Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Supple -1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
(through Virtual Mode)
Pronounced on 06.10.2026
Uploaded on 07.10.2026
CRM(M) No.779/2024
CrlM No. 1600/2024
c/w
CRM (M) No. 116/2025
CrlM No. 237/2025
CrlM No. 506/2025
Manhar Gupta and ors
…Petitioner(s)
(with clubbed matter)
Ms Radha Sharma, Adv.
Through:
( in CRM(M) No. 779/2024)
Mr. Sunil Sethi, Sr. Advocate
With Mr. Paras Sharma, adv.
(CRM (M) No. 116/2025)
VS.
Union Territory of J&K and Others.
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Mr. Raman Sharma , AAG
With Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Adv
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mohd. Yousuf Wani, Judge
JUDGMENT
1.
Through the medium of instant petitions having been filed in terms of the
provisions of Section 528 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
(BNSS for short), corresponding to Section 482 of the repealed Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973, (Code for short), the petitioners have thrown
challenge to the order dated 13.08.2024 passed by the Court of learned
Special Judge Anti-Corruption, Jammu (herein after referred to as ―Special
Judge‖ for short), on the final closure report/ Ikhtitami, presented by the
Anti-Corruption Bureau, (ACB) Jammu, bearing file number 361/
Ikhtitami/2022 titled UT of J&K through Police Station ACB Jammu vs.
Shri Manhar Gupta and others (four persons), whereby the learned
Special Court rejected the said Final Closure Report/Ikhtitami, which had
exonerated the accused public servants, namely: 1. Manhar Gupta, son of
Late Sh. A. R Gupta, R/o 168, Sec-D Sainik Colony, Jammu, 2. Asgar
Hussain, Late Sh Ghulam Mustafa Ishrat R/o Ishrat Manzil Kishtwar,
3. Tasaduq Hussain Sheikh S/o Sh. Gh. Mustafa Sheikh R/o Village
Khalu, BPO Bharla Tehsil Bhaderwah District Doda, and 4. Umesh
Perihar, son of
Late Shri M. R Parihar, R/o F-53 Karan Nagar,
Jammu, who had come to be associated in their official positions in the
execution of SAUBHAGYA
Scheme in Jammu Province, from any
criminal liability and had only recommended departmental action, (D.A)
against them for committing violations of the guidelines of the Scheme.
2.
The facts of the case relevant for disposal of the instant petitions are that
the Government of India launched a scheme, namely Pradhan Mantri
Sehaj Bijli Har Ghar Yojna (SAUBHAGYA) in order to electrify each and
every un-electrified household up to the last mile connectivity in both
urban and Rural areas of J&K through on grid and off grid mode. That the
objective of the scheme was to achieve universal household electrification
by providing last mile connectivity and electricity connections to all
households in rural and urban areas of erstwhile State of J&K.
That aforesaid SAUBHAGYA scheme was approved by the Ministry of
Power, Government of India on 11.10.2017 and 20.10.2017. That
according to the operational guidelines issued for implementation of said
scheme, Rural Electrification Corporation Ltd. (RECL), was nominated as
Nodal Agency for implementation of the said scheme and beneficiaries
under the said scheme were identified by using Socio Economic Caste
Census (SECC) done in the year 2011. That SAUBHAGYA scheme was
regarded as one of the most successful endeavours of Power Development
Department. That it was the largest network expansion program ever
happened in the history and was successfully accomplished within a
definite and very limited time frame. That a coordinated approach
involving various stakeholders and departments from the initial survey to
the commissioning of projects, coupled with close monitoring by
authorities at various levels and the immediate resolution of bottlenecks,
were key attributes to Scheme's success. That being a public benefit
scheme, the people remained associated with the Department throughout
its implementation period. That the efforts of the departmental workforce,
particularly those operating in remote and inaccessible areas were highly
appreciated. That these workers provided connections to households that
had been without electricity for the past 70 years. That additionally, in
some regions, material such as poles and transformers had to be
transported manually/head Load over distances of more than 20 km. That
pictures documenting the execution of the scheme in the challenging
terrains of J&K are available on record and have been featured in various
Government of India magazines. That for ensuring last mile connectivity
under the scheme, the public involvement was given top priority. That in
this regard, various camps were regularly organized to facilitate the
release of electricity connections right at the consumers' doorsteps. That
these efforts were widely published through print and electric media with
media records available on record.
That the execution of the aforesaid scheme was closely monitored by
various stakeholders including the Nodal Agency of Ministry of Power
(REC), JKPDD, Project Monitoring Agency and several other agencies.
That the Project Monitoring Agency (PMA) as per the assigned duties
maintained and updated each household and the associated progress
infrastructure on the MIS Portal which was accessible to all stakeholders.
That additionally, the list of beneficiaries was uploaded on the
SAUBHAGYA Portal developed by the Ministry of power for this
purpose. That despite extensive coverage of the scheme across nearly
every village and hamlet, minimal complaints were received from Doda
and Kishtwar regions which were also promptly addressed.
That the SAUBHAGYA scheme was completed in March, 2019.
However, on the basis of preliminary enquiry conducted by the AntiCorruption
Bureau,
J&K
with
respect
to
allegations
that
the
officers/officials of Power Development Department J&K had committed
certain alleged irregularities while implementing the SAUBHAGYA, two
FIRs viz.; FIR No.03/2020 with Police Station, Anti-Corruption Bureau,
Srinagar with respect to Ganderbal District of Kashmir region and FIR No.
04/2020 with Police Station, Anti-Corruption Bureau, Jammu came to be
registered with respect to District Doda in Jammu region in the month of
March, 2020. That, the investigation was extended in respect of various
other districts of the UT of J&K as well.
That both the Police Stations Anti-Corruption Bureau Srinagar and AntiCorruption Bureau, Jammu carried out extensive and exhaustive
investigation into the allegations in both the FIRs registered by them and
finally both these Police Stations Anti-Corruption Bureau Srinagar and
Anti-Corruption Bureau Jammu concluded the investigation by filing two
separate final closure reports/Ikhtitami’s before the Courts of Ld. Special
Judge, Anti-Corruption, Srinagar and Ld. Special Judge, Anti-Corruption
Jammu. That the Court of Ld. Special Judge, Anti-Corruption Srinagar on
receipt of the final closure report on 18.02.2022 carried out necessary
proceedings on the said report and finally vide order dated 08.06.2024
accepted the same in its entirety.
That in so far as final report (Ikhtitami) arising out of FIR NO. 04/2020
dated 05.03.2020 of Police Station, ACB Jammu is concerned, the same
was presented before the Court of Ld. Special Judge, Anti-Corruption,
Jammu on 07.02.2022 and the Ld. Court after examining the same
rejected it vide impugned order dated 13.08.2024 with directions to
Anti-Corruption Bureau Jammu to conduct further investigation.
That regarding the issue of unutilized material despite claims submitted to
the Government of India indicating that the SAUBHAGYA scheme
achieved its target of 100% electrification, it is to state the scheme in
question was approved by the Government of India in two parts. That in
the first part HH electrification/providing of connection to un-electrified
HHs works were sanctioned under 'Saubhagya' scheme for Rs. 133 Crores
That in the second part an amount of Rs. 875 Crores was sanctioned for
providing 'Additional infra under DDUGJY for system strengthening,
sanctioned 88 special dispensation for J&K alongwith some other States,
to supplement the HH electrification works taken up under Saubhagya
scheme. That the Saubhagya scheme was fully accomplished with desired
objectives achieved within the timeline (28.10.2018), as per the site
requirements. That the UCs/certificates of successful completion were
accordingly submitted for participation in the Saubhagya award scheme
announced by the MoP. That however, the other part
concerning
providing Additional infra under DDUGJY could not be fully completed
in view of stringent timeline (31.03.2019) and some material with almost
every division remained un-utilized. That the matter regarding un-utilized
material has been deliberated at State Level Standing Committee (SLSC)
headed by Chief Secretary, J&K and the Ministry of Power (MOP)
immediately after
closing of the scheme. That SLSC accorded its
approval for execution of unutilized material under state plan and later on
as the recommendation of SLSC, MOP sanctioned the cost of un-utilized
material along with its execution charges for providing Additional Infra
under DDUGJY scheme. That the MoP also approved time extension till
31.12.21 for execution of the said works, under Additional Infra
(DDUGJY). That as such, in view of time extensions provided for
execution of works by the authorities, the deadline of 31.03.2019 fixed by
Commissioner/Secretary
PDD
vide
instructions/
circular
dated
08.04.2019, highlighted in Court Judgment, has become null and void.
That it is apt to mention here that the un-utilized material under reference
comprises of poles, DTs, wires & conductor which is of daily use for the
department, having life expectancy of more than thirty-five years. That the
aforesaid aspects have been exhaustively dealt with by the investigating
agency and due findings and opinion in the closure report have been
reflected leaving no room for any further investigation in the matter. That
the Ld. Court below under the given circumstances ought to have accepted
the closure report.
That the petitioners alongwith all other officials associated with the
execution of SAUBHAGYA Scheme have been awarded by the Govt. of
India for timely and satisfactory execution of an extensive Scheme in the
state of J&K, but, the petitioner(s) despite being subjected to investigation
twice by the respondent and by the department, have again been subjected
to further investigation by virtue of order impugned, which renders the
impugned order highly vitiated and
liable to be quashed as the
petitioner(s) cannot be subjected to investigations again and again for the
same allegations.
That a bare perusal of the impugned order reveals that the closure report
remained pending before the learned trial court for about two and a half
years, during which the respondent failed to bring subsequent
developments in the case—namely, the RDA and third-party inspection—
to the court's notice. That had the outcome of the RDA and third-party
inspection been brought to the court's attention, the learned Special court
could not have directed for further investigation.
That it is also brought to the kind notice of this Court that in similar FIR
No.03/2020, closure report filed by the ACB stands accepted by the Court
of Ld. Special Judge Anti-Corruption, Srinagar vide order dated
08.06.2024. That it is pertinent to mention that the Anti-Corruption
Bureau J&K vide letter dated 27.01.2022 requested the Principal Secretary
to Government General Administration Department to initiate Regular
Departmental Action against the delinquent officers/officials. That
pursuant to the recommendations of Anti-Corruption Bureau J&K, a
Regular Department Action was initiated and finally the Government in
the Power Development Department issued Government order no. 78-
JK(PDD) Of 2024 dated 02.05.2024 wherein the following observations
have been returned: "(i). There is no material evidence that proves willful
wrongdoing on the part of any officer/official associated with the
implementation of Saubhagya scheme;
(ii). The omissions and commissions pointed out by the ACB
have been satisfactorily explained by both the MDs in their
respective reports after detailed verification.
(iii). The Government of India has conducted third-party
inspection of the works executed under Saubhagya Scheme along
with other central sector schemes in each district, which stands
uploaded on the SAKSHYA Portal and is in public domain,
showing no deficiency in the execution of works, which again
substantiates that the works have been executed satisfactorily as per
the DPR.
(iv). The closure statement of the Saubhagya scheme in
respect of all the districts was prepared in February 2022, which
stands submitted to the Government of India after proper audit,
certification by the CA alongwith necessary approval of the
authorities. The said repots have been duly accepted by the Gol and
no expenditure has been booked under the scheme beyond the
closure amount approved by the Gol.
Now, therefore, in the light of above facts and circumstances
there is no material evidence available on record to initiate
departmental proceedings (RDA) against the officers/officials
associated with the implementation of Saubhagya scheme. Hence
the matter is hereby closed."
3.
The impugned order has been assailed by the petitioners through these two
petitions on the grounds:(a) That same is not legally sustainable and is liable to be set aside on the
ground that Investigating officer has conducted very exhaustive and
thorough investigation into each of the allegations and returned sufficient
findings in the final report presented before the learned Special Court.
That the Court below, without properly evaluating the findings returned by
the investigating officer as recorded in the final closure report, in a hot
haste manner, disagreed with the findings and opinion of the investigating
officer and passed the impugned order directing further investigation
notwithstanding the fact that all the allegations and accusations had been
exhaustively examined in reference to the relevant records by the
investigating officer. That the nature of final report depended upon the
outcome of the investigation
and the findings of the Investigating
Agency.
(b) That the Special Court could not have compelled the investigating
agency to take a different view. That the impugned order, which directed
for further investigation is, in essence, a direction for reinvestigation, as is
apparent from the questionnaire framed by the learned Special Court,
which its beyond the jurisdiction.
(c) That after the submission of the closure report by the ACB, Jammu,
before the learned Special Court, a Regular Departmental Action (RDA)
was conducted by the Power Development Department, with holding of
simultaneous inspections and audits in which process the final closure
report of the ACB Jammu was accepted by the Government of India, and
such further material developments were not brought to the notice of the
learned Court by the ACB.
(d) That almost all the points raised by the learned Special Court for
investigation, as per the impugned order, had already been taken care by
concluding inspections during the pendency of the closure report in the
process of the aforementioned RDA, supported
with inspection and
audits.
(e) That a detailed verification was conducted with respect to the process
of tendering and quality of material procured during the RDA, and it was
ascertained that the methodology adopted for purchase of material by
erstwhile Procurement and Material Management Wing of J&K, as per the
records, was through e-tendering. That SICOP was also found to have
followed the prescribed procedure in letter and spirit. That the
authorization for procurement of material from the Procurement and
Material Management Wing of the PDD and SICOP was decided in the
SLSC meeting held under the chairmanship of the Chief Secretary, J&K.
That both agencies, being Government-owned, have followed the
prescribed procedure for procurement of material and for arriving at the
rates. That, besides, both the said agencies have their own quality-check
arrangements in place.
(f) That by the time the Saubhagya Scheme was completed, the execution
of works under DDUGJY, JAYPM, DP and RE Wing-xii Schemes were at
its initial stages in the Districts of Reasi, Udhampur and Ramban, which
were independently managed by DCIL and PCIL. Thus, the levelling of
allegations of misconduct on account of non-distinguishment between the
Saubhagya
works
and
similar
works
executed
under
different
schemes/plans appear to be without any substance.
(g) That third-party inspections continued after the completion of the
DDUGJY Scheme, RE Wing-xii, and the works included under the two
types of schemes, i.e., Saubhagya and other schemes, were separately
documented and uploaded on the portal along with complete photographs.
That the issue of certain bills having been uploaded on the PFMS portal
without PMA signatures was examined by the MD’s of both the
Corporations during the RDA proceedings, and satisfactory explanations
were provided.
(h)
That it was confirmed by the MDs that PMA personnel were
involved throughout the execution of the works under the Scheme and
consistently inspected and uploaded the progress as per the scope of the
MIS portal, which was accessible to both the PDD authorities and the
nodal agency/Ministry of Power.
(i) That, as such, the PMA's involvement at a later stage for the signing
of bills, as mentioned in the impugned order, was merely a procedural
lapse, having no physical or financial impact.
(j)
That further, following the instructions of the Government of India,
re-cost DPRs for each district were prepared by the respective divisions on
the basis of the actual work completed as on the date of closure of the
Scheme, i.e., 31st March 2019. That the said DPRs were duly verified and
signed by the PMA before submission to the SLSC for necessary
approval, thereby confirming that the PMA validated the quantum of
work executed by the J&K, PDD. That moreover, the works were also
inspected by the third-party agency appointed by the Government of India,
apart from the PMA appointed by the J&K, PDD.
(k) That in addition to the checks carried out by the PMA with respect to
the scope of work, a new concept introduced in J&K involved regular
inspections by officers at all levels, which continued prior to verification
of bills, in accordance with standard engineering norms and the prescribed
procedure for monitoring cost and progress during execution of the
Scheme and the projects.
(l)
That regarding the issue of unutilized material, despite the closure
of the Scheme, the matter was submitted to the Government of India.
(m)
That
the
learned
Special
Court,
vide
its
order
dated
17.03.2022, allowed the application for release of records containing
copies of the schemes, tenders, work orders, LOAs and other allied
documents seized by ACB Jammu in connection with FIR No. 04 of 2020,
while taking into consideration the specific submissions regarding the
accomplishment of the Scheme targets, as well as the pending liabilities
for payments which could not be considered and processed under rules in
the absence of the relevant records.
(n) That the said release order was passed by the learned Special Court
while keeping in view the fact that the case stood closed as ―Not proved‖
and the closure report stands presented. That the court thus observed that,
retention of the records sought to be released for an uncertain period,
pending consideration and disposal of the closure report, was not likely to
serve any useful purpose.
4.
That the respondent-UT, through ACB Jammu, has, however, resisted the
petitions in hand, inter alia, on the ground that the petitions are not maintainable,
having been filed by invoking the wrong provisions of law.
That the occurrences covered under FIR No. 04 of 2020, Police Station
ACB Jammu, pertain to the period prior to the enforcement of the J&K
Re-organisation Act, 2019, as also the new criminal laws, and, as such, the
petitions were required to be filed in terms of Sections 561–A of the
erstwhile and repealed J&K Code of Criminal Procedure.
That it is well settled that the inherent power of this Court could be
invoked only when there is gross misuse of powers or abuse of the process
of law. That so far as the matter in hand is concerned, there is no such
misuse or abuse of the process of law which could justify the invoking of
the inherent power of this Court.
That the alleged grievance of the petitioner(s) projected in their petitions is
unfounded, because the impugned order has been passed by the learned
Special Court in lawful exercise of the power vested in it under law. That
the grounds on which the petitioners have sought quashment of the
impugned order can be looked into and addressed only during the further
investigation so ordered by the learned Special Court in terms of the
impugned order.
That the learned Special Court, despite being of Sessions grade, also
enjoys magisterial powers and is, as such, well competent to direct further
investigation in a case for unearthing all facts and circumstances. That the
power to direct further investigation is vested in the learned Special Court
in terms of Section 173(8) of the Code, corresponding to Section 193 (9)
of the BNSS.
That through the medium of the impugned order, the
learned Special Court has ordered further investigation in the case and not
reinvestigation, as alleged by the petitioners.
That a criminal court is not always bound to accept the findings arrived at
by the investigating agency. That upon presentation of a final police
report, a Magistrate has three options: first, he may agree or disagree with
the findings of the investigating agency; second, he may order further
investigation; or third, he may take cognizance of the matter.
That the various contentions of the petitioners can be addressed during the
course of further investigation ordered in the matter vide the impugned
order, which, however, came to be stayed by this Court in terms of order
dated 14.10.2024 passed in these petitions.
That the plea of double jeopardy taken by the petitioners is without any
basis. That a person can take such a plea only when he is subjected to trial
twice for the same offence. That merely because an accused, being a
public servant, is contemplated to be subjected to criminal prosecution
besides departmental action does not amount to double jeopardy. That the
departmental action/ disciplinary proceedings and the criminal prosecution
or trial operate in different spheres, and have different parameters and
scope.
That the developments which have taken place in the matter during the
intervening period between the presentation of the closure report and the
passing of the impugned order can be looked into only during the course
of further investigation so ordered by the learned Special Court vide the
impugned order.
That the order passed by the learned Special Judge, Anti-Corruption,
Srinagar, on the final closure report/Ikhtitami in an identical case, i.e.,
FIR No. 03 of 2020 of Police Station ACB Srinagar, is not binding upon
the learned Special Court, which has passed the impugned order on the
basis of its own findings.
That the petitioners should not have felt aggrieved by the impugned order,
rather, they should avail the opportunity and prove their innocence on the
grounds pleaded by them. That there is no legal bar for subjecting an
employee both to departmental action (RDA) and criminal prosecution
and even the exoneration of an employee in departmental action is no
ground to exonerate him in the criminal proceedings as well.
5.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties, who almost reiterated the
stands already taken by them in their respective pleadings, i.e., the memo of
petition (s) and the objections.
6.
I have gone through the petitions in hand, as also the copies of the
documents enclosed with the same as annexures thereto, especially the
impugned order dated 13.08.2024 passed by the learned Special Judge,
Anti-Corruption, Srinagar, on the final closure report (Ikhtetami) dated
07.02.2022, arising out of case FIR No. 4 of 2020 dated 05.03.2020 of
Police Station ACB Jammu; the order dated 08.06.2024 passed by the
Court learned Special judge , Anti-Corruption, Srinagar, on the final
police closure report (Ikhtetami) bearing No. 1 of 2022 dated 18.02.2022,
arising out of case FIR No. 3 of 2020 dated 05.03.2020 of Police Station
ACB, SBG, Kashmir; the communication of the ACB dated 27.01.2022
addressed
to
the
Principal
Secretary
to
Government,
General
Administration Department, J&K, Jammu, on the subject of RDA and
alert notice in case FIR No. 3 of 2020, ACB Srinagar, and FIR No. 4 of
2020 of Police Station ACB Jammu.
Government Order No. 78-JK-PDD
of 2024 dated 02.05.2024 issued by the Power Development Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar; and the communication dated
04.10.2024 addressed by the Government of J&K, General Administration
Department (Vigilance), to the Director, Anti-Corruption Bureau, J&K.
7. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the rival arguments advanced
on both sides.
8. Keeping in view the aforesaid perusal and consideration, this Court, in the
peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, is of the opinion that it may meet
the ends of justice
in case the petition(s) in hand are
allowed and the
impugned order dated 13.08.2024 passed by the learned Special Judge is set
aside.
9. As hereinbefore mentioned, the Anti-Corruption Bureau, J&K, on the basis
of a preliminary inquiry conducted by it with respect to the allegations that the
officers/officials of the PDD, J&K, have committed certain irregularities while
implementing the Saubhagya Scheme, registered two FIRs, viz., FIR No. 3 of
2020 of Police Station ACB, Srinagar, with respect to Ganderbal District of
Kashmir region, and FIR No. 4 of 2020 of Police Station ACB, Jammu, with
respect to District Doda in Jammu Division, both dated 05.03.2020. It has also
been hereinbefore mentioned that the investigating agency, however, extended
the scope of investigation to various other districts of the UT of J&K as well.
10.
Both the police stations, i.e., Police Station ACB, Srinagar and Police
Station ACB, Jammu, carried out investigation with respect to the allegations
contained in the respective FIRs registered by them, which culminated in the
filing of two final closure reports (Ikhtetami’s) with the concerned Special
Courts at Srinagar and Jammu. The Special Court at Srinagar, after dealing with
the final closure report dated 18.02.2022, as per the procedure accepted with
the findings of the investigating agency vide its order dated 08.06.2024.
However, the learned Special Court at Jammu, after addressing the final closure
report (Ikhtitami) arising out of case FIR No. 4 of 2020 dated 05.03.2020 of
Police Station ACB, Jammu, placed before it, did not agree with the same and
passed the impugned order dated 13.08.2024, with directions to ACB, Jammu,
to conduct further investigation into the matter.
11. Case FIR Nos. 3 of 2020 and 4 of 2020, both dated 05.03.2020, are split
cases registered by the ACB, J&K, to investigate the same set of allegations in
a convenient manner . The Investigating Officer of case FIR No. 4 of 2020
dated 05.03.2020 of Police Station ACB Jammu, while concluding the
investigation in the said FIR as ―not proved‖, has, inter alia, observed at page-
14 of the final closure report that, in view of the facts emerging during the
course of investigation and scrutiny of the record, the officers/officials of the
Electric Department, J&K, 1 to 17, mentioned therein, including the present
petitioners, have
committed procedural lapses by not following the
SOPs/guidelines of the Saubhagya Scheme. The Investigating Officer
accordingly recommended RDA against them.
12.
However, the Investigating Officer, at the same time, observed that no
criminal offence could be established against the accused persons mentioned in
the FIR, as such, benefit under Section 169 Cr.P.C. was extended to the
accused persons, namely, Shri Manohar Gupta, Chief Engineer, Projects Wing,
Jammu; Shri Umesh Parihar, the then Superintending Engineer, EM & RE
Circle, Kishtwar, (now retired); Shri Asgar Hussain, Superintending Engineer,
EM & RE Circle, Kishtwar, (now retired); and Shri Tasaduq Hussain Sheikh,
the Executive Engineer Electric Division Doda. He accordingly recommended
the closure of the case as ―Not Proved‖.
13.
The Investigating Officer of case FIR No. 3 of 2020, Police Station ACB,
BSG, while concluding the investigation in case FIR No. 3 of 2020, Police
Station ACB BSG, as, ―Not admitted‖ however, recommended that RDA may
be initiated against those Engineers of the Electric Division, Ganderbal, who
failed to execute the works strictly in accordance with the Saubhagya
guidelines, and for allowing execution of works with deficient specifications,
against which a loss of Rs. 1.40 lakhs in four subdivisions of Electric Division,
Ganderbal, have been found caused during the physical inspection of the said
divisions.
14.
The Investigating Agency also recommended that an advisory may be
issued to the PDD, J&K, with regard to poor workmanship established during
the inspection of Electric Division, Ganderbal, which was in contravention to
the directions/agreement, and RODIC Consultancy has failed to complete its
contract agreement. That balance fee to M/s RODIC Consultancy be withheld
till a satisfactory Project Completion Report is submitted by the firm, duly
authenticated by the concerned Engineer-in-Charge, and that penalty, as per the
terms of the reference, on account of carelessness towards the contract
obligations and commitments, should be imposed on the firm.
Regarding Districts Kupwara, Baramulla and Bandipora, it has been observed
by the Investigating Officer, after conclusion of the investigation that
allegations of double drawls and misappropriation during the implementation of
the centrally sponsored Saubhagya Scheme, (Sahaj Bijli Har Ghar Yojina)
scheme
the loss to the State exchequer in Electric Division, Kupwara, could
not be established.
15.
As regards
District Anantnag, Kashmir Division, the Investigating
Officer (IO) has observed that the diversion of Saubhagya material to other
schemes by the Electric Division, Anantnag, was regularized by the SLSC and
could not be considered as loss though as per the applicable guidelines, such
diversion was not allowed.
16.
As regards the districts of Jammu, Samba, Udhampur and Kathua, the
IO, Police Station ACB Jammu, while concluding the investigation in Case
FIR No. 4 of 2022, observed that, on the basis of the investigation RDA is
recommended, and the part investigation of the FIR with respect to Jammu,
Samba and Kathua was recommended to be closed as “not proved.”
17.
With respect to the districts of Doda, Udhampur and Ramban, the
Investigating Officer, inter alia, observed that the investigation conducted so
far revealed that the concerned public servants have committed procedural
lapses by not following the guidelines/ SOPs and circulars in letter and spirit.
He finally concluded by recommending initiation of RDA against 17 named
delinquent public servants, besides issuance of an advisory for withholding
the pending payments of M/s Rodic Consultants Private Limited for not
delivering services as per the terms and conditions laid down in the LOA.
18.
As regards the districts of Poonch and Rajouri, RDA was recommended
by the Investigating Agency against 11 officers/officials of the Poonch
Division, as named in the report, for violation of the prescribed
procedure/conditions.
19. With respect to the investigation as regards the districts of Udhampur and
Reasi, the Investigating Officer, inter alia, observed that no criminality was
found on the part of the public servants; however, initiation of RDA against
the delinquent officers/officials was recommended.
20. The Anti-Corruption Bureau, UT of J&K, after culmination of the
investigation in the twin case FIRs, as ―Not proved‖ before filing of the final
closure reports of 7/02/2022 before the learned Special Courts, made a
communication dated 27.01.2022 to the Principal Secretary to the Government,
General Administration Department, J&K, Jammu, on the basis of the findings
of the investigation, with the following recommendations:
―a. That Regular Departmental Action (RDA) may
be initiated against the then Engineers of Electric
Division Ganderbal who failed to execute the works
strictly according to Saubhagya Guidelines and for
allowing the execution of works with deficient
specifications against which a loss of 1.40 Lakhs in
four Sub-Divisions of the Electric Division
Ganderbal have been found caused during the
physical inspection of the said Division.
b. Advisory may be issued to PDD J&K with
regard to poor workmanship established during the
inspection of Electric Division Ganderbal which is in
contravention to the contract agreement and Rodic
Consultancy has failed to complete its contract
agreement The balance fee to M/S Rodic Consultants
be withheld till satisfactory project completion report
is submitted by the firm duly authenticated by the
concerned engineer in charge and penalty as per
terms of reference on accountof carelessness towards
the contract obligation/commitments should be
imposed on the firm.‖
21.
The Government of J&K, Power Development Department, Civil
Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar, after initiation of RDA and consideration of
the alert notice in the twin case FIRs, pursuant to the recommendations of
the ACB J&K and the advice of the GAD, did the needful and issued
Government Order No. 78-JK (PDD) of 2024, dated 02.05.2024. The
operative paras of the order are reproduced as under:“ Whereas, based on the above advice of GAD, the entire
matter was re-examined in the department and it was observed that
verification had already been conducted at the department level by both
the Managing Directors and the reports were also examined by Secretary
(Technical), who was in agreement with the findings of the Managing
Directors. Further, the reports were sought from various central-level
agencies associated with the implementation and monitoring of the scheme
viz. REC, PFC and CEA, and nothing adverse was received from any
quarter. Moreover, J&K Government received a cash award of Rs. 100
crores from the Government of India for being the first amongst the
special category States in the country to achieve 100% HH electrification
within the given timeline; and
Whereas, the matter was further examined in the
Department keeping in view all the factors mentioned above, based upon
which, the following has been construed: -
i. There is no material evidence that proves wilful wrongdoing
on the part of any officer/official associated with the implementation of
Saubhagya scheme.
PDD -Plan/6/2022-05-POWER DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 4/0/0 Addl Secy JS
ii.
The omissions and commissions pointed out by the ACB
have been after detailed verification. satisfactorily explained by both the
MDs in their respective reports,
iii.
The Government of India has conducted a third-party
inspection of the works executed under Saubhagya scheme, along with
other central sector schemes in each district, which stands uploaded on the
SAKSHYA portal and is in public domain, showing no deficiency in the
execution of works, which again substantiates that the works have been
executed satisfactorily as per the DPR.
iv.
The closure statement of the Saubhagya scheme in
respect of all the Districts was prepared in February 2022, which stands
submitted to the Government of India after proper audit, certification by
the CA along with necessary approval of the authorities. The said reports
have been duly accepted by the Gol, and no expenditure has been booked
under the scheme beyond the closure amount approved by the Gol.
Now, therefore, in light of the above facts and
circumstances, there is no material evidence available on record to initiate
departmental proceedings (RDA) against the officers/officials associated
with the implementation of Saubhagya scheme. Hence, the matter is
hereby closed.
However, the Managing Directors of the corporations will
ensure that:a.
General circular instructions are issued to all the
employees of respective corporations for strict adherence to the SOPs and
the observations made by the ACB in its report dated 27.01.2022, while
executing works in future.
b. The officers/officials posted in the Electric Divisions of
Anantnag, Kupwara & Ganderbal during the execution of Saubhagya
scheme, in whose jurisdiction minor supervisory lapses were pointed out
during the enquiry, be issued a "warning" to remain careful, vigilant and
diligent while discharging their duties.
By order of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir.
Sd:Principal Secretary to the Government
Dated 2.05.2024”
22.
It is also necessary to mention that the Government of Jammu and
Kashmir, GAD (Vigilance), vide communication dated 04.10.2024 addressed to
the Director, Anti-Corruption Bureau, J&K, took up the matter for legal advice
in view of the two contradictory judgments on the same subject matter.
23.
A careful perusal of the impugned order reveals that the same has the
apparent trappings of a reinvestigation order, as also contended by Mr. Sethi,
learned Senior Advocate, during the course of his arguments. The learned
Special Court, while directing further investigation on the final closure report
pertaining to Case FIR No. 4 of 2020, Police Station ACB Jammu, has
proceeded to incriminate all the involved agencies which is apparent from the
concluding part of para-46 of the impugned order, being reproduced hereunder:
―Therefore, in the light of glaring incriminating facts
on the record, all the said Agencies are criminally liable for
commission of offences like misappropriation of public
money, creating and using of false evidence and criminal
conspiracy read with the offence of criminal misconduct as
defined under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 2006.”
24.
It is apparent from para-48 of the impugned order that the learned Special
Court, in a way, appears to have taken cognizance in the matter and directed
collection of evidence on the issues and in the manner directed by it.
25. It is also needful to mention that the learned Special Court, Srinagar,
on an almost identical set of allegations and based on similar findings by
the same investigating agency, concurred with the findings of the
investigating agency.
26. As rightly contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners, the learned
Special Court appears not to have been fully updated of the series of events that
occurred with effect from February 2022, i.e., the date of filing of the closure
report. The said fact was also communicated by the Government, General
Administration Department (Vigilance Section), to the Director, AntiCorruption Bureau, J&K, vide communication dated 04.10.2024.
27.
As hereinbefore mentioned, the RDA was initiated pursuant to the
recommendations of the ACB J&K, which led to the passing of Government
Order No. 78-JK (PDD) of 2024, dated 02.05.2024, with the observations inter
alia, that there is no material evidence to prove willful wrongdoing on the
part of any officer or official associated with the implementation of the
scheme.
28. That the omissions and commissions pointed out by the ACB have been
satisfactorily explained by both the Managing Director’s in their respective
reports after detailed verification. That the Government of India has conducted
third-party inspections of the works executed under the Saubhagya Scheme,
along with other Central Sector Schemes, in each district which stand uploaded
on the Sakshya Portal and is in the public domain, showing no deficiency in
the execution of the works, which, in substance, were executed satisfactorily as
per the DPRs.
29.
The learned Special Court, on the contrary, has, inter alia, observed in
para- 48 (xiii) that why the Government did not take departmental action
against the errant officials of the J&K PDD, as recommended by the IO of the
case in the instant closure report.
30. The learned counsel for the petitioner(s), during the course of arguments,
placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Ajit
Kumar v. State of NCT of Delhi and contended that it is a settled proposition of
law that once an employee is exonerated in departmental proceedings with
respect to the same allegations, no useful purpose would be served in
continuing the criminal proceedings.
It was further intimated to the Court during the course of arguments that some
of the petitioners have already retired, while some are suffering on account of
their due promotions, which fact is supposed to have caused mental agony and
trauma not only to them but also to their families.
31. The learned counsel for the petitioners inter alia submitted during their
arguments that we cannot loose sight of the fact that the engineers belonging
to different branches especially those, employed in Government sector may at
same times find themselves in difficult situations when on one hand they are
inevitably required to act strictly in accordance with the law and regulations
governing different works/ schemes being entrusted to them for execution and
on the other hand have to simultaneously face the brunt of the administration
or of the elected public representatives for speedy completion of the same.
They contended that some bona fide procedural irregularities or deficiencies
under guiding principles, and norms of major developmental schemes need to
be considered and weighed differently, otherwise, people will refrain from
joining the engineering profession, particularly in the government sector
They also contended that if the impugned order is allowed to operate, the
same will engage the present petitioners for the remaining years of their
life and
shall become oppressive against them, especially when the
investigating agency has already upon a thorough and in-depth
investigation, exonerated them from the accusation of having committed
criminal misconduct involving any guilty intention.
They further contended that prior preliminary inquiries (P.E.s) are desirable in
respect of allegations levelled against public servants in relation to matters
involving manifold intrinsic issues.
32. The investigation conducted by the ACB Jammu, culminating in the filing
of the closure report in terms of the provisions of Section 173 of the Code,
corresponding to Section 193 of the BNSS, followed by the RDA conducted by
the Government, Power Development Department, and the simultaneous thirdparty inspection/audit of the works executed under the Saubhagya Scheme,
along with other Central Sector Schemes in each district, under the directions of
the Government of India, exonerates the petitioners from the accusation of
commission of criminal misconduct or any conspiracy. However, the
investigating agency found them responsible for violations of the terms and
conditions as well as the prescribed procedure of the relevant scheme,
in
connection whereof the ACB recommended initiation of RDA.
33.
On the recommendation of the ACB, the Government of J&K, Power
Development Department, proceeded to do the needful and issued Government
Order No. 78-JK (PDD) of 2024, dated 02.05.2024, with the observations to
the effect as hereinbefore mentioned, that no material evidence was found to
the proof of willful wrong doing on the part of any Officer/official associated
with the implementation of Saubhagya Scheme . The Government, however,
issued general circular instructions to the Managing Directors of the
Corporations, as deemed appropriate.
34.
In the aforementioned backdrop, this Court is of the opinion that the
present case is a fit case warranting exercise of the inherent powers vested in
this Court in terms of the provisions of Section 528 of the BNSS, corresponding
to Section 482 of the Code.
35.
The present petitioners have already suffered the brunt of the
investigation, which commenced in Case FIR w.e.f. 05.03.2020. Prior to the
registration of the formal FIR, the petitioners associated with the Inquiry
Officer during the preliminary inquiry proceedings for a considerable period.
Even after the conclusion of the investigation, which culminated in a finding of
'Not proved', they were again associated with proceedings during the
departmental action as well as the Central Government-ordered inspections and
audits.
36.
The learned Special Court, in paragraph 35 of the impugned order, has
inter alia observed that the allegations of 'Double Drawls' were not specifically
addressed during the course of investigation. However, a thorough perusal of
the final closure report inter alia reveals that this aspect was also duly
addressed
37.
The learned Special Judge at Srinagar, while disposing of the final closure
report bearing File No. 56-B, instituted on 18.02.2022 in respect of Case FIR
No. 3 of 2020 P/S SGB Kashmir observed at para 9 of the order that based on
investigation none of the allegations such as double drawal, loss to the State
exchequer and exorbitance of the rates was established against the nominated
accused
officers of power development department Kashmir.
He further
observed that while examining the records of the concerned electric division,
it was found that only material bills as per the rates have been paid while as
execution bills are yet to be paid. That material supply agencies such as SICOP
and central store PDD have their own well settled pattern of fixation of rates
through bidding and quality control mechanism.
38.
The learned Special Court has, inter alia, mentioned in the impugned
order that a preliminary enquiry (P.E.) was rightly initiated upon receipt of
complaints. The learned Special Court has also made reference to the said
complaints. However, it is not apparent from the impugned order as to whether
the learned Special Court recorded the statements of the complainants or any
of them before passing the impugned order.
39.
In the celebrated decision of State of Haryana and Others v. Ch.
Bhajan Lal and Others, AIR 1992 SC 604, the Hon’ble Apex Court
considered in detail the scope of the powers of the High Court under Section
482 of the Cr.P.C. and Article 226 of the Constitution of India to quash
criminal proceedings, by referring to several judicial precedents.
40.
This Court is conscious of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in State of Haryana and Others v. Bhajan Lal and Others,
AIR 1992 SC 604, Upkar Singh v. Ved Prakash and Others, (2004) SC
4320, and “M/s Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra
and Others, (2021) 37 CRLJ 2419, to the effect that Courts should not
ordinarily interfere with criminal proceedings at the initial stage, particularly
where commission of cognizable offences is apparently discernible, unless
there are compelling reasons to do so, such as, where the allegations are absurd,
inherently improbable or actuated by malice.
41.
It has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Iman
Pratapgadhi vs. state of Gujrat” (2025) INSC 410, , at para 37 of the
judgment, that Section 528 of the BNSS, corresponding to Section 482 of the
Cr.P.C., empowers the High Court to quash criminal proceedings even after
filing of the charge-sheet and/or commencement of trial.
42.
The court in the facts and circumstances of the case is of the opinion that
it may meet the ends of justice in case the impugned order of the learned
Special Court Jammu is set aside.
43.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid discussion, the present petition(s) are
allowed. The impugned order dated 13.08.2024 passed by the Court of learned
Special Judge, Anti-Corruption, Jammu, while addressing the final closure
report No. 01 of dated 7.2.2022 arising out of Case FIR No. 4 of 2020 of
Police Station ACB, Jammu, bearing File No. 361 of 2022, titled UT of J&K
through Police Station ACB Jammu v. Shri Manhar Gupta and Others, is set
aside to the extent of the present petitioners, namely, 1. Manhar Gupta, son of Late
Sh. A. R Gupta, R/o 168, Sec-D Sainik Colony, Jammu, 2. Asgar Hussain, Late Sh
Ghulam Mustafa Ishrat R/o Ishrat Manzil Kishtwar, 3. Tasaduq Hussain Sheikh S/o Sh.
Gh. Mustafa Sheikh R/o Village Khalu, BPO Bharla Tehsil Bhaderwah District Doda, and
4. Umesh Parihar, son of Late Shri M. R Parihar, R/o F-53 Karan Nagar, Jammu, while
agreeing with the closure report No. 1 dated 07.02.2022 of case FIR No. 4/2020 of P/S
ACB, Jammu.
However, this order shall not be construed as granting of any permission for
release of any amounts in relation to the execution of the scheme. Any such
release, shall be regulated by the law governing the field, as also by the
Advisory/Alert notice issued by the ACB, J&K to the J&K Government and
also by any subsequent orders or instructions, issued by the Government of
India or the Government of the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir by way
of follow-up action.
44.
The petition(s) stand disposed of.
(Mohd. Yousuf Wani)
Judge
Srinagar:
06.10.2026
“Ayaz”
Whether approved for reporting in law journal? Yes
Whether judgment is speaking ?Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review