The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
34. In view of the above, no relief can be granted to the petitioner in the instant writ petition.
35. The writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present :-
Hon’ble Justice Amrita Sinha
WPA 29927 of 2025
Md. Asif
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
For the writ petitioner
:-
Mr. Debasish Kundu, Adv.
Mr. Sudeepto Kumar Basu, Adv.
Mr. Bidan Modak, Adv.
For UOI
:-
Mr. S.N. Dutta, Adv.
Mr. Anindya Sundar Das, Adv.
Heard on
:-
06.05.2026
Judgment on
:-
06.05.2026
Amrita Sinha, J.:-
1.
The petitioner participated in the recruitment process of Central
Armed Police Forces, 2025. He was declared medically unfit by the
Detailed Medical Examination Board on the ground of high blood
pressure, accessory nipple and under weight. The petitioner was
physically examined by the Review Medical Examination Board and he
was declared unfit on account of inferior ischemia changes and
accessory nipple.
2.
The petitioner got himself checked up by the State Government
hospital where he was declared medically fit.
3.
Challenging the manner in which medical examination of the petitioner
was conducted, the instant writ petition has been filed.
4.
A report was called for from the respondent authority which has been
filed and an exception thereto has also been filed by the petitioner.
5.
Specific contention of the petitioner is that the respondent authority
did not abide by the medical guidelines pursuant to which the medical
examination ought to have been conducted. Accessory nipple is
present in his body since his birth. The same is not a deformity. The
same does not interfere with his regular activities.
6.
It has been submitted that the ECG report relied upon by the authority
ought to have been co-related clinically. The same has not been done.
7.
It has further been submitted that the report of the State Government
hospital ought to be taken up for consideration as the doctors of the
State Government hospital have the same educational degree and the
knowledge of medicine similar to that of the doctors physically
examining the petitioner by the recruiting authority.
8.
Reliance has been placed on the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court on 29th May, 2025 in Civil Appeal No.7254 of 2025 (Divyanshu
Singh v. The Union of India & Ors.) where the Court directed the
candidate to be medically examined by the Medical Board of AIIMS,
New Delhi.
9.
It has been argued that the case of an unemployed youth seeking
appointment ought not to be brushed aside lightly. The authority is
interfering with the right of the petitioner to be considered for
appointment.
10.
Prayer has been made to either re-examine the petitioner medically by
an independent authority or to accept the medical report given by the
doctor of the State Government hospital upon setting aside the medical
report of the Review Medical Examination Board of the recruiting
authority.
11.
Submission and prayer of the petitioner is opposed by the learned
advocate representing the respondents. It has been submitted that a
person appointed in Central Armed Police Forces will be required to
perform duty under extreme pressure and weather condition. Physical
fitness of the candidate employed in the Armed Forces has to be
checked up in a very strict manner so that the health of the member
does not interfere with the duty assigned to him.
12.
It has been contended that the petitioner was examined medically first
by the Detailed Medical Examination Board and thereafter by the
Review Medical Examination Board and on both occasions, he has
been declared unfit by expert doctors.
13.
Report by any other doctor cannot be accepted and the report of the
experts of the recruiting authority ought to prevail over the report of an
outsider examiner. It has been further contended that the medical
guidelines for recruitment have been scrupulously followed by the
authority.
14.
Prayer has been made not to interfere with the report of the medical
experts of the recruiting authority.
15.
I have heard and considered the rival submissions made on behalf of
both the parties and have perused the materials placed before the
Court.
16.
In the instant case, the petitioner is aspiring for appointment in
Central Armed Police Forces – a disciplined body. The recruiting
authority has its own specified/codified medical guidelines which are
required to be followed for the purpose of conducting medical
examination of a candidate intending to be recruited in the disciplined
forces.
17.
Submission made by the learned advocate for the petitioner is that the
report of an outside medical practitioner may be considered for
examining the physical health of a job aspirant in Central Armed
Police Forces by disregarding the report of the experts of the recruiting
authority cannot be accepted by the Court.
18.
A candidate participating in recruitment process of the disciplined
Force would be bound by the recruitment Rules of the said Force and
the medical guidelines relating to the said Force. The authority took
the opinion of the medical experts twice; first by the Detailed Medical
Examination Board where the petitioner was declared medically unfit
on three grounds, thereafter by the Review Medical Examination Board
and he was found unfit on two conditions; first, inferior ischemia
changes and second accessory nipple. The ground of high blood
pressure found by the Detailed Medical Examination Board was not
accepted by the Review Medical Examination Board.
19.
The authority conducted ECG of the petitioner and the ECG graph has
been annexed to the report. The observation mentioned in the said
graph signed by a cardiologist of a diagnostic centre specifically
mentions of inferior ischemia. The said abnormality was to be
correlated clinically.
20.
Learned advocate for the petitioner contends that the clinical
correlation of the ECG graph was conducted and the petitioner has
been found to be fit by doctors of JNM Hospital.
21.
On a perusal of the OPD Patient Card dated 1st December, 2025 issued
in favour of the petitioner by the Surgical Male Department of the
College of Medicine & JNM Hospital, WBUHS, Kalyani, Nadia, it
appears that the patient was checked up for obtaining opinion for
accessory nipple. The doctors opined that the petitioner was medically
fit as regards accessory nipple. Opinion of JNM Hospital was not taken
as regards the inferior ischemia changes as contended by the
petitioner.
22.
It appears that the ECG graph of the petitioner was checked up by the
medical experts of the recruiting authority and inferior ischemia
changes were confirmed.
23.
The medical guidelines mentioning the grounds for rejection clearly
mentions that valvular or other disease of heart and any congenital
abnormality so as to impede efficient discharge of training/duties are
the grounds for rejection.
24.
According
to
the
authority,
accessory
nipple
is
a
congenital
abnormality and the same causes constant friction in an abnormal
area of the body while wearing combat gear while training and hard
duties. There is an established positive association between an
accessory nipple and coronary heart disease.
25.
Submission of the petitioner that he completed the test run within the
prescribed time period is an indication that he is absolutely fit cannot
be accepted by the Court. At the time of conducting the test run, the
petitioner was certainly not wearing any combat gear. He must be
wearing his regular dress.
26.
The authority has opined that with the combat gear, there may be a
chance of constant friction if there is an abnormal area in the body.
Such opinion of the expert authority cannot be ignored.
27.
As regards the inferior ischemia changes, the petitioner may not face
any problem at present; but it cannot be ruled out that the said
ground, which is a ground for rejection, will not interfere with his
duties in the armed forces.
28.
The principles that apply in the case of recruitment to disciplined
Forces involved with safety and security, internal and external, such
as the Paramilitary Force, or the Police, are distinct and different from
those which apply to normal civilian recruitment. The standard of
fitness and the rigour of the examination to be conducted are
undoubtedly higher and stricter.
29.
Submission of the learned advocate for the petitioner that the
authority ought to have taken further specialist opinion if there is any
doubt is also not accepted by the Court. It does not appear that there
was any doubt in the mind of either the Detailed Medical Examination
Board or the Review Medical Examination Board as regards the inferior
ischemia changes and accessory nipple of the petitioner. The expert
doctors of the authority were more than certain that the petitioner was
unfit for the job. Accordingly, there is no question of obtaining further
opinion from any specialist or super-specialist of the Government
Medical College or Hospital.
30.
Contention
of
the
petitioner
that
he
ought
to
have
been
admitted/hospitalized by the Board before his rejection on the ground
of hypertension also cannot be accepted in view of the reason that
hypertension was not the ground of rejection of the petitioner’s
candidature.
31.
Learned advocate for the petitioner argues that the submission made
in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the report of the respondents are
contradictory to each other.
32.
Such submission also cannot be accepted by the Court in view of the
fact that hypertension was not the final ground for rejection of his
candidature. The candidature of the petitioner stood rejected on the
ground of accessory nipple and inferior ischemia changes detected in
his ECG report.
33.
The Court is not an expert on medical issues and it will not be proper
to substitute the views of the medical experts of the recruiting body by
its own views.
34.
In view of the above, no relief can be granted to the petitioner in the
instant writ petition.
35.
The writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
36.
All parties shall act on the basis of a server copy of this order duly
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
37.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied
to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review