The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. As regards reliance placed upon by the learned counsel for the appellant on the order passed in other LAR is concerned, the application under Order 41, Rule 27 of CPC was filed and therefore that was judicial pronouncement. Even it was not brought to my notice that order passed in both the LARs was challenged or set aside by this Court. Therefore, once the judicial pronouncement from the same project is available, by way of application under Order 41, Rule 27 of CPC, the said order was placed on record and that there is no difficulty to consider the same and therefore, the contention of the learned counsel Mr. Sangle in respect of above contention is rejected for the reason that in those cases the order passed in LARs were FA No. 3507/11 directly tendered before the reference court. Here in this case, that is not fact. Hence, this court is of the view that the claimant is entitled to receive the compensation as was granted in L.A.R. No. 892/2005 i.e. Rs.827/- per R. Hence, Civil Application No. 7293/2017, seeking production of documents under Order 41, Rule 27 of C.P.C. is allowed considering the averments made in the application and disposed of. Applicant is permitted to produce on record the copy of judgment and order dated 28.6.2016 passed in LAR No. 892/2005 (Old No. 422/2001) by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Omerga, Dist. Osmanabad. Hence, the order. (i) The fi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:48871
FA No. 3507/11
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
906 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3507 OF 2011
BALBHIM SAYBANNA PATIL
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS
...
Advocate for Appellant : Mr. M.P. Tripathi
AGP for Respondent/State : Mr. S.N. Morampalle
Advocate for Respondent 3 : Mr. S.G. Sangle
...
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7293 OF 2017 IN FA/3507/2011
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11192 OF 2026 IN FA/3507/2011
…
CORAM
: SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.
Dated
: October 08, 2026
PER COURT :1.
As the acquisition proceeding is initiated in the year 1997, heard
finally with the consent of learned counsel for the respective parties.
2.
By this appeal, the appellant/original claimant assails the judgment
and order 29.1.2010 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Omerga in LAR No. 750/2005 (Old No. 186/2001), whereby the learned
reference court has enhanced the compensation, but not granted as claimed
by the appellant/original claimant.
3.
The lands of the claimant admeasuring 3 H. 93 R. from Gat No. 369
situated at village Kesarjawalga was acquired for Kesarjawalga Storage Tank
at village Kesarjawalga. Notification under section 4 of the Land Acquisition
Act came to be published on 21.4.1997. Declaration under section 6 of the
Act came to be published on 28.1.1999. The Special Land Acquisition Officer
(SLAO) has declared the award under section 11 of the Act on 27.12.1999
and granted compensation at the rate of Rs.31,000/- per H. and also
FA No. 3507/11
granted compensation towards the acquired trees. The claimant after
accepting the amount under protest filed references under section 18 of the
Act by contending that the SLAO has granted very meager compensation.
After considering the evidence on record, the learned reference court
enhanced compensation at the rate of Rs.45,000/- per H. Being dissatisfied
with the same, the present appeal is filed by the original claimant.
4.
Mr. Manish Tripathi, learned counsel for the appellant/claimant
submits that during the pendency of the present appeal, the reference court
has granted rate of Rs.827/- per R. for Jirayat land in LAR No. 892/2005
which arises from the same project, from the same notification and the
lands involved are also from the same village. He therefore submits that the
claimant is also entitled to receive the same rate on the ground of parity. As
of now, as per instructions, he submits that the order passed in LAR No.
892/2005 is not assailed by the other side or modified by this Court.
Therefore, he submits that in the present matter also, on the ground of
parity, the claimants are entitled to receive the same rate as was granted in
LAR No. 892/2005.
5.
Per contra, Mr. S.G. Sangle, learned counsel for the acquiring body/
respondent No. 3 and the learned AGP Mr. S.N. Morampalle for State submit
that as far as the rate enhanced by the reference court in the present first
appeal is concerned, it was just, proper and reasonable. They also fairly
submit that they have no instruction whether the order passed by the
reference court in LAR No. 892/2005 was challenged before this Court or set
aside by this Court. Mr. Sangle, learned counsel submits that in that matter
the learned reference court has relied upon the earlier order passed in LAR
No. 120/2008 and other connected matters decided on 3.6.2016. Mr.
FA No. 3507/11
Sangle, learned counsel further submits that even in LAR No. 120/2008, the
reference court has relied upon the sale instance, which was considered by
the SLAO and the rate was determined. He further submits that in LAR No.
120/2008 (supra) the sale instance which was relied by the reference court
was not proved and thus, by relying upon the order passed in LAR No.
120/2008 (supra) the reference court has passed order in LAR No.
892/2005 and therefore, the same cannot be made applicable in the present
matter. He further submits that as regards placing reliance on the order in
other LARs is concerned, that cannot be readily placed before this Court. In
support of his contention he relied upon para Nos. 14 to 17 in the case of
Manoj Kumar Etc. Vs. State of Haryana, reported in AIR 2018 (Supp) 247 :“14. In our opinion, the High Court could not have placed
an outright reliance on the decision of Swaran Singh’s case,
without considering the nature of transaction relied upon in
the said decision. The decision could not have been applied
ipso facto to the facts of the instant case. In such cases,
where such judgments/awards are relied on as evidence,
though they are relevant, but cannot be said to be binding
with respect to the determination of the price, that has to
depend on the evidence adduced in the case. However, in
the instant case, it appears that the land in Swaran Singh’s
case was situated just across the road as observed by the
High Court as such it is relevant evidence but not binding. As
such it could have been taken into consideration due to the
nearness of the area, but at the same time what was the
nature of the transaction relied upon in the said case was
also required to be looked into in an objective manner. Such
decisions in other cases cannot be adopted without
examining the basis for determining compensation whether
sale transaction referred to therein can be relied upon or not
and what was the distance, size and also bonafide nature of
transaction before such judgments/awards are relied on for
deciding the subsequent cases. It is not open to accepting
determination in a mechanical manner without considering
the merit. Such determination cannot be said to be binding.
We have come across several decisions where the High Court
FA No. 3507/11
is adopting the previous decisions as binding. The
determination of compensation in each case depends upon
the nature of land and what is the evidence adduced in each
case, may be that better evidence has been adduced in later
case regarding the actual value of property and subsequent
sale deeds after the award and before preliminary
notification under section 4 are also to be considered, if filed.
It is not proper to ignore the evidence adduced in the case
at hand. The compensation cannot be determined by blindly
following the previous award/judgment. It has to be
considered only a piece of evidence not beyond that. Court
has to apply the judicial mind and is supposed not to follow
the previous awards without due consideration of the facts
and circumstances and evidence adduced in the case in
question. The current value reflected by comparable sale
deeds is more reliable and binding for determination of
compensation in such cases award/judgment relating to an
acquisition made before 5 to 10 years cannot form the safe
basis for determining compensation.
15.
The awards and judgment in the cases of others not
being inter parties are not binding as precedents. Recently,
we have seen the trend of the courts to follow them blindly
probably under the misconception of the concept of equality
and fair treatment. The courts are being swayed away and
this approach in the absence of and similar nature and
situation of land is causing more injustice and tantamount to
giving equal treatment in the case of unequal’s. As per
situation of a village, nature of land its value differ from the
distance to distance even two to three-kilometer distance
may also make the material difference in value. Land
abutting Highway may fetch higher value but not land
situated in interior villages.
16.
The previous awards/judgments are the only piece of
evidence at par with comparative sale transactions. The
similarity of the land covered by previous judgment/award is
required to be proved like any other comparative exemplar.
In case previous award/judgment is based on exemplar,
which is not similar or acceptable, previous award/judgment
of court cannot be said to be binding. Such determination
has to be out rightly rejected. In case some mistake has
been done in awarding compensation, it cannot be followed
on the ground of parity an illegality cannot be perpetuated.
FA No. 3507/11
Such award/judgment would be wholly irrelevant.
17.
There is yet another serious infirmity seen in following
the judgment or award passed in acquisition made before 10
to 12 years and price is being determined on that basis by
giving either flat increase or cumulative increase as per the
choice of individual Judge without going into the factual
scenario. The said method of determining compensation is
available only when there is absence of sale transaction
before issuance of notification under section 4 of the Act and
for giving annual increase, evidence should reflect that price
of land had appreciated regularly and did not remain static.
The Recent trend for last several years indicates that price of
land is more or less static if it has not gone down. At
present, there is no appreciation of value. Thus, in our
opinion, it is not a very safe method of determining
compensation.”
He further relied upon para 19 of the order passed by the Division Bench of
this Court in First Appeal No. 253/2015 (The Executive Engineer Vs. The
State of Maharashtra and Ors.) and other connected matters decided on
4.5.2023, which is as under :“19. Now, the question would be what could be the
adequate compensation. We have already held that the sale
instances were not proper and sufficient to grant the rate of
the land as demanded by the claimants. Certainly the
reference Court erred in this aspect. Another fact to be
noted is that reliance has been placed on some other
decision i.e. L.A.R. Nos.216 of 2010 as well as 131 of 1997.
The first and the foremost fact which has to be mentioned
here that the certified copy of the judgment in L.A.R. No.131
of 1997 appears to be not produced by the claimants, as it is
not on record and it has not been marked exhibit. The trial
Court totally erred in considering that evidence, which was
not produced by either parties. The reference Court on its
own and without bringing the fact to the notice of the parties
cannot rely upon a piece of evidence by either calling the
original record from the another matter or by any other
means. If an opportunity would have been given to both
sides to put forth their say on the said judgment in L.A.R.
FA No. 3507/11
No.131 of 1997, they would have brought on record
something in their support. We do not know which land was
acquired in L.A.R. No.131 of 1997. It appears that in the
course of arguments, the learned Advocate for the claimants
had made the said prayer that the earlier award in L.A.R.
No.131 of 1997 should be considered. The procedure that is
adopted by the learned reference Court is totally wrong. At
the cost of repetition, we would say that the reference Court
erred in considering that piece of evidence which was not led
by both the claimants. If such shortcut is allowed to be
adopted, then we may not even require provisions of Indian
Evidence Act. The evidence has to be led by any party to a
litigation within the four corners of the Indian Evidence Act
and then only the same can be considered by the Courts of
law.”
He further placed reliance on the law laid down by the Apex Court in the
case of Chimanlal Hargovinddas Vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poon
reported in (1988) 2 SCC 751, which reads as under :“4.
The following factors must be etched on the mental screen:
(1)
A reference under section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act is
not an appeal against the award and the Court cannot take into
account the material relied upon by the Land Acquisition officer in
his Award unless the same material is produced and proved
before the Court.
(2)
So also the Award of the Land Acquisition officer is not to
be treated as a judgment of the trial Court open or exposed to
challenge before the Court hearing the Reference. It is merely an
offer made by the Land Acquisition officer and the material
utilised by him for making his valuation cannot be utilised by the
Court unless produced and proved before it. It is not the function
of the Court to suit in appeal against the Award, approve or
disapprove its reasoning, or correct its error or affirm, modify or
reverse the conclusion reached by the Land Acquisition officer, as
if it were an appellate court.
(3)
The Court has to treat the reference as an original
proceeding before it and determine the market value afresh on
the basis of the material produced before it. ”
Thus, he submits that the order passed in LAR No. 892/2005 cannot
be accepted as it is as the claimants are required to prove the same.
6.
FA No. 3507/11
Having heard the learned counsel for respective parties, I have gone
through the record and proceedings. The issue involved in the present
appeal is under very narrow campas. There is no dispute about the fact that
the land in the present matter was acquired from village Kesarjawalga for
Kesarjawalga Storage Tank and the land from the LAR No. 892/2005 was
also acquired for the same project and from the same village, but by way of
different notification under section 4 i.e. 29.5.1997, which came to be
issued after one month of the notification issued in the present matter. It
appears that during the pendency of the present appeal, LAR No. 892/2005
which arises from the same project, from the same village, the reference
court has enhanced compensation by relying upon the order passed in LAR
No. 120/2008 (supra), which also arise from the same project, from the
same village and from the same notification as was involved in LAR No.
892/2005. One thing need to be kept in mind that the lands involved in the
present matter and the above LARs are acquired for the same project, from
the same village, though by the different notifications.
7.
As regards reliance placed upon by the learned counsel for the
appellant on the order passed in other LAR is concerned, the application
under Order 41, Rule 27 of CPC was filed and therefore that was judicial
pronouncement. Even it was not brought to my notice that order passed in
both the LARs was challenged or set aside by this Court. Therefore, once
the judicial pronouncement from the same project is available, by way of
application under Order 41, Rule 27 of CPC, the said order was placed on
record and that there is no difficulty to consider the same and therefore, the
contention of the learned counsel Mr. Sangle in respect of above contention
is rejected for the reason that in those cases the order passed in LARs were
FA No. 3507/11
directly tendered before the reference court. Here in this case, that is not
fact. Hence, this court is of the view that the claimant is entitled to receive
the compensation as was granted in L.A.R. No. 892/2005 i.e. Rs.827/- per
R. Hence, Civil Application No. 7293/2017, seeking production of documents
under Order 41, Rule 27 of C.P.C. is allowed considering the averments
made in the application and disposed of. Applicant is permitted to produce
on record the copy of judgment and order dated 28.6.2016 passed in LAR
No. 892/2005 (Old No. 422/2001) by the learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Omerga, Dist. Osmanabad. Hence, the order.
ORDER
(i)
The first appeal is partly allowed.
(ii)
The appellant/claimant is entitled to receive compensation at the rate
of Rs.827/- per R. for his acquired Jirayat land.
(iii)
The claimant shall be entitled to all statutory benefits on the
enhanced compensation, in accordance with the provisions of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894.
(iv)
The impugned judgment and awards is modified accordingly.
(v)
The rest of the impugned judgment and award shall remain
unaltered.
(vi)
The claimants shall pay the deficit court fees, if any, on the enhanced
amount.
(vii)
The modified Awards be drawn accordingly.
(viii) Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed of.
ssc/
( SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J. )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review