The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary/ Commissioner/Secretary (DP), Government of Manipur, Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
3. The Director of Health Services, Manipur, Lamphelpat – 795001. … Respondents HON’BLEMR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH For the Petitioner :: Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, Senior Advocate asstd. by Mr. U. Augusta, Advocate For the respondents :: Mr. A. Vashum, GA Date of Hearing :: 16-08-2023 Date of Judgment & Order :: 05-09-2023 JUDGMENT & ORDER [1] Heard Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. U. Augusta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr A. Vashum, learned GA appearing for the respondents. [2] The core issue to be decided in the present writ petition is the validity period of a Waiting List prepared by a DPC/ Selection Committee in connection with giving appointments in Government services. [2] The facts of the present case, in a nutshell, is that the Medical Directorate, Government of Manipur, issued a Notification dated 20-12-2016 notifying the list of selected candidates recommended by a Selection Committee in its meeting held on 19th and 20th September, 2016 for appointment to the vacant posts of Pharmacist under the Health Department, Manipur. In the said Notification, altogether 82 (eighty two) candidates were shown as select candidates and 9 (nine) candidates, including the present petitioner, were shown as wait list candidates. In the wait list candidates, the name of the petitioner is shown at Sl. No. 1. The said Notification also indicated …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
SHOUGRA Digitally signed by
SHOUGRAKPAM
KPAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAN SINGH
Date: 2023.09.05
DA SINGH 13:13:48 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (C) No. 855 of 2021
Miss Saikhom Bidyarani Chanu, aged about 25 years, D/o (Late)
S. Dhaka Meetei, a resident of Moreh Ward No. 9, P.O. & P.S.
Moreh, Tengnoupal District, Manipur-795131.
... Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Manipur represented by the Principal Secretary
(Health), Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat, Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary/ Commissioner/Secretary (DP),
Government of Manipur, Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
3. The Director of Health Services, Manipur, Lamphelpat – 795001.
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLEMR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, Senior Advocate
asstd. by Mr. U. Augusta, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mr. A. Vashum, GA
Date of Hearing
::
16-08-2023
Date of Judgment & Order
::
05-09-2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. U. Augusta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr A.
Vashum, learned GA appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The core issue to be decided in the present writ petition is the
validity period of a Waiting List prepared by a DPC/ Selection Committee in
connection with giving appointments in Government services.
[2]
The facts of the present case, in a nutshell, is that the Medical
Directorate, Government of Manipur, issued a Notification dated
20-12-2016 notifying the list of selected candidates recommended by a
Selection Committee in its meeting held on 19th and 20th September, 2016
for appointment to the vacant posts of Pharmacist under the Health
Department, Manipur. In the said Notification, altogether 82 (eighty two)
candidates were shown as select candidates and 9 (nine) candidates,
including the present petitioner, were shown as wait list candidates. In the
wait list candidates, the name of the petitioner is shown at Sl. No. 1. The
said Notification also indicated that Offer Forms will be issued at the
Directorate w.e.f. 24th to 30th December, 2016 during office hours.
Even though the said select list was notified on 20-12-2016, no
appointment order was issued by the Government on account of the
enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct for the General Election in the
State of Manipur in the year 2017, pendency of Departmental investigation
initiated to verify the selection process and pendency of series of litigations.
Ultimately, this court passed two orders dated 24-01-2019 in WP(C) No.
992 of 2018 and 29-04-2019 in WP(C) No. 253 of 2019 directing the
respondents to expedite the process of consideration for appointment of
those petitioners and other eligible candidates to the posts of Pharmacist
at the earliest and within the stipulated time given in the said two orders. In
compliance with the directions given by this court in the aforesaid two
[3]
orders, the Director of Health Services, Manipur, issued two orders dated
08-03-2019 and 11-06-2019 appointing all the eighty-two recommended
candidates to the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) with the condition, inter
alia, that the appointees should join their respective place of posting within
ten days, failing which their appointment will be cancelled.
[3]
Out of the total 82 appointed Pharmacists, two appointees,
namely M. Surchandra Singh (UR category) and Umeshwori Devi
Nongthombam (OBC category) did not joined their service. On having
knowledge about the non-joining of the said two appointees, specially the
candidate belonging to the UR category, the petitioner, who belongs to UR
category and whose name is at Sl. No. 1 of the Waiting List, submitted an
application to the Director, Health Services, Manipur on 14-06-2019
requesting for appointing her against the vacant post.
The Chief Medical Officer, Tamenglong informed the Director,
Health Services, Manipur under a letter dated 20-08-2019 about the
non-submission of the joining report by the aforesaid two appointees by
giving their particulars and for taking necessary action. Taking into
consideration the application submitted by the petitioner on 14-06-2019 and
the non-joining report given by the CMO, Tamenglong under its letter dated
20-08-2019, the Director of Health Services, Manipur wrote a letter to the
Principal Secretary (Health & F.W.), Government of Manipur informing the
latter about the non-joining of the two appointees and requesting to convey
the administrative approval for appointment of two applicants, including the
present petitioner, as Pharmacist against the resultant vacancies occurred
due to non-joining of the two candidates.
[4]
[4]
When the State Government failed to take up any action with
regard to the aforesaid proposal made by the Director of Health Services,
Manipur, the petitioner again approached the authorities by submitting a
representation dated 21-01-2020 requesting for appointing her as
Pharmacist against the vacancies caused by non-joining of the said two
appointees. However, the State Government again failed to take up any
action in connection with the said representation submitted by the
petitioner. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner approached this court by filing
a writ petition being WP(C) No. 140 of 2020 with a prayer for directing the
respondents to consider for her appointment as Pharmacist against the
vacancies arose due to non-joining of service by two of the appointed
candidates. The said writ petition was disposed of by this court by passing
an order dated 24-03-2021 directing the authorities to consider and dispose
of the representation submitted by the petitioner within a period of three
months by issuing a speaking order. In purported compliance with the
directions given by this court, the Deputy Secretary (Health & Family
Welfare), Government of Manipur issued an order dated 05-10-2021
declining to appoint the petitioner as Pharmacist and rejecting the
representation submitted by her.
The only reason given by the authorities for rejecting the claim of
the petitioner for her appointment as Pharmacist against one of the
resultant vacancies is that all the Waiting List for direct recruitment for which
DPCs has been held more than one year back shall be deemed to
have been cancelled in view of para 4 of the Office Memorandum dated
20-12-1995 issued the Department of Personnel & Administrative Reforms
[5]
(PD), Government of Manipur. Having been aggrieved, the petitioner
approached this court again by filing the present writ petition for redressing
her grievances.
[5]
I have heard the submission advanced by the learned senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as the submission advanced by
the learned GA appearing for the respondents at length and also, carefully
examined the materials available on record.
In the present case, it is an undisputed fact that on the
recommendation of a Selection Committee in its meeting held on 19 th and
20th September, 2016, the Medical Directorate, Government of Manipur
notified a list of 82 selected candidates and 9 candidates in the Waiting List
for appointment to the vacant posts of Pharmacist in the Health
Department, Manipur, under the notification dated 20-12-2016. In the said
Waiting List, the name of the petitioner is at Sl. No. 1. Even though the said
select list as well as the Waiting List were notified on 20-12-2016, no
appointment order can be issued by the Government on account of the
enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct for the General Election in the
State of Manipur in the year 2017, pendency of Departmental Enquiry to
verify the selection process and pendency of various litigations. Ultimately,
this court passed two orders dated 24-01-2019 in WP(C) No. 992 of 2018
and 29-04-2019 in WP(C) No 253 of 2019 directing the State respondents
to expedite the process of consideration for appointment of the selected
candidates to the advertised posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) at the earliest
and in compliance with the said directions given by this court, the State
Government issued two appointment orders only on 08-03-2019 and
[6]
11-06-2019, about two and half years after the date of notification of the
selection list, appointing all the 82 selected candidates to the advertised
posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) with the condition that they should join their
respective place of posting within ten days, failing which their appointment
will be cancelled. Out of the 82 selected candidates, two candidates
namely, M. Surchandra Singh (UR category) and Umeshwori Devi
Nongthombam (OBC category) did not joined their service and accordingly,
two vacancies remained unfilled.
On having knowledge about the said two unfilled vacancies, the
petitioner, who is at Sl. No. 1 of the Waiting List promptly approached the
authorities to consider for her appointment against one of the UR vacancies
and the Director of Health Services, Manipur, also made a proposal to the
Government under a letter dated 09-09-2019 for conveying administrative
approval for appointment of the petitioner against the unfilled vacancy. The
only reason given by the respondents for rejecting the claim of the petitioner
is that the Waiting List shall be deemed to have been cancelled as the DPC
was held more than one year back as provided under para 4 of the
Memorandum dated 20-12-1995 issued by the Department of Personnel &
Administrative Reforms (PD), Government of Manipur. For ready reference,
para 4 of the said Memorandum are reproduced hereunder:“4. The Government have decided that all the waiting lists for the
Direct Recruitment for which DPCs has been held more than
one year back shall be deemed to have been cancelled. In
respect of the DPCs which are less then one year old, only the
names of the persons upto 10% of the vacancies for which the
selection process was held would be considered to be in the
waiting list and remaining portion of the list would be deemed
[7]
to have been cancelled. The appointments from these
truncated list would be made in accordance with para 2 above.”
[6]
The aforesaid Memorandum dated 20-12-1995 had been issued
by the Government with regard to clarification regarding waiting list for
appointment for direct recruitment through Departmental Promotion
Committee. In para 2 of the said Memorandum, it is, inter alia, provided that
whenever selection is held, except where it is for single post, it is normally
held by taking into account not only the number of vacancies existing on
the date of notification of the vacancies but even those which are likely to
arise in the future, within one year or so, due to retirement, promotion, etc.
and that such lists are prepared either under the rules or even otherwise
mainly to ensure that the working in office does not suffer if the selected
candidates does not join for one or other reason or the next selection or
examination is not held soon. It is further provided that a candidate in the
waiting list in the order of merit may, therefore, be appointed if one or other
selected candidate does not join or in the event of the resignation,
discharge or death, etc. of a candidate within the period of validity of the
waiting list. In my considered view, the provision under para 2 of the
aforesaid Memorandum dated 20-12-1995 is exactly applicable in the case
of the petitioner and the petitioner has legitimate right to claim for her
appointment against one of the unfilled vacant post of Pharmacist.
[7]
In the present case, the meeting of the Selection Committee was
held on 19th and 20th September, 2016 and the select list was notified on
20-12-2016. Only on 08-03-2019 and 11-06-2019, the State Government
issued the appointment orders after more than two years from the date of
notification of the said select list, meaning thereby, that the State
[8]
Government considered the select list notified on 20-12-2016 as still valid
even after about two and half years from its publication. In respect of the
list of 82 selected candidates, the stand of the State Government is that the
said select list is still valid even after more than two years from the date of
publication of the said select list whereas in respect of the waiting list, the
stand of the State Government is that it is invalid as it has lapsed the period
of one year and deemed to have been cancelled in view of para 4 of the
aforesaid Memorandum dated 20-12-1995. In my considered view, such
stand of the State Government in respect of the same select list as notified
under the notification dated 20-12-2016 is inconsistent, contradictory,
illogical, unreasonable, arbitrary and unsustainable in the eyes of law. It is
quite illogical and unfair to treat the same select list differently by applying
two different yardsticks and this court cannot give its countenance to such
arbitrary stand of the State Government.
[8]
In the case of “State of Jammu and Kashmir Vs. Sat Pal”
reported in (2013) 11 SCC 737, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as under:“11. In view of the factual position noticed hereinabove, the reason
indicated by the appellants in declining the claim of the
respondent Sat Pal for appointment out of the waiting list is
clearly unjustified. A waiting list would start to operate only
after the posts for which the recruitment is conducted, have
been completed. A waiting list would commence to operate
when offers of appointment have been issued to those
emerging on the top of the merit list. The existence of a waiting
list allows room to the appointing authority to fill up vacancies
which arise during the subsistence of the waiting list. A waiting
list commences to operate after the vacancies for which the
recruitment process has been conducted have been filled up.
In the instant controversy the aforesaid situation for operating
the waiting list had not arisen, because one of the posts of
Junior Engineer (Civil), Grade-II for which the recruitment
[9]
process was conducted was actually never filled up. For the
reason that Trilok Nath had not assumed charge, one of the
posts for which the process of recruitment was conducted, had
remained vacant. That apart, even if it is assumed for
arguments sake, that all the posts for which the process of
selection was conducted were duly filled up, it cannot be
disputed that Trilok Nath who had participated in the same
selection process as the respondent herein, was offered
appointment against the post of Junior Engineer (Civil), GradeII on 22-4-2008. The aforesaid offer was made consequent upon
his selection in the said process of recruitment. The validity of
the waiting list, in the facts of this case, has to be determined
with reference to 22-4-2008, because the vacancy was offered
to Trilok Nath on 22-4-2008. It is the said vacancy, for which the
respondent had approached the High Court. As against the
aforesaid, it is the acknowledged position recorded by the
appellants in the impugned order dated 23-8-2011 (extracted
above), that the waiting list was valid till May, 2008. If Trilok
Nath was found eligible for appointment against the vacancy in
question out of the same waiting list, the respondent herein
would be equally eligible for appointment against the said
vacancy. This would be the unquestionable legal position, in so
far as the present controversy is concerned.”
[9]
Taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the
present case and findings and reasons given hereinabove and keeping in
view the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of “Sat Pal"
(supra) quoted hereinabove, it is hereby held that the rejection of the
petitioner's claim for her appointment against the unfilled vacancy of
Pharmacist (Allopathy) earmarked for unreserved category due to
non-joining of the service by one of the selected candidates namely,
M. Surchandra Singh is illegal. Accordingly, the respondents are directed
to appoint the petitioner against the said post retrospectively w.e.f
11-06-2019 on which date the appointment order of M. Surchandra Singh
was issued or with effect from any date within the month of June, 2019 as
deem fit and proper by the authorities. It is made clear that such
[10]
retrospective appointment should be given notional effect without any
monetary benefit for the period from the date of her appointment till the date
of issuance of the said appointment order. However, the petitioner shall be
entitled to all the consequential service benefits including seniority and
pensionary benefits as permissible under law. The whole process of the
petitioner’s appointment should be completed within a period of two months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is allowed.
Parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review