therefore, prayed that the OP be dismissed.
6. Heard Sri.Benoy Kadavan for the petitioner and Sri.Sai
Krishna Rajagopal for the respondent.
7. The question to be considered in this O.P.(C) is whether
any interference is warranted with the order dated 13.2.2024 in
I.A.No.8 of 2022 in O.S.No.1 of 222.
8. The counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that
the learned District Judge had vacated the injunction order passed
in I.A. No.1 of 2022, through the order in I.A. No.2 of 2022,
without adverting to the mandate under Order 39 Rule 1 CPC and
also the averments in the plaint. Since there was an error apparent
on the face of the record, I.A.No.8 of 2022 was filed to review
the order in I.A.No.2 of 2022.
9. Argument of the counsel for the petitioner is that the
petitioner has obtained the trade mark ‘Misty Mountain’ by the
plaintiff’s predecessor in 1999, by late Michael A. Kallivayalil,
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
through application No.2441920 in Class 43 on 6.6.2019 and has
produced the same as per Ext.P1 in the suit. Along with the suit,
an application for temporary injunction was also filed. The
District Judge, finding that delay in issuing the notice will defeat
the object of the suit and having found a prima facie case, granted
an injunction in favour of the petitioner restraining the
respondent/defendant from using in any manner the trade mark
‘Misty Mountain Resort’ or any other mark similar or deceptively
similar to the registered trade mark of the petitioner ‘Misty
Mountain’, until further orders. The application to vacate the
interim injunction as I.A. No.2 of 2022
was filed without
bonafide and suppressing material facts.
The trade mark
registration granted to the plaintiff is valid and active, and the
order of the Registrar designating the status of the registration as
under ‘review’ has been stayed by this court as per order dated
17.5.2022 in W.P.(C) No.16075 of 2022. More so, when the
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
registration of the defendant has been removed from the Registrar
by a detailed order holding that the petitioner is the prior user of
the trade mark ‘Misty Mountain’.
10. The mere filing of the Review Petition does not entitle
the defendant to set up a claim over the removed trade mark.
When the court vacated the interim injunction, the review petition
was filed, but the review was dismissed on the ground that there
was no error apparent on the face of the record. Therefore, prays
that the order dated 13.2.2024 in I.A.No.8 of 2024, be set aside
and direct the learned District Judge to reconsider the same.
11.
The counsel for the respondent argued that when
O.S.No.1 of 2022 was filed by the petitioner herein, with a prayer
for a decree declaring that the plaintiff is the Registered
proprietor-owner and prior user of the trade under the name and
style of ‘Misty Mountain’ and for an injunction restraining the
defendant and its representatives, their men, agents assigns, or
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
acting through them from the use of trade mark ‘Misty Mountain’,
the plaintiff ought to have produced the trade mark as mandated
under The Trade Marks Act, 1999 (for short ‘the Act’) and not
Ext.P1, as produced in this O.P.
Ext.P1 is a certificate of
registration issued under Section 23(2) of the Act and Rule 56(1)
of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017. The certificate issued under Rule
56 cannot be used in a legal proceeding, and when this was
pointed out to the learned District Judge, the court vacated the
interim injunction.
12. He further argued that under Rule 56 (2), the certificate
of registration referred to in sub-rule (1) should not be used in any
legal proceeding, and instead, only a certificate under Section 137
of the Act shall be used in legal proceedings. In Ext.P1 itself, at
the bottom portion, it is specifically stated that the certificate is
not to be used in legal proceedings or for obtaining registration
abroad. So, the petitioner has committed fraud in the court by
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
producing Ext.P1 and not producing a certificate as provided
under section 137 of the Act.
13.
Furthermore, it was argued by the counsel for the
respondent that the certificate of registration for ‘Misty
Mountain’, issued on 13.12.2012 under application No. 2441920,
has been cancelled as per the order of the Assistant Registrar of
Trade Marks, Chennai dated 3.12.2021. The suit is filed on
16.3.2022. The averments in the suit is that he is the registered
proprietor of trade mark ‘Misty Mountain’ as on the date of filing
of the suit and therefore, the defendant using the same has
infringed the same and is entitled for a decree for declaration and
injunction is factually wrong.
14. W.P.(C) No.16075 of 2022 was filed on 16.5.2022, and
the operation of the order cancelling registration has been stayed
only from 16.5.2022. The present suit was filed on 16.3.2022,
at a time when the cancellation order was not stayed by this court.
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
He argued that the learned District Judge had rightly dismissed
the application as there was suppression on the part of the
petitioner in obtaining the interim injunction as on the date of
filing of the suit. The petitioner was not a registered trade mark
holder, but misrepresented that he had a registered trade mark and
obtained the ex-parte injunction order. When this was brought to
the notice of the learned District Judge in I.A.No.1 of 2022, the
order was vacated. There is no error apparent on the face of the
record in I.A. No.1 of 2022 and hence, prayed that the O.P. be
dismissed.
15. To provide an easy understanding of the case in hand, a
few sections of the Act and Rules are to be extracted.
Rule 56 of the Trade Mark Rules reads as follows:
“56. Certificate of registration.-(1) The certificate of
registration to be issued by the Registrar under sub-section (2) of
section 23 shall be on Form RG-2 and shall include the Trade
Mark. It shall bear the seal of the Trade Marks Registry.
(2) The certificate of registration referred to in sub-rule (1)
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
shall not be used in legal proceedings or for obtaining registration
abroad. The certificate issued under section 137 shall be used for
these purposes.
(3) The Registrar may issue duplicate or further copies of the
certificate of registration on request by the registered proprietor in
Form TM-M accompanied by the prescribed fee.”
Section 137 of the Act reads as follows:
“37. Evidence of entries in the register, etc.,
and things done by the Registrar.-(1) A copy of any
entry in the register or of any document referred to in
sub-section (1) of section 148 purporting to be certified
by the Registrar and sealed with the seal of the Trade
Marks Registry shall be admitted in evidence in all
Courts and in all proceedings without further proof or
production of the original.
(2) A certificate purporting to be under the hand
of the Registrar as to any entry, matter or thing that he is
authorised by this Act or the rules to make or do shall be
prima facie evidence of the entry having been made, and
of the contents thereof, or of the matter or things having
been done or not done.”
16. When there is a clear bar under Rule 56(2) that a
certificate referred to in sub-rule 1 shall not be used in any legal
proceeding, the plaintiff should have produced a certificate under
Section 137 of the Act as the suit document. The court should not
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
have acted on Ext.P1, issued under Rule 56 (1) to hold that the
petitioner was the registered trademark holder, when filing the
suit.
17. In this connection, it is to be noted that on a complaint
made by a 3rd party, proceedings having taken under Section 57
of the Act and a hearing was conducted and on verification of the
files, the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks found that the
application has been proceeded to registration pending a review
petition and therefore, it was cancelled. The status of the
application was changed to ‘review filed’ on 3.12.2021. So, the
plaintiff cannot contend after 3.12.2021 that he is a registered
holder of the trade mark ‘Misty Mountain’. Thus, it is evidently
clear that as of the date of filing of the suit i.e., on 16.3.2022, the
petitioner was not a registered holder of ‘Misty Mountain’.
18. The contention raised by the petitioner is that the said
cancellation has been stayed by this court on 16.5.2022 in W.P.(C)
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
No.16075 of 2022, and therefore, the cancellation of registration
was suspended, which entitled to a claim that he continues to be
the registered trade mark holder. It is true that the Writ Petition
was allowed on 13.3.2024, and the order cancelling the
registration dated 3.12.2021, was set aside. But the fact remains
that as on the filing date of the suit, the petitioner did not have a
registered trade mark.
19. Counsel for the petitioner relied on the judgment of the
apex court in Board of Control for Cricket in India and
another v. Netaji Cricket Club and others (2005 KHC 883)
wherein, the court has held as follows:
“91. It is true that in Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos v.
Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius (1955 (1) SCR 520 AIR 1954
SC 526) this Court made observations as regards limitations in the
application of review of its order stating:
"Before going into the merits of the case it is as well to
bear in mind the scope of the application for review which
has given rise to the present appeal. It is needless to
emphasise that the scope of an application for review is much
more restricted than that of an appeal. Under the provisions
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
in the Travancore Code of Civil Procedure which is similar
in terms to Order 47 Rule 1 of our Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, the court of review has only a limited jurisdiction
circumscribed by the definitive limits fixed by the language
used therein. It may allow a review on three specified
grounds, namely (i) discovery of new and important matter
or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was
not within the applicant's knowledge or could not be
produced by him at the time when the decree was passed, (if)
mistake or error apparent on the face of the record and (iii)
for any other sufficient reason. It has been held by the Judicial
Committee that the words 'any other sufficient reason' must
mean 'a reason sufficient on grounds, at least analogous to
those specified in the rule." but the said rule is not universal.”
It was also held that any other sufficient reason must be sufficient
on grounds, at least analogous to those specified in the rule, but
the said rule is not universal.
20. Reliance was also placed on a judgment of a Division
Bench of this court in Kamala Raphael v. Earnest and others
(2011 KHC 2412), wherein it is held as follows:
“34. xxx xxxx xxx
0.47 R.1 of the Code provides for filing an application for
review. Such an application for review would be maintainable not
only upon discovery of a new and important piece of evidence or
when there exists an error apparent on the face of the record but
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
also, if the same is necessitated on account of some mistake or for
any other sufficient reason.
Thus, a mistake on the part of the Court which would include
a mistake in the nature of the undertaking may also call for a review
of the order. An application for review would also be maintainable
if there exists sufficient reason therefor. What would constitute
sufficient reason would depend on the facts and circumstances of
the case. The words 'sufficient reason' in 0.47, R.1 of the Code is
wide enough to include a misconception of fact or law by a Court
or even an Advocate. An application for review may be/necessitated
by way of invoking the doctrine "actus curiae neminem gavabit.”
21. He further placed reliance on another judgment of a
division bench of this court in Tom Thomas and Another v.
State Bank of India and others [2017 (1) KHC 1], in which
paragraphs Nos.23 and 24, held as follows:
“23. It is true that the power of review is the creature of a Statute
and is to be exercised only within the delineated limits. However,
it would be pertinent to refer to the judgment of the Apex Court
in Board of Control For Cricket In India and Another v. Netaji
Cricket Club and Others, 2005 KHC 883: 2005 (4) SCC 741:
AIR 2005 SC 592 wherein the Apex Court has after referring to
Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos v. Most Rev. Mar Poulose
Athanasius, 1954 KHC 111: AIR 1954 SC 526 1954 KLT 385:
1955 (1) SCR 520: ILR 1954 TC 867, which emphasises the three
specified grounds as stated above, on which the power of review
could be exercised, proceeded to hold that the said Rule is not
universal. The Apex Court referred to the judgment in Lily
Thomas v. Union of India, 2000 KHC 536: 2000 (6) SCC 224:
2000 (2) KLT SN 62: 2000 (2) KLJ NOC 25: AIR 2000 SC 1650:
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
2000 CriLJ 2433 paragraph 52, which reads thus:
"52. The dictionary meaning of the word 'review' is
'the act of looking, offer something again with a view to
correction or improvement'. It cannot be denied that the
review is the creation of a Statute. This Court in Patel
Narshi Thakershi v. Pradyumansinghji Arjunsighji, held
that the power of review is not an inherent power. It must be
conferred by law either specifically or by necessary
implication. The review is also not an appeal in disguise. It
cannot be denied that justice is a virtue that transcends all
barriers and the rules or procedures or technicalities of law
cannot stand in the way of administration of justice. Law has
to bend before justice. If the Court finds that the error
pointed out in the review petition was under a mistake and
the earlier judgment would not have been passed but for
erroneous assumption which in fact did not exist and its
perpetration shall result in a miscarriage of justice nothing
would preclude the Court from rectifying the error.
24. As observed by the Apex Court in Lily Thomas
v. Union of India (supra) and accepted in Board of Control
For Cricket In India and Another v. Netaji Cricket Club
and Others (supra), justice is a virtue which transcends all
barriers and the rules or procedures or technicalities of law
cannot stand in the way of administration of justice. If a
mistake, its perpetration of which shall result in miscarriage
of justice nothing would preclude the Court from rectifying
the error. The Apex Court has in Board of Control For
Cricket In India and Another v. Netaji Cricket Club and
Others (supra) held that, depending on the circumstances,
the Court would even take into consideration a subsequent
event to exercise its power of review. To quote the Apex
Court, at paragraph 93, it held thus:
"93. It is also not correct to contend that the
Court while exercising its review jurisdiction in
any situation whatsoever cannot take into
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
consideration a subsequent event.”
Therefore, he prayed that in view of the change of circumstances
by which the cancellation of trade mark has been set aside by this
court in W.P.(C) No.16075 of 2022, the order in I.A.No.8 of 2022,
be set aside and be directed to reconsider in the light of the new
development.
22. Counsel for the respondent relied on paragraphs Nos.11,
12 and 13 of the judgment of the apex court in Om Prakash
Gupta v. Ranbir B. Goyal [(2002) 2 SCC 256]:
“11. The ordinary rule of civil law is that the rights
of the parties stand crystallised on the date of the institution
of the suit and, therefore, the decree in a suit should accord
with the rights of the parties as they stood at the
commencement of the lis. However, the Court has power
to take note of h subsequent events and mould the relief
accordingly subject to conditions being satisfied: (i) that
the relief, as claimed originally has, by reason of
subsequent events, become inappropriate or cannot be
granted; (ii) a that taking note of such subsequent event or
changed circumstances would shorten litigation and enable
complete justice being done to the parties; and (iii) that
such subsequent event is brought to the notice of the court
promptly and in accordance with the rules of procedural
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
law so that the opposite party is not taken by surprise. In
Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v. Motor & General Traders
this Court held that a fact arising after the lis, coming to
the notice b of the court and having a fundamental impact
on the right to relief or the manner of moulding it and
brought diligently to the notice of the court cannot be
blinked at. The court may in such cases bend the rules of
procedure if no specific provision of law or rule of fair play
is violated for it would promote substantial justice
provided that there is absence of other disentitling factors
or just circumstances. The Court speaking through Krishna
lyer, J. affirmed the proposition that the court can, so long
as the litigation pends, take note of updated facts to
promote substantial justice. However, the Court cautioned:
(1) the event should be one as would stultify or render inept
the decretal remedy, (ii) rules of procedure may be bent if
no specific provision or fair play is violated and there is no
other special circumstance repelling resort to that course in
law or justice, (iii) such cognizance of subsequent events
and d developments should be cautious, and (iv) the rules
of fairness to both sides should be scrupulously obeyed.
12. Such subsequent event may be one purely of law
or founded on facts. In the former case, the court may take
judicial notice of the event and before acting thereon put
the parties on notice of how the change in law is going to
affect the rights and obligations of the parties and modify
or mould the course of litigation or the relief so as to bring
it in conformity with the law. In the latter case, the party
relying on the subsequent event, which consists of facts not
beyond pale of controversy either as to their existence or
in their impact, is expected to have resort to amendment of
pleadings under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. Such subsequent
event, the Court may permit being introduced. into the
pleadings by way of amendment as it would be necessary
to do so for the purpose of determining real questions in
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
controversy between the parties. In Trojan & Co. v. RM.
N.N. Nagappa Chettiar³ this Court has held that the
decision of a case cannot be based on grounds outside the
pleadings of the parties and it is the case pleaded that has
to be found; without the amendment of the pleadings the
Court would not be entitled to modify or alter the relief. In
Sri Mahant Govind Rao v. Sita Ram Kesho Their
Lordships observed that, as a rule, relief not founded on
the pleadings should not be granted.
13. Power of the court to take note of subsequent
events, specially at the appellate stage, came up for the
consideration of a Full Bench of the Nagpur High Court
presided over by Justice Sinha (as His Lordship then was)
in Chhote Khan v. Mohd. Obedulla Khan. Hidayatullah, J.
(as His Lordship then was) held, on a review of judicial
opinion, that an action must be tried in all its stages on the
cause of action as it existed at the commencement of the
action. No doubt, courts "can" and sometimes "must" take
notice of subsequent events, but that is done merely "inter
partes" to shorten litigation but not to give to a defendant
an advantage because a third party has acquired the right
and title of the plaintiff. The doctrine itself is of an
exceptional character only to be used in very special
circumstances. It is all the more strictly applied in those
cases where there is a judgment under appeal. His b
Lordship quoted the statement of law made by Sir
Ashutosh Mookerjee, J. in a series of cases that merely
because the plaintiff loses his title pendente lite is no
reason for allowing his adversary to win if the
corresponding right has not vested in the adversary but in
a third party. In the case at hand, the defendant-appellant
has simply stated the factum of proceedings initiated by
HUDA against the plaintiff-respondent in an affidavit very
casually filed by c him. He has not even made a prayer to
the court to take notice of such subsequent event and
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
mould the relief accordingly, or to deny the relief to the
plaintiff-respondent as allowed to him by the judgment
under appeal, much less sought for an amendment of the
pleadings. The subsequent event urged by the defendantappellant is basically a factual event and cannot be taken
cognizance of unless brought to the notice of the court in
accordance with the d established rules of procedure which
if done would have afforded the plaintiff-respondent an
opportunity of meeting the case now sought to be set up by
the appellant. We do not think this Court would be justified
in taking notice of a fact sought to be projected by the
appellant in a very cavalier manner. The fact remains that
the present one is a landlord-tenant dispute and we cannot
upset the relief granted by the courts below and the High
Court to the plaintiff-respondent by relying on the doctrine
of eviction by title paramount as it cannot be said that the
proceedings initiated by HUDA against the plaintiffrespondent have achieved a finality or are such
proceedings wherein the plaintiff-respondent cannot
possibly have any sustainable defence.”
23. The counsel also relied on a judgment of the apex court
in S.P. Chengal Varaya Naidu (dead) by LRS. v. Jagannath
(dead) by LRs. and others [(1994) 1 SCC 1], wherein it is held
that a litigant who approaches the court is bound to produce all
the documents executed by him which are relevant to the
litigation and if he withholds a vital document in order to get
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
advance on the other side then he would be guilty of playing fraud
on the court as well as on the opposite party.
24.
According to the counsel for the respondent, the
petitioner has produced a document that is not in existence as of
the date of institution of the suit, and the injunction being an
equitable order, the petitioner ought to have approached the court
with clean hands. But he failed to do so. Thus, the injunction was
rightly vacated. The Review Petition was also rightly dismissed.
As I have already held, as on the filing date of the suit, the
petitioner did not have a registered trade mark. The court below
was justified in not entertaining the review on the ground that
there is no error apparent on the face of the record since the
injunction order was vacated when the court was convinced that
the averment that the petitioner was not a registered trade mark
holder as on the date of filing of the suit. I have gone through the
order in I.A. No.8 of 2022, and I am satisfied that the District
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
Judge was right in dismissing the application for the reasons
stated therein. Therefore, no interference is warranted with the
said order.
In the result, this O.P.(C.) is dismissed.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl/
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1810/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
: TRUE COPY OF THE TRADE MARK ‘MISTY
MOUNTAIN’ REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE ISSUED TO THE
PETITIONER WITHNO.2441920 DATED 06/06/2019.
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN OS.NO.1/2022 BEFORE
THE DISTRICT COURT THODUPUZHA
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF I.A.NO.1/2022 IN OS.NO.1/2022 OF
DISTRICT COURT, THODUPUZHA.
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 19/03/2022 IN
I.A.NO.1/2022 IN OS.NO.1/2022 OF DISTRICT COURT
THODUPUZHA
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF I.A.NO.2/2022 FILED BY THE
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED BY THE
PETITIONER IN I.A.NO.2/2022 IN O.S.NO.1/2022
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 13/07/2022 IN
I.A.NO.2/2022 IN OS.NO.1/2022
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE E-REGISTERED PRODUCED AS
EXHIBIT-A11 IN I.A.NO.2/2022
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF I.A.NO.8/2022 FILED FOR REVIEWING
THE ORDER IN I.A.NO.2/2022
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED BY
RESPONDENT IN I.A.NO.8/2022
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF I.A.NO.6/2022 FILED BY THE
PETITIONER.
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED BY THE
RESPONDENT IN I.A.NO.6/2022
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF I.A.NO.7/2022 FILED FOR ACCEPTING
ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS BY THE PETITIONER.
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF I.A.NO.5/2022 FILED BY THE
RESPONDENT FOR REJECTION OF PLAINT
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
Exhibit P15
TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED BY THE
PETITIONER IN I.A.NO.5/2022
Exhibit P16
CERTIFIED COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER PASSED BY THE
DISTRICT COURT THODUPUZHA IN
I.A.NO.6/2022,I.A.NO.7/2022,I.A.NO.8/2022.
Exhibit P17
: CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY DISTRICT
COURT IN I.A.NO.5/2022
Exhibit P18
TRUE COPY OF THE W.P.(C) NO.16075/2022 OF THE
HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA.
Exhibit P19
Exhibit P20
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF HON’BLE HIGH COURT
OF KERALA IN WP(C) NO.16075/2022
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION FOR CANCELLATION
TRADE MARK ‘MISTY MOUNTAIN’ WITH NO:2441920
FILED BY RESPONDENT
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R4
True copy of the Order dated 24/12/2021 passed by
the Ld. Asst. Registrar of Trade Marks, Chennai
Exhibit R4(a)
True copy of status of the word mark 'misty
mountain' bearing application no. 2441920 dated
09.10.2024
Exhibit R6
True copy of Letter dt 23rd November 2012
addressed to the Trade Mark Registry by the
proprietor of Trade Mark 'misty mountain' (word
mark) bearing application no. 2441920
Exhibit R1
True copy of Order dated 10/1/2022 passed by the
Ld. Asistant Registrar of Trade Marks, Chennai
Exhibit R2
True copy of Review Petition dated 2/2/2022 filed
in Rectification No. MAS 262882
Exhibit R7
True copy of Relevant extracts from the novel '
Hobbit ' by J.R.R. Tolkien dated nil
Exhibit R9
True copy of the Order dt. 15/5/2019 issued vide
Trade Mark Registry letter 27/5/2019
Exhibit R7(a)
True copy of Relevant extracts from the novel '
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
Hobbit ' by J.R.R. Tolkien dated nil
Exhibit R7(b)
True copy of Relevant extracts from the novel '
Hobbit ' by J.R.R. Tolkien dated nil
Exhibit R8
True copy of Relevant web pages showing the
'misty mountain ' forming part of a number of
hotels and resorts dated nil
Exhibit R10
True copy of the Review Petition filed by the
Opponent in Opposition no. 940638 dated
27.06.2019
Exhibit R11
True copy of the letter from the Trade Mark
Registry dated 5/12/2019 in connection with the
Proceedings in Opposition no. 940638
Exhibit R12
True copy of Hearing notices served in connection
with Opposition no. 940638 dated 04.01.2022
Exhibit R12(a)
True copy of Hearing notices served in connection
with Opposition no. 940638 dated 25.06.2022
Exhibit R12(b)
True copy of Hearing notices served in connection
with Opposition no. 940638 dated 28.07.2022
Exhibit R12(c)
True copy of Hearing notices served in connection
with Opposition no. 940638 dated 18.06.2024
Exhibit R13
True copy of the Trade Mark Application No.
2441920 in class 43 on Form TM-1 dated 05.12.2012
Exhibit R14
True copy of the relevant extract from the online
records of the Trade Marks Registry showing that
the application bearing no. 2441920 was filed by
Mr. Michael A. Kallivayalil and continues to
stand in his name even as on dated 09.10.2024
Exhibit R15
True copy of the Renewal intimation dated
25/12/2022 pertaining to trade mark application
no. 2441920
Exhibit R17
True copy of letter dated 14/12/2022 addressed to
the Trade mark Registry by the Petitioners’/
Plaintiffs’ Attorney
Exhibit R18
True copy of the application for Renewal filed on
22/12/2022 by the Attorney acting for the
OPC 1810/24
2025:KER:26738
Petitioner/ Plaintiff
Exhibit R16
True copy of the Rectification Application in
Rectification No. 279782 filed by the Respondent/
Defendant to trade mark application no. 2441920
dated 17.07.2023
Exhibit R5
True copy of the formal request for change of
proprietorship dt. 27/9/2019 along with True copy
of the Deed of Assignment and the Trade Marks
Registry Scrutiny Report
Exhibit R3
True copy of the draft of a rectification
application filed by the proprietor of the word
mark misty mountain (bearing application no.
2441920) as the basis of the Rectification
proceedings under no. MAS 262882 dated 06.04.2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review