Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed
Ningo Digitally
by Ningombam
mbam Victoria
Date: 2026.06.09
Victoria 15:08:21 +05'30'
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024
Md. Abdul Latif, aged about 43 years, S/O Md. Abdul Hamid
of Kwakta Ward No. 8, P.O. & P.S. Moirang, Bishnupur
District, Manipur – 795134.
…Petitioner
- Versus 1. Food Corporation of India (FCI), Zonal Office (North
East), Guwahati represented by the Executive Director,
Guwahati, Assam – 781007.
2. Asst. General Manager (AGM), Personnel Division,
Zonal Office (NE), FCI, Guwahati, Assam – 781007.
…Respondents
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
B EF O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(ORAL)
06-06-2026
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Surendrajit, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Mr. B.K. Singh along with Mr. W. Darakeshwar, learned Standing Counsel
on behalf of Food Corporation of India (FCI).
[2]
By the present petition, the petitioner challenges (i) the Office
Order – 140/2024 dated 28-06-2024 issued by the Assistant General
Manager (Personnel), FCI extending the period of probation of the petitioner
for another year w.e.f. 12-07-2023 and (ii) the Office Order – 181/2024 dated
04-09-2024 issued by the Executive Director (NE), FCI reverting the
petitioner from the post of Manager (Accounts), FCI to the lower post of
Assistant Grade-I (A/Cs) for non-satisfactory performance during the two
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
years of probation. The main ground for challenge is that the probation
extension order dated 28-06-2024 w.e.f. 12-07-2023 for one year was
issued after more than eleven months of the expiry of one year of extension
and the reversion order dated 04-09-2024 is punitive, stigmatic and is done
without conducting enquiry.
[3]
The admitted brief fact of the present case is that the petitioner
was initially appointed as Assistant Grade-III (Accounts) in FCI vide order
dated 24-08-2009. Vide another order dated 29-10-2013, he was promoted
to the post of Assistant Grade-II (Accounts); by another order dated 22-052017, he was further promoted to the post of Assistant Grade-I (Accounts);
and vide subsequent order dated 01-07-2022, he was promoted to the post
of Manager (Accounts) in FCI. As per Regulation 15 of the Food Corporation
of India (Staff) Regulations, 1971 (in short, “Regulation”), a probation period
of one year is mandatory for regular appointments and for promotions
involving a change of category, but no probation is required for promotions
within the same category or for promotions beyond the post of Deputy
Manager in terms of Clause (1) of Regulation 15. As per Clause (2), the
appointing authority has the discretion to extend the probation period for a
period not exceeding one year. Clause (3) of Regulation 15 empowers the
appointing authority to discharge an employee from service in case of direct
recruit and revert to the lower post in case of promottee when the
performance during the probation period as well as the extended period of
probation is not satisfactory and as per Clause (4) of Regulation 15, an
employee will be confirmed only after successful satisfactory completion of
probation period. It is mentioned in the promotion order dated 01-07-2022
that the requirements of Regulation 15 for probation are noted in para Nos.
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
5, 6, 7 & 8 of the promotion order dated 01-07-2022. Scanned copies of the
Office Order – 140/2024 dated 28-06-2024 and Office Order – 181/2024
dated 04-09-2024 are reproduced below:—
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
[4]
Mr. N. Surendrajit, learned counsel for the petitioner, draws the
attention of this Court to the Circular No. EP-01-2023-14 dated 19-05-2023
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
issued by the Asst. General Manager (EP), FCI notifying the “Guidelines for
Probation and Confirmation”. Learned counsel for the petitioner, refers to
Clause 4 of the Circular to the fact that the probation report for the first year
should be written on the performance during that year and the report should
be submitted to the Appointing Authority within fifteen days. Clause 7 of the
Circular says that the probation period should be one year and under no
circumstance, it should not be extended beyond the double normal period,
i.e., the maximum probation period is two years. Clause 8 of the Circular
says that if the performance of the officer during the first year of probation is
not satisfactory, the same can be extended for a period not exceeding one
year and while extending the period of probation, the shortcomings should
be informed to the officer so that he should have suitable opportunity for
improving his performance. Clause 8 also says that in case the probation
period is not extended, the intimation of the shortcomings is not required.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also further refers to Clause 11 of the
Circular that in case of successful completion of probation within one year,
the probationer shall be confirmed and in case of unsuccessful, the
probation period may be extended by one year. Clause 18 of the Circular
says that confirmation shall take effect from the date immediately following
the satisfactory completion of the prescribed or extended probation period.
If no order of confirmation, discharging or reversion is issued within eight
weeks after expiry of double the normal period of prescribed period, the
employee shall be “deemed” to have successfully completed probation
under second limb of Clause 18 of the Circular. Mr. N. Surendrajit, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that the probation extension order dated
28-06-2024 is not in tune with requirement of Clause 8 of the Circular dated
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
19-05-2023, as the shortcomings mentioned in the extension order has not
been intimated to the petitioner in time. The extended probation period was
due to expire on 11-07-2024 and the extension order dated 28-06-2024
extending probation period by one year w.e.f. 12-07-2023 was issued prior
to 13 days of the expiry of the extended period. In other words, the extension
order was issued after the expiry of eleven months and seventeen days. In
the circumstances, the petitioner was not afforded with an effective
opportunity to rectify the shortcomings as mentioned in Clause 8 of the
Circular. Learned counsel for the petitioner has urged that the impugned
order dated 04-09-2024 reverting the petitioner from the post of Manager
(Accounts) to Assistant Grade-I (A/Cs) is punitive, stigmatic and is not a
reversion simpliciter. In para 2 of the Office Order – 181/2024 dated 04-092024, the pendency of a criminal case and disciplinary proceedings against
the petitioner is cited as one of the reasons for reversion and the same
cannot be done without conducting any enquiry under proviso to Article 311
(2) of the Constitution of India and the observation of unsatisfactory
performance within the extended period of probation cannot be sustained,
as the petitioner did not get any sufficient time for improving his
shortcomings, if any. It is pointed out that the shortcoming was intimated at
the fag end of expiry of two years, i.e., within thirteen days of expiry of the
extended probation period. In short, it is submitted that the reversion order
dated 04-09-2024 is punitive and stigmatic in nature; having been passed
without any enquiry and without affording any realistic opportunity for
improving the shortcomings; and the same also cannot be sustained. Mr. N.
Surendrajit, learned counsel for the petitioner refers to the following case
law to substantiate his plea:—
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
i)
In AIR 1962 SC 1711, S. Sukhbans Singh versus
State of Punjab (five-judge Bench), Extra Assistant
Commissioner was reverted to the post of Tehsildar
during the period of probation and the warning was
issued after one year of the impugned reversion
order and the five-judge constitution Bench of
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the reversion is
punitive and it violates the protection under proviso
to sub-clause (2) of Article 311 of the Constitution of
India.
ii)
In 1971 (1) SCC 790, K.H. Phadnis versus State of
Maharashtra (five-judge Bench), particularly in para
Nos. 12 and 17, it is held that the order of reversion
simpliciter will not amount to a reduction in rank or a
punishment. However, in the cited case, the
reversion was stigmatic on the ground that a
temporary employee who has been holding the post
for a long time has been reverted to the lower grade
without any enquiry.
iii)
(2000) 3 SCC 239, V.P. Ahuja versus State of
Punjab & Ors (para Nos. 7,8 9 & 10) — The twojudge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
a stigmatic reversion of a probationer cannot be
done without complying with the principles of natural
justice.
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
iv)
(2013) 16 SCC 59, Registrar General, High Court
of Gujarat & Anr. Versus Jayshree Chamanlal
Buddhbhatti — The two-judge Bench of Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that a limited enquiry for
considering suitability of the probationer can be
conducted. However, if other stigmatic allegation
arises, the protection contemplated under Article 311
(2) of the Constitution of India must be observed.
[5]
Mr. N. Surendrajit, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
in view of the above cited judgments, the impugned probation extension
order dated 28-06-2024 and the reversion order dated 04-09-2024 are
stigmatic, punitive in nature and the petitioner was not afforded with
sufficient time to rectify the shortcomings, if any, and the same deserve to
be set aside and the petitioner be restored to the post of Manager
(Accounts).
[6]
Mr. B.K. Singh, learned Standing Counsel for FCI, draws the
attention of this Court to Clause 18 of the Circular, particularly the provision
relating to deemed confirmation, which stipulates that an employee shall be
deemed to have successfully completed probation, if no order of
confirmation, discharge or reversion is issued within eight weeks of the
completion of double period of probation, i.e., two years. It is submitted that
the double period of the extended probation was to expire on 11-07-2024
and the impugned order of reversion dated 04-09-2024 was issued within
one day of expiry of the prescribed period of eight weeks within the meaning
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
of Clause 18 of the Circular and as such, the petitioner cannot now claim
“deemed confirmation”. With regard to the extension of probation, it is
submitted that the Office Order dated 26-08-2024 clearly mentioned that the
probation was extended as the performance of the petitioner was not
satisfactory in view of the probation report as well as the pending vigilance
status. Attention of this Court is drawn to the probation report pertaining to
the period from 12-07-2022 to 11-07-2023, annexed to the affidavit-inopposition filed by respondent Nos. 1 & 2 wherein a chart defined for
“correctional” is shown:—
“CORRECTIONAL
Defects noticed if any
Officer needs to improve on
interpersonal skills, he should control
his temper during official work.
Action taken by reporting Verbal warnings and advice given to
officer to guide and the officer.
correct
Suitability for the present If he can improve on certain things he
job
is suitable for present job.
Fitness for promotion
[7]
Based on the outcome of the pending
departmental proceedings and CBI
case decision may be taken.”
Learned Standing Counsel for FCI also refers to the contents of
para Nos. 9, 11 & 14 of the affidavit-in-opposition (counter affidavit) to
emphasize that the probation period of the petitioner was extended on
account of his unsatisfactory performance, his involvement in a criminal
case for bribery and the pendency of a departmental enquiry. It is also
submitted that all these reports/status are found in the portal maintained by
the FCI and the petitioner has conscious knowledge of the shortcomings,
his involvement in the criminal case and the pending department enquiry. It
is explained that the alleged non-disclosure of the shortcomings on time is
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
a mere technical plea. In conclusion, Mr. B.K. Singh, learned Standing
Counsel for FCI, concludes that in view of the “Circular on Probation and
Confirmation dated 19-05-2023” as reflected in the pleadings of FCI in its
affidavit-in-opposition, there is no inherent defect in the probation extension
order dated 28-06-2024 and the reversion order dated 04-09-2024. It is
prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed on these grounds.
[8]
Mr. B.K. Sharma, learned Standing Counsel for FCI, relies on the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India & Ors
versus P.S. Bhatt, (1981) 2 SCC 761 (particularly in para Nos. 7, 8 & 9) in
support of the proposition that reversion of a probationer for alleged inherent
behavior which has been duly notified to him, i.e., indulging loose talks and
use of filthy language against the superior officer, is neither stigmatic nor
punitive and is a reversion simpliciter. In the present case, the petitioner has
been reverted for unsatisfactory performance during the extended period of
probation and the factual aspect of his involvement in the criminal case and
the pendency of a departmental proceeding cannot be denied. Reversion
order is also not stigmatic.
[9]
This Court has perused the materials on record, the relevant
provisions of law, especially Food Corporation of India (Staff) Regulations,
1971 and the Circular on Probation/Confirmation dated 19-05-2023.
[10]
The short issues arising for consideration are — (i) whether the
impugned probation extension order dated 28-06-2024 is issued in terms of
Clauses 8 & 12 of the Circular dated 19-05-2023; and (ii) whether the order
of reversion dated 04-09-2024 is punitive and stigmatic in nature so as to
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
attract the mandatory provisions of proviso to sub-clause 2 Article 311 of the
Constitution of India. Before proceeding further, it will be apposite to extract
the relevant provisions of Regulation and Circular. Scanned copies of
Regulation 15 of FCI (Staff) Regulations, 1971 and Circular on
Probation/Confirmation dated 19-05-2023 are reproduced hereinbelow:—
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
[11]
From perusal of Regulation 15 of FCI (Staff) Regulations, 1971, it
is clear that the probationary period is provided herein — Clause (1) of
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
Regulation 15 says that the period of probation will be for one year and under
Clause (2), the Appointing Authority may in his discretion extend the
probation for a further period of not exceeding one year. Clause (3)
empowers the competent authority to discharge direct recruit who is not able
to satisfactory complete the probation period and the reversion of the
promottee to the lower post for the same reason and Clause (4) of
Regulation says that an employee shall be confirmed only after satisfactory
completion of his probation.
[12]
Clause 1 of the Circular on Probation and Confirmation stipulates
that assessment including character and aptitude of work is one of the
requirements in the probation report. Clause (3) of the Circular says that the
probation shall stand successfully completed upon the issuance of an order
in writing. However, it is not desirable that an employee be kept on probation
for long periods. Clause 7 of the Circular is in tune with Regulation 15 (2) of
FCI (Staff) Regulations, 1971 wherein it prescribes that probation is for one
year and may extend to another year. Clause 8 of the Circular is very
important and if the performance of the officer is not satisfactory during the
first year of probation, the authority may extend the same for a period not
exceeding one year by informing him about the shortcomings to his works
so that the officer will have suitable opportunity for improvement of his
performance. Unless there is an extension of the probation period, there is
no necessity of conveying the shortcomings to the officer. Clause 10 of the
Circular says that if an employee is unable to complete at least 75% of the
prescribed probation period because of availing permissible leave during
probation, the probation period may be extended by a duration equivalent to
the leave taken. However, such extension cannot exceed twice the
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
prescribed probation period. Clause 12 of the Circular prescribes time limit
for issuance of order extending period of probation for another year. Such
extension should be issued soon after expiry of initial period of probation,
but not exceeding eight weeks of completion of normal probation of one
year. Clause 13 empowers the Appointing Authority to revert an officer to
substantive post held by him if his performance is not satisfactory during the
probation or extended period of probation. Clause 18 of the Circular says
that the date of confirmation will be the day immediately following the
satisfactory completion of the period of probation or extended period of
probation. Clause 18 further says that there will be “deemed completion of
probation period” if no order of confirming, discharging or reverting the
employee is issued within eight weeks after the expiry of double the normal
period of prescribed probation. In other words, Clause 18 provides for
“deemed confirmation” on failure to issue an order of confirmation, discharge
or reversion within eight weeks from the date of expiry of two years of
probation.
[13]
The factual matrix of the present case has to be examined through
prism of the provisions of Regulation 15 of FCI (Staff) Regulation, 1971 and
the “Circular on Probation and Confirmation” dated 19-05-2023 and more
particularly, Clauses 8, 12 & 18 of the Circular.
[14]
For deciding the core issues in writ petition, this Court deems it
necessary to highlight Clause 8 of the Circular which provides that while
extending probation period for another year for an employee, the authority
should inform the officer about the shortcomings in his performance during
his first year of the probation so that he has ample opportunity to improve
and rectify such shortcomings. Clause 18 of the Circular stipulates that the
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
employee will be “deemed” to have completed the probation period, if no
order confirming, discharging or reverting the employee is issued within
eight weeks after the expiry of double the normal period prescribed for
probation. The issues involved in the present case hinge on these three
Clauses of the Circular, i.e., 8, 12 & 18. On careful perusal of the extension
of probation order dated 28-06-2024, the probation report and vigilance
status of the officer is clearly mentioned and the same is technically in tune
with the stipulation of Clause 8 of the Circular on Probation and
Confirmation. Likewise, the reversion order dated 04-09-2024 has been
issued within the stipulated time of eight weeks from the last date of
extended period of double probation period as provided by Clause 18. In the
present case, the extended period of probation expired on 11-07-2024 and
hence, the expiry of eight weeks period for issuance of an order under
Clause 18 of the Circular will fall on 05-09-2024. Admittedly, the order of
reversion issued on 04-09-2024 is within the stipulated period of eight weeks
as provided under Clause 18 of the Circular. In a strictly technical sense, it
is the submission of Mr. B.K. Singh, learned Standing Counsel for FCI to the
effect that in the probation extension order dated 28-06-2024, the
shortcomings are mentioned and the reversion order dated 04-09-2024 is
issued within the stipulated time of eight weeks.
[15]
However, on close scrutiny, the impugned probation extension
order dated 28-06-2024 does not meet the test of Clauses 8 & 12 of the
Circular. The very soul and substance of Clause 8 of Circular is that while
extending the period of probation of an officer for unsatisfactory performance
during the first year of his probation period, the shortcomings have to be
intimated to him so that he has a reasonable time to improve upon the
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
shortcomings and rectify the same. The object of Clause 8 is to provide an
opportunity to the employee to improve his performance. However, by the
impugned extension order dated 28-06-2024, the extension is with effect
from 12-07-2023. It may be noted that the extended period of extension is
to expire on 11-07-2024. In another words, the petitioner has hardly thirteen
days to improve his performance and rectify the shortcomings as mentioned
in the extension order. Besides, the extension order dated 28-06-2024 was
issued after fifty weeks of completion of initial period of probation and not
within eight weeks as stipulated under Clause 12. Technically, reasons are
given in the extension order. However, the very object of providing an
opportunity of rectifying his shortcomings and improvement of his
performance, has become illusory for the simple reason that the extension
order has been issued almost on the verge of expiry of the extended period
of probation. This Court is of the view that the extension order dated 28-062024 cannot be said to be in strict compliance with the stipulation contained
in Clauses 8 & 12 of the Circular. The employee is not afforded with a
reasonable and effective period to improve his efficiency. Extension order
was issued after fifty weeks in contravention of stipulated time of eight weeks
as provided by Clause 12.
[16]
With regard to contents of the reversion order dated 04-09-2024,
it will be clear from the plain reading of para Nos. 2 & 4 of the order that the
same is punitive and stigmatic in nature. It is quite apparent that the
reversion order was issued for his involvement in a criminal case initiated
against him and for pending disciplinary proceedings for alleged illegal
gratification. It is admitted fact that both the disciplinary proceedings and the
criminal case are pending before the competent authority and the findings
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
are yet to be arrived in these two proceedings. The reversion order dated
04-09-2024 was issued in exercise of power conferred under Regulation 15
(3) of FCI (Staff) Regulation, 1971 and in consonance with the Circular dated
19-05-2023. It may be noted that in the above cited cases, Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that simpliciter reversion order is permissible under the applicable
rules. However, if the order is punitive and stigmatic, the same has to be
tested on the edifice of the protection guaranteed to an employee by the
proviso to sub-clause (2) of the Article 311 of the Constitution. In the present
case, it may be proper to reproduce para 2 of the reversion order dated 0409-2024.
“And whereas the period of probation of Md Abdul Latif,
Manager (Accounts) was extended for a period of another 1 (one)
year w.e.f. 12.07.2023 vide ZO (NE) O/O No. 140/2024 dated
28.06.2024, due to non-completion of probation period satisfactorily
and initiation of departmental proceedings against him under
Regulation 58 of the FCI (Staff) Regulations, 1971, vide ZO (NE)
Memorandum No. ZO NE-26.0014.0/8/2023-VIG-ZO-NE dated
08.12.2023, for demanding illegal gratification and was caught redhanded by the CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) on 08.09.2023
and subsequently, FIR bearing No. RC0172023A0011 dated
08.09.2023 has been registered by the CBI;”
[17]
From a bare perusal of the para 2 of the impugned reversion order
dated 04-09-2024, it is apparent that the reversion is done mainly on the
ground of involvement of the petitioner in a criminal case and pending
disciplinary proceedings against him. It is already noted above that both the
proceedings are yet to be completed and there is no adverse finding against
the petitioner in the disciplinary proceedings except for the allegation of his
involvement in illegal gratification. The petitioner has not been convicted in
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
the criminal case. In the circumstances, this Court is of the view that the
impugned reversion order dated 04-09-2024 is stigmatic and punitive and
cannot be an order issued in exercise of Regulation 15 (3) of the FCI (Staff)
Regulation, 1971.
[18]
Accordingly, Office Order – 140/2024 dated 28-06-2024 issued by
the Assistant General Manager (Personnel), FCI extending the probation
period w.e.f. 12-07-2023 is set aside as the same is in violation of Clauses
8 & 12 of the Circular dated 19-05-2023 only on the ground that the petitioner
has not been given any sufficient and realistic time to rectify the
shortcomings mentioned in the extension order; the petitioner gets only
thirteen days; and extension order was not issued within eight weeks.
Further the Office order – 181/2024 dated 04-09-2024 issued by Executive
Director (NE), FCI reverting the petitioner from the post of Manager
(Accounts) to the lower post of Assistant Grade-I (A/Cs), is also set aside as
the same being punitive and stigmatic in nature and without conducting any
enquiry.
[19]
As a corollary, since the order of reversion dated 04-09-2024 is
set aside meaning thereby the same does not exist being nullity, it leads to
a situation that there is no order of confirmation, discharge or reversion of
the petitioner within the meaning of Clause 18 of the Circular dated 19-052023. In such situation, according to second limb of Clause 18 of the
Circular, this Court holds that the petitioner shall be “deemed to have
successfully completed the extended period of probation” and shall
consequently be “deemed to have been confirmed in service” within the
meaning of sub-clause (4) of Regulation 15 of FCI (Staff) Regulation, 1971
read with Clause 18 of the Circular.
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
[20]
Since the order of reversion is set aside, the petitioner is entitled
to his due salary and other service benefits in terms of the applicable rules.
[21]
Conclusion: In view of observations and directions, this Court
holds that:—
i) Office Order – 140/2024 dated 28-06-2024 issued by Assistant
General Manager (Personnel), FCI is set aside.
ii) Office Order – 181/2024 dated 04-09-2024 issued by the
Executive Director (NE), FCI reverting the petitioner from the
post of Manager (Accounts) to the post of Assistant Grade-I
(Accounts) is set aside. Petitioner is retained as Manager
(Accounts), FCI.
iii) The probation of the petitioner is deemed to be successfully
completed and the petitioner is deemed to be confirmed within
the meaning of Regulation 15 (4) of the FCI (Staff) Regulation
1971 read with Clause 18 of Circular w.e.f. 06-09-2024 (i.e.
eight weeks from 11-07-2024 date of expiry of extended period
of probation).
iv) The petitioner is entitled to his due salary and other service
benefits in terms of the applicable rules.
[22]
With the above observations and direction, the writ petition is
allowed and disposed of. MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024 is also closed. Cost
is made easy.
[23]
Before
parting,
it
may
be
appropriate
to
record
the
acknowledgement of this Court to the contribution made by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties in assisting this Court with the necessary
Regulation, Circular and case law.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Victoria
WP(C) No. 674 of 2024 &
MC(WP(C)) No. 566 of 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review