Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27402
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
C. R.
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
TUESDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 521 OF 2019
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 29.07.2019 IN OS NO.36 OF 2016 OF
III ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, KOZHIKODE
----APPELLANT:
MINI VINOD KUMAR,
AGED 43 YEARS,
W/O.VINOD KUMAR.V.M., FLAT NO.203, 'A' BLOCK,
N.D.OLIVA LAYOUT, SOMASUNDARAPAALAYA, BANGALURU,
HSR LAYOUT POST OFFICE, KARNATAKA-560102.
BY ADVS.
NIRMAL. S
SMT.VEENA HARI
RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFFS:
K.VIJAYALAKSHMI,
AGED 69 YEARS
W/O.EZHUVATH RAJAN @ RAJAN MENON, 'SREE VALSAM',
RAJABHAVAN COMPLEX, M.S.BABURAJA ROAD, KALLAI.P.O.,
KOZHIKODE-673003.
K.SAI RAMESH,
AGED 33 YEARS, S/O.EZHUVATH RAJAN @ RAJAN MENON,
FLAT NO.'FOFI', 4TH FLOOR, AJANTHA MEDOWS APARTMENT,
3RD CROSS, AKSHAYA NAGAR, YELANAHALLI,
BEGUR POST OFFICE, BANGALURU-560068.
2025:KER:27402
RFA NO. 521 OF 2019
-2-
BY ADVS.
P.CHANDRASEKHAR
K.K.MOHAMED RAVUF
RANI MADHU
MANJARI G.B.
SATHEESH V.T.
THIS
REGULAR
FIRST
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
01.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:27402
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
R. F. A. No.521 of 2019
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 1st day of April, 2025
C. R.
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
The preliminary decree in a suit for partition is
under challenge by the defendants.
2. The first plaintiff is the mother. The second
plaintiff and the defendant are the son and the daughter
born to the first plaintiff and her husband, late Rajan
Menon. The issue involved in this appeal is confined to
plaint schedule II item No.1 (“the property”, and hence
the discussions hereunder are confined to that.
3. According to the plaintiffs the property sought
to be partitioned belonged to the father and the mother
(Rajan Menon and first plaintiff), under Exts.A1 and A2
Sale Deeds dated 17.12.1991 and 18.12.1991. On the death
of the father, his one-half right over the property
devolved
on
the
plaintiffs
and
the
defendant.
The
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 2 :-
plaintiff seeks for partition and separate possession of
their shares. The first plaintiff claims one-half share
of the property in addition to the share inherited by
her from her husband(4/6 shares).
4.
The
defendant
disputed
the
claim
that
the
property belonged to the father and the mother under
Exts.A1 and A2 Sale Deeds. According to her, she and her
mother – first plaintiff, had obtained property under
Ext.B1 Partition Deed dated 22.05.1987, executed in the
family of the mother. At that time, since the defendant
was
a
through
minor,
she
her
father
14.01.1992,
the
was
said
represented
as
guardian.
property
in
the
partition
Subsequently,
obtained
under
on
Ext.B1
partition, was sold away under Exts.B2, B3 and B4 Sale
Deeds for a total consideration of ₹ 82,500/-. At that
time though the defendant had just attained 18 years of
age, she was under the care and protection of the
parents. Utilising the consideration under Exts.B2 to B4
Sale Deeds the property in question was purchased under
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 3 :-
Exts.A1 and A2 Sale Deeds. The purchase is in trust for
the defendant. At the relevant time, the father did not
have other sources to purchase the property. Hence the
defendant has one-half right over the property, is the
claim.
5. The trial court held that the defendant was a
major at the time of execution of Exts.B2 and B3 Sale
Deeds and the burden of proof vested on her to prove
that the purchase was utilising the said funds and in
trust for the defendant. It was also held that the case
of the plaintiff that the sale consideration obtained
under
Exts.B2
educational
to
B4
purposes
of
sale
the
were
utilised
defendant,
is
for
the
probable.
Accordingly the claim of the defendant was negatived. It
was held that the first plaintiff and her husband Rajan
Menon has one-half share each over the property.
6. We have heard Sri.Nirmal.S, the learned counsel
for the appellant-defendant and Sri.P.Chandrasekhar, the
learned counsel for the respondents-plaintiffs.
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 4 :-
7. The points that arise for determination are:(i) Does the evidence on record probabilise the defendant's
contention that the acquisition of Exts.A1 and A2 Sale Deeds were
utilising the consideration obtained by sale under Exts.B2 to B4?
(ii) Is the claim of the defendant that the acquisition of property
under Exts.A1 and A2 is on her behalf under a trust by the parents, liable
to be upheld?
(iii) Is the defendant entitled to in specie partition of the property
purchased under Exts.A1 and A2 even if the acquisition thereunder was
utilising the consideration obtained by sale under Exts.B2 to B4?
8. Exts.A1 and A2 Sale Deeds were on 17.12.1991 and
18.12.1991. The sale under Exts.B2 to B4 were a month
later, in January, 1992. Therefore, the claim of the
defendant that the purchase under Exts.A1 and A2 was
utilising the sale consideration under Exts.B2 to B4 is
evidently unsustainable, is the contention.
9.
It
is
to
be
noticed
that,
the
total
sale
consideration for Exts.B2 to B4 was ₹ 82,500/- and the
purchase price under Exts.A1 and A2 was only ₹ 60,000/-.
The first plaintiff mother has deposed that the sale
under Exts.B2 to B4 was preceded by an agreement for
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 5 :-
sale and that the sale was after six months from the
agreement. She has also admitted that at the time of
purchase under Exts.A1 and A2 she had with her the sale
consideration of ₹ 82,500/- which is the consideration
under Exts.B2 to B4. She also admitted that there is no
material to show that her husband had any money or
reserves with him. The relevant deposition reads thus :“Ext.B1 പ്രകകാരരം എനനികക്ക് കനിടനിയ വസ്തു ഞകാൻ തതീറക്ക് വനിറ.
അതക്ക് 82,500/- രൂപയകാണക്ക് വനിറ്റതക്ക്.”
……….
“ടനി വനിൽപ്പന നടതനിയതനിനക്ക് എഗനിമമെനക്ക് ഉണകായനിരുന. ആ
എഗനിമമെനക്ക് കഴനിഞക്ക് 6 മെകാസരം കഴനിഞകാണക്ക് തതീറക്ക് നടന്നതക്ക്. അതനിമന
അഡഡകാൻസക്ക് തുക എത്രയകായനിരുന എന്നക്ക് ഓർതക്ക് പറയകാൻ പറ്റനില.
അനനകായപടനിക 1--കാരം നമ്പർ വസ്തു 60,000/- രൂപ തതീറക്ക് പ്രതനിഫലരം
മകകാടുതകാണക്ക് വകാങനിയതക്ക്. ടനി സമെയതക്ക് രകാജൻ മമെമനകാമന കകയനിൽ
എമന്തെങനിലരം
പണമമെകാ
നതീകനിയനിരനിമപ്പകാ
ഉണകായനിരുന
എന്നക്ക്
കകാണനികകാൻ മരഖയനില. എമന കകയനിൽ വസ്തുവനിറ്റ 82,500/- രൂപ
ഉണകായനിരുന.”
There is a clear admission from the part of the first
plaintiff that, at the time of purchase under Exts.A1
and A2 she was in possession of the sale consideration
for Exts.B2 to B4. It is only probable since the sale
under Exts.B2 to B4 was preceded by an agreement for
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 6 :-
sale for a period of six months and the conveyances were
executed within a period of one month thereafter. In the
light of the clear admission on the part of the first
plaintiff, and in the absence of any evidence to prove
that the father Rajan Menon had any money with him or
any source from which he had raised the money, the only
probability is that the purchase under Exts.A1 and A2
was
utilising
the
sale
consideration
obtained
under
Exts.B2 to B4. This is all the more so since PW1 has
admitted that Sri.Rajan Menon did not have any avocation
and that there are no documents to prove his income. She
has also admitted that they eked their livelihood by
dealing with their properties. Therefore, it is probable
that the purchase of property under Exts.A1 and A2 was
utilising the funds raised by sale under Exts.B2 to B4
Sale Deeds.
10. It is the contention of the plaintiffs that,
the share of the defendant out of the sale consideration
under
Exts.B2
to
B4
sales
were
utilised
for
her
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 7 :-
educational
purposes.
The
defendant
refutes
the
contention and claimed that she had secured admission
for her BDS course on merit. PW1 admitted that the
defendant had secured 90% marks for pre-degree course.
But for the bald claim that amounts were spent to secure
admission in the management quota and for the studies of
the defendant there is no evidence to substantiate the
same. All that the plaintiffs have produced is Ext.A35,
which is only the schedule of studies of examinations
of
the
institution.
admission
was
There
secured
by
is
nothing
paying
to
show
capitation
that
fee
or
otherwise. Therefore, the said contention is only to be
repelled.
11. It is next contended by the learned counsel for
the plaintiffs that amounts much in excess of the sale
consideration under Exts.B2 to B4 was given to the
defendant and her husband for purchasing and furnishing
an
apartment
of
the
defendant
at
Bangalore.
It
is
claimed that the gold ornaments belonging to the father
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 8 :-
and
mother
defendant
was
and
sold
her
and
amounts
husband
for
were
the
sent
above
to
the
purpose.
Straight away it is to be noted that, the plaintiffs do
not
have
a
case
that
the
sale
consideration
under
Exts.B2 to B4 was paid off accordingly.
12. As was noticed earlier, the father and mother
did not have any particular source of income. They were
living on the funds raised by sale of properties and
gold. As PW1 the first plaintiff has deposed “ എനനികരം
ഭർതകാവനിനരം മജകാലനി ഒനരം ഉണകായനിരുന്നനില.
......
സഡത്തുകൾ മനകാകനി
നടതനിയകാണക്ക് ഞങൾ ജതീവനിചനിരുന്നതക്ക് ”. She has also deposed that
“ബകാകനിയുള്ള 50 പവമന സഡർണരം 2005 മുതൽ പല ആവശനങൾകകായനി
വനിറ്റതകാണക്ക്. അതക്ക് പലനിശ അടകകാനരം ചനിലവനിനരം മെറ്റക്ക് ആവശനങൾകകായനിട്ടുമെകാണക്ക്
വനിറ്റതക്ക്”.
PW1 admitted that the defendant's husband had
provided
financial
support
to
examination she deposed “ വനിമനകാദക്ക്
them.
In
her
cross-
ഗൾഫനിൽ നനിനരം ചനിലവനിനകായനി
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 9 :സരംഖന അയചക്ക് തന്നനിട്ടുണക്ക് ”.
To a pointed question that the
defendant's husband supported Rajan Menon to purchase
item no.3 property in schedule II to the plaint, was not
denied.
Under
financial
such
capacity
circumstances
when
such
was
the
of
plaintiff
and
her
the
first
husband, it cannot be believed that they provided funds
to the defendant for purchase of flat and for its
furnishing. The defence that her gold ornaments which
were entrusted with the parents were sold and amounts
were sent to the plaintiff and her husband for the
purpose of purchase and furnishing the apartment, is
probable.
When
PW1
admitted
that
ornaments
were
sold
for
purpose
the
in
of
her
gold
payment
of
interest and expenses etc., it is quite improbable that
during the said period amounts would have been provided
to the defendant for furnishing her apartment. Under
such circumstances, the claim of the plaintiffs that the
sale consideration under Exts.B2 to B4 were paid to the
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 10 :-
defendant in the manner as claimed, cannot be accepted.
13. At the time of execution of Exts.B2 to B4 Sale
Deeds, the defendant was only 18 years of age and
unmarried. She was under the care and protection of the
father and the mother. The mere fact that she had
attained majority cannot lead to the conclusion that she
had taken her share of the money and utilised for her
purpose.
The
consideration
obtained
by
sale
of
the
property under Exts.B2 to B4 was with the father and the
mother. It needs no elaboration to find that they were
holding the money as trustees of the defendant who was
aged only 18 years. The purchase of the property was
utilising such funds.
14. Now the question is whether the defendant is
entitled to half rights over the property purchased
under Exts.A1 and A2 utilising such money.
15.
According
to
the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant-defendant, the acquisition of property being
utilising trust fund, the beneficiary is entitled to
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 11 :-
trace
the
fund
and
claim
right
over
the
converted
property. The argument is founded on Section 63 of the
Indian Trust Act (“the Act”).
16. Sections 63 of the Trust Act reads thus:“[s 63] Following trust property into the hands of the third persons.—
Where trust property comes into the hands of a third person inconsistently
with the trust, the beneficiary may require him to admit formally, or may
institute a suit for a declaration, that the property is comprised in the
trust.
Into that into which it has been converted.— Where the trustee has
disposed of trust property and the money or other property which he has
received therefor can be traced in his hands, or the hands of his legal
representative or legatee, the beneficiary has, in respect thereof, rights as
nearly as may be the same as his rights in respect of the original trust
property.”
What is relevant for us is the second paragraph of the
Section.
It
indicates
that,
when
the
trustee
has
acquired another property utilising his funds along with
the trust property, then, the right of the beneficiary
is nearly the same as that he had over the trust
property. The illustration to
very clear. It reads thus:-
Section 63 make the scope
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 12 :Illustrations
(a)
A, a trustee for B of Rs. 10,000, wrongfully invests the
Rs. 10,000 in the purchase of certain land, B is entitled to the
land.
(b)
A, a trustee, wrongfully purchases land in his own name,
partly with his own money, partly with money subject to a
trust for B. B is entitled to a charge on the land for the amount
of the trust money so misemployed.”
In illustration (a), the trust money is utilised by 'A'
for purchase of a land and 'B' is entitled for the said
land. In illustration (b) the trustee utilising his own
money and also the trust money purchases the property.
In such case the beneficiary is only entitled for a
charge
on
the
property
for
the
trust
money.
Under
Section 66 of the Act when the trustee mixes the trust
property with his own, the beneficiary is entitled to
charge on the whole property for the trust money.
“[s66] Right in case of blended property.— Where the trustee wrongfully
mingles the trust property with his own, the beneficiary is entitled to a
charge on the whole fund for the amount due to him.”
The role of illustrations to Sections, as being an
internal aid to interpret and understand the true scope
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 13 :-
of a Section has been highlighted by the Apex Court in
various judgments. In Dr. Mahesh Chand Sharma v. Raj Kumari Sharma
(1996) 8 SCC 128, the Apex Court held that illustrations help to
elucidate the principle of the Section. The Privy Council in
Mahomed Syedol Ariffin v. Yeoh Ooi Gark [1916] 2 AC 575 made the following
observations
regarding
the
importance
of
illustration
appended to a Section :“It is the duty of a court of law to accept, if that can be done, the
illustrations given as being both of relevance and value in the
construction of the text. The illustrations should in no case be rejected
because they do not square with ideas possibly derived from another
system of jurisprudence as to the law with which they or the sections deal.
And it would require a very special case to warrant their rejection on the
ground of their assumed repugnancy to the sections themselves. It would
be the very last resort of construction to make any such assumption. The
great usefulness of the illustrations, which have, although not part of the
sections, been expressly furnished by the legislature as helpful in the
working and application of the statute, should not be thus impaired.”
The apex court relied on the said observations of the Privy
Council in Jumma Masjid, Mercara v. Kodimaniandra Deviah and Ors. AIR 1962
SC 847 and observed that “It is not to be readily assumed that an
illustration to a section is repugnant to it and rejected.”
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 14 :-
17. In Re Hallett's Estate, Knatchbull v. Hallett (1879) 13 Ch.D 696 the
rights of the beneficiary in case of misapplication of
trust funds, was explained thus :“..... I will first of all, take his position when the purchase is clearly made
with what I will call, for shortness the trust money, although it is not
confined as I will show presently, to express trusts in that case, according
to the now well-established doctrine of equity the beneficial owner a right
to elect either to take the property purchased or to hold it as a security the
amount of the purchase money laid out in the purchase; or, as we
generally express it, he is entitled at his election either to take the
property, or to have a charge on the property for the amount of the trust
money. But in the second case, where a trustee mixed the money with his
own, there is the distinction, that the cestui eue trust, or beneficial.”
The
learned
author
N.Suryanarayana
Iyer
in
his
commentaries on the Indian Trust Act, relying on various
English judgments including Re Hallett's Estate (supra) has at
page 585 of the 5th edition of the book stated thus,
““The question of identification of a particular property as representing
the trust fund would present no difficulty where the trustee has utilised the
trust funds exclusively for the purchase of property. Where, however, he
mixed the trust moneys into his own and out of the mixed fund property is
bought, the cestui que trust cannot claim the property itself as trust
property. In such a case the purchase being from out of mixed funds, the
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 15 :right of the cestui que trust is only to claim a charge or lien for the
amount of the trust fund on the entire property so purchased.”.
The above is very much in tune with the distinction
drawn under the illustrations (a) and (b) to Section 63
noted above.
18. Therefore, taking it to be that the father and
mother
were
trustees,
holding
and
the
the
money
of
the
defendant
same
along
with
their
money
as
was
utilised for the purchase of property under Exts.A1 and
A2, the defendant cannot claim proprietary right over
such property but has a charge over the property, for
the trust money. The sale consideration for Exts.B2 to
B4 Sale Deeds was ₹ 82,500/-. The defendant was entitled
to one-half right of the same viz. ₹ 41,250/-. The
defendant has charge on the property purchased under
Exts.A1 and A2 for such amount. However, she cannot
claim right over one-half of the property.
19. Since the amounts were utilised for purchase of
a property, there is no reason to decline interest on
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 16 :-
the said amount. We are of the opinion that grant of
interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of
Exts.B2 to B4 Sale Deeds (the later of the date being
28.01.1992 will be reckoned). The amount of ₹ 41,250/with
interest
thereon,
will
be
a
charge
on
plaint
schedule II item no.1, purchased under Exts.A1 and A2
Sale Deeds. The decree and judgment of the trial court
is liable to be modified accordingly.
20.
The
partitioning
trial
the
court
has
granted
a
decree
for
liability
of
the
father
which
was
settled by the plaintiffs. Necessarily both the rights
and liabilities of the deceased devolves on the legal
heirs. Exts.A30 and 31 and 33 evidences the liabilities
of
late
Rajan
Menon
and
its
settlement
by
the
plaintiffs. The mere fact that she was not in receipt of
any
demand
notice
regarding
the
liabilities,
cannot
absolve her. The defendant being a legal heir is bound
to share the proportionate liability in accordance with
her share. The trial court was right in having reckoned
RFA No.521 of 2019
2025:KER:27402
-: 17 :-
the same.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed in part. It is
declared that the defendant shall be entitled to realise
an amount of ₹ 41,250/- with interest at the rate of 9%
per annum from 28.01.1992 charged on plaint schedule II
item No.1. The above direction shall form part of the
decree. In all other respects, the decree and judgment
of the trial court will stand affirmed.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review