The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. The reliefs to which the petitioner is directly entitled when denied, the petitioner cannot find out an alternate means in order to obtain the main relief which is denied. When he is not entitled for direct relief, he is not equally entitled to claim the said relief indirectly. For the reasons indicated above the present criminal petition is dismissed as not maintainable.
15. With the above observation and directions, the instant Criminal petition stands dismissed. As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stand closed. Paritosh 14:17:43 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.Petn. 32 of 2023
Manir Ali,
S/o Late Suraj Ali
Resident of Ichai Joypur,
P.S Kadamtala, North Tripura
- --------Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Home Secretary,
Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex
P.O Kunjaban-799001
2. Rakman Ali,
S/o. Late Suraj Ali
Resident of Ichai Joypur,
P.S Kadamtala, North Tripura
-------Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and
date of delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. D C Roy, Advocate
Mr. R. Dutta, P.P
12.01.2024
Yes/No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & order (Oral)
This a petition filed under Section 482 of the Criminal
Procedure Code 1973 for exercising the inherent power of this
Court against the Judgment dated 29.08.2023 passed by the
Hon’ble Chief Justice in Crl. Rev. Petition No.46 of 2023.
2.
The brief facts of this case is that on 22.07.2016 at
about 9 a.m at Ichai Jaipur, the informant, Rakman Ali and his
family members noticed that one Asit Nath was ploughing the
land of the informant using a power tiller as per instruction of the
accused persons. After noticing, the informant and his family
members immediately raised objection and Asit Nath left that
place. Thereafter, while the informant, his son Maharam Ali and
daughters Rajna Begam and Rumena Begam were returning
home, accused Gyash Uddin attacked Rumena Begum and while
saving his sister, Maharam Ali was also assaulted by the accused
Gyash Uddin along with other accused persons. The informant
went to save his son and in course of that he was also assaulted
by the accused persons. The neighboring people on hearing the
hue and cry started coming to the place of occurrence and the
accused persons in the mean time managed to flee away from
there.
3.
The informant lodged an ejahar regarding the incident
with Kadamtala PS and based on the ejahar, Kadamtala PS case
No. 41 of 2016, was registered and the I.O. on completion of the
investigation submitted charge-sheet against all the six accused
persons named Md. Manir Ali, Md. Gyash Uddin, Md.Gufur Uddin,
Md. Jainual Uddin, Md. Tajamul Ali and Md. Cherag Uddin U/Ss341/325/506/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860,(hereinafter
referred as IPC). The than learned CJM on receipt of the chargesheet took cognizance of offence U/Ss-341/325/506/34 of IPC
and sent the case record to the Court of Judicial Magistrate (1 st
Class), Dharmanagar, North Tripura.
4.
Thereafter, the learned Judicial Magistrate (1st Class)
in PRC (WP) 100 of 2016 framed the charges under sections
341/325/506 read with Section 34 of the IPC
against all six
accused persons and the same was read over and explained to
them to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
The prosecution adduced as many as 12 witnesses to establish
the charges against the accused persons.
5.
On perusal of the evidence and materials on record
and on hearing the arguments of the Counsel of both sides, the
Learned Court below ordered the following:
“ORDER
21.
In the result, it is observed that the ingredients for the offence under
section-341 is established against all the accused persons and the offence
under section-325 of IPC is proved only against Md. Manir Ali.
Hence, the accused persons named Md. Manir Ali, Md. Gyash Uddin,
Md.Gufur Uddin, Md. Jainual Uddin, Md. Tajamul Ali and Md. Cherag Uddin are
convicted for the offence under section-341 of IPC and Md. Manir Ali is
convicted for the offence under section-325 of IPC. This court also arrived at
the conclusion that the prosecution has failed to prove its case against the
accused persons under section- 506 IPC.
22.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I am of the
opinion that it’s not a fit case to invoke the provision under section-360 of
Cr.P.C. or Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 as the accused persons had caused
injuries in grave to the victim. In order to prevail peace and to avoid such
occurrence, requires severity to have deterrent effect in the society.
23.
Later on, heard the convicts on the quantum of sentence. They
pleaded clemency and denied of perpetration of alleged offence.
24.
Hence, I sentenced each of convicts to pay a fine of Rs. 300/-(Rupees
five hundred) each for the offence under section-341 of IPC in default to suffer
Simple Imprisonment for fifteen days (15) each and for the offence under
section-325 IPC, the convict to undergo rigorous imprisonment of two months
along with fine of Rs. 2000/- in default to payment of fine to undergo rigorous
imprisonment of one 1 month.
25.
The fine money, if realised, to be given to the complainant/victim.
26.
Nazir is directed to keep safe custody of the fine money which is to be
handed over to the complainant.
27.
A bail bond of Rs. 30,000/-under the provision of section 389 Cr.P.C
has been filed by the convict Md. Manir Ali with one surety of the like amount
and also by the convicts named Md. Gyash Uddin, Md. Gufur Uddin, Md.
Jainual Uddin, Md. Tajamul Ali and Md. Cherag Uddin of an amount of Rs. 30,
000/-each.
28.
Thus, the period of detention shall remain suspended against him for
thirty days with a direction to submit the form of appeal by the convicts ,
failing which the law will take its own course.
29.
The bail bond under the provision of 437-A Cr. P.C. for the period of
appeal shall remain in force.
30.
Furnished a free copy of this judgment to the convicted accused
persons.
31.
6.
The case is disposed of on contest.”
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred an appeal
in the Court of the District & Sessions Judge, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar being Criminal Appeal No. 02 of 2022. Vide order
dated 25.07.2023, the learned first Appellate Court upheld and
affirmed the conviction and sentence as passed by the learned
Trial Court under Section 341 of the IPC is concerned. In so far
as the sentence of imprisonment and fine under Section 325 of
the
IPC
is
concerned,
it
has
been
modified
to
rigorous
imprisonment for two months along with fine of Rs.2000 (two
thousand) each under Section 323 of IPC and with default
stipulation.
7.
Thereafter, the petitioner along with others challenged
the judgment of learned First Appellate Court and has preferred
a petition before this Court bearing registration No. Criminal
Revision Petition no. 46 of 2023. Vide order dated 29.08.2023,
passed by the Hon’ble Chief Justice of this Court, the same was
disposed of in the following manner:“Considering the nature of the evidence and the sentence imposed
under Section 341 of IPC and Section 325 of IPC on the respective
accused persons, this
Court does not find any ground to interfere in
the findings of the learned Appellate Court. As such, the instant
revision petition is disposed of with the aforesaid modification in the
sentence part of the accused/petitioner No. 1, Md. Manir Ali.”
8.
Thereafter, the petitioner for moulding the reliefs has
curved out a new method by filing the present Criminal Petition
No. 32 of 2023
under Section 482 Cr.P.C., before this Court
seeking the following reliefs:“a. Admit this petition
b. Issue notice upon the respondents and
c. After hearing be pleased to release the petitioner as per provisions
of Section 360 Cr.P.C or the Probation of Offenders Act.
AND
D. Would be further pleased to modify the imprisonment to suffer 2
months simple imprisonments.
e. Further be pleased to direct the petitioner to pay fine only in
commensurate with the offence U/s 323 I.P.C”
9.
Heard Mr. D. C Roy, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr.
R. Dutta, learned Public Prosecutor,
appearing for the State-respondent.
10.
Mr. D. C Roy, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner repeatedly made his submission that this is only a petty
offence where a small rift was there between the complainants
and the petitioner. Due to such small issue, the petitioner has
been suffering from erroneous orders and is entitled for relief
from this Court. He further contended that court can always
invoke its inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C., and grant
relief to his client herein in this present criminal petition.
11.
On the other hand, Mr. R. Dutta, learned Public
Prosecutor has made his submission that the present petition
filed under Section 482 CrP.C is not maintainable and Section
362 of Cr.P.C
also comes in the way of the petitioner, as the
sentenced once passed cannot be altered. He also relied on the
judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court titled as State of Madhya
Pradesh v. Man Singh reported in (2019) 10 SCC 161, the
relevant portion of the same is quoted hereunder:
“7. It is well settled law that the High Court has no jurisdiction to
review its order either under Section 362 or under Section 482 CrPC.
The inherent power under Section 482 CrPC cannot be used by the
High Court to reopen or alter an order disposing of a petition decided
on merits. After disposing of a case on merits, the Court becomes
functus officio and Section 362 CrPC expressly bars review and
specifically provides that no court after it has signed its judgment
shall alter or review the same except
to correct a clerical or
arithmetical error. Recall of judgment would amount to alteration or
review of judgment which is not permissible under Section 362 CrPC.
It cannot be validated by the High Court invoking its inherent powers.”
12.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record.
13.
This Court is of the opinion that once the petitioner
has invited the order(s) from the court and the matter has ended
in finality, the petitioner cannot challenge the same. If aggrieved,
the
petitioner
can
approach
before
any
other
competent
forum/Court. But the petitioner by way of filing this petition has
approached this court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. This Court feels
that this is only chance litigation and the hands of this court are
tied under law and, accordingly, the petitioner is not entitled for
any relief which is sought for.
14.
The reliefs to which the petitioner is directly entitled
when denied, the petitioner cannot find out an alternate means in
order to obtain the main relief which is denied. When he is not
entitled for direct relief, he is not equally entitled to claim the said
relief indirectly. For the reasons indicated above the present
criminal petition is dismissed as not maintainable.
15.
With the above observation and directions, the instant
Criminal petition stands dismissed. As a sequel, stay if any stands
vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stand closed.
JUDGE
Paritosh
SABYASAC
HI GHOSH
SABYASACHI GHOSH
Date: 2024.01.22
14:17:43 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review