Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)
WPA 24197 of 2012
Messrs Gloster Jute Mills Limited
Vs
Learned First Labour Court & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Ranjay De, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. S.K. Singh,
Mr. Sujit Sharma.
For the Respondent No. 3
:
Mr. Balaram Patra,
Mr. Suvadip Bhattacharjee.
Judgment reserved on
:
23.07.2026
Judgment delivered on
:
24.08.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:
1.
The writ application has been preferred challenging an award dated
15.05.2012, passed by the First Labour Court, Kolkata.
2.
Vide the impugned award the learned First Labour Court directed as
follows:“The applicant joined the Opposite Party in
the year 1990 and since then he had worked for
the Opposite Party and admittedly he was a
registered badly. He lost his job and remained
unemployed for the entire period. It is not pleaded
that he did not get job on all the days of a year.
So considering the entire facts and circumstances
of this proceeding in my view the applicant is
entitled
to
get
consequential
of
his
benefits
back
from
wages
the
date
with
of
termination of his service till the date of actual
reinstatement.
Under such circumstances the applicant is
entitled to be reinstated in service under the
Opposite Party and is to get full back wages and
consequential
benefits
from
the
date
of
termination of his service till the date of actual
reinstatement.
The Opposite Party is directed to reinstate
the applicant immediately and to pay him full
back
wages
with
consequential
benefits
immediately.”
3.
The petitioner’s case herein is that the respondent no. 3 herein was
engaged by the petitioner as a Registered Badli for work against
temporary requirements of labour arising sometimes at its said Jute
Mills.
4.
Petitioner states that the respondent no. 3 enrolled his name in the
list of 'Registered Badlis' of its said Jute Mills and in the year 1990
he was engaged for work in that capacity for the first time.
Thereafter, he was deployed for work as 'Registered Badli' from time
to time as an when required. Since he was a badli there was no
scope for him to work continuously for years together in the said
Jute Mills of the Company and, as a matter of fact, he never worked
for 240 days in any year in any of the years of his attachment with
the company.
5.
As per records, the respondent no. 3 was last engaged as a badli in
the year 2004, wherein his engagement as badli was for a period of
134 days only. The respondent no. 3 as a 'Registered Badli', was
covered under the E.S.I. Act, 1948 and as well as under the
provisions
of
Employees
Provident
Fund
and
Miscellaneous
Provisions Act, 1952.
6.
Petitioner states that the respondent no. 3 did not report to the
Labour Office of the petitioner company from January, 2005 till
October, 2005 and accordingly an intimation was issued to him in
terms of the Certified Standing Orders applicable to the petitioner
company's industrial establishment on 21.10.2005.
7.
Though the communication was correctly addressed, no response
was received from the end of the respondent no. 3. Under these
circumstances, the petitioner Company had no other alternative but
to take the decision to remove the said respondent's name from the
list of Registered Badlis of its said Jute Mills under clause 5 (b)(iii) of
the said standing orders and by a letter dated 12.11.2005, the name
of the respondent no. 3 had been removed from the said badli list of
the company.
8.
Although
for
a
prolonged
period
from
January,
to
11/11/2005, the date prior to delisting the name of the respondent
no.3 from the badli list, no intimation was received by the company
from him, by a letter dated 23.05.2006 the respondent no. 3
however made a representation to the Petitioner Company to
reconsider his case. The petitioner company by a letter dated
20.06.2006 in reply to the said letter dated 23.05.2006 of the
respondent no. 3 considered his representation in the following
manner:"On perusal it appeared that you did not submit Sick
Certificate,
ESIC-Med.
II
14.10.2005
and
Memorandum
a
for
the
period
No.
from
dt.
21.10.2005 issued reminding you to either report for
duty or to submit satisfactory cause of absence. But
you failed to do so and after waiting till 11.11.2005
your name was removed from the list of Registered
Badlis as per Clause 5(b)(iii), Rules of Service of the
Company's
Certified
Standing
Orders
vide
Memorandum No. 2 dated 12.11.2005 delivered to
you by Registered post treating the period as
unauthorized absence.”
9.
As the respondent pleaded sickness and informed that he are
suffering from MENTAL DISEASE (SCHIZOPHRENIA), but no where
in the Sick Certificates, it was so mentioned by the attending
Insurance Medical Practitioner, he was asked to produce:(1). Duplicate ESIC Medical Sick certificates for the period
from 14.10.2005 to 11.11.2005.
(2). A Certificate from the attending Medical Officer of
S.S.K.M. Hospital, Kolkata about the nature of his ailment
and the period to declare him Fit at least for the Record of
the company.
10. The respondent no. 3 never informed the company denying the
factum.
11. All on a sudden after a period of about 2 years rendering alleged
dispute nonest and dormant on 18.10.2007, he came to the
Petitioner company's said Jute mills with a so-called Medical
Certificate issued in his favour by the E.S.I. Corporation's Panel
Doctor and made the request to provide him job as earlier.
12. Since his name had been delisted from the badli list of the Jute Mills
with effect from 12.11.2005, there was no scope for the management
to provide the respondent no.3 with any job as earlier on the basis
of the so-called medical certificate and/fit certificate produced by
him on 18.10.2007.
13. The respondent no. 3 then raised an industrial dispute with the
Labour Department, Government of West Bengal, wherein, by a
Letter dated 02.04.2008, the petitioner company submitted its
comments
to
the
Assistant
Labour
Commissioner,
Uluberia
explaining the entire situation of the matter.
14. The petitioner company had made it abundantly clear that the
respondent no. 3 by a letter dated 23.11.2007, was asked to call at
the office of its
Chief Personnel officer, so that necessary
arrangement could be made for taking his attendance and provide
him with the job as and when required as a registered badli. The
respondent no. 3 inspite of receiving the said letter dated
23.11.2007 never reported to the office of the Chief Personnel Officer
of the Petitioner for the reasons best known to him.
15. Although the petitioner company made it absolutely clear before the
Conciliation Officer as well as to the respondent no. 3, he chose not
to report for work and mark his attendance as instructed by the
petitioner company and instead filed a case under Section 10(1B)(d)
of the said Act, against the petitioner before the respondent no. 1.
The said case was registered as Case No. 7 of 2008.
16. By an order no. 8 dated 04.02.2009 following issues were framed:“1. Was the applicant, Seraj Sk. a workman of the
opposite party within the meaning of section 2(s) of
the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947?
2) Whether the name of the concerned workman
firstly struck off from the Master Roll of the
company in the month of Sept, 2005 and has the
O.P. illegally terminated the service of the applicant
by refusing employment w.e.f. 18.10.2007?
3) Is the present case under section 10(1B)(d) of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 maintainable?
4) To what relief, is the applicant entitled?"
17. The parties filed their respective documents before the Labour Court
and the impugned award was passed.
18. Both parties have filed their respective written notes in the present
case along with the judgments relied upon.
19. The following judgments were relied upon by the petitioner in
support of their case:i)
Budge Budge Jute Mills Company Limited vs.
Workmen reported in 1970 (1) LLJ 222 (SC)
wherein it has been held:-
"3. A badli or a special badli is a workman
who is appointed in a vacant post or in the
post of
a permanent workman or a
probationer who is temporarily absent."
ii)
In Lalappa Lingappa vs. Lazmi Vishnu Textile
Mills Limited reported in (1981) 2 SCC 238 has
reiterated
the
concept
of
badly
as
a
workman/workmen who gets work only in the
absence,
temporary
or
otherwise
of
regular
employee (s). They do not have any right to the
post. In fact, they are really casual employees
without any right to be employed. Reference is
also made to Prakash Cotton Mills Pvt. Ltd. vs.
Rashtriya Mills Mazdoor Sangh reported in
(1986) 3 SCC 588.
iii)
Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation
& Anr. vs. S.G. Kotturappa and Anr. reported
in (2005) 3 SCC 409 while discussing the status
of a badly, the Court held as follows:"25. We have noticed hereinbefore the
relevant provisions of the Regulations. The
status of a Badli cannot be better than a
probationer.
If
the
services
of
the
probationer can be terminated for not being
able to complete the period of probation
satisfactorily, there is no reason as to why
the same standard cannot be held to be
applicable in the case of Badli worker."
iv)
In
the
case
of
Bangalore
Metropolitan
Transport Corporation vs. T.V. Anandappa
reported in (2009) 17 SCC 473 at paras 7, 8
and 9, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that a
badli does not have any protection under the
Act.
v)
That an Award passed in favour of a badli
workman
by
the
learned
First
Industrial
Tribunal, West Bengal directing the company to
reinstate him with 75% back wages from the date
of termination till the actual reinstatement in
service came up for consideration before the
Hon'ble High Court, Calcutta in the case of
Gloster Limited & Anr. Vs. State of West
Bengal & Ors. reported in 2013 SCC OnLine
Cal 22994. The Hon'ble Court set aside the
Award placing reliance on the judgment as
aforesaid.
vi)
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Dr.
Jagmittar Sain Bhagat & Ors. vs. Health
Services, Haryana & Ors. reported in (2013)
10 SCC 136 has been pleased to hold that the
findings
of
a
Court
or
Tribunal
becomes
irrelevant and unenforceable/in-executable once
the Forum is found to have no jurisdiction. If the
Court passes a decree without having jurisdiction
over the matter, such issue can be raised at any
stage of the proceedings.
vii)
Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation,
Jaipur vs. Phool Chand (Dead) through legal
representatives reported in (2018) 18 SCC
299.
viii)
Man Mohan Kmar Shahu vs. Union of India &
Ors. reported in 2024 SCC OnLine Cal 10962
para 24.
ix)
General Manager, Electrical Rengali Hydro
Electric Project, Orissa & Ors. vs. Giridhari
Sahu & Ors. reported in (2019) 10 SCC 695
para 45.
x)
M/s. Shree Gouri Shankar Jute Mills Limited
vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors. in WPA
30769 of 2024, this Hon’ble Court placing
reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Bangalore Metropolitan
Transport
Corporation
(Supra)
has
been
pleased to remand the matter with following
directions:-
"....... Learned counsel for the petitioner has
filed a report stating that they are not
necessary party in this case.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that in view of the judgment
relied
upon
the
respondent
no.
admittedly being a 'Badli' worker has
no right under the Industrial Disputes
Act (Bangalore Metropolitan Transport
Corporation (supra).
It appears that at the time of deciding the
prayer of the worker for interim relief, the
Court
did
not
consider
the
point
of
maintainability which was not seriously
agitated by the petitioner herein before the
Tribunal, but as issue of maintainability
goes to the root of every case, the said issue
is to be decided in accordance with law
prior to disposing of the case on merit…...”
xi)
K.K. Parmar & Ors. vs. H.C. of Gujarat
reported in (2006) 5 SCC 789.
xii)
Hooghly Mills Company Limited & Anr. vs.
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner &
Anr. reported in 2006 SCC OnLine Cal 204.
xiii) Ariane Orgachem Private Limited vs. Wyeth
Employees Union & Ors. reported in (2015) 7
SCC 561.
20. The petitioner has challenged the impugned award on the ground
that while granting the relief of reinstatement with back wages to
the private respondent, it has committed serious error in law since
in spite of taking note of the fact that the Private Respondent was a
badli/registered badli never took any venture to decide about its
jurisdiction to exercise its authority and/or jurisdiction to look
into the matter, specially when the Law of the Land as has been
propounded by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as well as this Hon'ble
Court has been pleased to hold that Badli does not have any right
which can be enforced under the said Act of 1947. Nothing could be
shown from the evidence that the private respondent has able to
prove that he had got "continuous service" as defined under
Section 25B of the said Act of 1947. The ratio of the decision of this
Hon'ble Court in the case of Gloster Limited & Anr. (supra) is fully
applicable in the instant case and as such the direction of
reinstatement with back wages of the Private Respondent being a
badli is also non-est in the eye of law committed serious error in law
by not considering that the entitlement to back wages is subject to
discharging of burden which lies on the person concerned to plead
and prove about his absence of gainful employment and/or earning.
Admittedly, the private respondent in his statement of claim never
pleaded about absence of gainful earning employment.
21. Absence of gainful employment vis-à-vis pleading and proving the
same initial burden is on the person concerned in Rajasthan State
Road Transport Corporation, Jaipur (supra).
22. Back wages is not an automatic relief in Man Mohan Kumar
Shahu (supra).
23. Learned counsel for the respondent no. 3/workman on filing
written notes has stated that the respondent no.3, workman was
employed by the company and started working from 18.01.1990
being L.B. No.3361 as weaving sadar, and rendered his service
continuously up to April, 2004 with full satisfaction.
24. Thereafter the respondent after recovery from the injury went to
resume his duty on 18.10.2007, at the time of resuming his duty he
had produced the fit certificate which was issued by the concerned
ESIC Authority on 15.10.2007.
25. It is further stated that the learned labour Court on the point of
240 days observed “there is no pleading that since 1990 the
applicant never worked for 240 days in a year”. There is no
pleading by the writ petitioner that the respondent no. 3 did not
work for 240 days in twelve months immediately preceding the date
of termination of service.
26. The respondent no. 3 has relied upon the following judgments:i)
Syed Yakoob vs. K.S. Radhakrishnan & Ors.
1963 SCC OnLine SC 24;
ii)
Delhi
Cloth
and
General
Mills
Ltd.
vs.
Shambhu Nath Mukherji & Ors. (1977) 4 SCC
415;
iii) L. Robert D’Souza vs. Executive Engineer,
Southern Railway & Anr. (1982) 1 SCC 645;
iv)
Naresh Chandra Das vs. Seventh I.T., West
Bengal in Civil Rule No. 4562 (N) of 1977
dated 23rd September, 1981;
v)
Deepali Gundu Surwase vs. Kranti Junior
Adhyapak
Mahavidyalaya
(D.ED)
&
Ors.
(2013) 10 SCC 324;
27. On hearing the learned counsels for the parties and on perusal of
the materials on record more so the impugned award, it appears
that the learned First Labour Court considering the case of the
parties and the evidence of the parties adduced before the said
Labour Court observed as follows:“……….From the reported decision it appears that the
aggrieved party i.e. the WBSEB approached the
Hon’ble Court for quashing certificate in Form-S as
per Rule 12A(3) of the West Bengal Industrial
Disputes Rules 1958 and the Hon'ble
Court also
observed in paragraph No. 48 of the said decision
that aggreived party may invoke the Constitutional
Writ Jurisdiction to ensure compliance of such
statutory duty.
But in the present proceeding the
Opposite Party has not approached before the Hon'ble
Court for quashing the said certificate issued in
favour of the applicant by the Conciliation Officer
regarding pendency of an industrial dispute. This
Court has no power to direct the Conciliation Officer
regarding performance of his duties or to quash the
certificate and for this reason. The Opposite Party has
to knock the doors of Hon’ble Court which has not
been done by the Opposite Party………….
……….Considering all these decisions and the facts
of the present proceeding it appeare that the applicant
deserves his right to defend himself for his absence. It
has already been discussed that the applicant
continuously tried to inform the management about
his illness and as he was unable to go to the office of
the Opposite Party he tried to inform the management
about his absence and illness by sending his
certificate through his representative which were not
accepted sometimes by the Opposite Party. It also
appears from the written statement of the Opposite
party that in paragraph Nos. 19 wherein the Opposite
Party admitted that even after removal of name of the
applicant
he
furnished
necessary
papers
substantiating the fact that from the period 8.1.2005
to 17.10.2007 he was unfit for work due to certified
sickness (page No.16 para No.19). The company also
admitted that due to this reason the Chief Personnel
Officer through his letter dated 23.11.2007 advised
him to report immediately to the said officer. So
considering the entire facts and evidences it appears
that the service of the applicant was terminated
arbitrarily and unjustifiedly and so he is to get back
his service and it also appears from the conduct and
Letters of Opposite Party that it admitted that the
applicant is entitled to be reinstated in his same
position………..”
28. Finally, the First Labour Court relying upon several decisions held
as follows:“……The applicant joined the Opposite Party in the
year 1990 and since then he had worked for the
Opposite Party and admittedly he was a registered
badli. He lost his job and remained unemployed for in
the entire period. It is not pleaded that he did not
get job on all the days of a year. So considering
the entire facts and circumstances of this proceeding
in my view the applicant is entitled to get of his back
wages with consequential benefits from the date of
termination of his service till the date of actual
reinstatement.
Under such circumstances the applicant is entitled to
be reinstated in service under the Opposite Party and
is to get full back wages and consequential benefits
from the date of termination of his service till the date
of actual reinstatement.
The Opposite Party is directed to reinstate the
applicant immediately and to pay him full back
wages with consequential benefits immediately……..”
29. The learned tribunal in the impugned award, also held that the
worker was employed as ‘Badli’ from January, 1990 till April 2004.
He was under medical treatment from January, 2001 till October
2007.
30. Admittedly
the
worker
did
not
produce
any
documents
of
employment. He only produced the medical papers and some
communication.
31. Section 25D of the Industrial Disputes Act, lays down:“25D. Duty of an employer to maintain muster-rolls
of workmen.- Notwithstanding that workmen in any
industrial establishment have been laid-off, it shall be the
duty of every employer to maintain for the purposes of
this Chapter a muster-roll, and to provide for the making
of entries therein by workmen who may present
themselves for work at the establishment at the
appointed time during normal working hours.”
32. In Ranbir Singh vs S.K. Roy, Chairman, Life Insurance, in Misc.
Application No. 1150 of 2019, decided on 27 April, 2022, the
Supreme Court held:“………..25. It is settled principle of law that
while considering the order/judgment of
Constitutional Court, this Tribunal is required to
keep in mind entire spectrum of the orders as
well as background of the case. It is not proper
to cull out a single para or a sentence from the
order/judgment so as to defeat the very purpose
of the order so passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court. If the orders dated 11/5/2018,
7/9/2018 and 10/9/2018 are taken into
consideration, it is crystal clear that claims of all
such workmen and Union/s who worked as
Badli workers during the period from
20/5/1985 to 4/3/1991 are required to be
considered by this Tribunal. Although I am in full
agreement with the submission made on behalf
of the PART B Management/LIC that initial
onus is always upon the workmen
concerned to prove that they were in the
employment of the Management at the
relevant time, however this Tribunal cannot
ignore the fact that UC has not filed on
record any document/record relating to
employment of various workmen rather has
simply taken a plea that same being old
record is not traceable.” 22 The Dogra Report
noted that LIC had admitted that 321 workers
were found to be eligible for absorption in terms
of the Srivastav Award. The report found fault
with LIC for making contradictory claims that
321 workers were eligible for absorption when
the records of workers were allegedly old and
not traceable. The Dogra Report drew an
adverse inference against LIC for having
failed to maintain the records in pursuance
of the burden cast upon it by Section 25D of the ID Act, particularly when the reference
was pending since 1991. Paragraph 29 of the
report is extracted below:
“29) During the course of arguments as well as
in the reply filed on behalf of the
Management/LIC, it is clear that Management
has admitted that till date 321 Nos. of
employees were found to be eligible in terms of
the Award and they were considered eligible for
absorption. It is not understandable to this
Tribunal as to what were the basis for the
Management/LIC for coming to the conclusion
that only 321 Nos. of workmen/employees were
found to be eligible and covered by the Award of
CGIT in ID case No.27/1991, when the
Management has come up with a plea that
record relating to the workmen being old record
is not traceable. It is worthwhile to mention
here that Section 25-D of the ID Act
specifically provides that it is the duty of
every Employer to maintain a muster roll
and to provide for the making of entries
therein by the workmen who may present
themselves for work at the establishment.
This Tribunal has to keep in mind a vital fact
that since the reference bearing ID No.27/1991
is pending before various Courts since 1991, the
Management/LIC was/is required to keep
the record in safe custody when the case of
such a huge magnitude was PART B
pending before the Courts. In such
circumstances, this Tribunal is constrained
to draw adverse inference against the
management.” 23 Based on the above
hypothesis, the report proceeded to decide
“prima facie” the claims of the Unions and
individual workers. While taking up the claims
made by the All India Life Insurance Employees
Association and its affiliate, Life Insurance
Employees Association, Delhi, the report notes
that 6998 claims had been filed (as contained in
Annexure A). Upon scrutiny, LIC drew the
attention of the CGIT to the fact that 3592
duplicate entries were found in the claims which
were submitted (as contained in Annexure A-1).
Noting that the “Unions have not seriously
disputed the same”, the Dogra Report concludes
that “such claimants are to be given benefit of
absorption only once”. The Dogra Report also
notes that workers who had started working
beyond the cut-off date of 4 March 1991 would
not be covered in the enquiry. This observation
in the Dogra Report was in view of the order of
this Court in the contempt proceedings arising
out of the review of TN Terminated Employees
Association (supra) on 7 September 2018, which
had specifically observed that whether the
benefit of the Srivastav Award should be given
to those who had been engaged as badli
workers after 4 March 1991 was a matter for
interpretation by this Court. Hence, for the time
being, CGIT had been directed to limit its enquiry
only to the claims for the period between 20 May
1985 and 4 March 1991 (as contained in
Annexure A-2). In this context, the Dogra Report
held that those workers who had commenced
work after 4 March 1991 would not be covered
by its enquiry……….”
33. The petitioner has placed copies of documents including the
workman’s service records, before this Court but it appears that
they were not placed before the labour Court, which passed the
impugned order.
34. The argument of the petitioner that a ‘badli’ is not a ‘workman’
and cannot sustain proceeding under the I.D. Act has no
substance in view of the inclusive definition of ‘workman’ under
2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act. The case before the tribunal
is thus maintainable.
35. Regarding the prayer for reinstatement and back wages.
36. The learned tribunal observed as to continuous service of the
‘worker’ as follows:“…….. there is no pleading that the applicant never
worked for 240 days immediately proceeding termination
and no document has been placed to show the same and
neither
there
is
any
cross
examination
nor
any
suggestion given to P.W.-1…………
…………… It appears also from the evidence of Opposite
Party that they have never denied the continuous service
of the applicant since 1990 and admitted that though he
was appointed as a Weaver later on he was posted as
their Line Sardar and there is no allegations against him
about his remaining absent from the duties……..”
37. In Gloster Limited & Anr. vs State of West Bengal & Ors., in
W.P. No. 17363(W) of 2013, decided on 24 July, 2013, the
Calcutta High Court held:“…………..It would be noticed that Section 25C of the Act
excludes the Badli or Casual Workman for claiming a
right of compensation in case of lay off. The explanation
appended thereto defines the Badli Workman as a
Workman
who is employed in an Industrial
Establishment in the place of another workman whose
name is included on the master role of the establishment
but shall cease to be regarded as such, for the purpose of
the said Section if he has completed one year continuous
service in the establishment. The Badli Workman has
not been excluded under Section 25F of the Act,
which requires certain conditions to be adhered
and/or followed for retrenchment of the workman.
The conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions would
lead to inevitably conclusion that in the event, the Badli
Worker has completed one year of continuous service in
the establishment, he would cease to be so and cannot be
retrenched unless the conditions embodied under Section
25F of the said Act is adhere to. The continuous service
should be considered in the light of Section 25B which
provides that the workman should render service of 240
days preceding the date with reference to which the
calculation is to be made……………….
…………….In view of the law as enunciated in the above
noted cases, what could be culled out is that the Badli
Workers are working in absence of a regular employees
and are really a casual workman or a probationer
without any right to be employed unless, they come
within the purview of the continuous service as defined
under Section 25B of the ID Act.
It leads to another point whether the respondent no. 4
has been able to establish that he has rendered
continuous service for 240 days in a year preceding to
the date with reference to which the calculation is to be
made. It also imbibes within itself the ancillary point
relating to the discharge of the onus…………..”
38. Considering the said facts on record, this Court finds that the
‘continuous’ service of the worker herein as badli was neither denied
nor was any document produced before the First Labour Court,
Kolkata to show that the worker herein has not put in 240 days in a
year for period employed.
39. Thus the badli worker herein being employed in ‘continuous service’
falls within the definition of ‘worker’ and as such can take recourse
to the industrial dispute Act, the case being maintainable before the
labour Court.
40. As the worker herein had put in continuous service, the petitioner
should have followed the rules of the Act of 1947 being Section 25(F)
when discontinuing with the service of the worker.
41. The termination was thus bad and the labour Court rightly decided
the issues, vide the impugned order dated 15.05.2012 passed by the
First Labour Court, Kolkata, which thus does not calls for any
interference.
42. Writ application is dismissed.
43. Applications,
if
any,
connected
thereto
stand
disposed
of
consequently.
44. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
45. Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be given to
the parties on priority basis upon compliance of all formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review