Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU& KASHMIR AND LADAKH
ATSRINAGAR
SWP No. 873/2014
Reserved On: 17th of September, 2026.
Pronounced On:
5th of October, 2026.
Uploaded On:
5th of October, 2026.
Operative part or full Judgment:
Full.
1. Javed Ahmad Bhat (30 Years)
S/O Abdul Kareem Bhat
R/O Lalbazar, Hubby Colony,
Srinagar.
2. Mohammad Shafi Hajam (39 Years)
S/O Ghulam Rasool Hajam
R/O Garind Khurid, Budgam
3. Furhan Ahmad Chachoo (35 Years)
S/O Mohammad Yaseen Chachoo
R/O House No.2, Sector-B, Canal Avenue,
Rawalpora, Srinagar.
4. Danish Ahmad Khan (23 Years)
S/O Manzoor Ahmad Khan
R/O Devi Angan, Hawal, Srinagar.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. R. A. Bhat, Advocate.
V/S
1. Union of India,
Through Secretary to Government,
Ministry of Human Resources Development,
New Delhi.
2. Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
3. Registrar (Administration),
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
4. Director, Regional Service Division,
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
5. Regional Director, Regional Centre Srinagar,
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Mantoo House, Rajbagh, Srinagar.
6. Selection Committee through its Convener,
Regional Centre, Srinagar.
… Respondents
Through: Ms Yasmeen Jan, Advocate vice
Mr Tahir Majid Shamsi, DSGI for R-1; and
Mr Bilal Ahmad Malla, Advocate for R-2 to 6.
Clubbed With:
(i) SWP No. 1548/2014
1. Peerzada Adil Mehboob (29 Years)
S/O Peerzada Gh. Ahmed
R/O 143 Housing Colony,
Bagi Mehtab, Srinagar.
2. Gulzar Ahmed Bhat (35 Years)
S/O Gh. Mohammad Bhat
R/O Puchal, Pulwama.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr R. A. Bhat, Advocate.
V/S
1. Union of India,
Through Secretary to Government,
Ministry of Human Resources Development,
New Delhi.
2. Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
3. Registrar (Administration),
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
4. Director, Regional Services Division,
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
5. Regional Director, Regional Centre Srinagar,
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Mantoo House, Rajbagh, Srinagar.
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
6. Selection Committee through its Convener,
Regional IGNOU Centre, Srinagar.
… Respondents
Through: Ms Yasmeen Jan, Advocate vice
Mr Tahir Majid Shamsi, DSGI for R-1; and
Mr Bilal Ahmad Malla, Advocate for R-2 to 6.
(ii) WP (C) No. 2870/2019
Manpreet Kour (30 Years)
D/O S. Jatinder Singh
R/O Gogji Bagh, Srinagar.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr R. A. Bhat, Advocate.
V/S
1. Union of India,
Through Secretary to Government,
Ministry of Human Resources Development,
New Delhi.
2. Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
3. Registrar (Administration),
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
4. Director, Regional Services Division,
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Maidan Garh, New Delhi.
5. Regional Director, Regional Centre Srinagar,
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Mantoo House, Rajbagh, Srinagar.
6. Selection Committee through its Convener,
Regional Centre, Srinagar.
… Respondents
Through: Ms Yasmeen Jan, Advocate vice
Mr Tahir Majid Shamsi, DSGI for R-1; and
Mr Bilal Ahmad Malla, Advocate for R-2 to 6.
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(JUDGMENT)
01.
Since, in all the three above-titled connected Petitions,
common questions of facts as well as law are involved, therefore, it is
proposed to decide the same by this common Judgment.
02.
The Petitioners, in all these three connected Writ Petitions,
claiming to have been engaged on contractual basis in the RespondentIndira Gandhi National Open University, Srinagar Centre for its different
Sections, seek a direction upon the Respondents to treat and regularize them
as Group C/ Group D employees against the posts on which they have been
working since the date of their engagement, as well as to release and extend
all benefits to them, as are being given to other regular employees of the
Respondent-University performing the same job as that of the Petitioners,
including leave. The Petitioners are also seeking direction upon the
Respondents not to effect the break in service of the Petitioners after every
89 days and continue their services, till they are regularized/ confirmed.
03.
Upon notice having been issued, the Respondents have filed
their Objections, stating therein that the Petitioners have been engaged
purely on daily-wage basis as a stop-gap arrangement for seasonal work
arising during the course of admission and examination, against the posts
which otherwise are required to be filled up in accordance with the
conditions and provisions of the Recruitment Rules of 2010; that the
services of the Petitioners, being purely daily-wage and seasonal in nature,
cannot be regularized as such; that no regularization in favour of the
Petitioners can be done against the provisions of the Rules which are in
vogue and govern the functioning of the Respondent-University; that the
Petitioners, being ineligible in terms of the Rules, cannot claim any benefit,
much less regularization, against the posts as claimed in the Petitions; that it
is settled position of law that when a person enters a temporary employment
or gets engagement as a daily wager/ casual worker and the engagement is
not based on proper selection, he is deemed to be aware of the natural
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
consequences of such an employment, therefore, cannot invoke Writ
jurisdiction of this Court to seek regularization, inasmuch as all such posts
are required to be filled up by a proper recruitment process under the
relevant Statute.
04.
Mr R. A. Bhat, the learned Counsel appearing for Petitioners in
all these three connected Writ Petitions, submits that the Petitioners have
been engaged against the posts which were lying vacant in the RespondentUniversity (IGNOU), w.e.f. 2008 onwards, through a due process of
selection and that they are possessing the relevant qualifications with
respect to the posts which they are holding; that the principle of “equal pay
for equal work” is a well-established legal doctrine that emanates from
Article 39 (d) of the Constitution of India, which directs the State to ensure
that there is equal pay for equal work, therefore, the Petitioners, being
engaged to perform similar work to that of their other regular counterparts,
have a legitimate claim to equal pay.
05.
He further submits that the Respondents, in the year 2010,
have published Indira Gandhi National Open University (Non-Academic
Employes-Group-A, B & C) Recruitment & Promotional Rules 2010 and,
as per the said Rules, insofar as the post of Junior Assistant-cum-Typist is
concerned, promotion to the said post has to be way of 25% from MultiTasking Staff, who have rendered a minimum of five years of continuous
service in that grade with 10+2 or its equivalent with a typing speed of 40
words per minute in English or 35 words per minute in Hindi on computers,
and keeping in view this rule position, as well as the fact that the Petitioners
were appointed in 2008 onwards, as such, were to be designated as MultiTasking Staff, rendering them eligible to be promoted to the post of Junior
Assistant-cum-Typist under the said 25% quota, having rendered five years
of service in that cadre, however, the Department has failed to adhere to this
rule position.
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
06.
Mr Bilal Ahmad Malla, the learned Counsel appearing for
Respondents No.2 to 6, on the other hand, submits that the Petitioners No. 1
to 4 in SWP No. 873/2014 were engaged as Daily Wagers in the year 2013
and, immediately after their engagement, they approached this Court and
got interim orders, which are still in force; that in SWP No. 548/2014, the
Petitioner No. 1 has already left the services during the pendency of this
Writ Petition, whereafter, the Writ Petition got dismissed on 19th of
February, 2025 and only Petitioner No.2, namely, Gulzar Ahmad Bhat, filed
an application seeking restoration, whereafter the Writ Petition got restored;
that, likewise, in WP (C) No. 2870/2019, the said Writ Petition got
dismissed in default on 19th of February, 2025, whereafter, the Petitioner
got the Writ Petition restored, however, the Petitioner has not joined the
services after applying for maternity leave on 11th of March, 2025.
07.
He has further argued that the similarly situated employees of
the Respondent-University had sought the same and similar reliefs in the
identical Petition which was allowed by the Writ Court vide Judgment
dated 14th of March, 2016 and that against the said Judgement of the
learned Writ Court, the Respondents filed a Letters Patent Appeal, being
LPASW No. 91/2016, which came to be disposed on 3rd of April, 2024 by
the Division Bench, thereby setting aside the Judgment/Order of the Writ
Court and the Respondents were directed to consider the case of the
Petitioners for regularization of their respective employment/ engagement.
08.
He has next argued that the Petitioners are continuing on the
strength of interim Orders passed by this Court and that the Constitution
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the celebrated Judgment rendered
in Uma Devi's case has held that no right is accrued to an employee, if he/
she is continuing on the interim Orders and will not create equity in favour
of the concerned employee; that the Indira Gandhi National Open
University (Non- Academic Employees, Group-A, B & C) Recruitment and
Promotion Rules, 2010 are only applicable to such employees working on
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
regular/ temporary basis and do not apply to ad hoc appointments or daily
wages or contractual employees, whereas, the terms and conditions of the
engagement of the Petitioners herein, are governed by the engagement
orders and undertakings submitted by them at the time of their respective
engagements.
09.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties, perused the pleadings
available on record and considered the matter.
10.
At the outset, it needs to be mentioned that the similarly
engaged persons in the Respondent-University, as that of the Petitioners
herein, way back in the year 2009, had approached this Court by way of a
Writ Petition bearing SWP No. 1429/2009, seeking regularization of their
services. The said Writ Petition came to be disposed of, vide Order dated
14th of March, 2016, by holding that the Petitioners therein shall be deemed
to have been appointed on regular basis on the posts they stand appointed
on contractual basis. It was further held by this Court that the Petitioners
therein shall be given all service benefits, including salary, by treating them
to have been appointed on regular basis and that they shall be entitled to all
service benefits from the date of their appointment in pursuance to the
selection process undertaken by the Respondents.
11.
This Order of the Writ Court was assailed by the Respondent-
University in LPA No. 91/2016 before the Division Bench of this Court.
The Division Bench considered the matter and, ultimately, vide Judgment
dated 3rd of April, 2024, the Division Bench, while observing that it is not
clear that if the Respondent No.2-IGNOU’s Regional Centre Srinagar is a
permanent establishment then whether its administration and management
is meant to be carried out by adhocism by hiring and firing the work force,
held the Order of the Writ Court to be not sound, be it on facts and/ or law
and, accordingly, set aside the same.
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
12.
Having set aside the Order of the Writ Court, the Division
Bench, in terms of the aforesaid Judgment, also issued certain directions in
Paragraph No. 48, which read as under:
“48. However, that is not the end of the lis as we have held
that it is not clear to us that if the respondent No.2-IGNOU’s
Regional Centre Srinagar is meant to have regular permanent service
cadre as is borne out from the last engagement orders of the
petitioners issued on the basis of selection process conducted then
why the petitioners are reckoned to be dispensable after having put
in respective length of service qua the positions held by them and
gaining good working experience as against any raw manpower
intended to be hired through outsourcing mode of getting manpower
supplying agency, so we are inclined to subject the case of the
petitioners for the consideration of the respondent No.2-IGNOU’s
decision making authority whomsoever that may be and are
therefore coming up with the disposal of the letters patent appeal
bearing the outcome and observations as under:In the facts and circumstances above stated, we cannot
concur with the directions passed by the learned writ court in its
impugned judgment dated 14.03.2016. We hold that the learned writ
court came to dawn upon itself the power and position of the
employer i.e. respondent no. 2 – IGNOU in declaring the writ
petitioners to be deemed to have been appointed on regular basis on
the posts for which they came to be appointed on contractual basis
and accordingly directing grant of all service benefits including
salary in favour of the writ petitioners by reckoning their
appointment on regular basis. The learned writ court overstepped its
writ jurisdiction in positioning itself as the respondent no. 2 –
IGNOU. We accordingly set aside the directions given in the
impugned judgment.
However, we also come to hold that the petitioners have not
been treated with clarity and fairness by the writ respondents 2 to 5,
in particular by the respondent no. 2 – IGNOU.
The writ petitioners have invested good length of their life in
service of the running of the writ respondent no. 2 – IGNOU’s
Regional Centre Srinagar though by mode of getting engaged on
daily wage/contractual basis but the recurring continuation/renewal
of their respective engagement kept the functioning of the IGNOU
Regional Centre Srinagar and in the course of time implanted an
impression in the understanding of the writ petitioners that they are
quasi-permanent in terms of their employment in IGNOU Regional
Centre Srinagar.
We hold that respondent no. 2’s Regional Centres, in
particular in the North-East, Sikkim and J&K, are in permanent
establishment mode and, as such, have the cadre posts for
employment and that is the reason that the petitioners came to be
engaged and renewed in their engagement from time to time for
working on the respective posts though on daily wage/contractual
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
basis against the posts available. Therefore, it is for the Board of
Management of the respondent no. 2 – IGNOU to consider the
aspect as to whether long serving contractual employees like the
petitioners
can
be
regularized
in
terms
of
their
employment/engagement or not, and get a reasoned decision passed
thereupon keeping in view the policy and practice if any being
followed by the respondent no. 2 – IGNOU.
We, therefore, hold that till the Board of Management of the
respondent no. 2-IGNOU considers and decides about the
regularization
of
the
petitioners
in
their
respective
employment/engagement the petitioners shall continue to be in
employment/engagement in IGNOU Regional Centre Srinagar not to
be replaced by any mode of daily wagers/contractual employment or
through manpower supplying agencies.
The respondent no. 5 Regional Director, Regional Centre
Srinagar, IGNOU shall forward the case of the petitioners detailing
their respective length of employment/engagement against the posts
to the LPASW 91/2016 Page 28 of 28 Board of Management of the
respondent no. 2 – IGNOU within a period of one month whereupon
the Board of Management of the respondent no. 2 shall consider and
take a decision with respect to regularization of the petitioners in
their respective employment/engagement.
Any decision on the part of the Board of Management of the
respondent No.2-IGNOU to this effect in the event of being adverse
to the petitioners shall entitle the petitioners to avail appropriate
legal remedy as may be available at their respective end if they so
desire at their respective discretion.”
13.
From the perusal of the aforesaid Judgment rendered by the
Division Bench of this Court, it is clearly discernible that the issues
involved in the Petitions on hand have already been elaborately dealt with
therein and, therefore, the directions as passed therein are squarely
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present Writ Petitions. The
claim of the Petitioners seeking regularization of their services as also their
continuation in service have been specifically dealt with in the directions
passed by the Division Bench and, as such, it shall be appropriate to dispose
of these connected Petitions on the same lines.
14.
Viewed thus, all the above titled three Writ Petitions are
allowed and shall stand disposed of in terms of the directions issued by the
Division Bench in the aforesaid Judgment dated 3rd of May 2024, rendered
in LPASW No. 91/2016 and the cases of the present Petitioners shall be
SWP No. 873/2014 c/w
SWP No. 1548/2014
WP (C) No. 2870/2019
considered and dealt with in tune with the directions passed by the Division
Bench in the aforesaid Judgment dated 3rd of April 2024, more particularly
its Paragraph No. 48.
15.
All these three Writ Petitions shall stand disposed of,
accordingly, along with connected CM(s), in the above terms.
16.
Registry to place a copy of this Judgment on all these three
connected Writ Petitions, before being consigned to records.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
5th of October, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Raj Kumar
2026.10.05 16:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes/ No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review