Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CHONGNUNKI
M GANGTE
Date: 2023.04.18 16:36:00 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.799 of 2016
Md. Wahidur Rahman, aged about 31 years. S/o Md.
Fazur Rahaman, Kwakta Village, P.O & P.S Moirang,
Bishnupur District, Manipur
....Petitioner
-Versus1. The Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of
Home Affairs, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan, New
Delhi – 110001.
2. The Director General of Police, CRPF, Head Quarters,
CGO Complex, New Delhi – 110003.
3. The Dy. Inspector General of Police, CRPF, Pulwama,
Srinagar.
4.
The Inspector General of Police, CRPF, Langjing Group
Centre, Langjing, Imphal, Manipur
….. Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEMBIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner ::
Mr. K. Roshan, Advocate,
For the Respondents::
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI
Mr. Nongdamba, Advocate
Dates of hearing
::
14-03-2023
Date of judgment ::
18-04-2023
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 1
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Heard Mr. K. Roshan, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI assisted
by Mr. Nongdamba, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents.
[1]
The present writ petition had been filed for
quashing and setting aside the orders dated 25-10-2012
imposing punishment of removal from service to the petitioner,
order dated 28-03-2014 rejecting the appeal preferred by the
petitioner against the order of his termination and order dated –
May, 2016 rejecting the revision petition preferred by the
petitioner coupled with a prayer for directing the respondents to
re-instate/take
back
the
petitioner
in
service
with
all
consequential benefits.
[2]
The brief facts of the present case is that, the
petitioner was enlisted in the CRPF on 28-11-2005 as
Constable, General Duty (CT/GD) and after completion of his
basic training at Lidhra Camp, Jalandhar (Punjab), he was taken
on the strength of 183 Bn., CRPF and he performed his duties
as a CRPF personnel till his removal from service w.e.f, 25-102012.
[3]
While
the
petitioner
was
serving
as
CRPF
personnel, the competent authorities of the CRPF carried out a
verification process of the educational certificates in respect of
all forces recruited during the last 5 (five) years including the
case of the petitioner. During the process of verification of the
educational certificates in respect of the petitioner, the Deputy
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 2
Director (Evaluation), National Institute of Open Schooling
(NIOS) wrote a letter dated 27-04-2010 to the Deputy
Commandant (ADM), Office of the DIGP, Group Centre, CRPF,
Srinagar (J & K) stating, inter alia, that the photo copy of the
petitioner’s certificate sent for verification was not genuine and
appeared to be tampered/fake, inasmuch as, the date of birth
recorded in the certificate of the petitioner which was sent for
verification did not match with the date of birth of the petitioner
recorded in the record maintained by the NIOS. In the said
letter, the authorities of the CRPF were also requested to send
the
original
documents
for
any
additional
comments.
Subsequently, after verification of the original mark statement of
the petitioner, the Deputy Director (Evaluation), NIOS sent
another letter dated 18-10-2011 to the Commandant, 183 Bn.
CRPF, stating that the earlier verification report dated 27-042010 in respect of the petitioner was correct as per the record
maintained by the NIOS and that the original document sent for
verification was tampered with.
[4]
On the basis of the verification report sent by the
authorities of the NIOS, a departmental enquiry was initiated
against the petitioner by issuing a memorandum dated 13-022012 framing the following two charges against the petitioner :“Article -1
That force No. 055154391 Sepoy/G.D Mohammad Wahidur Rehmand working on
the post of Sepoy/GD in 183 Battalion and being member of Central reserve Police
force, committed misconduct/misbehavior under section 11 (1) of Central reserve
police force Act, 1949, wherein, the personnel filed fake certificate at the time of
recruitment in C.R.P.F and was recruited. The said certificate was got verified by
the education board in connection with education No. A/04 023913 affiliated with
National MuktaVidyalayShikshaSansthan District TautamBudh Nagar (U.P) and the
certificate filed by the personnel was found fake.
Article – 2
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 3
That at the time of recruitment in the force, your date of birth is 07-02-1985
according to the educational certificate produced by you and your age was 20
years 09 months 21 days but according to the verification report obtained by this
office your date of birth is marked 04-05-1988 and accordingly at the time of
recruitment your age comes to 17 years 5 months 24 days. It appears from it that
for the purpose of recruitment in the force, you depended on false educational
certificate which is punishable offence under Section 11 (1) of C.R.P.F Act, 1949”
[5]
After completion of the departmental enquiry held
against the petitioner and on the basis of the report submitted
by the Enquiry Officer, the Commandant, 183 Bn, CRPF,
Pulwama
issued
an
order
dated
25-10-2010
imposing
punishment of removal from service upon the petitioner w.e.f.,
25-10-2012. Having been aggrieved, the petitioner preferred an
appeal to the DIGP, Group Centre, CRPF, Srinagar (J&K) on
12-11-2012, however, the said appeal was rejected by the
appellate authority by issuing an order dated 28-03-2014.
Having been not satisfied, the petitioner again preferred a
revision petition to the IGP, CRPF, Srinagar Sector, J&K on 2701-2016. The said revision was also dismissed by an order
dated – May, 2016 issued by the IGP, CRPF, Srinagar Sector
(J&K). Having been aggrieved, the petitioner approached this
Court by filing the present writ petition for redressing his
grievance.
[6]
Mr. K. Roshan, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner submitted that the correct date of birth of the petitioner
is 07-02-1985 and not 04-05-1988. The correct date of birth of
the petitioner is recorded in his birth certificate, all his
educational certificates/documents and other official documents.
The learned counsel also submitted that in the identity card
issued to the petitioner by the Regional Director, NIOS, while
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 4
studying Secondary course, his date of birth is recorded as 0702-1985. It has also been submitted that at the time of
declaration of the secondary examination results of NIOS in
2004, the date of birth of the petitioner is recorded as 07-021985. In the original mark statement issued in favor of the
petitioner for passing Secondary School Examination, the
provisional
certificate
for
passing
Secondary
School
Examination and Migration certificate – cum- transfer certificate
issued in favor of the petitioner on 28-07-2004, the correct date
of birth of the petitioner i.e., 07-02-1985 is recorded.
[7]
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submitted that at the time of submitting application forms for the
post of Constable (GD) in CRPF, the petitioner gave his date of
birth as 07-02-1985 and also enclosed a copy of the migration
certificate issued by the NIOS after passing the Secondary
School Examination, the mark statement of passing Secondary
School Examination and his birth certificate, wherein, his date of
birth is recorded as 07-02-1985 and that the petitioner never
make any alteration or tampered with his date of birth. It has
also been submitted that the petitioner simply submitted his
educational certificates/documents issued by the NIOS in
testimony of his educational qualifications and date of birth and
there is no question of making any alteration or tampering with
his date of birth. The learned counsel further submitted that in
the relevant records maintained by the NIOS, the concerned
authorities have wrongly recorded the petitioner’s date of birth
as 04-05-1988 instead of the correct date of birth i.e., 07-021985 and accordingly, at the time of verification process, the
authorities of NIOS gave the report that the mark statement of
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 5
the
petitioner
was
not
original
and
appeared
to
be
tampered/fake. The learned counsel vehemently submitted that
when the petitioner approached the concerned authorities of the
NIOS for correction of his date of birth recorded in the official
records maintained by the NIOS by submitting an application
along with all supporting documents, such as his identity card,
migration certificate, provisional certificate, result of the
secondary examination, birth certificate etc., wherein, the
petitioner’s date of birth is recorded as 07-02-1985, the
authorities of the NIOS corrected the date of birth of the
petitioner wrongly entered in the records maintained by the
NIOS and thereafter, issued a fresh certificate for having pass
the secondary examination held in the month of June, 2004 in
favor of the petitioner on 28-06-2012. The learned counsel
accordingly submitted that the reports given by the Deputy
Director (Evaluation), NIOS on 27-04-2010 and 18-10-2011 at
the time of verification process to the effect that the mark
statement in respect of the petitioner was not genuine and
appeared to be tampered/fake was given on the basis of the
wrong entry of the date of birth of the petitioner in the record
maintained by the institute and not on the basis of any
tampering or alteration made by the petitioner
in his mark
statement and as such, the petitioner cannot be penalized for
the mistake committed by the authorities of the NIOS and he is
entitled to re-instatement in his service along with all
consequential benefits.
[8]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing for the
respondents submitted that keeping in view instances of large
number of enlistment in the CRPF on the basis of fake
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 6
educational certificates and as per existing instructions issued
by the higher authorities, the Group Centre, CRPF, Srinagar
(J&K) carried out verification of educational certificates in
respect of all force personnel recruited during the last five years
including the case of the petitioner. In the said verification
process of his secondary mark statement, the Deputy Director
(Evaluation), NIOS wrote a letter dated 27-04-2010 stating that
the date of birth recorded in the mark statement submitted by
the petitioner and his date of birth recorded in the records
maintained by the institute does not tally and that the said mark
statement of the petitioner appeared to be tampered/fake and
also requesting for sending the original documents for any
additional comments. On the basis of the said letter, the
authorities of the CRPF send the original mark statement of the
petitioner for verification and after carrying out verification
process, the Deputy Direction (Evaluation), NIOS again wrote a
letter dated 18-10-2011 stating that the earlier report sent by
him was correct as per their record and that the original
document sent for verification was tampered with.
[9]
The learned DSGI submitted that on the basis of
such report submitted by the Deputy Director (Evaluation),
NIOS, the authorities of the CRPF took up a departmental
proceeding against the petitioner and after completion of the
departmental proceedings and on the basis of the report
submitted by the Enquiry Officer, the competent authority of the
CRPF issued the impugned orders imposing upon the petitioner
punishment of removal from service w.e.f., 25-10-2012.
[10]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI draw the attention
of this Court to a letter dated 20-05-2013 of the Deputy Director,
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 7
NIOS addressed to the office of the DIGP, CRPF, Srinagar
(South) which reads as under:“E. No: 221.01/4-7/NIOS/SSS/ADM/Corr./2012/1165
Dated 20th May, 2013
To,
Mr. P.P. Pradeep Kumar-21
Office of the Deputy Inspector General of Police,
Central Reserve Police Force,
Srinagar (South)
Jammu & Kashmir-190001
Sub:
Verification of Secondary Marks Statement in respect of MD. Wahidur
Rahman bearing Roll No. A12422240.
Sir,
Kindly refer to your letter no. A. XIII.183/2012-13-EC.III dated 14th March, 2013 of
the subject cited above. It is to inform you that candidate Wahidur Rahman was admitted in
secondary course vide enrolment no. A12422240 (91124202240) in the year 2002 and
passed in the year 2004. Details are as under:1.
At the time of his admission, the candidate filled up admission form wherein he has
indicated/filled up his DOB as 04/05/1988 and in support of this he has given the
documents as required.
2.
Candidate was declared pass in the year 2004 and was awarded certificate
showing his DOB as 04/05/1988.
3.
After a gap of 08 years the candidate applied for correction of his DOB from
04/05/1988 to 07/02/1985 on the basis of original Date of Birth Certificate issued on
dated 27/08/1990 by the Govt. of Manipur.
4.
The case of his correction of his DOB was examined at NIOS Regional center
Guwahati and recommended for correction in DOB.
5.
The Competent Authority of NIOS considered his case of correction in DOB and
approved correction for DOB from 04/05/1988 to 07/02/1985 on the basis of original
Date of Birth certificate issued on dated 27/08/1990.
6.
Accordingly, he was issued revised certificate no:18074 shown his correct DOB on
dated 02/07/2012 and dispatched to our Regional Center, Guwahati.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
(S.K Anand)
Deputy Director”
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 8
[11]
The learned DSGI submitted that taking into
consideration the above quoted letter of the Deputy Director,
NIOS, the authorities of the CRPF rejected the statutory appeal
as well as the revision petition filed by the petitioner and that
there is no ground whatsoever for interfering with the impugned
orders and for granting relief sought for by the petitioner. The
learned DSGI accordingly prays for dismissing the present writ
petition as being devoid of merit.
[12]
I have heard the rival arguments advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties at length and also
carefully examined the materials available on record.
The core issue which needs to be considered by
this Court in the present writ petition is whether there was
actually any alteration or tampering made in the secondary mark
statement of the petitioner especially in respect of the date of
birth of the petitioner or whether the reports of the Deputy
Director (Evaluation), NIOS under his letter dated 27-04-2010
and 18-10-2011 to the effect that the said secondary mark
statement of the petitioner appeared to be tampered/fake was
given only on the basis of the wrong entry of the date of birth of
the petitioner in the records maintained by the authorities of the
NIOS.
[13]
I have carefully examined the identity card of the
petitioner issued by the Regional Director, NIOS while studying
secondary course and in the said identity card, the date of birth
of the petitioner is recorded as 07-02-1985. In the secondary
examination result of the NIOS in respect of the petitioner, his
date of birth is also recorded as 07-02-1985. So also in the
migration certificate and provisional certificate issued on 28-07-
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 9
2004 in favor of the petitioner after passing the secondary
school examination held in the month of June, 2004, the
petitioner’s date of birth is recorded as 07-02-1985. In the
petitioner’s original mark statement of passing the secondary
school examination and in the birth certificate issued in favor of
the petitioner, his date of birth is recorded as 07-02-1985. It is
not the case of the respondents that the petitioner alter or
tamper his date of birth recorded in his original secondary mark
statement or that the said mark statement is not found to be
original. In fact, the case of the respondents is that in the
process of verification of his original mark statement, the
competent authorities had given the report that the date of birth
of the petitioner as recorded in his mark statement does not tally
with the date of birth recorded in the records maintained by the
NIOS and that the authorities of the NIOS has given a report
that the said secondary mark statement of the petitioner was not
genuine and appeared to be tampered/fake. Only on the basis
of such report, the service of the petitioner was terminated.
[14]
On careful examination of the materials available
on record, this Court is of the considered view that at the time of
verification of the secondary mark statement of the petitioner,
the concerned authorities of the NIOS did not take into
consideration the result of the secondary examination held in
the month of June, 2004 wherein, the date of birth of the
petitioner is recorded as 07-02-1985. The authorities also did
not take into consideration the identity card of the petitioner
issued by the Regional Director, NIOS while studying secondary
course, the migration certificate issued on 28-07-2004 after
passing the secondary school examination, the provisional
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 10
certificate of the petitioner issued on 28-07-2004 after passing
the secondary school examination as well as the birth certificate
of the petitioner wherein, the date of birth of the petitioner is
recorded as 07-02-1985. In my considered view, the Deputy
Director (Evaluation),NIOS gave the report under his letters
dated 27-04-2010 and 18-10-2011 that the said secondary mark
statement of the petitioner was not genuine and appeared to be
tampered/fake only on the basis of wrong entry of the date of
birth of the petitioner in the records maintained by the NIOS.
There is also no finding from the authorities to the effect that the
aforesaid identity card of the petitioner, the result sheet of the
secondary school examination of the NIOS held in the month of
June, 2004, the migration certificate issued in favor of the
petitioner on 28-07-2004, the provisional certificate issued in
favor of the petitioner on 28-07-2004, the birth certificate of the
petitioner, wherein the date of birth of the petitioner is recorded
as 07-02-1985, are not genuine and that all these documents
are fake documents.
[15]
In view of the above, this Court came to the
conclusion that the report of the Deputy Director (Evaluation),
NIOS under his letters dated 27-04-2010 and 18-10-2011 was
given only on the basis of the wrong entry of the date of birth of
the petitioner in the records maintained by the NIOS.
It is also on record that the wrong entry of the date
of birth of the petitioner in the records maintained by the NIOS
had also been subsequently corrected by recording the
petitioner’s correct date of birth as 07-02-1985 instead of 04-051988 as reflected in the letter dated 20-05-2013 of the Deputy
Director, NIOS and thereafter, a new mark statement/certificate
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 11
of passing the secondary examination held in the month of
June, 2004 had been issued in favor of the petitioner. After such
correction of the record maintained by the NIOS, especially the
wrong entry of the date of birth of the petitioner, there is actually
no ground to support the claim that the Secondary mark
statement of the petitioner is not genuine and appeared to be
tampered/fake.
[16]
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered
view that the petitioner has been wrongly penalized for no fault
on his part and for the mistake committed by the authorities of
the NIOS. Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that
the penalty imposed upon the petitioner under the impugned
orders is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
[17]
In view of the facts and circumstances of the
present case and for the findings and reasons given herein
above, the present writ petition is disposed of with the following
directions :(i)
The respondents or the concerned authorities of
the CRPF are directed to re-verify the genuineness of the
secondary mark statement of the petitioner with the
concerned authorities of the NIOS or any such authorities
more particularly with reference to the date of birth of the
petitioner by taking into consideration all the relevant
documents of the petitioner and to complete the process
of re-verification within a period of one month from the
date of receipt of a copy of this order.
(ii)
After completion of the re-verification process
within the stipulated period, if it is found that there is no
variance or doubt about the genuineness of the
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 12
secondary mark statement of the petitioner more
particularly, the date of birth of the petitioner, the
impugned orders dated 25-10-2012, 28-03-2014 and –
05, 2016 shall be cancelled and the petitioner shall be reinstated in service immediately w.e.f., the date of his
termination i.e., 25-10-2012 with all consequential service
benefits except back wages.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ
petition is disposed of. Parties are to bear their own cost.
JUDGE
Kim
(FR/NFR)
WP(C) No. 799 of 2016
Page 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review