Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 30TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 1031 OF 2015
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 31.08.2014 IN OPMV NO.1806 OF 2008 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ,PERUMBAVOOR
APPELLANT:
JOSEPH
S/O. DEVASSY, KAITHARATHUCHIRA HOUSE, VADAKKUMBHAGAM,
MANJAPRA PO,ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682581
BY ADV SRI.V.N.SUNIL KUMAR
RESPONDENTS:
MARIYAMMA
AGED 52 YEARS
W/O. ALIYAS,KOORAN HOUSE, ANGADIKADAVU, ANGAMALI
PO(MOTHEER OF DECEASED)PIN-683572
BAIJU SO. ALIYAS
AGED 34 YEARS
KOORAN OUSE, ANADIKADAVUT ANGAMALI PO, (BROTHER OF
DECEASED)PIN-6835723
REENA WO. SAJU
AGED 31 YEARS
PALAKKUDY HOUSE, LALLEKKADU KURUPPUMPADY, PERUMBAVOOR
PO, (SISTER OF DECEASED), PIN-683542
SAJI SO ALIYAS
AGED 29 YEARS
KOORAN OUSE, ANADIKADAVUT ANGAMALI PO, (BROTHER OF
DECEASED)PIN-6835723
JOSE K.D.
S/O. DEVASSY, 5/416(2/419) KAITHARATH HIOUSE,M
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
NADUMURUM, MANJAPRA PO, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT PIN683581
THE MANAGER THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, POALAKKATT BAUILDING, MARKET
JUNCTION, TRIPUNITHURA PIN-682301
BY ADV SRI.A.R.GEORGE-SC
OTHER PRESENT:
SMT. ANUPAMA JOHNY -APP.
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 19.02.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.1509/2015, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 30TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 1509 OF 2015
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED IN OPMV NO.1806 OF 2008 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,PERUMBAVOOR
APPELLANTS:
MARIYAMMA
AGED 56 YEARS
W/O. ALIAS, KOORAN HOUSE, ANGADIKKADAVU, ANGAMALY
P.O., (MOTHER OF THE DECEASED).
BAIJU
AGED 38 YEARS
S/O. ALIAS, KOORAN HOUSE, ANGADIKADAVU, ANGAMALY
P.O. (BROTHER OF THE DECEASED).
REENA
AGED 35 YEARS
W/O. SAJU, PALAKKUDY HOUSE, PALLEKKADU,
KURUPPAMPADY, PERUMBAVOOR. (SISTER OF THE
DECEASED).
SAJI
AGED 34 YEARS
S/O. ALIAS, KOORAN HOUSE, ANGADIKKADAVU, ANGAMALY
P.O., (BROTHER OF THE DECEASED).
BY ADVS.
SRI.REJI GEORGE
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
SMT.ANUPAMA JOHNY
RESPONDENTS:
JOSEPH
S/O. DEVASSY, KAITHARATHUCHIRA HOUSE,
VADAKUMBHAGAM, MANJAPRA P.O., ERNAKULAM-682 102.
JOSE K.D.
S/O. DEVASSY, 54/16(214/19), KAITHARATH HOUSE,
NADUMURI, MANJAPRA P.O., ERNAKULAM-682 102.
THE MANAGER
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., DIVISIONAL
OFFICE, PALAKKATT BUILDING, MARKET JUNCTION,
TRIPUNITHURA-682 531.
BY ADVS
SRI. A.R GEROGE -SC
SRI.V.N.SUNIL KUMAR
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 19.02.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.1031/2015, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 19th day of February, 2025
The petitioners in O.P.(M.V.) No. 1806/2008 on the file of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor, are the appellants in
M.A.C.A.No. 1509/2015. The 1st respondent in the O.P is the appellant in
M.A.C.A.No. 1031/2015. (For the purpose of convenience, the parties are
hereafter referred to as per their rank before the Tribunal)
2.
The O.P. was filed under under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, by the Mother and siblings of the deceased Eldho, who
died in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 19.10.2008. According to
them, on 19.10.2008, at about 9.15 p.m., while the deceased was riding a
motorcycle, a Tate Ace bearing Reg.No.KL-41/A-5262 driven by the 1 st
respondent in a rash and negligent manner, hit him down and as a result of
which he sustained serious injuries and later on he succumbed to the injuries,
on the same day, while under treatment.
3. The 1st respondent is the driver, the 2nd respondent is the owner
and 3rd respondent is the insurer of the offending vehicle. According to the
petitioners, the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
offending vehicle. The quantum of compensation claimed in the O.P. was
Rs.32,31,100/-(limited to Rs.30,00,000/-)
4. The insurance company filed a written statement, admitting the
accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on the part of the
driver of the offending vehicle.
5. The evidence in the case consists of the oral testimony of PW1
and documentary evidence Exts.A1 to A15 and B1 to B3.
6. After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal found
negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle, awarded a total
compensation of Rs.2,95,500/- and directed the insurer to pay the same.
7. Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal, the petitioners and the 1st respondent preferred these appeals.
8. Now the point that arises for consideration is the following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal is just
and reasonable?
9. Heard Sri. V.N Sunil Kumar , the learned Counsel appearing for
the petitioners/appellants, Smt. Anupama Johny, the learned Counsel
appearing for the respondents 1 & 2 and
Sri.A.R George, the learned
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
rd
Standing Counsel for the 3 respondent.
10. The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid policy of
the offending vehicle are admitted. One of the contentions raised by the
learned counsel for the petitioners is regarding the income of the deceased as
fixed by the Tribunal. According to him, the deceased was working as Welder
in UAE, getting a monthly income of more than Rs.28,000/-, but the Tribunal
fixed his monthly income at Rs.3500/-/-. The learned counsel for the insurer
would argue that the income fixed by the tribunal is reasonable.
11. In order to prove the income of the petitioners, he has relied
upon Ext.A13 certificate issued by the K.S.E.B and Ext.A8 employment
contract issued by the Lamprell Dubai LLC . Ext.A12 certificate issued by the
Ministry of Labour and Social affairs UAE and Ext.A10 passport. From
Ext.A10 passport it is revealed that the deceased returned from UAE to India
only on 18.10.2008, the day before the accident. In Exts. A9 it is stated that
the basic salary of the deceased was 2288 UAE Dhs
along with other
allowances. However, Exts.A8 and A9 documents were not seen attested by
the Embassy officials and as such they cannot be relied upon.
From Ext.A13 certificate issued by the K.S.E.B it is revealed that
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
the deceased was engaged as a Fitter-cum-X-ray Welder, under M/s.West
Coast Concrete products, the civil contractor of the Malankara Small Hydro
Electric Project of K.S.E.B during the period of 2004 and 2005. In Ext.A13 it
is further stated that, during his service he has attended various works relating
to fabrication and erection of steel penstock pipes, draft tube cones etc. It is
true that the petitioners could not prove the income of the deceased, as
claimed in the OP. From the above documents it can be seen that, the
deceased was a Welder by profession as claimed by the petitioners. As per the
dictum laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the decision in
Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co.
Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], the notional income of a coolie, during the year
2008 will come to Rs.6500/-. Therefore, considering the fact that the deceased
was a Welder by profession and he returned from abroad only on the day
prior to the accident, I am inclined to fix this notional income is fixed at Rs.
8000/-, for the purpose of computing the loss of dependency.
12. On the date of accident, the deceased was aged 26 years.
Therefore, 40% of the monthly income is liable to be added towards future
prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.Ltd v Pranay
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be applied is 17, as held in
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121. Since the
deceased was a bachelor who left behind only one dependent, towards
personal and living expense, 1/2 of the income is liable to be deducted, as
held in Sarla Verma (supra). In the above circumstances, the loss of
dependency will come to Rs.11,42,400/13. The learned counsel for the 1st respondent would argue that,
during the relevant period the 1st respondent had valid licence and as such the
tribunal was not justified in permitting the 3rd respondent to recover the
compensation from the 1st respondent.
14. The learned counsel for the 3rd respondent would argue that, on
an earlier occasion the 1st respondent had produced a fake driving licence.
However, Ext.B2 driving licence issued by the RTO Angamaly shows that,
the 1st respondent had valid driving licence with effect from 19.10.2007. Since
the date of the accident was on 19.10.2008 it is to be held that on the date of
the accident he had valid driving licence. Therefore the tribunal was not
justified in permitting the 3rd respondent to pay and recover the compensation
from the 1st respondent. Therefore the 1st respondent is liable to be exonerated
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
rd
and 3 respondent is to be directed to pay the compensation to the petitioners.
15. The Tribunal has awarded Rs.2,500/- towards loss of estate,
Rs.25,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.30,000/- towards love and affection
and towards loss of consortium the tribunal has not awarded any amount. In
the light of the decision in Pranay Sethi (supra), the appellants are entitled to
get a consolidated sum of Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses, and the dependents (parents, children and spouse)
are entitled to get a sum of Rs.40,000/- each towards loss of consortium, with
an increase of 10% in every three years. Therefore, towards loss of estate and
funeral expense they are entitled to get a sum of Rs.18,150/- each. Towards
loss of consortium, petitioners together are entitled to get a sum of
Rs.48,400/- (48,400 x1).
16. Since compensation for loss of consortium was given, further
compensation for love and affection cannot be granted,
in view of the
decision in New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Somwati and Others,
(2020)9 SCC 644. Therefore, the compensation awarded towards love and
affection is to be deducted.
17. No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other heads,
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and
reasonable.
18. Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to get a total
compensation of Rs.12,54,100/-, as modified and recalculated above and
given in the table below, for easy reference:
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Amount awarded by
Tribunal (in Rs.)
Amount Awarded in
Appeal (in Rs.)
Transport to hospital
Rs.1500/-
Rs.1500/-
Funeral expenses
Rs.25,000/-
Rs.18150/-
Loss of dependency
Rs.2,31,000/-
Rs.11,42,400/-
Pain and sufferings
Rs.5,000/-
Rs.25,000/-
Damage to clothes etc.
Rs.500/-
Rs.500/-
Love and affection
Rs.30,000/-
NIL
Loss of estate
Rs.2,500/-
Rs.18150/-
Loss of consortium
NIL
Rs.48,400/-
Total
Rs.2,95,500/-
Rs.12,54,100/-
Enhanced
Rs.9,58,600/-
19. In the result, these Appeals are dispose of directing the 3rd
respondent to deposit a total sum of Rs.12,54,100/-, (Rupees Twelve lakhs
fifty four thousand one hundred Only), less the amount already deposited, if
any, along with interest @ 8% per annum from the date of the petition till
realisation/deposit, with proportionate costs, within a period of two months
MACA NOs. 1031 of 2015
&1509 OF 2015
2025:KER:23017
from today.
20. On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall disburse
the entire amount to the petitioners, in the ratio fixed by the Tribunal,
excluding court fee payable, if any, without delay, as per rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
vnk/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review