Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 27TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MACA NO. 2838 OF 2018
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 13.03.2018 IN OP(MV) NO.917 OF
2016 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, PALAKKAD
APPELLANT/2ND RESPONDENT:
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD.
MANGALAM TOWERS, T.B.ROAD, PALAKKAD - 678 014,
REPRESENTED BY ITS LEGAL CLAIMS MANAGER,
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD., ERNAKULAM.
BY ADV
SRI. TAPAS VARMA A.
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS:
MEENAKSHY AMMAL
AGED 80 YEARS, W/O.KRISHNA THEVAR,
CHEENICODE KALAM, CHATHAMANGALAM POST,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 673 601.
UMAPARVATHY,
AGED 47 YEARS, W/O.CHANDRAN, CHEENICODE KALAM,
CHATHAMANGALAM POST, PALAKKAD DISTRICT-673 601.
SHYAM,
AGED 22 YEARS,S/O.CHANDRAN, CHEENICODE KALAM,
CHATHAMANGALAM POST, PALAKKAD DISTRICT-673 601.
SAJITH,
AGED 20 YEARS,S/O.CHANDRAN, CHEENICODE KALAM,
CHATHAMANGALAM POST, PALAKKAD DISTRICT-673 601.
BY ADV
SRI.BABY MATHEW
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 18.03.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.3984/2018, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 27TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MACA NO. 3984 OF 2018
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 13.03.2018 IN OP(MV) NO.917 OF
2016 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, PALAKKAD
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
MEENAKSHY AMMAL.,
AGED 80 YEARS, W/O KRISHNA THEVAR,
UMAPARVATHY,
AGED 47 YEARS, W/O CHANDRAN,
SHYAM,
AGED 22 YEARS, S/O CHANDRAN,
SAJITH,
AGED 20 YEARS, S/O CHANDRAN,
ALL THE APPELLANTS RESIDING AT CHEENICODE KALAM,
CHATHAMANGALAM P.O.,PALAKKAD DISTRICT
BY ADV
SRI. BABY MATHEW
RESPONDENT/2ND RESPONDENT:
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
MANGALAM TOWERS,T.B.ROAD, PALAKKAD - 678 014 (INSURER
OF CAR REG.KL-49/D-5425).
(POLICY NO 2209552311003820)(VALID FROM 11/12/2015 TO
10/12/2016)
BY ADV
SRI. TAPAS VARMA A.
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 18.03.2025, ALONG WITH MACA 2838/2018, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 18th day of March, 2025
The petitioners in O.P.(M.V.) No.917/ 2016 on the file of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Palakkad are the appellants in
MACA No.3984 of 2018. The Respondent No. 2 in the said OP MV is
the appellant in MACA No.2838 of 2018. (For the purpose of
convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as per their rank
before the Tribunal)
2. The O.P. was filed under under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, by the mother, wife and children of the deceased by
name Chandran, who died in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on
25.01.2016. According to the petitioners, on 25.01.2016, at about 6.45
a.m., while the deceased was riding a motorcycle through the public
road, a car having reg. number KL-49-D-5425 driven by the 1 st
Respondent in a rash and negligent manner, dashed against the vehicle
of the deceased and as a result of which he sustained serious injuries
and later on he succumbed to the injuries, on the same day, while under
treatment.
3. The 1st respondent is the owner cum driver and the 2nd
respondent is the insurer of the offending vehicle. According to the
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
petitioners, the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of
the offending vehicle. The quantum of compensation claimed in the
O.P. was Rs.25,00,000/-.
4. The insurance company filed a written statement,
admitting the accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on
the part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
5. The evidence in the case consists of the oral testimony of
PW1 and documentary evidence Exts.A1 to A17. No evidence was
adduced by the respondents.
6.
After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal
found negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle,
awarded a total compensation of Rs.23,87,448/- and directed the
insurer to pay the same.
7. Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by
the Tribunal, the Respondent No.2 preferred MACA 2838 of 2018 and
dissatisfied by the quantum of compensation, petitioners preferred
MACA 3984 of 2018.
8.
Now the point that arises for consideration is the
following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
is just and reasonable?
9. Heard Sri. Tapas Varma A. , the learned Standing Counsel
appearing for the insurance company and Sri. Baby Mathew, the
learned Counsel for the original petitioners.
10. The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid policy
of the offending vehicle are admitted. One of the contentions raised by
the learned counsel for the petitioners is that the tribunal has applied
the split multiplier method for assessing the loss of dependency, which
is against law. Further, he submits that the tribunal was not justified in
deducting half of the pension while fixing the notional income of the
deceased. According to the learned counsel for the petitioners, the
deceased was working as Tracksman in Indian Railway, earning Rs.
42,234/- per month, but the Tribunal fixed his monthly income at
Rs.28,804/-. The learned counsel for the insurer would argue that the
income fixed by the tribunal is reasonable.
11. On the other hand the learned counsel for the 2nd
respondent would argue that the tribunal was not justified in awarding
compensation under the head loss of love and affection, in addition to
the compensation awarded under the head of loss of consortium.
12. From the impugned award itself, it is revealed that the
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
deceased was getting a salary of Rs.21405/- and also Rs.20,829/towards pension. Therefore, the total income from salary and pension
will come to Rs.42,234/-. The tribunal has deducted half of the pension
on the ground that his wife will get half of the pension by way of family
pension.
13.
The learned counsel relied upon the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Maya Singh & Ors. Vs. The Oriental
Insurance Co.Ltd. & Ors., (arising out of SLP (C)No.30398 of 2019)
decided on 07.02.2025, in support of his argument. In the above
decision, the Apex Court at paragraph No.11 held that unless there is
any special reasons, the tribunal will not be justified in applying split
multiplier method in assessing loss of dependency.
In the above
circumstances, in this case, the notional income of the of the deceased
is liable to be taken as Rs.42,234/-. Therefore, his annual income
during the year 2015-16 will come to Rs.5,06,508/- ( 42234 x 12).
14. During the year 2016-17, there was no income tax for the
first 2.5 lakhs and for the income exceeding Rs.2.5 Lakh - upto 5 lakhs,
income tax payable was 10% and for income exceeding 5 Lkahs but
upto 10 lakhs it was 20%. Therefore, the income tax payable by the
deceased for the income of Rs.5,06,808/- was Rs.26,360/-. Therefore,
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
the annual income of the deceased, less the income tax will come to
Rs.4,80,440/-.
Therefore, the monthly income after deducting the
income tax will come to Rs.40,037/-.
15. On the date of accident, the deceased was aged 53 years
and was a permanent employee. Therefore, 15% of the monthly income
is liable to be added towards future prospects, as held in the decision in
National Insurance Co.Ltd v Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the
multiplier to be applied is 11, as held in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport
Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121]. Since the deceased was married who
left behind 4 dependents (mother, wife and two major children).
Therefore, the tribunal has deducted 1/3 of the income towards
personal and living expense.
Law is well settled that even if the
children are major there is no bar for them to claim compensation for
loss of dependency and as such only ¼ income is liable to be deducted
towards personal and living expense, as held in Sarla Verma (supra). In
the above circumstances, the loss of dependency will come to
Rs.45,58,212/- (46042.55 x 12 x11 x 3/4).
16. The Tribunal has awarded Rs.15,000/- towards loss of
estate, Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.40,000/- towards loss
of consortium and Rs.50,000/-towards love and affection. In the light
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
of the decision in Pranay Sethi (supra), the appellants are entitled to get
a consolidated sum of Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses, and the dependents (mother, wife and two
major children) are entitled to get a sum of Rs.40,000/- each towards
loss of consortium, with an increase of 10% in every three years.
Therefore, towards loss of estate and funeral expense they are entitled
to get a sum of Rs.18,150/- each. Towards loss of consortium,
petitioners together are entitled to get a sum of Rs. 1,93,600/- (48,400 x
4).
17. Since compensation for loss of consortium was given,
further compensation for love and affection cannot be granted, in view
of the decision in New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Somwati and
Others, (2020)9 SCC 644. Therefore, the compensation awarded
towards love and affection is to be deducted.
18. Towards the head ‘pain and sufferings’, the Tribunal has
awarded Rs.10,000/-, which according to the learned counsel for the
petitioners, is on the lower side. The deceased died in this case on the
date of the accident. In the above circumstances, I hold that the
compensation awarded towards pain and suffering is on the lower side,
and hence, it is enhanced to Rs.25,000/-
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
19. No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other
heads, as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just
and reasonable.
20. Therefore, the appellants/Petitioners are entitled to get a
total compensation of Rs.48,18,112/-, as modified and recalculated
above and given in the table below, for easy reference:
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Amount awarded
by Tribunal (in
Rs.)
Amount Awarded
in Appeal (in Rs.)
Transport to hospital
4,000
4,000
Damage to clothing and
article
1,000
1,000
Funeral expenses
15,000
18,150
Compensation for loss of
estate
15,000
Loss of consortium
40,000
1,93,600
Compensation for pain and
suffering
10,000
25,000
Loss of love and affection
50,000
Nil
Compensation for loss of
dependency
22,52,448
45,58,212
Total
23,87,448/-
48,18,112/-
18,150
Enhanced Rs.24,30,664/-
21.
In the result, these Appeal are disposed of, and the
insurance company is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.48,18,112/(Rupees Forty eight lakhs eighteen thousand one hundred and twelve
Only), less the amount already deposited, if any, along with interest at
MACA Nos.2838 & 3984 of 2018
2025:KER:25314
the rate ordered by the Tribunal) from the date of the petition till
realisation/deposit, excluding interest for a period of 113 days, the
period of delay in filing the appeal, with proportionate costs in MACA
3984 of 2018, within a period of two months from today. (enhanced
compensation will carry interest @8%).
22.
On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal
shall disburse the entire amount to the petitioners, in the ratio fixed by
the Tribunal, excluding court fee payable, if any, without delay, as per
rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
S.M.K.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review