The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 11.2015.” [7] Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner draws the attention of this Court to the peculiar fact that on perusal of the Show Cause notice and the reinstatement order, the very purpose of reinstatement of service of the petitioner is to face Departmental Enquiry and once the reinstatement order is set aside, the proceeding of Departmental Enquiry cannot survive on its own independently. [8] On the other hand, Mr. Shyam Sharma, learned GA submits that Departmental Enquiry can be proceeded against the retired employee and there is no infirmity to continue with impugned Departmental Enquiry against the petitioner and the same may be WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016 allowed to continue. He has also pointed out that the petitioner has not avail the alternative remedy of approaching the Appellate Authority under Assam Police Manual and the petitioner approached this Court directly without affording alternative statutory remedy. It is also stated that the petitioner has concealed the fact of his involvement in the previous criminal case. [9] Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has clarified that the petitioner can approach the Appellate Authority in case of any punishment imposed against him by the authority but in the present case, the impugned order of reinstatement is not a punishment and hence there is no occasion to approach the Appell…
27. 11.2015 has been set aside by this Court by an order dated WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
13. 06.2017 in WP(C)No. 1026 of 2015 filed by the petitioner herein, the very basic foundation for initiating the Departmental Enquiry against the petitioner is no longer in existence and the Departmental proceeding is devoid of any authority. [11] Accordingly, the present writ petition is allowed and the Office Memorandum dated 07.01.2016 and the article of charges are set aside on this limited ground only. [12] It is clarified that the respondents may proceed as per law if the same is permissible and if so advised. [13] With the above observations, this writ petition is disposed of. John Kom WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2024.04.04
TELEN KOM Date:
10:01:06 +05'30'
Item No. 19
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.83 of 2016
Md. Nasir Khan, aged about 41 years, S/o Md. Bashir, Ex-Rifleman
No.1194148, “C” Coy, 2nd Bn. Manipur Rifle and a resident of Wangoi,
PO & PS Wangoi in Imphal West District, Wangoi
…Petitioner
- Versus
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Principal Secretary, Home
to the Govt. of Manipur at the Civil Secretariat Complex, Imphal.
2. The Director of General of Police, Manipur at the Manipur Police
Headquarter at Imphal.
3. The Commandant, 2nd Bn. Manipur Rifles at Imphal.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
JUDGEMENT&ORDER
(Oral)
03.04.2024.
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel assisted by Ms.
Sapna, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. Shyam
Sharma, learned GA for all the respondents.
[2]
The fact of the present case is that the petitioner was a
Rifleman in 2nd Bn. Manipur Rifles and his application for voluntary
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
retirement was accepted by the authority vide order dated 28.03.2015
w.e.f. 01.04.2015 and allowed to retire from the service. Thereafter, the
respondent (Commandant, 2nd Bn. Manipur Rifles, Imphal) issued a show
cause notice dated 20.10.2015 to the petitioner regarding the suppression
of a pending FIR case against him in his representation for voluntary
retirement and as to why order of the voluntary retirement should not be
revoked to face the Departmental Enquiry with respect to the FIR case
No.12(2)2010 u/s 400/489-C IPC.
[3]
Subsequently, the petitioner submitted a detailed written
statement dated 05.11.2015. However, vide order dated 27.11.2015 the
Commandant, 2nd Bn. Manipur Rifles recalled and revoked the voluntary
retirement order and re-instate the petitioner in service to face
Departmental Enquiry in connection with the aforesaid FIR. The relevant
portion of the order dated 27.11.2015 is reproduced as below:
“Now, therefore, the undersigned Commandant, 2MR Imphal in
exercise of the power conferred upon me under rules 66 of AP
Manual Part-III do hereby revoked and re-instate Ex-Rifleman
No.1194148, Md. Nasir Khan from voluntary retirement with
immediate effect and conduct a Departmental enquiry against him
for his grave misconduct by involving FIR case No.12(2)2010
WGI-PS u/s 400/489-C IPC during his service.”
[4]
The petitioner challenged the revocation order dated
27.11.2015 by way of writ petition being WP(C)No.1026 of 2015 and this
Court passed an interim order dated 16.12.2015 restraining the
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
respondents not to take coercive action against the petitioner if he was not
able to attend office after his reinstatement.
[5]
The
Memorandum
Commandant,
dated
2nd
Bn.
Manipur
Rifles
issued
to
the
petitioner
for
initiating
07.01.2016
Departmental Enquiry against him
in connection
with the above
mentioned FIR case and the petitioner has challenged the said
Memorandum dated 07.01.2016 as well as article of charges by way of the
present writ petition i.e. WP(C)No.83 of 2016.
[6]
During the course of hearing, Mr. N. Umakanta, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that vide order dated 13.06.2017 passed
by this Court in connected writ petition being WP(C)No.1026 of 2015, the
reinstatement order dated 27.11.2015 was quashed on the ground that
once the voluntary retirement of the petitioner was accepted by the
authority, the authority did not have jurisdiction to recall the order by which
the relationship between an employer and an employee had already been
snapped and there was no provision to revive the same. The relevant
portion of the order dated 13.06.2017 is reproduced herein below:
“7. Normally, an authority which has the power to issue an order
has the power to revoke, amend, vary or rescind the same as
provided under Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1987.
But in the present case, what is of interest if that by the order
dated 28.03.2015 by accepting the request for voluntary
retirement sought by the petitioner, the relationship of the
petitioner and the State Government as an employee and
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
employer is snapped. Once the voluntary retirement is accepted,
a Government employee ceases to be a Government employee
except for the purpose of any retiral and other benefits which
would accrue because of the service already rendered by the
Government employee and which will be governed by the
relevant rules/pension rules. Otherwise, there ceases to be any
relationship between the Government employee and the
Government. Therefore, the question which arises is as to
whether once the relationship of employee and employer is
snapped, can the ex-employer i.e., the State Government
continue to treat the petitioner as an employee so as to subject
him to any further action by way of giving show cause notice and
recalling an order by which the relationship of an employee and
employer had already been snapped? In the opinion of this Court,
once the employer-employee relationship is snapped, it becomes
irreversible. For the same reason, the petitioner also cannot
seek withdrawal of his application for voluntary retirement once it
has been accepted and given effect to. Voluntary retirement is
just another method of terminating the service of the Government
employee and as such once the service is effectively terminated,
his relationship with the State Government as a Government
employee ceases and the employee has no further obligation
towards the employer except for the purpose of retiral or
pensionery benefits which could be withheld or deprived of in
accordance with the provisions under the relevant Pension
Rules. If the service rules enable the authority to revoke any such
order of voluntary retirement, the matter would have been
otherwise. However, the learned Sr. GA for the State
respondents has not been able to show or point out any such
provision under any rule which enables the State Government to
revoke an order allowing voluntary retirement from service which
had already become effective. The relationship between the
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
employee and the employer is governed by the statutory rules
and if the statutory rules do not provide for governing the service
conditions post employment, the employer will have no authority
to do anything which is not provided by the rules. Accordingly,
this Court is of the view that the authorities has no jurisdiction to
recall and order by which the relationship between and employer
and an employee has been snapped. Therefore, this Court is of
the opinion that the petition should be allowed as the respondent
authorities have no jurisdiction or authority to recall any such
order allowing voluntary retirement.
For the reasons discussed above, the present writ petition
is allowed by setting aside the impugned order dated
27.11.2015.”
[7]
Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner draws the attention of this Court to the peculiar fact that on
perusal of the Show Cause notice and the reinstatement order, the very
purpose of reinstatement of service of the petitioner is to face
Departmental Enquiry and once the reinstatement order is set aside,
the proceeding of Departmental Enquiry cannot survive on its own
independently.
[8]
On the other hand, Mr. Shyam Sharma, learned GA
submits that Departmental Enquiry can be proceeded against the
retired employee and there is no infirmity to continue with impugned
Departmental Enquiry against the petitioner and the same may be
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
allowed to continue. He has also pointed out that the petitioner has not
avail the alternative remedy of approaching the Appellate Authority
under Assam Police Manual and the petitioner approached this Court
directly without affording alternative statutory remedy. It is also stated
that the petitioner has concealed the fact of his involvement in the
previous criminal case.
[9]
Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has clarified that the petitioner can approach the Appellate
Authority in case of any punishment imposed against him by the
authority but in the present case, the impugned order of reinstatement
is not a punishment and hence there is no occasion to approach the
Appellate Authority.
[10]
This Court has considered the submission made by the
learned counsel for the parties at the Bar and perused the materials on
record. On perusal of the Show cause notice dated 20.10.2015 and the
reinstatement as well as the revocation of voluntary retirement order
dated 27.11.2015, it is clear that the purpose of reinstatement is to
initiate Departmental Enquiry against the petitioner in connection of his
involvement in the aforesaid FIR. Once the reinstatement order dated
27.11.2015 has been set aside by this Court by an order dated
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
13.06.2017 in WP(C)No. 1026 of 2015 filed by the petitioner herein, the
very basic foundation for initiating the Departmental Enquiry against
the petitioner is no longer in existence and the Departmental
proceeding is devoid of any authority.
[11]
Accordingly, the present writ petition is allowed and the
Office Memorandum dated 07.01.2016 and the article of charges are
set aside on this limited ground only.
[12]
It is clarified that the respondents may proceed as per law
if the same is permissible and if so advised.
[13]
With the above observations, this writ petition is disposed
of.
JUDGE
John Kom
WP(C)NO.83 OF 2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review