Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHOUGRA Digitally signed by
SHOUGRAKPAM
KPAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAN SINGH
Date: 2023.06.16
DA SINGH 14:23:56 +05'30'
IN. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(Cril.) No. 46 of 2023
Md. Abdul Matalib
Vs.
State of Manipur & ors.
… Petitioner
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
16-06-2023
A. Bimol Singh, J.
[1]
Heard Mr. Shakir Khan, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, Mr. Phungyo Zingkhei, learned Dy. GA appearing for the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 5 and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI assisted
by Mr. Y. Paikhomba, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
No. 3 and 4.
[2]
The present petition had been filed by the father of the detenu
assailing the order dated 12-01-2023 passed by the Commissioner
(Home), Government of Manipur, thereby detaining the detenu under
sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substance Act, 1988, as well as the order dated
24-02-2023 passed by the Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur
thereby confirming the detention of the petitioner and fixing the period of
detention for 12 (twelve) months from the date of detention.
[3]
The brief facts of the present case is that the detenu was
arrested by a Police team of Thoubal P.S. on 08-08-2022 and an FIR being
FIR No. 134(8)2022 TBL-P.S. u/s 21 (b)/ 29 ND & PS Act was registered
against the detenu. While the detenu was in custody, the Commissioner
(Home), Government of Manipur issued the impugned detention order
dated 12-01-2023 thereby detaining the petitioner’s son under sub-section
(1) of Section 3 of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in ND & PS Act, 1988.
The grounds of detention was furnished to the detenu on 17-01-2023
and on receiving the said grounds of detention, the detenu submitted a
representation
dated
14-02-2023
to
the
Commissioner
(Home),
-2-
Government of Manipur with a request for taking a photocopy of the said
representation and forwarding it to the Deputy Secretary (PIL-ND & PS)
Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, New Delhi. On receiving the
said representation and after considering it, the State authorities disposed
of the representation submitted by the petitioner by an order dated 20-022023 issued by the Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur
thereby rejecting the said representation as being devoid of merit. After
rejection of the representation submitted by the detenu, the Commissioner
(Home), Government of Manipur issued another order dated 24-02-2023
confirming the detention of the petitioner’s son and fixing the period of
detention for 12 (twelve) months from the date of his detention.
It is the case of the petitioner that the representation submitted
by the detenu was forwarded by the State authorities to the respondents
No. 3 and 4 on 17-02-2023 through an e-mail and the respondents No. 3
and 4 disposed of the representation submitted by the detenu only on
13-03-2023 after a delay of about 27 (twenty seven) days.
[4]
The impugned detention order as well as the impugned
confirmation order have been challenged by the petitioner on various
grounds. One of the grounds raised by the counsel for the petitioner is that
the representation dated 14-02-2023 submitted by the petitioner was
disposed of by the concerned authorities of the Central Government after
about 27 (twenty seven) days delay and that no explanation whatsoever
had been given by the respondents No. 3 and 4 about the delay in
disposing of the representation submitted by the petitioner. The learned
counsel for the petitioner vehemently submitted that the unexplained delay
in disposing of the representation submitted by the petitioner vitiates the
impugned detention order and that only on this ground, the impugned
detention order is liable to be quashed and set aside. In support of his
contention, the learned counsel for the petitioner cited the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of “Rajammal Vs. State of Tamil Nadu &
anr.” reported in (1999) 1 SCC 417 wherein it has been held as under:-
-3“7. It is a constitutional obligation of the Government to consider the
representation forwarded by the detenu without any delay.
Though no period is prescribed by Article 22 of the Constitution
for the decision to be taken on the representation, the words "as
soon as may be" in clause (5) of Article 22 convey the message
that the representation should be considered and disposed of at
the earliest. But that does not mean that the authority is preempted from explaining any delay which would have occasioned
in the disposal of the representation. The court can certainly
consider whether the delay was occasioned due to permissible
reasons or unavoidable causes. This position has been well
delineated by a Constitution Bench of this Court in K.M. Abdulla
Kunhi v. Union of India. The following observations of the Bench
can profitably be extracted here: (SCC p. 484, para 12)
"It is a constitutional mandate commanding the authority
concerned to whom the detenu submits his representation to
consider the representation and dispose of the same as
expeditiously as possible. The words 'as soon as may be'
occurring in clause (5) of Article 22 reflects the concern of the
Framers that the representation should be expeditiously
considered and disposed of with a sense of urgency without
an avoidable delay. However, there can be no hard and fast rule
in this regard. It depends upon the facts and circumstances of
each case. There is no period prescribed either under the
Constitution or under the detention law concemed, within
which the representation should be dealt with. The
requirement, however, is that there should not be supine
indifference, slackness or callous attitude in considering the
representation. Any unexplained delay in the disposal of
representation would be a breach of the constitutional
imperative and it would render the continued detention
impermissible and illegal."
“8. The position, therefore, now is that if delay was caused on
account of any indifference or lapse in considering the
representation, such delay will adversely affect further detention
of the prisoner. In other words, it is for the authority concerned to
explain the delay, if any, in disposing of the representation. It is
not enough to say that the delay was very short. Even longer delay
can as well be explained. So the test is not the duration or range
of delay, but how it is explained by the authority concerned.”
“10. Mr V.R. Reddy, learned Senior Counsel for the State of Tamil Nadu,
referred to a decision of this Court in U. Vijayalakshmi v. State of
-4T.N. to contend that it could not be said that there was any delay
in considering the representation from 9-2-1998 to 14-2-1998. In
that case also, the detention was under Section 3(1) of the Act.
The detenu made a representation against the detention which
was received by the State Government on 18-5-1992 and the State
Government conveyed the rejection of the representation on 236-1992. The detenu received the rejection order on 26-6-1992. It
was submitted that there was an inordinate long delay in dealing
with the representation and that the detenu was entitled to have
the detention order quashed. This Court noticed that in the
counter-affidavit filed by the Deputy Secretary to the State
Government, the manner in which the representation was dealt
with after its receipt on 18-5-1992 had been stated in detail. The
Court then observed:
"We have perused the stages through which the file containing
the representation was dealt with promptly and there was no
indifference, lethargy or negligence in dealing with the same.
The file was not unnecessarily held up at any level but moved
from level to level promptly. We are, therefore, satisfied that
the explanation tendered by the Deputy Secretary in this behalf
is acceptable and does not betray any lack of sense of urgency
in dealing with the representation. We, therefore, do not see
any merit in the first contention."
In the present case, however, there is no explanation forthcoming
as to why the representation could not be dealt with by the
Minister concerned from 9-2-1998 to 14-2-1998.”
“11. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the delay from 9-2-1998 to
14-2-1998 remains unexplained and such unexplained delay has
vitiated further detention of the detenu. The corollary thereof is
that further detention must necessarily be disallowed. We,
therefore, allow this appeal and set aside the impugned judgment.
We direct the appellant-detenu to be set at large forthwith.”
[5]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI, by drawing the attention of
this court at para 4 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed on behalf of
the respondents No. 3 and 4, submitted that the representation dated
14-02-2023 submitted by the detenu was received by the Ministry from the
State Government of Manipur through an e-mail on 17-02-2023 and
subsequently, parawise comments on the representation was forward
to the Ministry by the State Government of Manipur through an e-mail dated
-5-
23-02-2023. It is also submitted that on receiving the said parawise
comments, the concerned authorities examined the representation along
with the facts of the case and the relevant materials provided by the State
Government of Manipur and the same was submitted to the Secretary
(Revenue) on 01-03-2023 and thereafter, the Secretary (Revenue) on
behalf of the Central Government, after carefully considering the material
facts on record, disposed of the representation submitted by the detenu on
13-03-2023 by issuing a Memorandum and the said Memorandum was
sent to the State authorities by sending an e-mail dated 13-03-2023 for due
communication to the detenu. The learned DSGI further submitted that
the authorities have expeditiously and with due diligence consider the
representation submitted by the detenu and there is no lapses on the part
of the authorities.
[6]
We have heard the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties and also carefully examined the materials
available on record.
[7]
In the present case, it is admittedly on record that the
representation dated 14-02-2023 submitted by the detenu was forwarded
by the State authorities to the respondents No. 3 and 4 on 16/17-02-2023
and subsequently, parawise comments was also forwarded to the Ministry
by the State Government of Manipur through an e-mail dated 22/23-022023. It is also an admitted fact that the representation dated 14-02-2023
along with the parawise comments which was received on 22/23-02-2023
was placed before the concerned authorities of the Central Government
i.e., the Secretary (Revenue) only on 01-03-2023, after about 7 (seven)
days from the date of receipt of the parawise comments and thereafter, the
Secretary (Revenue) of the Central Government disposed of the said
representation only on 13-03-2023 after about 13 (thirteen) days from the
date of receipt of the said representation by issuing a Memorandum dated
13-03-2023.
[8]
On careful examination of the record as well as the affidavit-in-
opposition filed by the respondents No. 3 and 4, we do not find any
-6-
explanation given by the respondents No. 3 and 4 about the delay in
disposing of the representation submitted by the petitioner. It has been
clearly held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Rajammal (supra)
that Article 22(5) of the Constitution mandates that the authority concerned
to whom detenu submitted his representation should be considered and
disposed of the same as expeditiously as possible and with a sense of
urgency without an avoidable delay. It has also been held by the Hon’ble
Apex Court that unexplained delay in disposal of the representation will be
a breach of the constitutional imperative and it will render the continued
detention impermissible and illegal.
[9]
In the present case, since no explanation had been given by the
concerned authorities for the delay in disposing of the representation, we
are of the considered view that such unexplained delay violates the
fundamental right of the detenu guaranteed under Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India and it vitiates the detention orders and renders the
detention impermissible and illegal. Accordingly, we hereby quashed and
set aside the impugned detention orders dated 12-01-2023 and the
impugned
confirmation
order
dated
24-02-2023
issued
by
the
Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur. We further direct the
respondents to release the detenu forthwith if his further detention is not
required in connection with any other cases.
With the aforesaid directions, the present petition is disposed of.
JUDGE
Devananda
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review