Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 744 OF 2021
Miss Aparajita Das, D/o Sri Amitava Das, resident of
Amtali, P.O. Amtali, P.S. Amtali, Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799130.
Vrs.
1. The Union of India (to be represented by the Secretary,
Department of Higher Education 127C Shastri Bhavan,
New Delhi, 110001, India).
2. The Central Board of Secondary Education ( to be represented by the
Chairman, CBSE, Shiksha Kendra, 2, Community Centre,
Preet Vihar, Delhi, 110092).
3. The Principal, Assam Riffles Public School (affiliated to
Central Board of Secondary Education), Assam Riffles Complex,
Agartala.
4. The Director, IIT Bombay, IIT Bombay, Powai,
Mumbai 400076, Maharastra, India.
----Respondents
Present:
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate.
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. T. Datta Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Asstt. S.G.
Mr. T. Halam, Advocate.
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate.
Whether fit for
reporting
: No.
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
27.09.2022
Judgment & Order (oral)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by
Ms. A. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard
Mr. T. Datta Majudmer, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. T. Halam
appearing for the respondent no.2, Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
no.3 and Mr. B. Majumder, learned Asstt. S.G. appearing for the
respondent nos.1 and 4.
2.
By way of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:“Under the circumstances stated above, it is submitted, that the
Hon’ble High Court would be kind enough to:(I) Issue rules upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and direction of like nature
shall not be issued directing the Respondents quashing and
cancelling the Senior Examination Results 2021 of the
Petitioner as declared by the CBSE.
(II) Issue rules upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and direction of like nature
shall not be issued directing the Respondents to declare Senior
School Certificate Examination, 2021 of the Petitioner in terms
of Notification dated 17.06.2021 issued by the CBSE.
(III) Issue rules upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and direction of like nature
shall not be issued whereby declaring that in terms of
Notification, dated 17.06.2021 the Petitioner scored 46+27=73
marks in Chemistry, Physics 49+30=79 marks and in
Mathematics 54+18=72 marks in Central Board of Secondary
Education Examination 2021.
(IV) Pass an interim order directing IIT Bombay to keep 1
seat vacant in Bachelor of Design Coarse and/or to give
provisional admission to the Petitioner subject to outcome of the
Writ Petition.
(v) Make rules absolute.
(VI) Call for records.
(VII) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble High
Court considered fit and proper.”
3.
Briefly stated, the petitioner was a student of Assam Riffles
Public School at Agartala, the respondent no.3 herein. She has challenged
her result of the Senior School Examination 2021 declared by the
respondent-CBSE. It is stated that due to pandemic situation no
examination could be conducted. The marks were allotted under a specific
guideline issued by CBSE under the approval of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court. The petitioner has stated that in terms of CBSE Notification dated
17.06.2021, her final marks would be as under:Subjects
Class
X
Marks (Best
Average=78)
80% of 78
(A)
30%
of
Class
X(A)
Class
XI
(B)
30%
of
Class
XI
Class XII 40% of Total
Marks
Class XII (B)+(C)+(E)
(1st+2nd)
Marks(D)
Screening
Tests(D)
(C)
(E)
Physics
Chemistry
Maths
4.
32+36=68
(70% of
68)=47
22+37=59
(70% of
59)=41
41+25=67
(80% of
67)=54
The petitioner in her affidavit by way of rejoinder has stated
that, as per the tabulation sheet of respondent no.3, 21 marks was
erroneously deducted from Physics, 18 marks was erroneously deducted
from Chemistry, and 25 marks was deducted from Mathematics. Such
deduction was in violation of the CBSE Notification dated 17.06.2021, for
the simple reason, that, the Notification dated 17.06.2021 held that
variation due to standardization shall be only +/- 5 marks.
5.
The marks as shown in the above chart have not been disputed
by the respondent-CBSE. At Para 10 of its counter affidavit the marks
obtained by the petitioner is admitted. It is clarified in the guideline that
average of best 3 subjects out of main 5 subjects is to be taken into account
for the purpose of calculating the marks to give benefit to the students
omitting the scores of the subjects in which they underperformed due to
any reasons.
5.1
The broad distribution of marks assigned to various
components on the basis of which the final marks of every student would
be computed is as under:Theory Marks
5.2
Class X
30%
Class XI
30%
Class XII
40%
Practical/IA
Marks
Total Marks
Class XII
Class X
Class XI
Class XII
Clause 8 of the said guideline deals with the computation of
theory marks, which is as under:
“8 (a) Class XII Theory Marks
The computation of theory marks for class XII will be based on
performance in one or more Unit Test(s)/Mid-Term/Pre-Board(s) theory
examination. The result committee of the school may decide wightage to
be given to each exam based on the credibility and realibility of the
assessment. For example, if the committee may be of the considered view
that only the Pre-Board exams may be taken into consideration, then a
full weightage can be given to that component. Similarly, another school
Result committee may decide to give equal weightage to Pre-Board
exams and Mid-Term exams.
As for as Unit Test(s)/Mid-Term/Pre-Board Examination(s) are
concerned during the session 2020-2021, following is possible: there may be differences in terms of the mode of conduct of
examination i.e. Online/Offline.
that some of the students may not have appeared in any or some
of the examinations conducted by schools.
In all the above cases, Result Committee constituted by the School will
have to address these challenges based on the analysis and study of the
situation prevailing in the school and thereafter draw up a criterion for
the assessment of Class-XII component. Committee is fully responsible to
take any decision after analysis and study of the situation prevailing in
the school and with the students. The aim should be to cover as broad a
range of assessment objectives as possible. The Rationale for the criteria
should be well thought out, objective and should be documented in the
form of Rationale document (Annesure-2), explaining in detail how the
school assessed marks of Class-XII component.
(a) the reasons for the weightage given to different exams/tests.
(b) in cases where students have not appeared in none of the tests/exam
categories then basis for the assessment should be indicated.
The committee should, in all cases, clearly record all its decisions in
writing with the reasons in the Rationale document and take decision.
(b) Class XI Theory Marks
Computation of class XI theory marks shall be on the basis of year end
final theory exam in respective subjects.
(c) Class X Theory Marks
Computation of class X theory marks shall be based on average theory
marks obtained by the student(s) in best three performing subjects out of
main 5 subjects. This average will be uniformly awarded to all the class
XII subjects based on theory weightage.
To facilitate ease in entering the theory marks of class X, the Board will
provide the marks for the students who have appeared in CBSE class X
examinations. For students of other Boards, the schools will have to
enter the information based on the class X mark sheets of the students
available with schools.”
6.
Thereafter, the marks are to be standardized, moderated and
aligned as per Clause 10 of the said guideline. The grievance of the
petitioner is that the standardization, moderation and alignment of the
marks had not been properly done by the school authority, as such, in two
subjects i.e. Chemistry and Mathematics she secured less than the pass
mark i.e. compartmental and thus, to repeat theory papers, that is, in
Chemistry and Mathematics.
7.
Considering the grievance of the petitioner, I have given my
thoughtful consideration to the statements made in the respective counter
affidavits filed by the School concerned i.e. the Assam Riffles Public
School, the respondent no.3 and the respondent-Board as well.
7.1
At the outset, I may reproduce Para 17 of the counter affidavit
of the CBSE which is as under:“17. That with regards the contents of Para 14 of the
petition I say that as per clause 10 of the Notification dated
17.06.2021 the concerned school is required to standardize marks of
Class XI and XII by internally moderate the marks to account for the
school level variation by using a reliable reference standard. The
school shall calculate the total theory marks for each student by
adding the marks for the class X, XI and XII as per the weightage of
each class. Thereafter based on the total marks, moderation shall be
carried out by the school in Class XI and Class XII. Scaling up or
scaling down of Class XI and Class XII marks may have to be done in
affair and transparent manner by the result Committee.
I further submit that as per Clause 10(a) of the
Notification historical performance of the school, in terms of the best
overall performance in the previous three years Board Examination
will be taken as the reference for moderating the marks assessed by
the school for 2020-2021.
As per Sub clause (b) of clause 10 of the Notification it
was stipulated that subject wise marks assessed by the school for
2021-2021 should be within a range of +/- 5 marks obtained by the
students in the school in the subject in the reference year. However,
the overall average marks for the school assessed in 2020-2021, for
all the subjects, should not exceed the overall average marks obtained
by the school by 2 marks in the specific reference year.
In case date for a school for only two years is available
then the best performance out of two years will be taken and in case,
data is available for only year, the same will be taken.
Furthermore, in schools, wherever the students are
appearing in the Class XII Board Examination for the first time and
hence, have no historical date available, the Board will provide the
historical data in the manner provided in clause (I)(ii) & (iii) (d)10 of
the Notification.
The marks of the petitioner might have been scale down
following the above criteria. This policy is for all and the same is not
aimed at a particular student. Therefore, there is no prima facie case
established by the petitioner. It is not a fact that awarding of marks in
the Class XII Board Examination 2021 is beyond the criteria as
notified in Notification dated 17.06.2021.”
7.2
Next, the respondent-Assam Rifles Public School in their
counter affidavit has stated thus:
“2.2
With reference to the statements/averments/contentions
made in Paragraph-4 of the WP, it is most humbly and respectfully
submitted that based on the marks statement of Class-X, and
according to the Guidelines of the CBSE Notification dated
17.06.2021, the average theory marks, obtained by a student, in best 3
performing subjects out of maximum 5 subjects, was uploaded in the
CBSE Result Tabulation Sheet Online. Accordingly, the calculation
for Class X component of the petitioner is as under:Average of best 3 main subjects (including practical) of
the petitioner is (73+72+86)/3=77.
Average of Theory component of the petitioner is 77-20
(internal assessment)=57.
Therefore, 30% of 57 stands to 17, and hence, the
petitioner’s claim of 19 is incorrect.
It is most humbly and respectfully submitted that in
Class XI, as per the Marks Statement (Annexure-2 to the WP),
submitted by the petitioner, the theory marks in:(i) Chemistry is 13.30% component whereof would
stand at 3.9 (rounded off to 4),
(ii) Physics is 33.30% component whereof would stand
at 9.9 (rounded off to 10), and
(iii) Mathematics is 27.30% component whereof would
stand at 8.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
2.5
With reference to the statements/averments/contentions
made in Paragraphs-7 & 8 of the WP, it is most humbly and
respectfully submitted that the results of Class X and XII were strictly
tabulated as per the Guidelines laid down by the respective Board,
and hence, the answering respondent No.3 cannot be held liable.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
2.7
With reference to the statements/averments/contentions
made in Paragraph-10 of the WP, it is most humbly and respectfully
submitted that after uploading of Class X, XI and XII component on
the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE for short) website
separately, further calculation and tabulation was auto done by the
CBSE. Thereafter, the CBSE provided the moderated marks, based on
the historical performance of individual students in every subjects for
which the respondent No.3, cannot be held responsible.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
2.9
With reference to the statements/averments/contentions
made in Paragraphs-12, 13, 14 & 15 of the WP, it is most humbly and
respectfully submitted that for resolution of the dispute, the petitioner
had submitted a representation, in connection wherewith, the Dispute
Committee had checked her Tabulation Sheet again and again, but no
error was found in the said Tabulation. It is pertinent to mention
herein that the CBSE had not conducted examination for the academic
year 2020-2021, and hence, there is no such option of review. So the
claim of the petitioner of review of her result is totally illogical.
It is further stated that the calculations, as shown in
Paragraph 13 of the WP does not conform to the CBSE norms of
tabulation. Moreover, she has not taken into account moderation of
marks, brought about in every subject of all students, as per the
directions of the CBSE, based on the historical performance of the
school in the subjects in the previous years’ board results.”
8.
Mr. Datta Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent-CBSE has clarified the situation. Mr. Datta Majumder, learned
senior counsel has submitted that the standardization and moderation of
marks were done by the School considering the historical backgrounds etc.
and also taking into account its performance in the previous three years.
Thereafter, these marks were aligned with the broad distribution of marks
given by the CBSE and then, it was placed in the portal of CBSE and if it
appeared to be matched with the standard of marks in the portal, in that
case only the portal would accept the respective marks of the students. If
there was any mismatch, then, the portal would not accept it. Thereafter,
overall marks will be allocated by the CBSE on the basis of which
certificates indicating the marks obtained by a particular student were
issued.
9.
On consideration of the submissions advanced by learned
counsels appearing for the parties and an overview of the above procedures
as are indicated in the guideline, in my opinion, it is a special procedure
adopted by the Board being approved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in special circumstances. The court cannot doubt the allocation of
marks being placed in the portal on the basis of which overall assessment
made by the School in favour of a particular student. Moreover, it is found
that the petitioner had approached the Result Committee constituted to
resolve all disputes arising out of declaration of results including
distribution of marks to the students. The said Committee had examined
the claim of the petitioner time and again and ultimately, no error was
detected in the allocation/tabulation of marks.
10.
In the opinion of this court, the Committee has been formed
by the experts and in this circumstance, it will not be prudent to sit over the
findings
of
the
Expert
Committee
on
the
basis
of
which
tabulation/distribution of marks was carried out. There cannot be any doubt
that the Result Committee constituted by the experts had specialised
knowledge on the subject in issue and the Court has limited scope to
interfere with the process of evaluation of marks in a particular subject or
subjects.
11.
Accordingly, I do not find any material to interfere with the
result declared by the CBSE in respect of the petitioner.
12.
In the result, the instant writ petition fails and accordingly,
stands dismissed.
JUDGE
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review