The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. This order dated 8-3-2000 was not brought to the notice of this Court on 10-4-2000 and apart from that, it is not known under what authority the Government can refuse to pay back wages etc. by way of an administrative order when the High Court order dated 20-5-1999 was in full force. By an administrative order the Government cannot overrule a judgment. Such an administrative order is no ground for review. [13] Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel for the respondent no. 3 has strongly objected the submissions of the learned sr. counsel for the petitioners that upon the acceptance of decretal amount by the respondent no. 3, the sale deed dated 10.10.2008 (which has been upheld by the Civil Court) cannot be nullified. [14] This Court has considered the materials on record, the submissions made at the bar and case laws cited by the parties. [15] Upon execution of sale deed dated 10.10.2008 in favour of respondent no. 3 for sale of Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur, the claim of the respondent no. 3 is that he become the chief of the said village and chiefship has been transferred along with sale deed. In the circumstances, the D.C., Churachandpur issued order dated 23.05.2009 transferring the chiefship from respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 and the same was challenged by respondent no. 4 before the Civil Court and the Civil Court decreed that chiefship cannot be transferred by sale de…
19. 02.2014, the D.C., Churachandpur recognized the respondent no. 3 as chief of the Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur. In passing the impugned order, the D.C., Churachandpur also directed to make necessary entry in the land record as sale deed was valid. This Court is of the opinion that the Civil Court order did not set aside the sale deed dated 10.10.2008 executed by respondent no. 4 in favour of respondent no. 3 transferring the whole Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur, but the decree set aside the transfer of the chiefship from respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 by earlier order dated 23.05.2009 passed by D.C., Churachandpur on the ground that chiefship is not transferrable. This finding has attained finality and the same is not open to be agitated before the D.C. Churachandpur or others on administrative side. If the respondent no. 3 is still aggrieved by the finding of the Civil Court, the correct course should be to challenge the same on the judicial side or higher forum or by filing review of the same. The operative portion of the impugned order dated 19.02.2014 is reproduced herein below: “Therefore, in suppression of the earlier order issued vide No. DC(CCP)/Hills/Misc- Case No. 1 of 2014 dated 10-01-2014 regarding Chiefship of Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur SubDivision and from all supporting documents and circumstances stated above, it hereby order that Shri Letsei Va…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed
OINAM Digitally
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
by OINAM
THOIBA
MEITEI
AT IMPHAL
THOIBA Date: 2025.12.04
MEITEI 18:05:14 +05'30' W.P. (C) No. 210 of 2015
Mangjacob Tungdim and 1 Anr.
Item no. 16
…. Petitioners
- Versus State of Manipur & 4 Ors.
…. Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
ORDER
(Oral)
25.11.2025
[1]
Heard Mr. HS Paonam, learned sr. counsel assisted by Mr. A.
Arunkumar, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned GA for
the State respondent nos. 1, 2 & 5 and Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel for the
respondent no. 3.
[2]
The respondent no. 4 (Shri Tongkhogin Tungdim) who is the
original Chief of the village and father of the 2(two) petitioners died in the year
2019 during the pendency of the present writ petition. However, admittedly
2(two) petitioners are the only serving LRs of the respondent no. 4. Hence, no
LRs are brought on record to represent the respondent no. 4.
[3]
The petitioners approach this Court challenging the order dated
19.02.2014
issued
by
Deputy
Commissioner,
Churachandpur
declaring
respondent no. 3 as Chief of the Tuinuphai Village, Churachandpur as well as
other consequential relief of the chiefship to the respondent no. 4, who is the
father of the petitioners herein and original Chief of the said village. The prayer
is reproduced herein below:
i) Issue rule nisi and call for the records,
ii) quash and set aside the impugned order dt. 19-2-2014
declaring the respondent No. 3 as Chief of Tuinuphai Village,
Churachandpur as illegal as well as any consequential order
for restoring the chiefship to the respondent No. 4 &
iii) pass any further order(s) direction(s) which this Hon'ble
court may seem fit and proper to secure the ends of justice.
[4]
The learned sr. counsel for the petitioners submits that the D.C.,
Churachandpur issued an order dated 23.05.2009 declaring that Chiefship of
Tuinuphai Village has been transferred from Tongkhogin Tungdim (respondent
no. 4 herein) to Letsei Vaiphei (respondent no. 3 herein). The said order was
challenged by respondent no. 4 before the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.),
Churachandpur by way of Original Suit No. 1 of 2010/ 6 of 2011. In the suit filed
by the respondent no. 4, the Trial Court framed 8(eight) issues and the same
are reproduced below:
“ISSUES
The 29th day of September, 2010
1. Whether the plaintiff borrowed a sum of Rs. 1,30,000/- from
the defendant or not?
2. Whether the plaintiff was taken by the defendant to the Office
of Sub-Registrar, Churachandpur and induced him to sign on
stamp paper or not?
3. Whether the plaintiff was taken by the defendant on 10-102008 to the Office of Sub-Registrar, Imphal or not? If so,
whether the plaintiff was induced to sign on an already
prepared stamp paper or not?
4. Whether the plaintiff has sold out the Tuinuphai Village along
with its lands to the defendant or not?
5. Whether
the
order
dated
23-5-2009
of
the
D.C.
Churachandpur was passed without the knowledge and
consent of the plaintiff or not? If so, what is the legal
consequences?
6. Whether the Suit is maintainable or not?
7. Cause of action?
8. Reliefs, if any?”
[5]
With respect to issue nos. 3, 4 & 5, it was held that there was a
sale deed executed by respondent no. 4 in favour of respondent no. 3. However,
with respect to issue no. 5 regarding validated order dated 23.05.2009 issued by
D.C., Churachandpur transferring the chiefship from respondent no. 4 to
respondent no. 3, it was held that chiefship cannot be transferred and that too
without affording opportunity of being heard. It was also held that respondent
no. 4 herein, borrowed a sum of Rs. 1,30,000/- (Rupees one lakh thirty
thousand) only from defendant no. 3 herein and for that purpose, the sale deed
dated 10.10.2008 was executed. The respondent no. 3 filed an appeal against
the order dated 27.05.2013 passed by the Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.),
Churachandpur, cancelling the transfer of the chiefship vide order dated
23.05.2009 issued by D.C., Churachandpur, transferring the chiefship of
Tuiniphai Village, Churachandpur from respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3.
[6]
Vide order dated 04.12.2013 in Civil Appeal No. 7 of 2013, the Ld.
District Judge, (the then Manipur West) now, Imphal West dismissed the appeal
holding that execution of the sale deed is not accompanied by transfer of
chiefship. Accordingly, the findings of the Trial Court in suit merged with the
judgment of the Ld. District Judge, Manipur West in appeal to the fact that
chiefship cannot be transferred by sale deed.
[7]
It is admitted at the bar that no further appeal or review have
been preferred against the orders passed by the Civil Courts and the same have
attained finality. However, the D.C., Churachandpur passed the impugned order
dated 19.02.2014 recognizing the respondent no. 3 as Chief of the Tuinuphai
Village, Churachandpur district, thereby, impliedly restoring the earlier order
dated 23.05.2009 passed by D.C., Churachandpur.
[8]
Mr. HS Paonam, learned sr. counsel for the petitioners submits
that the impugned order dated 19.02.2014 is issued restoring the earlier order
dated 23.05.2009 transferring the chiefship to respondent no. 3 from respondent
no. 4, even though, the earlier order dated 23.05.2009 has been set aside by
the 2(two) Civil Courts on the ground that chiefship is not transferable. The
learned sr. counsel for the petitioners further submits that as per decisions of
Gauhati High Court in “Ningom & Ors. –vs- Samjamang, Chief” reported in
“(1990) 2 GLR 331” at para no. 18, it is stated that the kuki tribe holding
chiefship is a hereditary one and submitted that chiefship cannot be transferred
by way of sale deed.
[9]
The learned sr. counsel for the petitioners also relies on the
decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court in “M.P. Peter vs. State of Kerala”
reported in “(2009) 7 SCC 786” there is a prima-facie that executive order
cannot be nullified the judicial order which attains finality. It is prayed that the
impugned order dated 19.02.2014 issued by D.C. Churachandpur be set aside.
[10]
On the other hand, Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned GA relying on the
counter affidavit, it is mentioned that the impugned order dated 19.02.2014 was
passed by the D.C. Churachandpur as the petitioners herein and their
representatives failed to appear and this Court may pass appropriate order in the
facts of the present case.
[11]
Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel for the respondent no. 3 submits
that the respondent no. 3 purchased the Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur from
respondent no. 4 by way of registered sale deed with a consideration amount of
Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only. The learned counsel for the respondent
no. 3 refers to the judgment and decree dated 27.05.2013 passed by the Ld.
Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Churachandpur in O.S. No. 1 of 2010/ 06 of 2011
whereby, there is definite findings that respondent no. 4 executed sale deed of
the village in favour of respondent no. 3 for a consideration of Rs.1,00,000/(Rupees one lakh) only and Civil Court set aside the earlier order dated
23.05.2009 issued by D.C., Churachandpur confined to transfer of the chiefship
from respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3. The Trial Court gave the findings
that there was a registered sale deed in favour of the respondent no. 3. Since,
the whole village was transferred by sale deed, the chiefship was rightly
transferred by D.C., Churachandpur vide order dated 23.05.2009. As the sale
deed was not cancelled by the Civil Court, the impugned order dated 19.02.2014
just recognized chiefship of the respondent no. 3. It is also submitted that order
dated 19.02.2014 is in compliance of the decree of the Civil Court.
[12]
Mr. HS Paonam, learned sr. counsel for the petitioners has
pointed out that in the decree passed by the Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.),
Churachandpur it was held that respondent no. 4 borrowed a sum of Rs.
1,30,000/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand) only from respondent no. 3 for his
personal use and order dated 23.05.2009 passed by D.C., Churachandpur was
held to be nullity. The learned sr. counsel for the petitioners refers to the
additional affidavit dated 28.11.2017 filed by the petitioners herein, to the fact
that in Civil (Execution) Case No. 1 of 2015 with regards to the decree filed by
the respondent no. 3, the Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Churachandpur passed an
order dated 28.08.2017 directing deduction of a sum of Rs. 1,30,000/- (Rupees
one lakh thirty thousand) only from the account of the respondent no. 4 and it
is stated that the whole amount has been deducted as directed by the Executive
Court and the money has been executed by respondent no. 4 without any
protests. In the circumstances, upon the return of the borrowed money, the
registered sale deed has become infructuous and a nullity. The following case
laws have been relied by Mr. HS Paonam, learned sr. counsel for the petitioners:
1. Commissioner of Central Excise, Nagpur v. Gurukripa
Resins (P) Ltd., (2011) 13 SCC 180
It was held that the Board circular will not prevail over
the Order of the Supreme Court. It was further held that
a circular which is contrary to the statutory provisions has
no existence in law.
12. Placing reliance on the decision of the Constitution Bench
of this Court in CCE v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries
[(2008) 13 SCC 1] , learned counsel contended that the
circulars issued by the Revenue Department cannot be given
primacy over the decisions of the courts. In order to
substantiate his point that it is not necessary that power
should be used in all the processes involved in the
manufacture of finished goods, the learned counsel placed
reliance on the decision rendered by the Constitution Bench
of this Court in Union of India v. Delhi Cloth & General Mills
Co. Ltd. [AIR 1963 SC 791 : 1963 Supp (1) SCR 586] It was
thus stressed that in the light of the settled legal position on
the issue by this Court, the impugned decisions deserve to
be set aside.
30. In that view of the matter, when the law on the question
at issue before the Tribunal had already been declared by
this Court, the Tribunal should not have based its decisions
on the clarification issued by the Board, which otherwise
stood rescinded, on the specious ground that the said
clarification issued by the Board was binding on the Deputy
Commissioner as also on the Commissioner (Appeals). It is
well-settled proposition of law that circulars and instructions
issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs are no
doubt binding in law on the authorities under the respective
statutes but when this Court or the High Court declares the
law on the question arising for consideration, it would not be
appropriate for the courts or the Tribunal, as the case may
be, to direct that the Board's circular should be given effect
to and not the view expressed in a decision of this Court or
a High Court.
2. Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting
& Wire Industries, (2008) 13 SCC 1
Order of the Supreme Court/High Court will prevail over
circular and instructions issued by the Central Board of
excise and Customs.
7. Circulars and instructions issued by the Board are no
doubt binding in law on the authorities under the respective
statutes, but when the Supreme Court or the High Court
declares the law on the question arising for consideration, it
would not be appropriate for the court to direct that the
circular should be given effect to and not the view expressed
in a decision of this Court or the High Court. So far as the
clarifications/circulars issued by the Central Government and
of the State Government are concerned they represent
merely their understanding of the statutory provisions. They
are not binding upon the court. It is for the court to declare
what the particular provision of statute says and it is not for
the executive. Looked at from another angle, a circular
which is contrary to the statutory provisions has really no
existence in law.
3. Commissioner of Income Tax (CNTL) vs. Hero Cycles (P)
Ltd., (1997) 8 SCC 502
14. Moreover, it is well settled that circulars can bind the
Income Tax Officer but will not bind the appellate authority
or the Tribunal or the Court or even the assessee. There is
nothing in the alleged circular which supports the contention
of the assessee. It merely says that each case has to be
examined and the issue would be basically a find of fact. The
assessee had not made his claim before the Income Tax
Officer by relying on this circular.
4. Ravi S. Naik v. Union of India, 1994 Supp (2) SCC 641 at
page 661
40. As to whether the order of the Speaker could be a
subject-matter of court proceedings and whether his
decision was final were questions involving the interpretation
of the provisions contained in Tenth Schedule to the
Constitution. On the date of the passing of the stay order
dated December 14, 1990, the said questions were pending
consideration before this Court. In the absence of an
authoritative pronouncement by this Court the stay order
passed by the High Court could not be ignored by the
Speaker on the view that his order could not be a subjectmatter of court proceedings and his decision was final. It is
settled law that an order, even though interim in nature, is
binding till it is set aside by a competent court and it cannot
be ignored on the ground that the court which passed the
order had no jurisdiction to pass the same. Moreover the
stay order was passed by the High Court which is a superior
Court of Record and “in the case of a superior Court of
Record, it is for the court to consider whether any matter
falls within its jurisdiction or not. Unlike a court of limited
jurisdiction, the superior Court is entitled to determine for
itself questions about its own jurisdiction.
5. Manohar Lal v. Ugrasen, (2010) 11 SCC
29. In view of the above, it is evident that any order passed
by any authority in spite of the knowledge of the interim
order of the court is of no consequence as it remains a
nullity.
6. State of Haryana v. Ram Kumar, (2002) 9 SCC 703
5. This order dated 8-3-2000 was not brought to the notice
of this Court on 10-4-2000 and apart from that, it is not
known under what authority the Government can refuse to
pay back wages etc. by way of an administrative order when
the High Court order dated 20-5-1999 was in full force. By
an administrative order the Government cannot overrule a
judgment. Such an administrative order is no ground for
review.
[13]
Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel for the respondent no. 3 has
strongly objected the submissions of the learned sr. counsel for the petitioners
that upon the acceptance of decretal amount by the respondent no. 3, the sale
deed dated 10.10.2008 (which has been upheld by the Civil Court) cannot be
nullified.
[14]
This Court has considered the materials on record, the
submissions made at the bar and case laws cited by the parties.
[15]
Upon execution of sale deed dated 10.10.2008 in favour of
respondent no. 3 for sale of Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur, the claim of the
respondent no. 3 is that he become the chief of the said village and chiefship
has been transferred along with sale deed. In the circumstances, the D.C.,
Churachandpur issued order dated 23.05.2009 transferring the chiefship from
respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 and the same was challenged by
respondent no. 4 before the Civil Court and the Civil Court decreed that chiefship
cannot be transferred by sale deed. However, the sale deed was upheld by Trial
Court vide order dated 10.10.2008. The operative part of the decree is that
respondent no. 4 borrowed a sum of Rs. 1,30,000/- (Rupees one lakh thirty
thousand) only fro the respondent no. 3. The order dated 23.05.2009
transferring the chiefship from respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 was set
aside as chiefship is non-transferrable. However, in the execution case filed by
respondent no. 3 against the respondent no. 4, vide order dated 28.08.2017
passed by the Executive Court and a sum of Rs. 1,30,000/- (Rupees one lakh
thirty thousand) only was order to be deducted from the salary of respondent
no. 4. It is submitted at the bar that the money has already been deducted.
[16]
By
the
impugned
order
dated
19.02.2014,
the
D.C.,
Churachandpur recognized the respondent no. 3 as chief of the Tuinuphai village,
Churachandpur. In passing the impugned order, the D.C., Churachandpur also
directed to make necessary entry in the land record as sale deed was valid. This
Court is of the opinion that the Civil Court order did not set aside the sale deed
dated 10.10.2008 executed by respondent no. 4 in favour of respondent no. 3
transferring the whole Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur, but the decree set
aside the transfer of the chiefship from respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 by
earlier order dated 23.05.2009 passed by D.C., Churachandpur on the ground
that chiefship is not transferrable. This finding has attained finality and the same
is not open to be agitated before the D.C. Churachandpur or others on
administrative side. If the respondent no. 3 is still aggrieved by the finding of the
Civil Court, the correct course should be to challenge the same on the judicial
side or higher forum or by filing review of the same. The operative portion of the
impugned order dated 19.02.2014 is reproduced herein below:
“Therefore, in suppression of the earlier order issued vide
No. DC(CCP)/Hills/Misc- Case No. 1 of 2014 dated 10-01-2014
regarding Chiefship of Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur SubDivision and from all supporting documents and circumstances
stated above, it hereby order that Shri Letsei Vaiphei is recognized
as the chief of Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur with immediate
effect. The SDO/Churachandpur is directed to make necessary
entry and correction in Touzi records accordingly. However, upon
clarification of the status of land ownership by any competent
authority or upon nullification of SALE DEED bearing No. 2754 of
2008 dated 10-10-2008 which is presently in favour of Shri.
Letsei Vaiphei this order may be reviewed and Order issued
accordingly.”
[17]
This Court is of the opinion that transfer of chiefship from
respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 and/or recognition of respondent no. 3 as
chief of Tuinuphai village, Churachandpur is not opened today in terms of the
earlier decisions of the Civil Courts. Accordingly, the first part of the impugned
order recognizing respondent no. 3 as chief of the Tuinuphai Village,
Churachandpur is set aside and chiefship be determined in terms of the
applicable rules and customary practices. This Court is not able to agree with the
submissions of Mr. HS Paonam, learned sr. counsel for the petitioners that return
of the amount of Rs. 1,30,000/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand) only by
respondent no. 4 to respondent no. 3 in the execution case, will amount to
cancellation of the sale deed dated 10.10.2008. It may be noted that sale deed
has been upheld by Civil Courts. In the conclusion, the writ petition is partly
allowed by setting aside the operative portion of the impugned order dated
19.02.2014 passed by D.C., Churachandpur transferring/recognizing the
chiefship to respondent no. 3, as the same is amounts to review of the order
dated 27.05.2013 passed by Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Churachandpur in O.S. No.
1 of 2010/ 6 of 2011 and affirmed by Ld. District Judge, Manipur West in Civil
Appeal No. 7 of 2013. However, remaining portion of the impugned order is not
disturbed.
[18]
It is made clear that this Court does not express any opinion on
other matter and the issues of chiefship is decided in terms of the applicable
rules and customary practices subject to the conditions that chiefship is not
saleable.
[19]
The W.P. (C) No. 210 of 2015 is disposed of in terms of the earlier
observations. No cost.
JUDGE
Thoiba
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review