Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.Rev.P. No.28 of 2025
Md. Thoufik Hossain,
S/O- Md. Narul Ulla,
R/O- Rangamatia, Khedabari
Near Saw Mill, P.S.-Sonamura,
District-Sepahijala, Tripura.
….Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. Smt. Kazi Jasma Begam,
W/O- Md. Thoufik Hossain
2. Miss. Naima Aktar,
D/O- Md. Thoufik Hossain
The respondent No.2 being minor is represented by
Smt. Kazi Jasma Begam (mother)
Both presently residing at: Vill.- Khilpara,
Kalibari, P.S.- R.K. Pur, Udaipur,
District- Gomati, Tripura, P-799114
3. The State of Tripura
….. Respondents.
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Rishiraj Nath, Adv,
Mr. Jilu Rahaman, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.,
Ms. Mampi Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
27.02.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
03.03.2026
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This
criminal
revision
is
filed
challenging
the
judgment and order dated 05.04.2025 passed by Learned
Judge, Family Court, Udaipur, Gomati District in connection
with case No.Cr.Misc.03 of 2022. By the said judgment,
Learned Judge, Family Court has directed the O.P., i.e. the
petitioner
herein
to
pay
Rs.6,000/-
per
month
to
the
respondent-petitioners as maintenance w.e.f. 06.01.2022 i.e.
from the date of filing the petition before the Learned Court.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. R. Nath appearing on
behalf of the petitioner and also heard Learned Counsel, Ms. M.
Chakraborty appearing on behalf of the respondents. Learned
P.P. is also present on behalf of the State-respondent.
03.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner
drawn
the
attention
of
the
Court
the
cross-
examination of PW1 before the Learned Trial Court wherein she
specifically admitted that she filed a case against her husband
vide case No.CR (CC) 13 of 2021, she also stated that she had
withdrawn the names of her husband, daughter and her name
from the family ration card and family register of her husband’s
joint family and included those in her paternal family. She
further stated that she has been residing in the residence of
her father since the year 2016. Thereafter, she also stated that
she did not submit any document as regards the profession of
her husband as driver or as regards his ownership of fisheries
and landed properties or that he was earning Rs.60,000/- per
month.
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
petitioner submitted that the Learned Trial Court at the time of
delivery of judgment did not consider those relevant parts of
evidence before awarding maintenance in favour of the
respondent-petitioners.
He further drawn the attention of the Court referring
Annexure-4 i.e. the copy of judgment in connection with case
No.CR(CC) 13 of 2021, the case which was filed by the
respondent-petitioner No.1 against the present petitioner and
his family members under Section 498A/323/506/34 of IPC
and the said case ended in acquittal in favour of the present
petitioner, but that was not considered by the Learned Trial
Court.
He also drawn the attention of the Court referring
Annexure-5 i.e. the copy of judgment in connection with one
CR (DV) 60 of 2022 filed by the respondent-petitioner No.1
against the husband i.e. the petitioner herein and also referred
para nos.12, 17, 18, 20, 22, 24 and 26 and submitted that by
the said judgment Learned CJM dismissed the application filed
by the petitioner regarding returning back of streedhan
properties. He also submitted that before the Learned Judge,
Family Court the petitioner failed to prove her case by
adducing oral/documentary evidence on record but the Learned
Trial Court did not consider the evidence on record and
ultimately awarded maintenance in favour of the respondentpetitioners for which the same needs to be interfered with.
He further submitted that since the petitioner
herself admitted that she was staying separately from her
husband since the year 2016, in that case in pursuance of
Section 125(4) of Cr.P.C. she was not entitled to get any
maintenance as her case does not cover by the provision of the
aforesaid Section. But the Learned Trial Court at the time of
consideration of the case did not consider all those aspects and
urged for setting aside the judgment of the Learned Trial Court
or alternatively, he urged for remanding back the matter to the
Learned Trial Court for taking fresh evidence. Finally, Learned
Counsel for the petitioner submitted that since the respondentpetitioner No.1 herself withdrawn her from the society of the
present petitioner-husband, so, in view of Section 125(4) of
Cr.P.C. she is not entitled to get any maintenance from her
husband. But Learned Counsel did not press for maintenance
granted in favour of the minor daughter.
05.
The submission of Learned Counsel was countered
by Learned Counsel for the respondent-petitioners, Smt. M.
Chakraborty. In course of her submission, Learned Counsel
stated that in para No.59 of the examination-in-chief inaffidavit filed by the present petitioner-husband, he specifically
admitted that on 14.03.2020 the present petitioner came from
Saudi Arabia and went to Bangalore for the purpose of
treatment of his daughter and stayed Bangalore for two
months
with
the
respondent-petitioner.
Learned
Counsel
further drawn the attention of the Court referring the crossexamination of the present petitioner by the respondents,
wherein, he specifically admitted that he is not paying any
maintenance to his daughter and wife. Further, he admitted
that he did not file any case for restitution of conjugal rights to
bring back his wife. He also admitted that he did not mention
the date, the names of the persons present in the conciliation
meeting, again admitted that he did not submit any document
as regards the withdrawal of the name of his wife from his
family ration card. Further admitted that he did not lodge any
complaint before police or any authority complaining the
alleged illicit relation of his wife as mentioned by him. He
further admitted that he did not submit any document
reflecting that he remitted the sum of Rs.15,00,000/- to
Rs.20,00,000/- to the bank account mentioned in paragraph
No.7 of his examination-in-chief in affidavit.
Learned Counsel further drawn the attention of the
Court the cross-examination of OPW4, Md. Nur Ullaha, who is
the father of the present petitioner and during his crossexamination he specifically stated that his grand-daughter,
Smt. Naima Aktar has a disease in her lips and his son is not
paying any maintenance to his wife and daughter.
Learned Counsel further submitted that in para
No.22 & 23 of the judgment delivered by Learned Trial Court
the entire thing has been discussed in threadbare by the
Learned Court, rather the respondent No.1 was driven out from
her matrimonial home by the present petitioner. Furthermore,
the petitioner by the style of cross-examination could not
discard the evidence on record of the respondent No.1 and as
such there is no merit in the revision petition filed by the
present petitioner and prayed for dismissal of the revision
petition with costs.
06.
Heard both the sides and perused the record of the
Learned Trial Court including the judgment delivered by the
Learned Trial Judge. The respondents as petitioners filed the
petition for granting maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C.
before the Learned Judge, Family Court with the assertions
that the marriage of respondent-petitioner No.1, Kazi Jasma
Begam was held with O.P. Thoufik Hossain on 25.04.2010 as
per Mohammedan rites and customs in the house of the
respondent-petitioner No.1 and at the time of the marriage,
the parents of the respondent No.1 gave a sum of Rs.50,000/in cash along with gold ornaments and other articles. Soon
after the marriage, the respondent-petitioner No.1 and the
present
petitioner-husband
started
residing
together
as
husband and wife and gave birth to a daughter namely, Naima
Aktar, the respondent-petitioner No.2, who was nine years at
the time of filing the case. After the birth of the minor
daughter, the present
petitioner-husband and
his family
members started causing mental cruelty upon the respondentpetitioner No.1 and used to cause physical cruelty also upon
her for bringing money from her residence, i.e. father and in
this regard, on several occasions money was given, but inspite
of payment of money on so many occasions, the respondent
No.1 was driven out from her matrimonial home. In this
regard, conciliation meetings were held but although the
petitioner-husband assured not to cause torture upon the
respondent-petitioner
No.1
but
that
was
continued
and
ultimately on 09.03.2021 the respondent-petitioner No.1 was
again driven out and on 12.06.2021 the present petitionerhusband came to the parental residence of the respondentpetitioner No.1 and created pressure demanding money but as
her parents expressed their inability to make any payment,
then the petitioner-husband misbehaved with the respondentpetitioner No.1 and tried to assault them and left her house
threatening with dire consequences and as no maintenance
was given, so, she was under compulsion to file the petition for
maintenance. The proceeding was contested by the present
petitioner as O.P.-husband denying the assertions, but, he did
not dispute his marriage with the respondent-petitioner No.1
but denied to receive any cash amount, gold ornaments and
other articles. Rather the petitioner-husband took the plea that
after six months of marriage, the respondent-petitioner No.1
stayed in her parental house for six months but as the O.P.
tried to bring her back but she did not come back. Conciliation
meeting took place and she came back to her matrimonial
home. In the meantime, the petitioner-husband went to Saudi
Arab seeking a job on 01.01.2016 and on 01.01.2017 the
petitioner-respondent No.1 again left her matrimonial home
with all her gold ornaments, clothes, furniture and all her
personal belongings. In the month of October, 2017 the
petitioner-husband returned back from Saudi Arabia on leave
for four months and was compelled to reside in the house of
the respondent-petitioner No.1 and by that time, her parents
transferred the ration card of the petitioner-husband to
Khilpara from Melaghar and entered his name in the Family
Register of Khilpara Gram Panchayat and after four months the
O.P.-husband returned to Saudi Arabia but thereafter, the
respondent-petitioner
No.1
never
came
back
to
her
matrimonial home. On 14.03.2020 the petitioner-O.P. returned
from Saudi Arab and went to Bangalore for the purpose of
treatment of daughter and stayed therein for two months with
the respondent-petitioner. After that they returned back to
Tripura and staying at quarantine at Melaghar started residing
together at Udaipur. That time the petitioner-husband noticed
that respondent-petitioner No.1 developed some relation with
some boys when the petitioner informed the matter to his inlaws but they did not pay any heed to that and being
requested she did not stop rather she continued to maintain
her relation with some other boys.
It
was
further
submitted
that
that
petitioner-
husband send maximum of his income in Saudi Arabia to the
bank account of the respondent-petitioner No.1. Thus, he has
spent Rs.15,00,000/- to 20,00,000/-. It was further submitted
that the petitioner-husband constructed a house with kitchen,
toilet etc. in the premises of the house of his parents-in-law at
Khilpara by his own income and as the petitioner lost his job
during
Covid-19
pandemic
and
thus,
he
has
become
unemployed.
However, the Learned Trial Court upon the pleading
of
the
parties
framed
raised
the
following
points
for
determination of the proceeding:
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Whether the petitioner no 1 is the legally
married wife of the OP and the petitioners no
2 is their minor daughter?
Whether the petitioner no 1 has any valid
reason of not staying with the OP?
Whether the petitioners are entitled to get
maintenance?
What should be the quantum of maintenance,
if allowed?
And finally determined the maintenance at the rate
of Rs.6,000/- per month in total i.e. Rs.3,000/- each for each
of the petitioners.
07.
I have also perused the judgment of the Learned
Trial Court below and gone through the record of the Learned
Trial Court including the evidence on record. At the time of
hearing, Learned Counsel for the petitioner tried to draw the
attention of the Court referring the cross-examination part of
the
respondent-petitioner
judgments
against
the
No.1
and
also
referred
respondent-petitioner
No.1
some
and
referring those citations he tried to draw the attention of the
Court that the respondent-petitioner No.1 voluntarily left the
company of her husband and as such she was not entitled to
get any maintenance from her husband, i.e.
the petitioner
herein.
However, after going through the cross-examination
of the petitioner-husband, it appears that during his crossexamination he specifically stated that he did not pay any
maintenance towards the expenses of the petitioners, nor
submitted any petition for restitution of conjugal rights, also he
did not submit any document as regards withdrawal of the
name of his wife from his family ration card. He also did not
lodge any complaint before any police regarding the alleged
illicit relation of his wife, nor he submitted any document
showing that he remitted Rs.15,00,000/- to 20,00,000/- from
Saudi Arabia to the bank account of his wife, i.e. the
respondent-petitioner No.1. Rather his father during his crossexamination as OPW4 very specifically admitted that his son,
i.e. the present petitioner herein has not been paying any
maintenance to his wife and daughter.
From the judgment of the Learned Trial Court it
appears that at the time of delivery of judgment, Learned Trial
Court has considered all these aspects and after considering
the evidence on record decided to allow maintenance in favour
of the respondents. The present petitioner by the style of
cross-examination and also by way of evidence failed to satisfy
the Learned Trial Court that the respondent-petitioner No.1 has
wilfully withdrawn her society from her husband voluntarily to
disallow her petition for maintenance under Section 125(4) of
Cr.P.C. and since the petitioner-husband himself on oath
before
the
Court
admitted
that
he
is
not
paying
any
maintenance to his wife and daughter and rather in his
examination-in-chief he admitted that he stayed with the
respondent-petitioner
No.1
at
Bangalore
at
the
time
of
treatment of his daughter, so, it appears that he has failed to
adduce any cogent evidence on record to disbelieve the
evidence of his wife, i.e. the respondent-petitioner No.1 herein.
08.
Furthermore, in a proceeding under Section 125 of
Cr.P.C. Court is to decide whether there is any refusal or
neglect on the part of the husband to pay maintenance to his
wife and children or not, which in my considered view, Learned
Trial Court has rightly considered and decided in this case.
09.
Situated thus, I do not find any irregularity or
impropriety in the order passed by Learned Trial Court dated
05.04.2025 in connection with case No.Cr.Misc.No.03 of 2022
and as such the same does not call for any interference and
furthermore, Learned Trial Court considering the evidence on
record rightly awarded Rs.6,000/- as maintenance in favour of
the
respondent-petitioners.
Admittedly,
the
respondent-
petitioners before the Learned Trial Court could not produce
and prove any documentary evidence on record regarding the
monthly
income
of
the
petitioner-husband.
However,
considering all aspects Learned Trial Court in my considered
view has rightly determined the amount of maintenance in
favour of the respondent-petitioners which is also reasonable
and furthermore, the petitioner is able-bodied and is legally
bound to provide maintenance to the respondents.
10.
In the result, the petition filed by the present
petitioner bears no merit for interference and as such the
revision petition filed by the petitioner stands rejected being
devoid of merit. The order dated 05.04.2025 passed by
Learned Judge, Family Court in Cr. Misc.No.03 of 2022 is
accordingly
stands
uphold
and
affirmed.
The
petitioner-
husband is asked to pay the maintenance as ordered by the
Learned Trial Court in favour of the respondent-petitioners to
prevent them from any sort of hardship and sufferings.
Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court
along with a copy of this judgment/order
With this observation, this petition stands disposed
of on contest.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
PURNITA
DEB
Purnita
PURNITA DEB
Date: 2026.03.05
16:56:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review