The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2026:BHC-AUG:46969 WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt WRIT PETITION NO.12128 OF 2026 Ori. Claimant : Matrix Life Science Pvt. Ltd. (formerly known as Matrix Fine Sciences Pvt. Ltd.) Through its Director, Mr. Ashok Ramkishan Sikchi Age: 73 years, Occ: Business, Having Registered Office at 12, Shilp Nagar, Railway Station Road, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad). ..VERSUS.. RESPONDENT : The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Ori. Respondent Through its Divisional Manager Having Office at 3rd Floor, ABC East Building, Near Prozone Mall, MIDC Chikalthana, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad). Mr. S. S. Rathi, Advocate for petitioner. Mr S. V. Adwant, Advocate for the Respondent. : ROHIT W. JOSHI, J. : 05.10.2026 JUDGMENT: 1) Heard finally with consent of learned advocates for the respective parties. 2) The present petition is filed in order to challenge order dated 13.08.2026 passed by the learned Sole Arbitrator, Justice P. R. Bora, in arbitration proceedings between the petitioner and respondent, thereby allowing the application WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt filed by the respondent/Insurance Company for filing evidence affidavits of all the witnesses that the petitioner/claimant intends to examine on its behalf simultaneously within a period of 15 days from the date of the said order. 3) The petitioner had initiated arbitration proceedings against the respondent seeking compensation under, “Stan…
17. 06.2026. It appears that the learned advocate for the WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt petitioner had stated that first evidence of an authorized officer of the petitioner-company would be filed and, if needed, two more witnesses will be examined. Learned advocate for the petitioner also stated that he will communicate the names of the witnesses to the learned advocate for the respondent in advance. It was decided that evidence affidavit of the first witness would be tendered on the next date of hearing before the Arbitral Tribunal. However, it does not appear from the minutes that it was expressly decided that affidavit of one witness at a time will be tendered. 16) The contention appears to be raised before this Court for the first time. Perusal of the reply filed to the application for directions to tender affidavits of all witnesses together will demonstrate that such a stand, that the parties had earlier agreed for tendering evidence of one witness at a time and the procedure agreed did not contemplate filing of affidavits of all witnesses together, is not raised in the reply. 17) Assuming the contention of Mr. Rathi to be correct, yet, in the considered opinion of this Court, the impugned WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt order does not fall within any of the categories prescribed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court warranting interference with procedural orders passed in pending arbitration pro…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:46969
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.12128 OF 2026
PETITIONER
Ori. Claimant
: Matrix Life Science Pvt. Ltd.
(formerly known as Matrix Fine Sciences
Pvt. Ltd.) Through its Director, Mr. Ashok
Ramkishan Sikchi Age: 73 years, Occ:
Business, Having Registered Office at 12,
Shilp Nagar, Railway Station Road,
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad).
..VERSUS..
RESPONDENT : The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
Ori. Respondent
Through its Divisional Manager Having
Office at 3rd Floor, ABC East Building,
Near Prozone Mall, MIDC Chikalthana,
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad).
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. S. S. Rathi, Advocate for petitioner.
Mr S. V. Adwant, Advocate for the Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM
: ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.
DATE
: 05.10.2026
JUDGMENT:
1)
Heard finally with consent of learned advocates for
the respective parties.
2)
The present petition is filed in order to challenge
order dated 13.08.2026 passed by the learned Sole Arbitrator,
Justice P. R. Bora, in arbitration proceedings between the
petitioner and respondent, thereby allowing the application
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
filed by the respondent/Insurance Company for filing
evidence
affidavits
of
all
the
witnesses
that
the
petitioner/claimant intends to examine on its behalf
simultaneously within a period of 15 days from the date of
the said order.
3)
The petitioner had initiated arbitration proceedings
against
the
respondent
seeking
compensation
under,
“Standard Fire and Perils Policy”. After the petitioner and
respondent filed their statement of claim and statement of
defence, respectively, issues came to be framed by the learned
Arbitral Tribunal on 23.03.2026.
4)
On 17.06.2026, learned advocate for the petitioner
stated that it will first adduce evidence of an officer of the
petitioner who is conversant with the subject matter and, if
required, may also examine two more witnesses. The learned
advocate stated that names of the witnesses will be
communicated in advance to learned advocate for the
respondent/Insurance Company. It was further stated that
evidence affidavit of the first witness will be submitted on the
next date by serving a copy thereof to the learned advocate
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
for respondent one week in advance.
5)
On 07.07.2026, i.e. on the next date of hearing, the
petitioner sought further accommodation for filing of
evidence
affidavit
of
its
first
witness.
Request
for
adjournment was granted and hearing of arbitration was
adjourned to 17.07.2026. On 17.07.2026, affidavit of
examination-in-chief of the Managing Director of the
petitioner/company
was
filed.
Learned
advocate
for
respondent/insurance company sought accommodation in
order to peruse the affidavit and documents annexed thereto.
The proceeding was adjourned to 19.07.2026.
6)
The
respondent/insurance
company
filed
application before the Arbitral Tribunal inter alia, seeking
directions against the petitioner/claimant to file affidavits of
examination-in-chief of all the witnesses proposed to be
examined simultaneously. The said application is based on
Order XVIII Rule 4(1-A) to (1-C) of the Code of Civil
Procedure (hereinafter referred to as “the CPC” for brevity),
as made applicable to commercial suits filed under the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The said application was
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
opposed by the petitioner/ claimant contending that
provisions of the CPC are not applicable to arbitration
proceedings and that, once the petitioner/claimant was
permitted to file affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief of its
first witness, forcing it to file affidavits of all the witnesses
simultaneously will not be permissible. It was contended that
adopting such a course will help the respondent/insurance
company to improve its case by filling the gaps after crossexamination of witness No.1. It was also contended that
adopting such a course would curtail the substantive right of
the petitioner/claimant to lead evidence step by step.
7)
After hearing the parties, the learned Arbitral
Tribunal allowed the said application vide impugned order
dated 13.08.2026. The learned Tribunal has held that
although the proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal are not
strictly governed by the provisions of CPC and the Evidence
Act, the Arbitral Tribunal can be guided by the provisions of
CPC and the Evidence Act and that the underlying principles
of the said statutes are required to be followed. The learned
Arbitral Tribunal has also recorded that in the first meeting
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
held on 12.08.2025, it was decided that principles laid down
in CPC and the Evidence Act will be guiding factors for
conducting the arbitral proceedings. Having observed so, the
learned Tribunal has further observed that directing the
petitioner/claimant to file affidavits of all the witnesses
proposed to be examined simultaneously was necessary to
ensure procedural fairness. It is also recorded that it is not
necessary that all the witnesses whose affidavits are filed
must be examined. Lastly, it is directed that the same course
would be adopted even during the course of evidence by the
respondent/insurance company.
8)
Mr. Swapnil Rathi, learned Advocate for the
petitioner, argues that, in view of Section 19(1) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred
to as “the A&C Act” for brevity), the Arbitral Tribunal is not
bound by the provisions of CPC and the Evidence Act.
Drawing attention to section 19(2) of the A&C Act, the
learned advocate argues that the parties before the Arbitral
Tribunal are free to agree on the procedure to be followed in
arbitration proceedings. He contends that the minutes of
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
meeting dated 17.06.2026 will indicate that it was agreed
that the claimant/petitioner will file affidavit of examinationin-chief of the first witness and, thereafter, file further
affidavits of other witnesses, if needed. He contends that the
respondent had agreed to adopt this course and thereafter
had moved the application for directing filing of affidavits of
all
witnesses
simultaneously.
The
learned
advocate
vehemently argues that the application ought to have been
rejected since the same was against the agreed procedure as
determined by the parties mutually. The learned advocate has
placed reliance on judgment of this Court in the case of M/s.
Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. Vs. M/s. Interocean
Shipping (India) Pvt. Ltd.,1 to argue that, once the procedure
for conducting arbitration is decided between the parties,
such procedure can be modified or altered only by the parties
mutually and that, in the absence of such modification or
alteration, the Arbitral Tribunal is bound to follow the
procedure agreed upon. The learned advocate, therefore,
submits that the impugned order, which discards the agreed
procedure for recording evidence as is reflected in the
AIROnline 2018 Bom 270
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
minutes of meeting dated 17.06.2026 cannot be sustained.
9)
Mr. Adwant, learned advocate for the respondent
raises a preliminary objection to maintainability of the
petition. He places reliance on judgment of the Supreme
Court in the case of SBP and Co. Vs. Patel Engineering Ltd.,
and anr,2 to contend that procedural orders passed by an
Arbitral Tribunal cannot be challenged by invoking Article
226 or 227 of the Constitution of India. Apart from this,
reliance is also placed on judgments of the Delhi High Court
in VRS Natarajan Vs. Oyo Hotels and Homes Pvt Ltd, 3 Easy
Trip Planners Ltd. Vs. One97 Communications Ltd., 4 and in
the case of Railtel Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Primatel
Fibcom Ltd.,5. Mr. Adwant would argue that unless the
petitioner establishes a case of bad faith or a case that it
would be rendered remediless if the petition is not
entertained, interference at the hands of this Court with a
procedural order passed by the learned Arbitral Tribunal is
not permissible. The learned advocate contends that the
(2005) 8 SCC 618
2022:DHC:3461,
2022 SCC OnLine Del 2186
2026:DHC:7171
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
impugned order merely directs mode in which affidavits have
to be tendered, which is a purely procedural order, challenge
to which cannot be entertained either under Article 226 or
227 of the Constitution of India. It is further contended that,
in the event the occasion arises, grounds of challenge in this
regard can be raised in a petition under Section 34 of the
A&C Act.
10)
Mr. Rathi places reliance on Division Bench
judgment of this Court in the matter of Shri Guru Govind
Singhji Institute of Engineering and Technology Vs. M/s. Kay
Vee Enterprises,6 and argues that the Division Bench, after
considering the Supreme Court judgment in the case of Patel
Engineering (supra) and the judgment in the case of
L.
Chandra Kumar Vs. Union of India and others, 7 has
categorically held that power of judicial review vested with
this Court is a part of basic structure of the Constitution of
India and that said jurisdiction cannot be excluded by any
statutory provision such as Section 5 of the A&C Act. The
learned advocate draws attention to paragraph 24 of the
(Writ Petition No.9868 of 2024 decided at Aurangabad Bench on 05.12.2024)
(1997) 3 SCC 261
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
judgment to contend that the observations in
Patel
Engineering (supra) in relation to maintainability of a Writ
Petition cannot be construed as ratio of the said judgment
since the issue involved in the said case was with respect to
nature of jurisdiction of the Chief Justice or its designate
under Section 11 of the A&C Act. The learned advocate also
places reliance on another Division Bench judgment in the
case of Central Depositories Services (India) Limited and Ors.
Vs. Ketan Lalit Shah and Ors,8 in support of his contention
that jurisdiction of this Court to entertain a challenge against
interlocutory orders passed by Arbitral Tribunal is not
excluded by way of Section 5 of the said Act. Reliance is also
placed on judgment of Delhi High Court in Surender Kumar
Singhal and Ors. Vs. Arun Kumar Bhalotia and Ors, 9. It is his
contention that the learned Arbitral Tribunal has travelled
beyond its jurisdiction in altering the agreed procedure for
recording evidence. The learned advocate contends that the
preliminary objection should, therefore, be rejected.
11)
AIR 2025 Bom 185
AIR Online 2021 Del 415
The legal position which emerges from the
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
aforesaid judgments relied upon by the rival parties is that
jurisdiction of this Court to entertain a petition under Article
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India against orders
passed by an Arbitral Tribunal is not completely excluded.
However, while holding that petition against orders passed by
Arbitral Tribunal is maintainable and that Section 5 of the
A&C Act cannot bar entertaining such petitions, all the
judgments come with a caveat that High Courts should be
extremely slow in entertaining challenges to interlocutory
orders passed by Arbitral Tribunal. There is complete
unanimity that interference at the hands of this Court to
procedural orders should be restricted in cases where the
Arbitral Tribunal acts in bad faith, or failure to interfere
would result in rendering the petitioner remediless, or if the
order passed by the arbitrator is completely perverse, in the
sense that no reasonable person could have passed such an
order and such perversity is ex-facie apparent.
12)
As regards the scope of interference with an
interlocutory order passed in arbitration proceedings in a
petition filed under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
India, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Serosoft
Solutions Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Dexter Capital Advisors Pvt. Ltd., 10 has
held that interference by the High Court in proceedings
pending before the Arbitral Tribunal should be discouraged
and that it is not prudent to exercise jurisdiction under
Articles 226/227 in matters pending before the Arbitral
Tribunal. It is held that power under Article 226/227 must be
exercised in case of exceptional rarity or in case of bad faith
or only if the order is completely perverse and perversity
stares on the face of the order. This view of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court is followed by this Court in the Case of Ketan
Lalit Shah (supra). In the light of authorities cited by both the
learned advocates, it must be held that there cannot be a
blanket bar on entertaining writ petitions challenging
interlocutory orders passed by Arbitral Tribunal. However,
interference must be restricted to cases wherein order reflects
exercise of power in bad faith or is absolutely perverse on the
face of it or in cases of exceptional rarity or renders the
petitioner remediless
10 2025 SCC OnLine SC 22,
13)
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
The facts of the present case are required to be seen
in the backdrop of this legal position. The learned Arbitral
Tribunal has categorically recorded that in the preliminary
meeting held on 12.08.2025, it was agreed that principles
laid down in CPC and Evidence Act will be followed as
guiding factors. The learned Arbitral Tribunal has, vide the
impugned order, directed filing of affidavits of all witnesses
simultaneously, as is prescribed under Order XVIII Rule 4(1B) of the Code of Civil Procedure, as it is made applicable to
suits before Commercial Courts. The Arbitral Tribunal has
directed that the same course would be adopted during the
course of evidence of the respondent.
14)
However, Mr. Rathi, by drawing attention to the
minutes of meeting dated 17.06.2026, contends that the
agreed procedure was that evidence will be recorded step by
step and that direction to file affidavits of examination-inchief of all witnesses together results in alteration of the
agreed procedure without consent of the parties.
15)
I have perused the minutes of meeting dated
17.06.2026. It appears that the learned advocate for the
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
petitioner had stated that first evidence of an authorized
officer of the petitioner-company would be filed and, if
needed, two more witnesses will be examined. Learned
advocate for the petitioner also stated that he will
communicate the names of the witnesses to the learned
advocate for the respondent in advance. It was decided that
evidence affidavit of the first witness would be tendered on
the next date of hearing before the Arbitral Tribunal.
However, it does not appear from the minutes that it was
expressly decided that affidavit of one witness at a time will
be tendered.
16)
The contention appears to be raised before this
Court for the first time. Perusal of the reply filed to the
application for directions to tender affidavits of all witnesses
together will demonstrate that such a stand, that the parties
had earlier agreed for tendering evidence of one witness at a
time and the procedure agreed did not contemplate filing of
affidavits of all witnesses together, is not raised in the reply.
17)
Assuming the contention of Mr. Rathi to be correct,
yet, in the considered opinion of this Court, the impugned
WP. NO.12128 OF 2026.odt
order does not fall within any of the categories prescribed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court warranting interference with
procedural orders passed in pending arbitration proceedings.
18)
The learned Arbitral Tribunal has passed order
directing the parties to go by the procedure prescribed under
Order XVIII, Rule 4(1-B) of the CPC. The impugned order is
not likely to cause any irreparable damage to the case of the
petitioner. Apart from this, an appropriate ground of
challenge can be raised in a petition under Section 34 of the
A&C Act, if the occasion arises. It must be stated that even
Section 105 of the CPC provides that if an interlocutory order
is passed against a party to a suit, a ground that the order
was erroneously passed can be set up in the appeal to be filed
against the decree, if the occasion arises.
19)
In the light of aforesaid, in the considered opinion
of this Court, no case for interference is made out.
20)
Writ Petition is dismissed with no order as to costs.
(ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.)
Tαɳɱαყ...
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review