The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
06. 03.2025 was perhaps due to heavy schedule in the WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 & MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025 Government Press. It is prayed that the writ petition be dismissed with exemplary cost being devoid of any merit. [11] Mr. Boyboy Potsangbam, learned CGC submits that the writ petition is bad for mis-joinder of necessary party. It is explained that National Minority Commission is not a necessary party in the present petition and it does not have any role in the appointment of the Manipur State Minorities Commission and prays that the writ petition be quashed qua NMC. None appeared on behalf of the respondent No.4 in spite of proper service of summon. [12] This Court has perused the materials on record minutely, the submissions made at bar and the provisions of the statute, i.e., Act No.9 of 2010. For deciding the disputes involved in the present case for adjudication, it will be relevant to refer to Section 3 of the Manipur State Minorities Commission Act, 2010 and the same is reproduced below :
3. Constitution of the State Commission for Minorities – (1) The state Government shall constitute a body to be known as Manipur State Minorities Commission to exercise the powers conferred on, and to perform the functions assigned to it under this Act. (2) The Commission shall consist of a Chairperson and two Members to be nominated by the State Government from amongst persons of eminence, ability and integrity and such WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 & MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025 persons shall be from amongst the notified minority communities. [13] From a cursory reading of Section 3 of the Act of 2010, it is clear that the Chairperson and two Members of the Commission should be amongst persons of eminence, ability and integrity from the notified minority communities. The provision does not prescribe any minimum educational qualification, nor is the word ‘eminence’ explained in the Act. This Court agrees with the submission of Mr. M. Rarry, learned senior counsel appearing for the State Government that there is no minimum education qualification prescribed and the word ‘eminence’ cannot be construed in a narrow span. In absence of any rule or notification in this regard, Mr. Rabi Khan cannot say that the respondent No.4 does not have requisite qualification of being appointed as Chairperson of Manipur State Minorities Commission. The grounds as stipulated in subsection (3) of Section 4 of t…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non-reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.244 of 2025
MC[WP(C)] No.228 of 2025
Dr. Md. Rabi Khan, Advocate, aged about 50 years,
S/o (Late) Md.Alimuddin,
Resident of Minuthong Golapati Tanky,
PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur 79500
… Petitioner
-Versus-
1.
The State of Manipur through the
Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur,
Old Secretariat Building, Babupara,
PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West
District, 795001.
2.
The Secretary (Minority Affairs),
Govt of Manipur, New Secretariat Building,
PO & PS Imphal, District Imphal West,
Manipur 795001.
3.
The Secretary, National Commission
for Minorities, 1st Floor, Block 14, C.G.O
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi 110003.
4.
Md.Deepak Shah, Keirang Awang
Leikai, Imphal East, Manipur 795010
… Respondents
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
:: Dr.Md.Ravi Khan, Advocate
(in person)
:: Mr.M.Rarry, Sr.Adv. & M. Nikita, Adv.
Mr.Boboy Potsangbam, CGC
:: 16.09.2025
:: 23.12.2025
For the respondents
Date of hearing
Date of order
ORDER (CAV)
[1]
By
the
present
writ
petition,
petitioner
is
challenging the order dated 30.01.2025 appointing the private
respondent No.4 to the post of Chairperson, Manipur State
Minorities Commission.
[2]
The petitioner-in-person is an Advocate practicing
in High Courts and District Courts in the State of Manipur and
other States belonging to the most backward and micro
minority (Manipuri Muslim), was elected as a member of the
Bar Council of Manipur and an elected member of the Waqf
Board Manipur in the year 2021 and also a former Executive
member of the All Manipur Bar Association. The petitioner
submitted an application dated 01.02.2025 to the Hon’ble
Chief Minister’s Secretariat (i/c Minority Affairs) and the
Secretary (Minority Affairs), Govt. of Manipur respectively,
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
requesting for his appointment as Chairperson of the Manipur
State Minorities Commission (in short, MSMC or Commission)
and the same was forwarded to the Joint Secretary (MOBC).
[3]
It is stated that one Md. Abdul Samad and Syed
Wahidur Rahman, had also submitted their applications for
appointment to the said post. However, both the applicants
did not pursue their applications further, as they came to know
that one Md. Deepak Shah (Respondent No.4 herein), had
already been appointed as Chairperson of the Commission.
Thereafter, on 25.02.2025 an order was uploaded through
Social Media page that respondent No.4, was nominated as
Chairperson to the Manipur State Minorities Commission. In
the said order, the Deputy Secretary (MA) digitally signed on
30.01.2025 and the said order was not sent/supplied to the
Director (Printing & Stationery), Govt of Manipur. On
26.02.2025, the petitioner submitted representations each to
the Chief Secretary and the Hon’ble Governor of Manipur
thereby requesting them to reconsider/review the order dated
30.01.2025 for not complying the provisions of law for
appointment/nomination
of
Chairperson/member
of
the
submitted
RTI
Commission.
[4]
The
petitioner,
thereafter,
application dated 28.2.2025 (under Section 6(1) of the RTI
Act, 2005), to furnish information regarding appointment of
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
Chairperson to the Manipur State Minorities. It is also alleged
that the order dated 30.01.2025 issued by the Deputy
Secretary (MA), Govt of Manipur was published in Manipur
Gazette only on 06.03.2025 after issuance of the order way
back in January, 2025.
[5]
It is further submitted that private respondent
No.4 has not resigned/removed from being member of the
Waqf Board Manipur, a Statutory Body, constituted under the
State Government.
[6]
Respondent
Nos.1
and
filed
affidavit-in-
opposition stating that the petitioner cannot claim to be an
aggrieved person without even submitting application for
consideration of appointment as Chairperson of Manipur State
Minorities Commission, as his application was submitted only
after new appointment was issued on 30.01.2025 in favour of
the respondent No.4.
[7]
It is further stated that appointment of respondent
No.4 as Chairperson of MSMC was done under sub-section (2)
of Section 3 of the Manipur State Minorities Commission Act,
2010 (Manipur Act No.9 of 2010) and that respondent No.4
had already submitted his resignation from being member of
the Waqf Board Manipur.
[8]
Respondent No. 3 filed an affidavit submitting that
it has been wrongly included as a party. The National
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
Commission for Minorities (NCM) formed under the NCM Act,
1992, has been inter-alia, entrusted with the responsibility to
safeguard the interests of the Minority communities. It is
submitted that the Commission under National Commission for
Minority Act, 1992, is not empowered to nominate/appoint
chairperson or member in the NCM or in the State Minorities
Commissions.
[9]
Dr. Rabi Khan, petitioner-in-person, has submitted
that the appointment of the respondent No.4 has been done
in complete non-compliance of the provisions of the Manipur
State Minorities Commission Act, 2010 (Manipur Act No. 9 of
2010). It is pointed out that the Chairperson and Member of
the Commission shall be nominated by the State Government
from amongst persons of eminence, ability and integrity and
such persons shall be from amongst the notified minority
communities. The respondent No.4 is alleged to be a person
not falling under the category of eminence, ability and
integrity. He has been appointed without submitting any
formal application and without showing his academic records
to consider him a person of eminence. Besides, the respondent
No.4 did not resign from the post of Member of Waqf Board,
Manipur before his appointment as Chairperson of the
Commission. It is alleged that his only qualification is that he
belongs to the constituency of a former Chief Minister. It is
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
prayed that the appointment of the respondent No.4 as
Chairperson of the Manipur State Commission for Minorities be
set aside and directed to appoint a fresh and qualified person
in terms of the Act.
[10]
Mr. M. Rarry, learned senior counsel appearing for
the State respondents, submits that the writ petition is not
maintainable, as the petitioner is not an aggrieved person for
the simple reason that he has applied for the post of the
Chairperson of the Commission only on 01.02.2025 after the
appointment of the respondent No.4 vide order dated
30.01.2025. Further, it is also pointed out that the petitioner
cannot claim as a matter of right for appointment as
Chairperson of the Commission contrary to the relevant rule.
Learned senior counsel explains that the respondent No.4 was
appointed as Chairperson of the Commission in terms of subsection (2) of Section 3 of the Act of 2010. It is highlighted
that the provision of Section 3 does not provide any specific
educational qualification and the word ‘eminence’ cannot be
construed so narrowly. The allegation of back dated order is
denied, as the order dated 30.01.2025 appointing the
respondent No.4 was digitally signed and the delay in
publication of the appointment order in Gazette only on
06.03.2025 was perhaps due to heavy schedule in the
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
Government Press. It is prayed that the writ petition be
dismissed with exemplary cost being devoid of any merit.
[11]
Mr. Boyboy Potsangbam, learned CGC submits that
the writ petition is bad for mis-joinder of necessary party. It is
explained that National Minority Commission is not a necessary
party in the present petition and it does not have any role in
the appointment of the Manipur State Minorities Commission
and prays that the writ petition be quashed qua NMC. None
appeared on behalf of the respondent No.4 in spite of proper
service of summon.
[12]
This Court has perused the materials on record
minutely, the submissions made at bar and the provisions of
the statute, i.e., Act No.9 of 2010. For deciding the disputes
involved in the present case for adjudication, it will be relevant
to refer to Section 3 of the Manipur State Minorities
Commission Act, 2010 and the same is reproduced below :
3. Constitution of the State Commission for Minorities –
(1) The state Government shall constitute a body to be
known as Manipur State Minorities Commission to exercise
the powers conferred on, and to perform the functions
assigned to it under this Act.
(2) The Commission shall consist of a Chairperson and two
Members to be nominated by the State Government from
amongst persons of eminence, ability and integrity and such
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
persons shall be from amongst the notified minority
communities.
[13]
From a cursory reading of Section 3 of the Act of
2010, it is clear that the Chairperson and two Members of the
Commission should be amongst persons of eminence, ability
and integrity from the notified minority communities. The
provision does not prescribe any minimum educational
qualification, nor is the word ‘eminence’ explained in the Act.
This Court agrees with the submission of Mr. M. Rarry, learned
senior counsel appearing for the State Government that there
is no minimum education qualification prescribed and the word
‘eminence’ cannot be construed in a narrow span. In absence
of any rule or notification in this regard, Mr. Rabi Khan cannot
say that the respondent No.4 does not have requisite
qualification of being appointed as Chairperson of Manipur
State Minorities Commission. The grounds as stipulated in subsection (3) of Section 4 of the Act of 2010 for removal from
office are- insolvent, conviction for an offence of moral
turpitude, unsound mind and incapable of acting in the interest
of the minorities and public. No specific averment is made
against
the
respondent
No.4
towards
any
of
the
disqualifications mentioned in Section 4. The petitioner has
miserably failed to point out any specific allegation that the
respondent No.4 is not qualified at all. This Court of the opinion
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
that the Act does not require the publication of the
appointment order in the Manipur Gazette within a specified
time period, failing which the appointment will become void.
[14]
This Court does not find in the merit of the case
and the writ petition is dismissed. Misc. case is also disposed
of. Cost is made easy.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
PRIYOJIT
SINGH
R PRIYOJIT
Date: 2025.12.23
SINGH
12:31:03 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 244 OF 2025 &
MC(WP(C)) NO. 228 OF 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review