Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) 696/2021
Megha Technical and Engineer Private Limited, A company incorporated
under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 having its marketing office
at C/O R.K. Udyog, Near Ginger Hotel, Khejur Bagan, Agartala, Tripura
and its registered office at Lumshnong, P.O. Khaliehriat, District- East
Jaintia Hills, Meghalaya and in the present proceedings represented by Sri
Sanjib Kumar Saharia, the authorized signatory of the petitioner company.
---- Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary, Government of
Tripura, Agartala, New Civil Secretariat, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital
Complex (NCC), District- West Tripura, PIN- 799006.
2. The Commissioner State Taxes, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
3. Superintendent of State Taxes, Agartala, Charge-V, Agartala, Tripura
(West), 799001.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Dr. Ashok Saraf, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Baruah, Advocate
Mr. Kousik Roy, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Dey, Additional GA
Date of hearing and delivery :
14.03.2023
of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
14/03/2023
(T. Amarnath Goud, ACJ)
Heard Mr. Ashok Saraf, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P.
Baruah, learned counsel and Mr. Kousik Roy, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner as well as Mr. K. Dey, learned Additional GA, appearing on
behalf of the respondents.
Page 2
2.
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the
impugned show cause notice dated 21.05.2020 (Annexure V to the writ
petition) and order dated 10.12.2020 (Annexure II to the writ petition) issued
under Section 70(1) of the Tripura VAT Act, 2004 by the respondent no. 2
herein.
3.
Briefly stated, the petitioner submitted its returns under TVAT Act,
2004 for the assessment years 2015-16, 2016-17 and 2017-18 (upto June,
2017). The petitioners being insisted by the assessing authority had paid
advance tax in the month of March and the assessment was completed by
respondent no. 3 vide order of assessment dated 03.05.2019 for the
assessment years 2015-16 to 2017-18 under Section 31 of the TVAT Act,
2004 and it was recorded that the petitioner had paid Rs. 33,32,202/- as
excess tax amount for the assessment year 2016-17 and a part of the same
was adjusted against the tax liability for the year 2017-18. The further case
of the petitioner is that after adjustment of the amount of tax refundable for
the assessment year 2016-17, the total amount refundable to the petitioner
was Rs. 30,25,031/-. Accordingly, the petitioner prayed for refund of the
excess amount paid, but he received a notice dated 10.12.2020 from
respondent no. 2 in exercise of power under Section 70(1) of the Act
wherein it was stated that the petitioner had made excess payment of tax to
the tune of Rs. 30,25,031/-. The petitioner submitted his reply dated
11.06.2020, and on receipt of the same, respondent no. 2 issued the
impugned notice dated 21.05.2020 upon the petitioner
Page 3
4.
During arguments, Dr. Saraf, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner has argued that there was no jurisdictional error in completing the
assessment and thus the order dated 03.05.2019 passed by the Commissioner
of Taxes is absolutely illegal. Learned senior counsel has further submitted
that the Commissioner of Taxes without assuming jurisdiction under Section
70(1) of the Act the order has been passed. Learned senior counsel has
further submitted that there is no error in the original assessment done by the
assessing officer. Learned senior counsel has also submitted that there was
no prejudicial to the interest of the State Revenue. Learned senior counsel
has lastly urged this court to set aside the impugned show-cause notice dated
21.05.2020 and the impugned order dated 10.12.2020 passed by the
respondent no. 2.
5.
Learned Additional GA has submitted that the show-cause notice
dated 21.05.2020 and the order dated 10.12.2020 passed by the respondent
no. 2 are not illegal and the same had been passed within the ambit of law.
6.
Considered the submission of learned counsel appearing for the
parties. We have also perused the record.
7.
From the Assessment Order dated 03.05.2019 issued by the respondent
no. 3, it is evident that the petitioner has paid tax for the year 2017-18 (upto
30.06.2017) to the tune of Rs. 33,32,202/-. The computation is reproduced
here-in-below:
Page 4
“COMPUTATION
Assessment Years
Rate of Tax
T.O.R.
Turnover accepted
Tax payable
Interest U/s 25(1)
Penalty U/s 25(3)
Penalty U/s 25(4)(d)
Total Payable
Tax Paid
Balance Due
Say
8.
2015-16
14.5%
184348033.08
184348033.08
26730464.80
1567.68
227.2
10000
26742259.68
2,67,30,461.00
11798.68
11799
2016-17
14.5%
652525503
652525503
94616197.94
94616597.94
9,46,16,204.00
393.93
2017-18 (upto 30.06.17)
14.5%
2117040
2117040
306970.80
307170.80
3332202
-3025031.20
3025031 (Excess)
From the record, it is evident that, as per assessment dated 03.05.2019
for the assessment years 2015-16 to 2017-18 (upto 30.06.2017), the
respondent no. 3 confirmed that the petitioner has paid excess tax amounting
to Rs. 33,32,202/- for the assessment year 2016-17 and a part of which was
adjusted against tax liability for the year 2017-18 and after adjustment the
amount of tax refundable for the assessment year 2016-17 against the tax
liability for the assessment year 2017-18 amounting to Rs. 3,06,971/-, the
respondent no. 3 determined the total amount refundable to the petitioner was
amounting to Rs. 30,25,031/-. Thereafter, the petitioner has submitted an
application on 07.02.2020 to the respondent no. 2 wherein he prayed for
initiating a refund process of the excess tax paid amount to Rs. 30,25,031/- for
the assessment year 2017-18 (upto 30.06.2017) and release the amount in his
favour.
9.
On 21.05.2020, the respondent no. 2 had issued a show-cause notice
upon the petitioner asking him to appear in-person or by authorized
representative and explain as to why suitable order shall not be passed which
Page 5
may include enhancing or modifying/cancelling the assessment order dated
03.05.2019 passed by the respondent no. 3 herein, since as per respondent no.
2 the assessment order dated 03.05.2019 for the year 2017-18 (upto June,
2017) is prejudicial to the interest of State revenue. The order dated
21.05.2020, is reproduced here-in-below:
“ORDER
21.05.2020
Whereas, the assessment of M/s Megha Technical & Engineers Pvt. Ltd. C/O K.R. Udyog,
Near Ginger Hotel, Khejur Bagan, Agartala, Tripura for 2015-16, 2016-17 & 2017-18 (upto
June, 2017) was completed by the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V, Agartala on
03.05.2019
AND
2. Whereas, the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V, Agartala assessed the dealer under
section 31 of the TVAT Act, 2004 for the years 2015-16, 2016-17 & 2017-18 (upto June, 2017)
and raising demand Rs. 11,799/- & Rs. 394/- for the eyar 2015-16 & 2016-17 respectively and
determined excess tax paid Rs. 30,25,031/- for the year 2017-18 (upto June, 2017)
AND
3. Whereas, the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V, Agartala on the said assessment order
has mentioned that the dealer has made excess tax payment of Rs. 30,25,031/- for the year
2017-18 (upto June, 2017) and the dealer subsequently submitted an application for refund
of the said amount of Rs. 30,25,031/AND
4. Whereas, in the assessment order of the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V, Agartala as
per return and payment statement for the year 2017-18 total tax payable and paid for that
year is Rs. 3,06,971/- but as per computation tax paid amount is shown as Rs. 33,32,202/and the payable amount remained unchanged and it is deduced that the tax payer has made
excess payment of tax to the tune of Rs. 30,25,031/5. Whereas, it was also observed that the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V, Agartala has
not obtained authorization of the person representing the dealer in the process of
assessment and has merely relied upon the claim of the representative that he is the
Accountant of the dealer
6. Whereas, on the basis of above facts and circumstances, it appears that the assessment
order dated 03.05.2019 for the year 2017-18 (upto June, 2017) is erroneous in so far as it is
prejudicial to the interest of state revenue
7. Now, therefore, in exercise of the power conferred upon me U/S 70(1) of the TVAT Act,
2004, the dealer is hereby asked to appear in person or by his authorized representative
before the undersigned on the date and time given below and to explain as to why suitable
order shall not be passed which may include order of enhancing or modifying the
assessment or cancelling the aforesaid assessment order dated 03.05.2019 passed by the
Assessing Authority, the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V, Agartala for the assessment
year 2017-18 (upto June, 2017) with direction for fresh assessment.
To 25.06.2020 at 12.05 P.M. for hearing.”
10.
On receipt of the said notice dated 21.05.2020, the petitioner has
submitted his reply on 11.06.2020 to the respondent no. 2 wherein the
Page 6
petitioner has prayed for refund of the amount of Rs. 30,25,031 as excess tax
paid for the assessment year 2017-18 (upto June, 2017). Surprisingly, without
addressing the grievance of the petitioner and without giving any opportunity
to the petitioner of being heard personally, the respondent no. 2 under section
70(1) of the TVAT Act, 2004, had passed an order on 10.12.2020 observing
that the petitioner has made excess payment during 2016-17 and there was no
payment of tax during 2017-18 (upto June, 2017) but the same has not
reflected clearly in the assessment order dated 03.05.2019. Considering the
case from all aspects it is remanded to the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-V,
Agartala for making assessment afresh and to record the tax payment, liability
etc. year wise and to pass a detailed and reasoned order within next 3 (three)
months after providing the dealer reasonable opportunity of being heard.”
10.
Section 70(1) of the TVAT Act 2004 says that the Commissioner may
call for and examine the record of any proceeding under this Act, and if he
considers that any order passed therein by any person appointed under subsection (1) of section 18 to assist him, is erroneous in so far as it is prejudicial
to the interest of the revenue, he may, after giving the dealer or transporter an
opportunity of being heard and after making or causing to be made such
enquiry as he deems necessary, pass such orders thereon as the circumstances
of the case justify, including an order enhancing or modifying the assessment,
or cancelling the assessment and directing a fresh assessment.
11.
The petitioner in his reply has urged the respondent no. 2 to exempt him
or his representative from personal appearance before him since pandemic
Page 7
situation was prevailing causing him huge business loss and sought for release
of the excess amount paid, but the respondent no. 3 acting beyond section
70(1) of the Act has passed the suo motu order without any proper explanation
or without indicating any error in the assessment of the assessing authority.
Moreover, the respondent no. 2, acting as revisional authority without
verifying the records had passed a non-speaking order so as to establish that
the respondent no. 2 is not convinced with the assessment order.
12.
In the case in hand, we are of the considered view that there is no
jurisdictional error in the assessment of the assessing authority, and
accordingly, the respondent no. 2 has acted beyond section 70(1) of the Act.
This casual approach of the respondent no. 2 cannot be permitted since he is
trying only to prevent the payment of refund amount to the petitioner.
13.
The respondent authorities acting as quasi judiciary authority by
invoking the power under statute are expected to act judiciously, but they are
not expected to work as money generating authority. Very often it is noticed
by this court that the orders are passed by the respondent authorities in an
arbitrary manner which is driving the Tax-payers/dealers to file appeals by
depositing 50% of the disputed tax while filing statutory appeals. But for the
casual approach of the respondent-authorities, a Tax-payer/dealer cannot be
put to hardship. Such action of the respondent-authorities cannot be
appreciated. The impugned order dated 21.05.2020 is due of its nature. This is
nothing else, but a burden on the business class. This court finds that the
officers need to be more vigilant and tax-payers friendly. Accordingly, a cost
Page 8
of Rs. 25,000/- is imposed upon the revisional authority, and the said amount
to be paid from his salary to the credit of Tripura High Court Bar Association
for passing such orders.
14.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands allowed of in terms of the above
observations and directions. Consequently, the notice dated 21.05.2020
(Annexure V to the writ petition) and order dated 10.12.2020 (Annexure II to
the writ petition) issued by the respondent no. 2 stand set-aside. Pending
application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
15.
The Revisional Authority to pay the cost to the account of Tripura
High Court Bar Association within 1 (one) month from today. Copy of this
order be communicated to the President of the Bar Association.
JUDGE
Saikat
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review