Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury
WPA 27705 of 2025
Sri Manas Kumar Sengupta & Anr.
Versus
The Howrah Municipal Corporation & Ors.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Ayan Banerjee
Mr. Suman Banerjee
For the respondent no.5
:
Ms. Shebatee Datta
Ms. Poulami Roy
For the Howrah
Municipality Corporation
:
Mr. Sandipan Banerjee
Mr. Ankit Sureka
Heard on
:
19.01.2026.
Judgment on
:
19.01.2026
Raja Basu Chowdhury, J (Oral):
1. The writ petition has been filed, inter alia, challenging the order
dated 24th November, 2025 whereby the petitioners’ prayer for
regularization dated 23rd April, 2025 has not been considered.
2. The matter has a checkered history.
3. Complaining of illegal construction at the behest of the writ
petitioners in premises No. 87A, Mohiary Road, Jagacha, P.S. –
Jagacha, Howrah – 711112, a writ petition was moved, which was
registered as WPA 25522 of 2023. A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
WPA 27705 of 2025
by order dated 29th July, 2024 by noting the submissions made by
the parties including those made by the writ petitioners herein who
were arrayed as respondent nos. 12 and 13 in such writ petition,
that
the
alleged
construction
that
had
undertaken
without
permission from the Howrah Municipal Corporation, and that the
corporation had already issued a notice dated 15th September, 2023
under the provisions of Section 177(1) of the Howrah Municipal
Corporation Act, 1980 on the respondent nos. 12 and 13 as
aforesaid, had directed the Assistant Engineer, in charge Building
Department of Howrah Municipal Corporation to complete the
proceedings within one month from the date of communication of the
order after giving opportunity of hearing to all concerned.
4. In terms of the aforesaid order the Municipality/Corporation had
held a joint inspection on 21st March, 2025 wherein the following
points were noted:
(1) The building comprising in the captioned holding is now G+3
storied. But sanctioned was accorded for a G+3 building. It
has been observed that the main entrance of the building
lock and key, so the measurement work was done outside of
the building. Deviation on all floors from ground floor to 3rd
floor has been done.
Comparative statement regarding
sanctioned area and unauthorized areas (floor wise) is
appended below.
(2) Constructed area of each floor = 74.865 Sq. m.
WPA 27705 of 2025
(3) Sanctioned area at each floor = 56.828 Sq. m.
(4) Deviated area at each floor = 18.037 Sq. m.
(5) Total unauthorized area more or less 72.148 Sq. m.
(6) Self Demolition Notice has already been issued, but alleged
offender has not complied the Self Demolition Notice by
himself till date.
5.
Following the aforesaid, the Assistant Engineer-in-Charge, Howrah
Municipal Corporation in terms of the order dated 29th July, 2024 by
giving opportunity of hearing to the parties passed an order dated 9 th
April, 2025 thereby directing that the unauthorized construction
being in violation of the Building Rules be demolished within 15 days
from the date of such order.
6. After the aforesaid order was passed, the writ petitioners herein had
applied for regularization of the minor deviation. According to the
writ petitioners herein since, the application for regularization was
kept pending, the writ petition being WPA 10642 of 2025 was filed.
Independent of the above, challenging the demolition notice dated
25th March, 2025 and order dated 9th April, 2025 a writ petition
being WPA 7973 of 2025 was filed. Both the writ petitions came to
be disposed of by a common order whereby a Co-ordinate Bench of
this Court without expressing any opinion on the merits as to
whether the construction is capable of being regularized had directed
the Commissioner of Municipal Corporation to take an independent
WPA 27705 of 2025
decision strictly in accordance with law after affording opportunity of
hearing to the petitioners as well as of other concerned parties.
7. Pursuant to the aforesaid the Assistant Engineer, in charge, Building
Department, Howrah Municipal Corporation had conducted a
hearing on 24th June, 2025 and by once again identifying the extent
of deviation in each floor and noting the total unauthorized area to
be 72.148 Sq.m rejected the prayer made by the petitioner nos. 1
and 2.
8. The aforesaid order was challenged by the writ petitioners by filing a
writ petition which was registered as WPA 19213 of 2025. By an
order dated 3rd September, 2025, a Coordinate Bench of this Court
had remanded the matter back to the Commissioner to decide the
same afresh in accordance with law regarding regularization and in
terms of the earlier order of the Court. Pursuant to the aforesaid
order
the
matter
was
taken
up
for
consideration
by
the
Commissioner, Howrah Municipal Corporation on 24 th November,
2025. The Commissioner, Howrah Municipal Corporation by noting
the inspection report dated 31st October, 2025 had considered the
deviation and following the aforesaid he directed the Howrah
Municipal Corporation to demolish the unauthorized construction of
the petitioners.
9. Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the writ
petitioners would submit that the Commissioner, Howrah Municipal
Corporation did not adhere to the directions of the Court and did not
WPA 27705 of 2025
decide on the application filed by the petitioners for regularization.
According to Mr. Banerjee, the inspection report dated 31st October,
2025 based on which the above order was passed was also not made
over to the petitioners. Accordingly, the above would constitute
violation of principles of natural justice. The order cannot be
sustained and should be set aside.
10. When the matter came up for consideration on 17th December, 2025
this Court by noting that the inspection report had not been
supplied to the petitioners had by the above order directed service of
the inspection report on the petitioners. In terms of the above
direction, the inspection report has been disclosed in the present
case and made over to the advocate for the petitioners. On 9 th
January, 2026 when the matter came up for consideration, having
regard to the disclosures made by the Municipality the advocate for
the petitioners had sought for an adjournment to take appropriate
instruction in the matter. Today Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate
appearing for the petitioners would submit that since the inspection
report had not been supplied before the order was passed, the order
should be set aside and the matter be remanded to the Municipality.
According to him, the prayer for regularization was also not
considered. The order impugned cannot be sustained in law and
should be set aside.
11. Ms. Datta, learned advocate appears for the respondent no.5, while
Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate appears for the Municipality.
WPA 27705 of 2025
12. Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective
parties, I find that though the petitioners had claimed that the
inspection report had not been supplied to the petitioners, a copy of
the inspection report had been made over, pursuant to orders
passed by this Court. The petitioners had not objected to the
contents of the inspection report by filing any exception to the same.
13. To morefully appreciate the relevant inspection report, the same is
extracted hereinbelow:
WPA 27705 of 2025
14. Going through the inspection report, it would transpire that there
are deviations not only in the area of frontal portion but also on the
side and rear portions of the building.
15. Considering the above inspection report it would also transpire that
the inspection was carried out in presence of the writ petitioners and
also in presence of the private respondent. Though the report
records that there has been no additional floor constructed, upon
considering the inspection report it would transpire that the area
otherwise permitted to be constructed at the ground floor was 56.828 Sq.
m. while at the time of inspection the same has turned out to be
72.96 Sq. m.
Therefore, on the basis of arithmetic calculation, the
department has ascertained that there has been an additional
construction of 15.83 Sq. m. in the ground floor itself and the
deviation of the total constructed area upto the third floor, works out
to be 69.69 Sq. m. which is approximately 611 Sq. ft. Therefore an
additional 611 Sq. ft. has been constructed illegally by the
respondents. Although, Mr. Banerjee would like to highlight the fact
that the application for regularization of the deviations has not been
considered at all, however, by noting the provisions of Section 177 of
the Howrah Municipal Act, 1980 (hereinafter referred to as the “said
Act”) it would appear that the power had been conferred on the
Commissioner to regularize certain unauthorized execution of work
to the extent provided therein. To morefully appreciate the aforesaid,
WPA 27705 of 2025
scope of regularization of illegal construction by the Commissioner,
the relevant provision is extracted hereinbelow.
“177. Order of demolition or stoppage of buildings and
works.
(1)Where the erection of any building or the execution of any
work in pursuance thereof has been commenced, or is being
carried on, or has been completed without or contrary to the
sanction or in contravention of any of the provisions of this Act
or the rules and the regulations made thereunder, the
Commissioner may in addition to any other action that may be
taken under this Act, make an order directing that such erection
or work shall be stopped or demolished or such addition or
alteration thereto be made as the Commissioner considers
necessary, by the person at whose instance the erection or the
work has been commenced, or is being carried on, or has been
completed :
Provided that no order under this provision shall be made
unless such person has been given a reasonable opportunity of
being heard in accordance with such procedure as may be
prescribed.
[Provided also that the Commissioner may by order, on such
terms and conditions and on payment of such fees as may be
prescribed by regulations, regularize the minor unauthorized
erection, or execution of any minor work without sanction under
this Act, or minor deviation from the sanctioned plan or
execution of any minor erection or work in contravention of any
sanctioned plan under this Act or the rules or the regulations
made thereunder, as the case may be:
WPA 27705 of 2025
Provided also that the Commissioner may, by order, delegate
his powers and functions under the first and the second proviso
of this sub-section to the Special Officers, appointed by the
Commissioner with the approval of the State Government on
such terms and conditions as may be determined by the
Corporation, and the expenses for payment of such officers shall
be borne on from the Municipal Fund.] [Added by Act No. 33 of
2017, dated 15.9.2017.] ”
16. Going through the 2nd proviso to Section 177 of the said Act, it is
apparent and clear that regularization is only permissible in case of
minor unauthorized construction and/or execution of any minor
work without sanction.
17. In my view, the illegally constructed area of 611 sq. ft. does not
appear
to
be
a
minor
deviation.
As
such
application
for
regularization was rightly not allowed. This apart the petitioners
have also failed to identify how the petitioners were prejudiced in
non-supply of the inspection report when the contents thereof were
not contested by the petitioners. On such grounds, I am not inclined
to remand the matter back to the Municipal Authorities. The writ
petition fails and is accordingly dismissed.
18. There shall be no order as to costs.
19. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be made
available to the parties upon compliance of requisite formalities.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
gb
A.R. (Court)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review