The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Be that as it may, we find that the reasoning of the rent control court as well as the appellate court in rejecting the claim of bona fide need under Section 11(3) also does not inspire confidence in us. It is true that the landlord was in possession of another building. But it has come out in evidence that the same was occupied by other tenants. As regards the need projected by the landlord, we find that no evidence is let in by the tenant to discredit the need projected by the landlord. It is now settled law that the tenant cannot dictate the terms to the landlord as regards the need projected by him. Therefore, we are of the view that the reasoning given by the rent controller as well as by the appellate court on the 2025:KER:29296 RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019 bona fide need also needs to be interfered with. In the light of the compelling facts as disclosed in the report of the Advocate Commissioner, the learned counsel for the tenant submitted before this Court that his client is prepared to surrender the premises, provided a reasonable time is granted. We are of the view that such a request cannot be entertained by us in the light of the overwhelming facts disclosed before us by the report of the Advocate Commissioner, Smt.Lakshmi Sreedhar. Hence, we are of the view that the revision petitioner is entitled to succeed, especially since the appreciation of the evidence being perve…
8. In the result, we allow the revision petition, set aside the order/judgment of the rent controller in RCP No.2/2013 confirmed by the appellate court in RCA No.4/2015 and order eviction under Section 11(3) of the Act. We also take note of the fact that the tenant has ceased to occupy the premises during the pendency of the revision petition. However, considering the request made by the learned counsel for the respondent-tenant, we feel in the interest of justice, a period of two weeks from today can be granted for the tenant to vacate the premises. Accordingly, the respondent-tenant 2025:KER:29296 RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019 is directed to vacate the premises within a period of two weeks from today, failing which the revision petitioner can execute the order, in accordance with law. Ordered accordingly. Sd/DR.A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR, Sd/EASWARAN S., jg 2025:KER:29296 RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019 Annexure R1(a) CERTIFICATE DATED 14-08-2002 ISSUED BY THE CHAIRMAN & SUPERINTENDENT, DISTRICT HOSPITAL, KANNUR Annexure R1(b)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 09.07.2018 IN RCA NO.4 OF
2015 OF III ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, THALASSERY ARISING
OUT OF THE ORDER DATED 12.11.2014 IN RCP NO.2 OF 2013 OF
MUNSIFF’S COURT, THALIPARAMBA
REVISION PETITIONER/APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
MARAKKAVALAPPIL NAZEER
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O.IBRAHIMKUTTY, MARAKKAVALAPPIL HOUSE,
KADEEJA MANZIL, P.O.PAYANGADI R.S., KANNUR
TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.ABDUL RAOOF PALLIPATH
SRI.E.MOHAMMED SHAFI
SRI.K.R.AVINASH (KUNNATH)
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
ACHUMMANTAKATH ABDUL MAJEED
AGED 48 YEARS, S/O.MUHAMMADKUNHI, MADAYI
AMSOM, VENGARA DESOM, P.O.VENGARA, KANNUR
TALUK, KANNUR-670305.
BY ADV SRI.MAHESH V RAMAKRISHNAN
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV COMMISSIONER LAKSHMI SREEDHAR
THIS
ADMISSION
RENT
ON
CONTROL
REVISION
04.04.2025,
THE
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
DR. A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR, J. & EASWARAN S., J.
------------------------------R.C.R. No.138 of 2019
----------------------------------Dated this the 4th day of April, 2025
ORDER
Easwaran S., J.
The revision petition is filed by the landlord aggrieved by the
judgment of the Rent Control Appellate Aauthority (Additional
District Court-III), Thalassery, in RCA No.4/2015 dated 9.7.2018.
2.
The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the revision
petition are as follows:
The revision petitioner-landlord approached the rent control court,
Taliparamba with a petition under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the
Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (‘Act’, for
short).
The buildings in question originally belonged to Jameela
Beegam and the tenant obtained one room from Jameela Beegam on
6.10.1997 for a period of three months and another room for
conducting a travel agency on 21.2.1995 for six months.
On
2.12.2010, the revision petitioner purchased the petition schedule
buildings and ever since the respondent continued to be the tenant
under the revision petitioner. It was alleged that the tenant has
defaulted in payment of rent and the petitioner is in bona fide need
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
of the petition schedule buildings along with the adjacent buildings
in possession of Valiya Valappil Padinjarepurayil Haneef and
Pulimoottil C.L.Vasanthan for starting a furniture shop. Accordingly,
notice was issued to the respondent-tenant on 13.10.2012 and the
same was accepted on 17.10.2012, but the tenant did not vacate the
premises.
3.
The respondent-tenant entered appearance and objected
to the claim stating that the need projected by the landlord is not
bona fide.
On behalf of the revision petitioner, Exts.A1 to A6
documents were marked and PW1 was examined. The respondenttenant produced Ext.B1 extract of the building tax assessment
register and RW1 to RW3 were examined.
On appreciation of
evidence, the rent controller found that the petitioner could not
establish the contention that rent is due from 2.12.2010 and that the
need projected by the landlord was not bona fide and accordingly
dismissed the prayers under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the Act.
Aggrieved by the said order, the revision petitioner-landlord
preferred an appeal as RCA No.4/2015. In appeal, the finding under
Section 11(3) of the Act was affirmed, but however, the order of the
rent controller dismissing the claim under Section 11(2)(b) of the Act
was set aside and the landlord was granted eviction under Section
11(2)(b) of the Act.
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
4.
Dissatisfied with the findings rendered by the rent
control appellate court in RCA No.4/2015 confirming the findings of
the rent controller in RCP No.2/2013 on the bona fide need under
Section 11(3) of the Act, the landlord has come up with the present
revision petition. In the meantime, it is stated across the bar that
the other tenants have vacated the premises.
However, the
respondent alone is not evicted.
5.
Heard Sri.Abdul Raoof P., the learned counsel appearing
for the revision petitioner-landlord and Sri.Mahesh V.Ramakrishnan,
the learned counsel appearing for the respondent-tenant.
6.
When the matter was taken up for consideration on
21.2.2025, the learned counsel appearing for the revision petitionerlandlord asserted before this Court that the tenant has ceased to
occupy the tenanted premises and therefore, the revision petitioner
is entitled to get eviction of the tenant on the sole ground alone. At
the request of the revision petitioner, we appointed Smt.Lakshmi
Sreedhar as the Advocate Commissioner to ascertain the assertion
made by the revision petitioner.
Accordingly, the Advocate
Commissioner visited the tenanted premises on 22.2.2025.
The
Advocate Commissioner has filed a report dated 22.2.2025.
Paragraph Nos.5 to 7 of the said report are extracted hereunder for
reference:
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
“5. The rooms did not have electricity, and when
asked about this, the respondent explained that the
electricity supply had been disconnected the previous
night. The room contained two tables in a dilapidated
state, five chairs, a couple of tubelights, a printer that
appeared unused and was kept aside, a scanner kept on
the table without being connected to any power source,
two laptops, and a few discarded electronic devices,
including a CPU. Additionally, there was an exhaust fan.
The walls had visible marks and empty spaces, indicating
that air conditioners or some other fixtures might have
been removed.
6. The overall condition of the room was deplorable.
The tables were in poor condition, covered in mold. The
paint on the walls was peeling off, and there were visible
signs of significant deterioration, including water seepage.
When inquired about the operation of the travel agency
from the tenanted premises, the employees of Awwummas
Jewellery, located on the ground floor, stated that the
rooms had been shut for an extended period. They further
mentioned that the space had remained unoccupied for a
long time.
7. The petitioner pointed out that the respondent had
relocated his travel agency to the adjacent building and
has been conducting his business from there. To verify this
claim, an inspection was carried out from the balcony of
the petitioner’s building. From this vantage point, I could
see one travel agency namely, Kit Kat Tours & Travels
operating in the adjacent building.”
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
The facts as presented by the Advocate Commissioner speaks for
itself.
It is thus indisputable fact that the tenant had ceased to
occupy the tenanted premises during the pendency of the revision
petition and that a feeble attempt was made by the tenant to make it
appear that he is still in occupation of the tenanted premises.
However the Advocate commissioner who was present in the court
appraised us about the real facts which is reflected through her
report. Having come out that the tenant is running a business in a
different rented premises, we are of the view that the landlord has
made out a case for eviction on the ground of cessation of
occupation.
7.
Be that as it may, we find that the reasoning of the rent
control court as well as the appellate court in rejecting the claim of
bona fide need under Section 11(3) also does not inspire confidence
in us.
It is true that the landlord was in possession of another
building. But it has come out in evidence that the same was occupied
by other tenants. As regards the need projected by the landlord, we
find that no evidence is let in by the tenant to discredit the need
projected by the landlord.
It is now settled law that the tenant
cannot dictate the terms to the landlord as regards the need
projected by him. Therefore, we are of the view that the reasoning
given by the rent controller as well as by the appellate court on the
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
bona fide need also needs to be interfered with. In the light of the
compelling facts as disclosed in the report of the Advocate
Commissioner, the learned counsel for the tenant submitted before
this Court that his client is prepared to surrender the premises,
provided a reasonable time is granted. We are of the view that such
a request cannot be entertained by us in the light of the
overwhelming facts disclosed before us by the report of the Advocate
Commissioner, Smt.Lakshmi Sreedhar. Hence, we are of the view
that the revision petitioner is entitled to succeed, especially since
the appreciation of the evidence being perverse, which calls for
interference in the exercise of the revisional jurisdiction of the High
Court under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent
Control) Act, 1965.
8.
In the result, we allow the revision petition, set aside the
order/judgment of the rent controller in RCP No.2/2013 confirmed
by the appellate court in RCA No.4/2015 and order eviction under
Section 11(3) of the Act. We also take note of the fact that the tenant
has ceased to occupy the premises during the pendency of the
revision petition. However, considering the request made by the
learned counsel for the respondent-tenant, we feel in the interest of
justice, a period of two weeks from today can be granted for the
tenant to vacate the premises. Accordingly, the respondent-tenant
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
is directed to vacate the premises within a period of two weeks from
today, failing which the revision petitioner can execute the order, in
accordance with law.
Ordered accordingly.
Sd/DR.A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR,
JUDGE
Sd/EASWARAN S.,
JUDGE
jg
2025:KER:29296
RCREV. NO. 138 OF 2019
APPENDIX OF RCREV. 138/2019
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
WARRANT
WARRANT
NOTICE BY THE
NOTICE BY THE ADVOCATE COMMISSIONER
ADVOCATE
COMMISSIONER
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
Annexure R1(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE DISABILITY
CERTIFICATE DATED 14-08-2002 ISSUED
BY THE CHAIRMAN & SUPERINTENDENT,
DISTRICT HOSPITAL, KANNUR
Annexure R1(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE UNIQUE DISABILITY ID
ISSUED BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA TO
THIS RESPONDENT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review