Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC040009242023
2026:GAU-AP:1004-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRL.A(J)/22/2023
Mekhya Paffa W/o Late Jotin Paffa,
Resident of Vill Changya, PO/PS Khenwa, Dist. East Kameng, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP Represented by the PP, AP
2:Gama Paffa Age: 0 Occupation :
Son of Late Jotin Paffa Village Changya PO and PS Khenewa
East Kameng District Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner : Nikita Danggen, Amicus Curiae
Advocate for the Respondent : P P of AP, Dicky Panging, Sr. Adv,Amicus Curiae
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
Advocate for the appellant
: Ms. N. Danggen, amicus curiae
Advocate for the respondents
: Ms. T. Jini, Addl. PP
Mr. D. Panging, Sr. Adv
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 23.07.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 24.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of operative part of the judgment?: NA
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced?: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER[CAV]
(Budi Habung, J.)
Heard Ms. Nikita Danggen, learned amicus curiae appearing on behalf
of the appellant. Also heard Ms. Topi Jini, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor,
Arunachal Pradesh, appearing on behalf of the respondent.
Page No.# 2/15
2.
This jail appeal has been preferred by the appellant Smti. Mekhya
Paffa, from jail under Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, against the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
03.05.2023 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Bomdila in Sessions
Case No. 14/2022 arising out of Khenewa P.S. Case No. 01/2022 whereby
the appellant was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life and to pay a
fine of Rs. 10,000/-, in default thereof, to undergo simple imprisonment for
3 months.
3.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that during the intervening night of
08-09.07.2022, the deceased, Jotin Paffa, was found lying inside his house
with several cut and stab injuries. The appellant, who was his wife, was
found standing inside the house, holding dao in her hand.
4.
The First Information Report (FIR) was lodged by their son, PW-7 Shri
Gama Paffa. He was not present at the place of occurrence. During
investigation, the police seized:- (1). One iron dao(machete) with plastic
handle[approx. 2 feet length]; (2). one iron dao[machete] with black tube
handle[approx. 3 feet length]; and (3). One iron spearhead[approx. 5 feet
length]; from the place of occurrence.
5.
The post-mortem examination disclosed multiple injuries over the
forehead, parietal region, chest, knee, neck and hip. The Doctor opined
that the death of the deceased was due to head injury causing subdural
hematoma leading to cardio-palmary arrest and that the death was
homicidal.
6.
The prosecution examined as many as 9(nine) witnesses. However,
none of them claimed to have actually seen the appellant inflicting fatal
injuries upon the deceased, but they being the neighbours, have arrived at
Page No.# 3/15
the place of occurrence immediately after the alleged occurrence of the
incident upon hearing the crying sound of the deceased.
7.
Upon consideration of the evidence and on hearing the parties,
particularly, the presence of the appellant inside the house with a dao
immediately after the neighbours had reached there, the presence of the
deceased with multiple injuries and the absence of any other person inside
the house except the deceased and the appellant, held the appellant had
caused the death of the deceased. The learned trial Court rejected the plea
of the appellant under Section 84 of Indian Penal Code, 1860. The main
ground for rejection is that there was no medical document showing mental
illness of the appellant and that she had been found fit to police custody
immediately after her arrest.
8.
The learned amicus curiae for the appellant submitted that the
conviction of the appellant is based entirely upon circumstantial evidence
and that none of the prosecution witnesses had seen the appellant
assaulting the deceased. The learned amicus curiae further submitted that
when the prosecution witnesses arrived at the house of the deceased, the
door was found open. The learned amicus curiae argued that had the
appellant actually planned to murder her husband, why would she keep the
door open for public view to the commission of the alleged crime. The
learned amicus curiae further submitted that the injuries found by the
Doctor is not supported by the forensic evidence. She further submits that
at the time of the occurrence of the incident, the appellant was mentally
not stable and that the prosecution evidence itself contains material
circumstances suggesting that the appellant had a history of mental illness.
In this regard, the learned amicus curiae submitted that on earlier occasion
also, the appellant had attacked her husband while suffering from such
mental illness. It is also submitted that the prosecution failed to establish
Page No.# 4/15
the complete chain of circumstances and thus failed to establish the
requisite mental intention/mens rea for commission of the alleged offence
under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
9.
The learned Addl. Public Prosecutor, Arunachal Pradesh, on the other
hand, has submitted that the appellant was found inside the closed house
immediately after the occurrence of the incident holding a dao while the
deceased was lying there with multiple injuries. It is further submitted that
after hearing the cries of the deceased, the prosecution witnesses who are
the neighbours, entered into the house of the appellant and found the door
of the bedroom closed. However, when they broke open the door, they saw
the appellant standing near the body of the deceased holding a dao in her
hand and tried to assault them as well. It is also submitted that there was
no other person present inside the house other than the appellant. The
learned Addl. Public Prosecutor, Arunachal Pradesh, further submitted that
all the circumstances clearly point towards the appellant for commission of
the alleged offence and none other. She further submitted that the plea of
insanity was not proved by any medical evidence. Even in her examination
under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the appellant
failed to explain as to why she was standing beside the body of the
deceased holding a dao in her hand when the prosecution witnesses
entered her house and if she is not the one who killed her husband, then,
who else did it. It is also not the appellant’s pleaded case that she neither
remembered the incident nor pleaded insanity at the time of the occurrence
of the incident. The appellant only evasively denied all allegations stating
that the same was not true and that she did not kill her deceased husband.
There is absolutely no indication of any other person entering the house
prior to or during the incident and no explanation why she was holding dao
and standing near the body of the deceased.
Page No.# 5/15
10.
Upon hearing the rival submissions advanced by the learned counsel
for the parties and the materials available on record; the following
questions arises for consideration:
(i).
Whether the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt
that the appellant caused the death of the deceased Jotin Paffa?
(ii). Whether the circumstances proved by the prosecution form a
complete chain of circumstances inconsistent with the innocence
of the appellant?
(iii). Whether the evidence on record raises a reasonable doubt
regarding the mental illness of the appellant at the time of the
occurrence of the incident so as to entitle her to the benefit of
Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860? or, in any event, to
the benefit of reasonable doubt?
11.
The investigating officer of the case i.e. PW-9 held inquest and found
the dead body lying on the bedroom on the floor of the chang ghar. The
investigating officer found multiple sharp cut injuries on head and chest of
the dead body. He recorded that the cause of the death was due to
excessive bleeding and recommended for post-mortem examination.
12.
PW-1,
Dr.
Tage
Tagyang,
who
conducted
the
post-mortem
examination, found the following injuries on the body of the deceased:
“2-Wounds-position, size and character:
1. Longitudinal cut injuries forehand measuring 5 X 3 cm²
2. Multiple cut injuries left parietal region (3 x 3 cm²) (2 x 3 cm²)
3. Stab wound right chest 1/2 inch.
4. Stab wound lateral aspect of left knee 1/2 inch.
5. Superficial cut injury left neck 8 cm.
6. Superficial cut injury left hip.”
“1-Scalp, Skull, vertebrae:
1. Multiple cut marks present in scalp as described above. Alongwith
Page No.# 6/15
scalp skull was cut through and exposed.”
“2-Membrane - Membrane perforated at frontal region.”
“3-Brain and spinal cord - Hematoma present in subdural space”
“MORE DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF INJURY OR DISEASE:
1. Longitudinal cut injury forehead measuring 5 X 3 cm²
2. Multiple cut injuries left parietal region (3 X 3 cm²) & (2 x 3 cm²)
3. Stab wound right chest 1/2 inch.
4. Stab wound lateral aspect of left knee 1½ inch.
5. Superficial cut injury left neck 8 cm i.e. length.
6. Superficial cut injury left hip 2 cm in length.
“OPINION OF SUB-ASSISTANT SURGEON AS TO CAUSE OF DEATH:
In my opinion, the most probable cause of death is head injury causing
subdural Hematoma leading cardio-palmary arrest.”
13. Thus, the Doctor/PW-1 found multiple cut and stab injuries and opined
that the cause of the death was head injury resulting in subdural
hematoma leading to cardio-palmary arrest. There was no serious dispute
that the death of the deceased was homicidal. Therefore, the factum of
homicidal death is sufficiently established. However, the medical evidence
does not establish that the injuries were necessarily inflicted by the
particular dao or spearhead seized from the place of occurrence. The
Doctor has not identified the weapon of offence which caused the injuries.
There is also no evidence on record demonstrating a forensic connection
between
the
seized
weapons
and
the
injuries.
However,
these
circumstances by itself, may not be sufficient to discard the prosecution
case. Recovery or forensic linkage of the weapons seized from the place of
occurrence is not an indispensable requirement where there is otherwise
reliable ocular evidence.
14. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in such case has held that non-recovery or
lack of proof regarding the weapon does not by itself defeat the prosecution
supported by trustworthy direct evidence. However, in the present case, as
stated above, there is no direct prosecution witness who claimed to have
Page No.# 7/15
seen the appellant assaulting the deceased.
15.
PW-3 Smti. Deepa Paffa is the neighbour whose house is just nearby
the house of the appellant and the deceased. On the intervening night, she
heard some unnatural sound of the deceased. She informed the same to
her brother PW-4. However, she admittedly did not enter the house of the
appellant and did not see the appellant assaulting the deceased.
16.
PW-4 Shri Karling Paffa reached the house of the appellant after
being informed by the PW-3. He stated that the appellant had already killed
the deceased. He further stated that he had seen several injury marks on
the body of the deceased and blood was oozing out. However, in his crossexamination, PW-4 stated that he did not see the act of the appellant killing
the deceased.
17.
PW-5 Smti. Fem Paffa, after hearing the cries of the deceased, rushed
to the house of the appellant along with her husband PW-4. Her evidence is
that after entering the house of the appellant, she saw the door of the
bedroom was closed from inside. She further stated that they have
forcefully opened the door and on entering the house of the appellant, she
saw the appellant holding a dao in her hand and thereafter, she tried to
attack them, however, her husband overpowered and snatched away the
dao from the appellant’s possession and threw it in the house and later on,
tied the appellant. However, in her cross-examination, she stated that she
did not see the appellant assaulting the deceased.
18.
PW-6 Smti. Ayang Paffa, likewise, went to the house of the appellant
and saw that the appellant had already injured the deceased. She also has
seen several cut injury marks on face, neck and body of the deceased and
blood was oozing out. She further stated that the deceased was about to
die but he was not able to speak. She also stated that the appellant tried to
Page No.# 8/15
attack them with a dao but they overpowered and tied her. In her crossexamination, she stated that she did not see the appellant killing the
deceased.
19. The settled principle is that in a case based on circumstantial evidence,
each circumstance must be firmly established and all the circumstances
must form a complete chain which points only towards the guilt of the
accused and excludes reasonable hypothesis consistent with the innocence
of the accused.
20.
In
the
present
case,
certain
circumstances
are
undoubtedly
established. The circumstantial chain is quite strong. From the evidence of
the
prosecution
witnesses,
following
circumstances
are
cumulatively
established:
(i).
The
neighbours
heard
the
cries/suspicious
sounds
and
immediately reached their house.
(ii). The deceased and the appellant were the only persons found
inside the house when the prosecution witnesses reached their
house immediately after the occurrence of the incident.
(iii). The occurrence took place inside their local/OBT house during the
intervening night.
(iv). According to the PW-5, the door was found closed from inside
and had to be forcefully opened.
(v).
The learned trial Court accepted these circumstances. Even if
there were some discrepancies about the door, it does not
materially break the chain.
(vi). On entering the house, the prosecution witnesses found the
appellant holding a dao. The appellant attempted to assault
Page No.# 9/15
them. This is a highly incriminating circumstance because it
shows that she was not merely an innocent person present at
the crime scene at the relevant point of time. However, the
appellant
was
overpowered
and
tied
by
the
prosecution
witnesses. Her husband was lying inside the bedroom with
multiple severe stab injuries and was profusely bleeding. The
injuries were homicidal and included a major head injury
causing subdural haematoma leading to cardio-palmary arrest.
(vii). The weapon of offence i.e. dao/machete and a spearhead was
recovered and seized from the place of occurrence. There was
no evidence of any other person having entered the house
immediately before and at the time of the occurrence of the
incident.
(viii). As per the evidence of PW-9, the deceased was alive for some
time after the assault and according to the prosecution
witnesses, he told those present at the crime scene that his wife
had assaulted him while he was sleeping. There is evidence that
the appellant had on earlier occasion also, attacked the
deceased.
(ix). The investigating officer of the case PW-9 deposed and stated
that the appellant had disclosed that she suspected her
deceased husband of having extra-marital relationship and
although such relationship was not found, but, it provides a
plausible background for the occurrence of the incident.
(x). Most importantly, when the incriminating circumstances were put
to the appellant in her examination under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, she simply denied them and
Page No.# 10/15
gave no alternative explanation whatsoever.
21.
Upon examination, it appears that this is a classic case of
circumstantial evidence. The prosecution does not have to prove the
murder through an eye-witness if the circumstances form a complete chain.
In the present case, the circumstance is not merely for the fact that the
appellant was present in the house but it is a case where the appellant was
found inside the house with the deceased. Immediately, after hearing the
cries of the deceased, the neighbours entered the house and she was found
holding a dao and attempted to attack them. The deceased was found
inside the same bedroom with multiple cut injuries and profusely bleeding.
Not only that, the weapons of offence which was snatched from the
appellant’s hand were recovered and seized from the place of occurrence.
Besides that, there was no any other person found present in the house
other than the appellant and the deceased. Moreover, there is no plausible
explanation from the appellant in her examination under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, as to how her husband sustained those
injuries why she was standing beside the body holding dao on her hand.
The
above
circumstances
established
a
very
powerful
chain
of
circumstances indicating towards the appellant for commission of the
alleged offence.
22.
Section 6 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872(corresponding to Section 4
of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023), provides relevancy of facts
forming the part of same transaction. Section 6, being relevant, is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“6. Relevancy of facts forming part of same transaction. -Facts which,
though not in issue, are so connected with a fact in issue or a relevant
fact as to form part of the same transaction, are relevant, whether they
occurred at the same time and place or at different times and places.”
Page No.# 11/15
23.
Facts which, though not in issue, are so connected with a fact in issue
or a relevant fact as to form part of the same transaction, are relevant,
whether they occurred at the same time and place, or, at different times or
places. Once, the prosecution establishes the foundational circumstances
showing that the deceased was killed inside a dwelling house occupied by
the appellant and the deceased and the appellant was found there,
immediately, thereafter in possession of the weapon of offence and
behaving aggressively the manner in which the deceased received those
injuries, becomes a fact particularly within the appellant’s knowledge.
24.
It is to be noted that in her examination under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the appellant was specifically asked and
her answer was basically “I do not know” and “I have not killed my
husband”. This statement is a bare denial. The appellant did not say or care
to explain that if somebody else entered the house; there was an
accidental injury; the deceased attacked her and the injuries resulted
during her struggle; another person assaulted the deceased; the appellant
found the deceased already injured; or, any other circumstances explaining
the injuries sustained by the deceased.
25. It is understood that her silence cannot prove guilt, but, when
the prosecution chain of circumstantial evidence is otherwise complete, the
absence of any reasonable explanation is an additional incriminating
circumstance.
26. Coming to the next issue “mental illness”, PW-6, in her crossexamination,
stated
that
sometimes,
the
accused
used
to
behave unnaturally as if she had some mental illness. The PW-7, who is
the son of the appellant, stated that the appellant might have did the
same as she was suffering from mental illness. He further stated that
Page No.# 12/15
earlier his mother had attacked his father when she was suffering from
mental illness. PW-8, who has seen injury marks on the deceased, also, in
his cross-examination stated that it may be the reason that the accused
was
suffering
from
mental
illness
when
she
attacked the
deceased. However, the alleged mental illness does not automatically
entitle her to acquittal. The above PW-6, PW-7 and PW-8 have given
evidence suggesting that the accused sometimes behaved abnormally and
had earlier attacked her husband, but, it does not establish that at the
precise time of the occurrence of the incident, the appellant was incapable
of knowing the nature of the act, or, that she was doing what was either
wrong, or, contrary to law.
27.
It is seen that there is no medical record establishing such incapacity.
There is no expert evidence indicating her insanity. There is also no
evidence that the appellant was under treatment for a mental illness at any
point of time. There is also no evidence that the appellant was continuously
incapable of understanding her actions. There is also no evidence that the
appellant did not know what she was doing immediately after the
occurrence. In
fact,
her
conduct
immediately
after
the
assault
is
significant. The appellant was found holding the dao and attempted to
assault the neighbours who entered the house. However, the appellant was
thereafter overpowered and tied. The conduct of the appellant can
reasonably be regarded as a conscious conduct. Such conduct is not
conclusive by itself that it was a conscious conduct of the appellant, but, it
substantially weakens the plea that she was incapable of knowing the
nature of her act at the time of incident. Likewise, her medical examination
immediately after her arrest, shows that she was fit to be kept in custody,
is not proof of sanity, but it is certainly a circumstance which the appellate
court can consider along with the rest of the evidence.
Page No.# 13/15
28.
Coming to the question if there was any motive of the commission of
the alleged offence, the prosecution need not prove motive when the other
evidence is convincing. Therefore, the fact that the alleged adultery was
not subsequently proved, does not destroy the prosecution case. In the
present
case,
the
investigating
officer/PW-9
stated
that
during
interrogation, the appellant disclosed that she killed her husband because
she suspected him of having an extra-marital affair but the investigating
officer admitted that he did not find any such extra-marital relationship of
the deceased.
29.
In the present case, the nature and number of injuries sustained by
the deceased support the prosecution case under Section 302 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860. The medical evidence shows a cut injury on the
forehead, multiple cut injuries on the left parietal region, stab wounds on
the right chest and left knee, and superficial cut injuries on the left neck
and left hip. The fatal injury was on the head. The use of a dao/spear-type
weapon on the head and chest, causing multiple serious injuries, shows
that the assailant had knowledge that such injuries were likely to cause
death of the deceased. The nature of the injuries also indicates the
intention to cause death or such bodily injury as was sufficient in the
ordinary course of nature to cause death. This is, therefore, not a case
where the offence can be treated merely as culpable homicide not
amounting to murder. The prosecution has established a complete chain of
circumstances. Once such a chain is established, the failure of the appellant
to explain the presence of the deceased inside the house with such injuries,
particularly when she was found immediately thereafter holding the weapon
of offence, assumes significance under Section 106 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872.
30. In the circumstances, we are of the opinion that the prosecution has
Page No.# 14/15
proved beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was murdered inside
the house. The appellant was found there immediately thereafter, holding
the dao, and attempted to assault the persons who entered the house. She
has offered no explanation for the fatal injuries suffered by the deceased.
These circumstances form a complete chain and exclude the reasonable
possibility of any other person having committed the offence.
31. On an overall consideration of the evidence on record, we find that the
prosecution has been able to establish the homicidal death of deceased
Jotin Paffa. The prosecution has also established, beyond reasonable doubt,
that the appellant was the person responsible for causing death of her
deceased husband. We find that the circumstances proved by the
prosecution are consistent with the guilt of the appellant and inconsistent
with any reasonable hypothesis of her innocence. The fact that there is no
eyewitness to the actual assault is, in the facts and circumstances of the
present case, not sufficient to discard the prosecution case.
32. We are also not persuaded by the plea of insanity under Section 84 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The evidence regarding the appellant’s
previous abnormal behaviour or alleged mental illness does not establish
that, at the time of the occurrence, she was incapable of knowing the
nature of her act or that what she was doing was wrong or contrary to law.
In order to bring the case within the exception under Section 84 IPC, the
burden lies with the defence. However, the defence failed to discharged the
necessary burden. The evidence regarding her conduct immediately after
the occurrence, particularly her being found holding the dao and attempting
to assault the persons who entered the house, further does not support the
plea of legal insanity.
33. The learned Sessions Judge has, therefore, rightly appreciated the
Page No.# 15/15
evidence and convicted the appellant under Section 302 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860. We find no perversity, illegality or material error in the
impugned judgment warranting interference by this Court. The sentence
imposed upon the appellant is also in accordance with law.
34. Accordingly, the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
03.05.2023 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Bomdila in Sessions
Case No. 14/2022 arising out of Khenewa P.S. Case No. 01/2022,
convicting the appellant under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
and sentencing her to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life and to pay a
fine of Rs.10,000/-, in default whereof to undergo simple imprisonment for
three months, are hereby affirmed.
35. Consequently, the jail appeal is dismissed.
36. The appellant shall continue to remain in custody to serve out the
sentence imposed upon her. The period of detention already undergone by
her shall be set-off in accordance with law.
37. Let a copy of this judgment along with the records of the learned trial
Court be returned.
38. Before parting with the matter, we record our appreciation for the
assistance rendered by the learned Amicus Curiae appearing for the
appellant. The learned Amicus Curiae shall be entitled to the prescribed
legal remuneration.
Bikashkonwar, Private Secretary
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review