Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LAIRENMAYUM
INDRAJEET
SINGH
LAIRENMAYUM INDRAJEET
SINGH
Date: 2023.06.21 14:40:27
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Crl.) No. 50 of 2023
Md. Nurul Huda (32 yrs.), S/o late Md. Noorjaman of Lilong Turel Ahanbi
Lou Manga, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795130.
… Petitioner
- Versus –
1. Commissioner (Home) Govt. of Manipur, Babupara, Old Secretariat
Building, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District- Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
2. The State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secretary, Government
of Manipur, Babupara, Old Secretariat Building, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
District Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
3. The Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail, at Sajiwa near Khabeisoi,
P.O. Porompat, P.S. Heingang, Imphal East District, Manipur- 795001.
4. The Deputy Secretary (PIT-NDPS) Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Near North Block, Room No. 26 – Church Road, RFA-Barrack,
New-Delhi-110001.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. MV MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
For the respondents
:
:
Date of Hearing
:
Mr. L. Diko, Advocate.
Mr. Phungyo Zingkhai, Dy. G.A. for
respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3.
Mr. S. Vijayanand, Sr.PCCG for
respondent No. 4.
12.06.2023
Date of Judgment & order
:
21.06.2023
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
A. Guneshwar Sharma, J.
[1]
Heard Mr. L. Diko, learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr. Phungyo
Zingkhei, learned Dy. Government Advocate, appearing for respondent Nos. 1 , 2 &
3; and Mr. S. Vijayanand, learned Sr. PCCG, appearing for respondent No. 4.
[2]
By the present petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution, the detenu
has challenged the detention order dated 08.09.2022 issued by the Special
Secretary(Home), Government of Manipur, detaining him under Section 3(1) of the
Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (PITND&PS), 1988.
[3]
The points for determination involved in the present petition are:
(a) Whether the detention order ought to be confirmed before
expiry of the period of 3 months for further detention as mandated by
Article 22(4) of the Constitution?
(b) Whether unexplained delay in disposal of the representation
submitted by the detenu vitiates the detention as provided under Article
22(5) of the Constitution?
[4]
Mr. L. Diko, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the
petitioner/detenu was arrested on 28.04.2022 in connection with F.I.R. No. 71(4)2022
SJM PS U/S 21(b)/60(3) ND&PS Act on alleged possession of heroin No. 4 from his
vehicle and he was remanded to police custody and then to judicial custody. Vide
order dated 31.08.2022, passed by the learned Judge, Special Court (ND&PS),
Manipur in Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 239 of 2022, the detenu was released on default
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
bail as the prosecution could not file charge-sheet within the stipulated time.
Thereafter, vide impugned order dated 08.09.2022, the Special Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur, issued a detention order detaining the detenu under Section
3(1) of PIT-ND&PS Act for preventing him from further involvement in illicit trafficking
of drugs and after released on bail he would likely continue with the illegal activities.
By letter dated 12.09.2022, the Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur,
furnished grounds of detention under Section 3(3) of PIT-NDPS Act to the detenu.
Vide order dated 23.12.2022, the Commissioner (Home), Govt. of Manipur, confirmed
the detention order dated 08.09.2022 and fixed the period of detention for 12(twelve)
months from the date of detention. Mr. L. Diko, learned counsel, also submitted that
the detenu make common representation dated 01.03.2023 to the Deputy Secretary
(PIT-ND&PS), Government of India and the Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur,
through the Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa, for revocation of the
detention order. Vide order dated 10.03.2023 issued by the Commissioner (Home),
Government of Manipur, the representation dated 01.03.2023 submitted by the
detenu was rejected. It is submitted that at the time of filing of the writ petition, there
is no information regarding the disposal of the representation by the Central
Government. The detention order is challenged mainly on the ground that there is
total non-application of mind, mandatory provisions of the PIT-ND&PS Act have not
been complied, the Central Government has failed to dispose of the representation.
[5]
The State Government filed counter affidavit and Mr. Phungo Zingkhei,
learned Dy. Government Advocate, submits that the detenu was arrested for
possession and trafficking of the illegal drugs and after release on bail , he was
continuing the illegal activities and for this reason he was detained after considering
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
materials submitted before the detaining authority. It is also submitted that there is
no lapse on the part of the State Government in dealing with the detention and the
disposal of the representation. Representation dated 01.03.2023 submitted by the
detenu was received on 03.03.2023 from the IG(Prisons) and a copy of the same was
forwarded to the Central Government on 06.03.2023 and parawise comment was also
furnished to the Government of India on 10.03.2023. Parawise comment was received
by the State Government on 09.03.2023 and the representation of the detenu was
disposed of as rejected by order dated 10.03.2023. Mr. Phungyo Zingkhei, learned Dy.
Government Advocate, submits that there is no delay on the part of the State
Government and the writ petition may be rejected.
[6]
Mr. S. Vijayanand, learned Sr. PCCG for the Central Government, relying
upon the affidavit submits that the representation dated 01.03.2023 submitted by the
detenu was received from the State Government by e-mail dated 06.03.2023 and the
parawise comments were received from the State Government by e-mail on
10.03.2023. Thereafter, the matter was submitted to the competent authority i.e.,
Secretary (Revenue) on 16.03.2023 and after perusing all the materials on record,
Secretary (Revenue) rejected the
representation vide memorandum dated
21.03.2023. Mr. S. Vijayanand, learned Sr. PCCG, submits that time taken by the
Central Government in disposal of the representation is not fatal and the same is due
to normal office process and he prays that the writ petition may be rejected.
[7]
Considered the submissions made by the parties, perused the materials
on record and the relevant law in this regard. Grounds of detention were furnished
within 5 days as stipulated under Section 3(3) of PIT-ND&PS Act and the detention
order was furnished to the Central Government within 10 days as stipulated under
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
Section 3(2) of the PIT-ND&PS Act. On the advice of the Advisory Board vide
opinion/report dated 22.11.2022, the detention order dated 08.09.2022 was
confirmed by State authority vided order dated 23.12.2022. Representation dated
01.03.2023 was submitted by the detenu through the Superintendent, Manipur Central
Jail, Sajiwa, and the same was received on 03.03.2023 from the office of IG(Prisons)
and the parawise comments were received on 09.03.2023 and the representation was
rejected vide order dated 10.03.2023. This Court is of the opinion that there is no
delay on the part of the State Government while disposing the representation
submitted by the detenu.
[8]
However, there has been a serious lapse on the part of the State
Government for its failure to confirm the detention order dated 08.09.2022 within the
stipulated period of 3 months as mandated by Article 22(4) of the Constitution. In a
catena of cases, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the opinion of the Advisory of
existence of the sufficient grounds for detaining the detenu beyond the period of 3
months, should be confirmed by the detaining authority before expiry of the stipulated
period. Otherwise, any detention beyond the period of three months is illegal.
Important case laws in this regard may be considered.
[9]
In the case of Ujjal Mandal v. State of W.B., (1972) 1 SCC 456,
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the detention order is valid only for three months as
mandated under Article 22(4) of the Constitution and unless it is confirmed before the
expiry of three months, further detention would be without any authority of law.
Relevant para are reproduced below:
8. Article 22(4) of the Constitution has specified the maximum limit of initial
detention, and detention for a longer period than three months can only be made
on the basis of the report of the Board. The Act authorises a possible detention
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
of more than three months. It is because the appropriate Government wants to
detain a person for more than three months that the matter is referred to the
Board and it is only when the Board makes its report that the appropriate
Government can fix the period of detention under sub-section (1) of Section 12.
So, when the Government receives the report of the Board stating that there is
sufficient cause for detention of a person, if the Government wants to detain him
for a period beyond three months, it has to pass an order or make a decision
under Section 12(1) to confirm the order of detention. The confirmation of the
detention order without anything more would result in an automatic continuation
of the detention, even if there is no separate decision to continue the detention
for any specific period as held by this Court in Dattatreya Moreshwar Pangarkar
v. State of Bombay. When Section 12(1) of the Act speaks of “and continue the
detention of the person concerned for such period as it thinks fit”, it can only
mean continuance of detention from the point of time at which detention would
become illegal if the order of detention is not confirmed, namely, the expiry of
three months from the date of detention. It would not be necessary to confirm
the order of detention even after the receipt of the report of the Board by the
Government if the Government only wants to continue the detention for the
period of three months from the date of detention, as the initial order of
detention would authorise the continuance of detention for that period without
any confirmation. Confirmation is necessary only to continue the detention after
the expiry of three months. If that be so, it stands to reason to hold that the
order of detention must be confirmed before the expiry of the three months.
9. To put the matter in a nut-shell: the State Government has power under the
Act to detain a person without trial beyond a period of three months but limited
to a period of one year. That power the State Government may exercise on the
receipt of the opinion of the Board that there is sufficient cause for the detention.
When the State Government receives that opinion, it has still the option to
exercise the power and to continue the detention beyond the period of three
months or not. Confirmation is the exercise of the power to continue the
detention after the expiry of three months. Unless that power is
exercised within the period of three months from the date of detention,
the detention after the expiry of that period would be without the
authority of the Law.
[10]
In the case of Deb Sadhan Roy v. State of W.B.: (1972) 1 SCC
308, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that no person can be detained for any period
beyond three months or for any period thereafter up to twelve months unless the
Board’s opinion is confirmed within three months from the date of initial detention.
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
[11]
In the case of Shibapada Mukherjee v. State of W.B.: (1974) 3
SCC 50, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the detention order has to be confirmed by
the detaining authority before expiry of 3 months period after receiving the Board’s
report, otherwise further detention beyond 3 months is invalid.
[12]
In the case of Nirmal Kumar Khandelwal v. Union of India: (1978)
2 SCC 508, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the if the detention order is not
confirmed within the period of 3 months as mandated by Article 22(4) of the
Constitution after receiving the opinion of the Advisory Board finding sufficient grounds
for detention, further detention will be without any authority. Para 9 & 10 are
reproduced below:
“9. We do not find any merit in the contention that since the period prescribed
for the Advisory Board to make its report has been increased from 10 weeks (as
prescribed under MISA) to 11 weeks in COFEPOSA, leaving only a short period
for the Government to take a decision under Section 8( f), the legislative intent
was that the order of confirmation of the detention and its continuance could be
made after the expiry of three months from the date of the detention. It is true
that in certain situation when the Advisory Board makes its report in favour of
the detention just before the expiry of 11 weeks from the date of the detention,
the time left to the Government for taking a decision as to the confirmation of
the detention and its continuance would be hardly two weeks. That only shows
the anxiety on the part of the legislature to ensure that the Government
continues the preventive detention of a person beyond three months after due
application of mind and for that purpose acts with utmost promptitude. The law
does not lend its authority to the continuance of the detention even for
a day more than the initial period of three months if the Government
does not take a decision for that purpose on the report of the Advisory
Board within three months of the commencement of the detention.
10. There is no reason to doubt the law enunciated by this Court in the aforesaid
decisions. Respectfully following the ratio of those decisions, we hold that since
no order of confirmation of the detention was made under clause (/)
of Section 8 within three months of the date of detention by the
appropriate Government, further detention of the petitioner after the
expiry of that period is without the authority of law.”
[13]
From the above decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court, it is the settled
proposition of law with regard to the mandatory provision of Article 22(4) of the
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
Constitution that an order of detention issued under the preventive detention law will
not be valid beyond a period of 3 months, if the opinion/report of the Advisory Board
for existence of sufficient cause for such detention is issued before the expiration of
the period of 3 months from the date of detention and that such opinion/report is
confirmed by the detaining authority before the expiration of the stipulated period of
3 months.
[14]
In the present case, the detention order was issued on 08.09.2022. The
Advisory Board held its sitting on 17.11.2022 and made the opinion/report on
22.11.2022. After considering the report of the Board, the detention order dated
08.09.2022 was confirmed by the State authority vide order dated 23.12.2022. It is
seen that the opinion/report of the Board was made on 22.11.2022 before expiry of
the stipulated period of 3 months, but the State authority confirmed the detention
order only on 23.12.2022, ie, after 15 days of the expiration of the stipulated period
of 3 months. There is no controversy in this regard that the detention order should be
confirmed by the detaining authority before the expiry of 3 months as contemplated
by Article 22(4) of the Constitution. We are of the considered view that as the
confirmation order was issued after expiry of 3 months from the date of initial
detention, further detention beyond 08.012.2022 is without any authority. The
detention order is liable to be set aside on this ground alone.
[15]
On the other hand, the representation dated 01.03.2023 submitted by
the detenu was received by the Central Government on 06.03.2023 by e-mail and the
parawise comments were received on 10.03.2023 from the State Government by email. On 16.03.2023, the file was put up before the competent authority i.e. Secretary
(Revenue), Government of India, for passing an appropriate order and vide
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
Memorandum dated 21.03.2023, the representation dated 01.03.2023 submitted by
the detenu was rejected. It took 20 days for the Central Government in disposal of
the representation. However, the period from 01.03.2023 to 06.03.2023 is explained
as the time take in receiving the representation from the State Government. Further,
the period from 06.03.2023 to 10.03.2023 has been explained as time taken in
receiving parawise comments from the State Government. Hence, the Central
Government took 11 effective days in disposal of the representation. There is no
explanation for pending of the file for 6 days in the Ministry and 5 days’ time taken by
the Secretary (Revenue) in passing the memorandum dated 21.03.2023. In short,
delay of 11 days has not been explained by the Central Government while disposing
the representation.
[16]
In the case of Rajammal vs. State of Tamil Nadu reported as 1999
(1) SCC 417, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that though no period is prescribed by
Article 22 of the Constitution for the decision to be taken on the representation, the
word ‘as soon as may be’ in clause 5 of Article 22 conveyed the message that
representation should be considered and disposed of at the earliest. It was further
held that authority is permitted to explain the delay occasioned in the disposal of the
representation. If the delay is not explained properly, the detention order is vitiated
for violation of the fundamental rights enshrined under Articles 21 and 22(5) of the
Constitution.
[17]
In the case of Sarabjeet Singh Mokha Vs. the District Magistrate,
Jabalpur reported in MANU/SC/1011/2021, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
detention order can be invalidated on the grounds of- (1) unexplained delay on the
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
part of the authority in deciding the representation, and (2) failure of the authority to
communicate the rejection of the representation in timely manner.
[18]
In a very recent case of Pramod Singla Vs. Union of India (UOI) &
ors., reported in MANU/SC/0349/2023, the Honb’e Supreme Court observed in
para 44 as follows:
‘44. …. Every procedural rigidity, must be followed in entirety by the
Government in cases of preventive detention, and every lapse in procedure
must give rise to a benefit to the case of the detenue. The Courts, in
circumstances of preventive detention, are conferred with the duty that has
been given the utmost importance by the Constitution, which is the
protection of individual and civil liberties. …..’
[19]
From the above decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court, it is clear that
compliance of the statutory provisions should be construed strictly and for any lapses
on the part of the authorities, the benefit of the same be given to the detenu. This
principle is propounded on the presumption that in a preventive detention a person is
confined in custody without facing a trial and on the basis of the subjective satisfaction
of the authority only.
[20]
In the present case, Central Government cannot explain the effective
period of 11 days taken while disposing the representation submitted by the detenu.
As already observed above, the State Government also did not confirm the detention
order within the stipulated period of 3 months as prescribed by Article 22(4) of the
Constitution. In the circumstance, we are of the considered opinion that detention
order cannot be sustained in the eyes of the law as it infringes the fundamental rights
conferred on a citizen by Articles 21 & 22 of the Constitution.
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
[21]
Accordingly, detention order dated 08.09.2022 and the confirmation
order dated 23.12.2022 are set-aside. The detenu Md. Nurul Huda, be immediately
released from detention forthwith, if not required in any other case.
[22]
Writ petition is allowed.
[23]
No costs.
[24]
Send a copy of this order to the Commissioner (Home), Government of
Manipur and the Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail Sajiwa for information and
necessary compliance.
JUDGE
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Indrajeet
W.P.(CRL.) NO. 50 OF 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review