Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITA YADAV
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
WRIT APPEAL NO. 479 OF 2023
BETWEEN:MANIRAM OJHA (M.R. OJHA) S/O SHRI
PARMANAND OJHA, AGED 65 YEARS,
OCCUPATION – RETIRED FROM THE
POST OF O.A. GRADE-II, DIVISIONAL
OFFICE, ASHOK NAGAR, PRESENTLY
RESIDENT OF G-2, SHRI KRISHNA
PARADISE, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
….....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI D.P. SINGH – ADVOCATE)
AND
1. MADHYA PRADESH MADHYA KSHETRA
VIDYUT VITARAN COMPANY LIMITED
(GOVERNMENT OF M. P. UNDERTAKING),
NISHTHA PARIAR, GOVINDPURI, BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH) THROUGH ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR)
2. THE
CHIEF
GENERAL
MANAGER
(GWALIOR REGION), MADHYA PRADESH
MADHYA KSHETRA VIDYUT VITARAN
COMPANY LIMITED) GOVERNMENT OF
M.P.
UNDERTAKING),
MOTIJHEEL,
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. THE GENERAL MANAGER, MADHYA
PRADESH MADHYA KSHETRA VIDYUT
VITARAN
COMPANY
LIMITED,
(GOVERNMENT OF MP UNDERTAKING),
GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH).
4. THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (O &
M),
MADHYA
PRADESH
MADHYA
KSHETRA VIDYUT VITARAN COMPANY
LIMITED,
(GOVERNMENT
OF
MP
UNDERTAKING),
ASHOK
NAGAR,
DISTRICT ASHOK NAGAR
….....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI RAGHVENDRA DIXIT – ADVOCATE)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
03/01/2024
Delivered on
:
24/1/2024
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This petition having been heard and reserved for orders, coming
on for pronouncement this day, the Hon'ble Shri Justice Milind
Ramesh Phadke pronounced/passed the following:
JUDGMENT
The present intra-Court appeal under Section 2(1) of Madhya
Pradesh Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khandpeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005
has been filed by the petitioner assailing the order dated 13.03.2023
passed by learned Single Judge in Writ Petition No.25849 of 2018;
whereby, the learned Single Judge while exercising the writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, had not countenanced the
submissions of the petitioner that the moment delinquent denies the
charges, a regular inquiry under Sub-Rules (i) to (xxiii) of Rule 14 of
the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal)
Rules, 1966, is imperative and while placing reliance on the judgment
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in the matter of Smt.
Pratibha Mishra vs. State of MP & Others [Writ Appeal No. 383/2022,
decided on 15.07.2022], had dismissed the writ petition.
2.
Assailing the aforesaid order, reliance was placed by learned
counsel for the appellant/petitioner in the matter of O.K. Bhardwaj vs.
Union of India reported in (2001) 9 SCC 180 contending that when a
delinquent employee had denied the allegations made in the show cause
notice then the employer has no option except to conduct a fact finding
inquiry and when it is apparent that the show cause notice which was
duly replied by the appellant/petitioner denying the allegations had been
filed, then without conducting an inquiry, the Disciplinary Authority
could not had inflicted the penalty, thus while inflicting such penalty it
had failed to exercise its discretion fairly and impartially which has
caused serious prejudice to the appellant/petitioner.
3.
The other ground which has been raised by the counsel for the
appellant/petitioner is that the learned Writ Court had recorded a
perverse finding that looking to the allegations levelled against the
appellant/petitioner, they were not grave in nature and therefore, doesn't
want any documentary evidence to be submitted or there was no
requirement of regular inquiry,when the Disciplinary Authority had
inflicted the penalty without any proof of evidence or dealing with the
reply of the appellant/petitioner.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant/petitioner has further raised a
ground that the subjective satisfaction of the Disciplinary Authority is
open to judicial review and as it was wrongly held by the learned Single
Judge that since the Disciplinary Authority upon due consideration of
the nature of the charges had recorded its satisfaction, the same would
not be open for judicial review, is not correct, thus, would be subjected
to judicial review.
5.
With regard to the order passed by the Appellate Authority while
dismissing the appeal by non-speaking order, it was contended that the
said order is de-hors the provisions of law, as laid down by the Honb'le
Supreme Court in the matter of O.K. Bhardwaj vs. Union of India
(supra) and the order passed by the Division Bench of this Court in the
matter of Bholaram Soni vs. Union of India passed in Writ Petition
No.3021 of 2014, decided on 09.01.2015 and in the matter of Dr. Arun
Dubey vs. State of M.P. passed in Writ Appeal No.369 of 2017,
decided on 28.11.2017. It was thus contended that the impugned order
is per-se illegal and deserves to be set aside and the matter is relegated
to the Appellate Authority for its fresh consideration.
6.
Per contra, Shri Raghvendra Dixit – Advocate appearing for the
respondents while placing reliance on the order dated 08.09.2020 passed
by Division Bench of this Court in the matter of Ratan Singh Silawat
and Others vs. State of M.P. & Others had submitted that the decision
of O.K. Bhardwaj vs. Union of India (supra) is cited very often for the
proposition that even if charge-sheet is for minor punishment, if the
delinquent employee denies the charges which are factual in nature,
then it is incumbent upon the Disciplinary Authority to conduct fullfledged inquiry under Rule 14 of the
M.P. Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 failing which, the
order of punishment would be vitiated but while considering the effect
of decision of O.K. Bhardwaj vs. Union of India (supra), the Division
Bench of this Court in above matter had held that the proposition of law
as laid down doesn't apply in a case where withholding of increments is
non-cumulative, as the decision of O.K. Bhardwaj vs. Union of India
(supra) was a case arising out of a judgment where while dismissing the
petition of the employee, it was held that since withholding of
increments of pay with cumulative effect was a minor penalty under the
relevant Rules, the need for full-fledged inquiry gets obviated, as
whenever stoppage of increment is imposed cumulatively, it causes
permanent dent/depreciation in the salary of the delinquent employee
which further adversely affects the pensionary benefits for all times to
come. While on the other hand, if withholding of increments is noncumulative then same is restored to delinquent employee after expiry of
the period of withholding, causing no adverse affect upon the
salary/pensionary benefits.
7.
In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the petitioner
had further placed on the order dated 02.01.2018 passed by the Division
Bench of this Court in the matter of Union of India & Others vs. Ajay
Agrawal [M.P. Nos.1798 of 2017 and 1799 of 2017].
8.
On the premise of the aforesaid submissions, it was contended
that the present appeal being devoid of any substance is liable to be
dismissed.
9.
After hearing counsel for the parties and going through the
judgments cited by the parties and the judgment relied upon by the
learned Writ Court in the matter of Smt. Pratibha Mishra vs. State of
MP (supra), this Court finds that the decision of O.K. Bhardwaj vs.
Union of India (supra) relied upon by the appellant/petitioner was a
case arising out of a judgment of Delhi High Court where the High
Court while dismissing the petition of the employee held that since
withholding of increments of pay with cumulative effect was a minor
penalty under the relevant Rules, the need for full-fledged inquiry gets
obviated. The Apex court in the matter of O.K. Bhardwaj vs. Union of
India (supra) while upturning the decision of Delhi High Court held
otherwise. This aspect has been considered by the Division Bench of
this Court in the matter of Smt. Pratibha Mishra vs. State of MP
(supra) and Ratan Singh Silawat and Others vs. State of M.P. (supra)
and it had been held that the misconduct did not relate to any heavy
financial loss to the government which may have led to imposing heavy
financial burden of recovery from the petitioner or the nature of charges
were not such which could be termed as complicated or involving
complex factual matrix which could be proved only by holding of fullfledged inquiry and there was no requirement of conducting a regular
inquiry in the matter as contemplated under Sub-Rules (i) to (xxiii) of
Rule 14 of the Rules of 1966.
10.
Further, the learned Single Judge while passing the impugned
order had observed that the allegations made against the petitioner were
not of such grave nature either to involve moral turpitude or misconduct
of the nature of embezzlement/misappropriation of public funds, forgery
or fraud or destroying official documents or manipulation causing loss
to the respondents which require factual adjudication based on oral or
documentary evidence warranting a regular inquiry, which to this Court
appears to be in consonance with the principles of law laid down by the
Division Bench in the judgment cited above.
11.
With regard to the contention that the satisfaction recorded by the
Disciplinary Authority is open to judicial review is not denied but the
said subjected satisfaction by itself is not open for judicial review unless
the said subjected satisfaction is clothed with perversity of approach or
based upon some extraneous considerations, but neither the aforesaid
aspect has been pleaded or argued; thus, this Court doesn't find any
reason to go into the aforesaid aspect.
12.
Consequently, the admission is declined and the appeal is hereby
dismissed.
(SUNIT YADAV)
JUDGE
pwn*
PAWAN
KUMAR
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=b864d1ab4ace2215bfcf3ab301c34d631287f1b1cdd90b4a49f265f02d9d593f,
postalCode=474001, st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=61B9D129971D2EA4FD4455ED49EA436EA65E26164BEEED89153191C56E
98CE21, cn=PAWAN KUMAR
Date: 2024.01.30 16:49:14 +05'30'
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review