The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. 01.2016, the same was disposed of by directing the respondents to consider the representations dated 01.10.2015 & 06.10.2025 submitted by the petitioners to examine whether they would be entitled to any compensation and the same to be decided within a period of 2(two) months. [8] In compliance of the directions of this Court in order dated
20. 01.2016, the Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Manipur issued the impugned order dated 01.12.2017 rejecting the representations submitted by the petitioners. While passing the impugned order, the Chief Engineer considered the report dated 08.09.2016 submitted by the D.C., Ukhrul to the effect that the list of 455 beneficiaries was prepared in the year 2012 after proper verification conducted by the joint team comprising Village Authorities headed by the Headman/ Chairman, SDO Phungyar, the representatives of D.C. and IFCD at the Village and the said joint verification was conducted after wide publication in the local newspapers. [9] It is stated that the names of the petitioners were not found in the list of 455 beneficiaries and their claim arose for the first time in the last part of 2015. The relevant portions of the report dated 08.09.2016 of the DC, Ukhrul is reproduced below:“Whereas, the Deputy Commissioner Ukhrul District submitted its report to the Commissioner IFC vide Office Letter No. 10/99/2016-Rev (Ukl) dated 8.9.2016 with the following information/ findings:"List of beneficiaries numbering 455 (four hundred fifty five) which were reportedly genuine affected families for granting WP(C) No. 94 of 2018 Rehabilitation & Resettlement package was submitted to the government in the year 2012 after proper verification conducted by a Joint team comprising Villag…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
1. Ms. Meryta Mahong, aged about 40 years old, D/o Willson Mahong, a
permanent resident of Chadong Village, Ukhrul District, Manipur at
present residing at S.P. Colony, Chingmeirong, Imphal East, Manipur.
2. Smt. Marynah Kashung, aged about 53 years old, W/o (Late) Ks.
Theingai, a resident of Chadong Village, Ukhrul District, Manipur at
present residing at Paomei Colony, Imphal East, Manipur
… Petitioners
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur through the Additional Chief Secretary (Water
Resources), Govt. of Manipur.
2. The Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Manipur.
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Kamjong District, Manipur at present
stationed at the Office of the Tribal Development Department, Manipur
near Telephone Office.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners :
Mr. N. Jotendro, Sr. Adv. &
Md. Syed Murtaza Ahmed, Adv.
For the respondents :
Mr. Th. Sukumar, Govt. Adv.
Date of reserved
08.07.2025
:
Date of Judgement :
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
11.07.2025
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Jotendro, learned sr. counsel assisted by Md.
Syed Murtaza Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. Th.
Sukumar, learned GA for the State respondents.
[2]
By the present petition, the petitioners are praying for
quashing and setting aside the impugned order dated 01.12.2017 passed
by the Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Manipur rejecting
the representations dated 01.10.2015 & 06.10.2015 submitted by the
petitioners to the Additional Chief Secretary, (Irrigation & Flood Control),
Govt. of Manipur and the Deputy Commissioner, Ukhrul, Manipur
requesting for granting rehabilitation and resettlement package for
Chadong village.
[3]
It is the case of the petitioners that after their divorce, they
have been staying in the Chadong village in the year 1955 and 2003
respectively in respect of petitioner nos. 1 & 2.
[4]
It is stated that their names have been left out from the list
of beneficiaries prepared by the respondents and as such, they did not get
any compensation for their lands and houses submerged by the Mapithel
Dam Multipurpose Project.
[5]
It is submitted that since they were not given any notice and
their name were not included in the list of beneficiaries prepared by the
respondents and thus, they were left out from the list of affected 455
beneficiaries and they did not get any compensation for the submerged of
their houses and lands.
[6]
In
this
respect,
the
petitioners
submitted
separate
representations dated 01.10.2015 and 06.10.2015 to the Additional Chief
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
Secretary, (Irrigation & Flood Control), Govt. of Manipur and the Deputy
Commissioner, Ukhrul, Manipur to re-verify their case and with a request
for payment of compensation.
[7]
The petitioners also earlier approached this Court by way of
writ petition being, W.P. (C) No. 11 of 2016 and vide order dated
20.01.2016, the same was disposed of by directing the respondents to
consider the representations dated 01.10.2015 & 06.10.2025 submitted by
the petitioners to examine whether they would be entitled to any
compensation and the same to be decided within a period of 2(two)
months.
[8]
In compliance of the directions of this Court in order dated
20.01.2016, the Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Manipur
issued the impugned order dated 01.12.2017 rejecting the representations
submitted by the petitioners. While passing the impugned order, the Chief
Engineer considered the report dated 08.09.2016 submitted by the D.C.,
Ukhrul to the effect that the list of 455 beneficiaries was prepared in the
year 2012 after proper verification conducted by the joint team comprising
Village Authorities headed by the Headman/ Chairman, SDO Phungyar, the
representatives of D.C. and IFCD at the Village and the said joint
verification was conducted after wide publication in the local newspapers.
[9]
It is stated that the names of the petitioners were not found
in the list of 455 beneficiaries and their claim arose for the first time in
the last part of 2015. The relevant portions of the report dated 08.09.2016
of the DC, Ukhrul is reproduced below:“Whereas, the Deputy Commissioner Ukhrul District submitted its
report to the Commissioner IFC vide Office Letter No. 10/99/2016-Rev (Ukl)
dated 8.9.2016 with the following information/ findings:"List of beneficiaries numbering 455 (four hundred fifty five)
which were reportedly genuine affected families for granting
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
Rehabilitation & Resettlement package was submitted to the
government in the year 2012 after proper verification conducted by a
Joint team comprising Village Authorities headed by the Headman/
Chairman, SDO Phungyar, representative of D.C. and IFCD at the
Village. The said joint verification was conducted after due Notification
were given to the villagers and wide publication in the leading local
News papers. Besides, further opportunities were also given for those
left out families during the joint verification for filing claims and
objections. The genuine list of families to be entitled were forwarded
to the government after completion of all the necessary formalities
and approval given by the Cabinet, payment of Rehabilitation &
Resettlement package have been completed.
The two Petitioners have made their claims in the last part of
2015 whose names were found not appearing in the said list of 455.
In the absence of their names in the final list of beneficiaries for
Rehabilitation & Resettlement package, the request for grant of
Rehabilitation & Resettlement package appears to be not acceptable
on the part of the Government Respondents.
It is, therefore, requested to kindly dispose the representations
dated 01.10.2015 and 06.10.2015 of the Petitioners, so as to comply
the order of the Hon'ble High Court at your ends."
[10]
Being aggrieved by the impugned order, the petitioners
approached this Court that their names were wrongly left out from the list
of 455 beneficiaries as no notice was issued to them. Since they are
resident of the affected village, they are also entitled to the benefits given
to the other affected families. It is requested that their representations
dated 01.10.2015 & 06.10.2015 be re-considered.
[11]
The State respondents filed counter affidavit stating that a
joint verification was conducted by a team comprising of village authority
headed by the Headman/ Chairman, SDO Phungyar, representative of D.C.
and IFCD. In para 4, it is stated that the verification was conducted after
due Notification were given to the villagers and wide publication in the
local newspapers. Further opportunities were also given for those left out
families during joint verification process for filing claims and objections.
However, the names of the petitioners are not found in the genuine list of
the families who are entitled for the compensation. And, as such, they are
not entitled to any relief.
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
[12]
It is also stated that in para no. 7 of the counter affidavit,
the petitioners are not resident of the Chadong village, and therefore they
are not entitled to receive a sum of Rs. 14,70,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs
seventy thousand) as claimed.
[13]
It is prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed being
devoid of any merit and the prayer being belated.
[14]
The petitioners also filed rejoinder affidavit to the counter
affidavit filed by respondent and stated that the petitioners could not
appear for the joint verification as they were threatened by some unknown
persons and it is reiterated that since they are residents of the affected
village, they are entitled to the petitioners. The petitioners also filed
additional affidavit bringing on records, certain documents such as,
Domicile Certificate, Permanent Residential Certificate.
[15]
During the course of hearing, the learned sr. counsel for the
petitioners has clarified that the petitioners could not appear before the
joint verification as they were threatened by some unknown persons and
in fact, they are inhabitants of the affected village and are entitled to the
benefits given to the 455 affected families.
[16]
It is also submitted that the petitioners being divorcees, the
State respondent ought to have sympathetic view to the representations
submitted by the petitioners. It is prayed that the respondents may be
directed to re-consider their representations afresh.
[17]
On the other hand, the learned GA for the State respondents
submits that the list of 455 beneficiaries were prepared by a joint team of
the Village Headman/ Chairman, SDO Phungyar, the representatives of DC
and IFCD and the same was conducted after wide publication and left over
families were also permitted to make their representations during the joint
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
verification. It is pointed out that the petitioners have miserably failed to
produce any complaint or document to show alleged threatening by some
unknown persons for participating in the joint verification.
[18]
It is also stated that any other persons were not threatened
by miscreants and such plea of threatened by unknown persons is an afterthought and without any basis. The plea of not issuing any notices cannot
be sustained as the petitioners were aware of the date of joint verification
but their inability to appear before the team was due to alleged threat by
some unknown persons. It is pointed out that claim of the petitioners are
belated and without any basis and the writ petition may be rejected.
[19]
This Court has considered the materials on records and
submissions made at the bar. The plea of the petitioners is that there are
also inhabitants of the affected village of Mapithel Dam Multipurpose
Project area and their houses and lands have been submerged and hence,
they are also entitled to get the benefits given to the 455 affected families
prepared by the respondents. Since their names were not in the list of
affected villagers prepared by the respondents, they were not given any
benefits as compensation for their submerged houses and lands. The
reasons given for inability to appear before the joint verification team was
due to the alleged threat by some unknown persons.
[20]
This Court has perused the report dated 08.09.2016
submitted by the DC, Ukhrul which has been extensively reproduced in the
impugned order dated 01.12.2017. It appears from the report of the DC,
Ukhrul that a joint verification was conducted in the year 2012 by a joint
team of comprising Village authorities headed by the Headman/ Chairman,
SDO Phunyar, the representative of D.C. and IFCD and 455 beneficiaries
were identified as affected by the Mapithel Dam Multipurpose Project.
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
[21]
It is also stated that the report was prepared after joint
verification was conducted. For this purpose, wide publication in the local
newspapers was issued and after proper verification the compensation was
given to the 455 affected families.
[22]
It is the case of the petitioners that the petitioner no. 1 has
been staying in the affected village since 1955 and the petitioner no. 2
since 2003. If that be so, they should have appeared before the verification
Committee in the year 2012. In absence of any document of threat to the
petitioners, the plea of their inability to appear before the joint verification
team cannot be accepted. It may be noted that other 455 families did not
face any threat as alleged by the petitioners.
[23]
In the circumstances, the belated plea of the petitioners
cannot be considered and from the report of the Deputy Commissioner,
Ukhrul, it cannot be established that they are also affected families.
[24]
Accordingly, this Court does not find any merit in the writ
petition and the same is dismissed. No cost.
signed
OINAM Digitally
by OINAM
MEITEI
THOIBA THOIBA
Date:
MEITEI 2025.07.11
10:44:33 +05'30'
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Thoiba
WP(C) No. 94 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review