Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.737/2023
1. Merry Debbarma, wife of Sri Subodh Debbarma, resident of village-Joy Ram
Kobra Para, P.O.-Ramchandranagar, P.S.-Bodhjungnagar, District:-West
Tripura, Pin:-799008, Age-31.
2. Amal Debbarma, son of Late Sukuram Debbarma, resident of village-Birbal
Para, P.O.-Ramchandranagar, P.S.-Bodhjungnagar, District:-West Tripura,
Pin:-799008, Age-32.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Department of Law and Parliamentary Affairs, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital
Complex, Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
2. The District & Sessions Judge, North Tripura Judicial District (Chairman of
the Selection Committee), Dharmanagar, P.O. & P.S.-Dharmanagar, DistrictNorth Tripura.
3. Sri Chiranjit Tripura, son of Krishna Mohan Tripura, resident of villageNorth Ichachara, P.O.-Debdaru, P.S.-Baikhora, District-South Tripura, Pin799141.
4. Sri Koushal Chakma, son of Tarun Chakma, resident of village and P.O.Mainama, P.S.-Chailengta, District-Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 14th December, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners and Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondent No.1-State.
2.
Petitioners participated in a recruitment process under the
advertisement dated 05.04.2021 for recruitment to 50 number of posts of Peon/
Orderly/Guard etc. (Group-D) on regular pay scale basis and 48 number of
vacant posts of Peon/Orderly/Guard etc. (Group-D) on fixed pay basis
(totalling 98 posts) under the Sub-ordinate Judiciary of Tripura conducted by
the District & Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar. The selection
process was twofold, (i) written test (of 75 marks); and (ii) viva voce test (for
25 marks). 75 marks allotted to written test was further bifurcated into three
parts, viz. (i) Letter writing (of 25 marks); (ii) Handwriting test (of 25 marks);
and (iii) G.K. & Current Affairs (of 25 marks). Petitioners appeared in the
written test on 05.12.2021 on conclusion whereof call letters were issued
asking the shortlisted candidates to appear in the viva voce test. The viva voce
test was held between 10.12.2022 to 18.12.2022. The Final Common Merit List
was published on 17.01.2023 which was computed on the basis of the marks
obtained in the written test as well as the viva voce test.
3.
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, learned counsel for the petitioners,
submits that the petitioners though being very hopeful and confident could not
find their names in the Final Merit List out of 125 selected candidates. Under
RTI, petitioner No.1 Merry Debbarma sought for supply of the relevant select
list of all the candidates including the marks obtained by them in the written
test and viva voce test. The Public Information Officer [Civil Judge (Jr.
Division), North Tripura, Dharmanagar] through letter dated 30.03.2023
supplied a copy of the select list (Annexure-4). The breakup of the selected
candidates in each category has been tabulated under paragraph-2.12. Noticing
the variance in the marks of the first candidate in the selected candidates under
the ST category and the last candidate, petitioners have borne a reasonable
apprehension that why they were not selected. They sought supply of copies of
their respective answer sheets and information regarding breakup of their
respective marks as awarded in the written test and viva voce test. Petitioner
Merry Debbarma found that in the written test, she had scored 39 marks
whereas she got only 3 marks in the viva voce test, totalling 42 marks. The
written examination was for 75 marks and the viva voce examination was for
25 marks. Petitioner No.2 Amal Debbarma found from his answer sheets that
he had scored 34 marks in the written test whereas he got only 6 marks in the
viva voce test, totalling 40 marks.
4.
Petitioners on scrutiny of their answer sheets supplied by the
Public Information Officer found that in the handwriting test, they had been
awarded very meager and negligible marks despite the fact that they had
actually attempted and performed very well in the same. Question No.2, in
particular, required Bengali and English Handwriting of the precis piece
indicated therein. According to the petitioner Merry Debbarma, there were no
spelling mistakes in the Bengali Handwriting which was also very neat, nice
and legible. However, she was awarded only 4 marks out of 12.5 marks.
Similarly, in the English Handwriting part, there were no spelling mistakes and
the handwriting was very neat, nice and legible, but she was erroneously
awarded only 4 marks out of 12.5 marks. Similarly, in respect of petitioner
No.2 Amal Debbarma in the Bengali Handwriting though there was only one
spelling mistake and the handwriting was very neat, nice and legible, he was
erroneously awarded only 4 marks out of 12.5 and in English Handwriting
though there were no spelling mistakes and the handwriting was neat, nice and
legible, he was awarded only 5 marks in Bengali out of 12.5. Had the
evaluation been properly made, they could have scored higher and come into
the category of successful candidates. Both the petitioners, therefore, have an
apprehension that the evaluation has not been fairly made. As such, the
petitioners have prayed for direction upon the official respondents to appoint an
independent Expert Body to re-scrutiny and re-check the respective answer
sheets of the petitioners. They have also prayed for quashing the impugned
Final Merit List dated 17.01.2023 and impugned select list (Annexure-3 and 4
respectively). Petitioners have also sought a direction upon the official
respondents to award higher marks to the petitioners in the concerned written
test as well as in the viva voce test.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that, therefore, the
respondents may be called upon to respond to the categorical assertions
regarding improper evaluation of the answer sheets of the petitioners, in
particular, the answer to Question No.2 which related to Bengali and English
Handwriting. Learned counsel for the petitioners has sought to make good his
point by referring to relevant answers to Question No.2 obtained under RTI
being part of the pleadings. Learned counsel for the petitioners, in support of
his submission, has relied upon the decision of the Apex Court in the case of
Registrar General, High Court of Delhi vrs. Ravinder Singh reported in 2023
LiveLaw (SC) 553.
6.
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondent No.1-State, submits that the principles as regards
reevaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet are now well settled by the Apex
Court. He has relied upon the decision rendered by the Apex Court in the case
of Ran Vijay Singh and others vrs. State of Uttar Pradesh and others reported
in (2018) 2 SCC 357 and submitted that this Court should not re-evaluate or
scrutinize the answer sheets of the petitioners since it has no expertise in the
matter. The academic matters are best left to academics. The petitioners have
failed to demonstrate that a material error has been committed in the
evaluation process.
7.
This Court has given anxious consideration to the submission of
the petitioners and also taken note of the pleadings placed from the record. The
principles in respect of evaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet have been
well settled by virtue of decisions rendered by the Apex Court which have been
summarized in the case of Ran Vijay Singh (supra) at paragraphs-30 and 31
which are extracted hereunder:
"30. The law on the subject is therefore, quite clear and we only
propose to highlight a few significant conclusions. They are:
30.1. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
permits the re-evaluation of an answer sheet or scrutiny of an answer
sheet as a matter of right, then the authority conducting the examination
may permit it;
30.2. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
does not permit re-evaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet (as distinct
from prohibiting it) then the court may permit re-evaluation or scrutiny
only if it is demonstrated very clearly, without any “inferential process
of reasoning or by a process of rationalisation” and only in rare or
exceptional cases that a material error has been committed;
30.3. The court should not at all re-evaluate or scrutinise the
answer sheets of a candidate—it has no expertise in the matter and
academic matters are best left to academics;
30.4. The court should presume the correctness of the key
answers and proceed on that assumption; and
30.5. In the event of a doubt, the benefit should go to the
examination authority rather than to the candidate.
31. On our part we may add that sympathy or compassion does
not play any role in the matter of directing or not directing re-evaluation
of an answer sheet. If an error is committed by the examination
authority, the complete body of candidates suffers. The entire
examination process does not deserve to be derailed only because some
candidates are disappointed or dissatisfied or perceive some injustice
having been caused to them by an erroneous question or an erroneous
answer. All candidates suffer equally, though some might suffer more
but that cannot be helped since mathematical precision is not always
possible. This Court has shown one way out of an impasse — exclude
the suspect or offending question."
8.
Petitioners have not referred to any rule which permits
reevaluation of the answer sheets under the advertisement in question as a
matter of right. Petitioners, in fact, have by inferential process of reasoning
tried to draw this Court into evaluation of the answers transcribed by the
petitioners which relate to Question No.2 both in Bengali and English. It is not
a case that the answer to this question both in Bengali and English have not
been evaluated at all. Both the petitioners have been allotted (4+4) and (4+5)
marks respectively by the examiner. This Court does not have the expertise to
sit as an expert in evaluation of an answer sheet and substitute the evaluation
undertaken by the examiner. The adoption of a particular approach to
evaluation by an examiner cannot be subjected to judicial scrutiny in case of
the present petitioners if the allotment of marks are not up to the expectations
of the concerned candidate. As observed above, it is not a case of no evaluation
of the answer sheets of the petitioners regarding Question No.2. The petitioners
have not been able to point out such material error which makes out a rare or
exceptional case. Petitioners, in fact, have through an inferential process of
reasoning or rationalization sought to invite the Court to evaluate the marking
on the answer sheet by the examiner against Question No.2. In the absence of
any mala fide or demonstrable rare and exceptional case, this Court should not
direct reevaluation of an answer sheet as sympathy or compassion does not
play any role in such matters. The illuminating opinion of the Apex Court in
the case of Ran Vijay Singh (supra) do require Courts exercising the powers of
judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to exercise
restrain in interference in such matters.
9.
Having regard to the facts and circumstances noted above and the
reasons recorded and in view of the principles laid down by the Apex Court in
the case of Ran Vijay Singh (supra), this Court does not find any merit to
entertain this writ petition. The principles laid down in case of Ran Vijay
Singh have been followed in Ravinder Singh (supra) cited by the learned
counsel for petitioners.
10.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also shall stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
2023.12.18
PULAK BANIK Date:
18:15:01 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review