Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
CIVIL EXTRA-ORDINARY JURISDICTION
DATED : 25th May, 2018
---------------------------------------------------------------------D.B.
:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
---------------------------------------------------------------------W.A. No. 01 of 2016
1.
Malvika Foundation
B-II/66, M.C.I.E.,
Delhi – Mathura Road
New Delhi – 110044
Through its Trustee Sh. Suresh Sachdev
2.
Eastern Institute for Integrated
Learning in Management University
8th Mile, Budang, Malabassey,
West Sikkim – 737 121
Through Sh. Suresh Sachdev,
Trustee of sponsoring body
of Appellant No.2
… Appellants.
versus
1.
Human Resource Development Department
Govt. of Sikkim
Tashiling Secretariat
Gangtok.
2.
State of Sikkim
Through Chief Secretary
Govt. of Sikkim
Gangtok, Sikkim.
…
Respondents.
Writ Appeal under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
---------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Ms. Chitra Sharma, Mr. Shakeel Ahmed, Mr. Yogesh Kumar
Sharma and Ms. Zola Megi, Advocates for the Appellants.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with Mr.
Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate, Mr. Santosh Kr.
Chettri, Ms. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocates and
Mr. Bhusan Nepal, Advocate (Legal Retainer, HRDD) for the
Respondents.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
JUDGMENT
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
Impugning
the
Judgment
and
Order
dated
02.11.2016 rendered in WP(C) No.33 of 2015 by the learned
Single Judge, the instant Appeal is filed by the Writ Petitioners
(Appellants herein).
2.
Learned Single Judge, on examination, came to the
conclusion that the notice was issued to the Writ Petitioners/
Appellants herein, on 29.01.2015 and also no prejudice
whatsoever was caused to the Writ Petitioners and as such, the
Writ Petition was dismissed.
3.
The provenance of the lis is that the Appellant No.2-
University came into existence under the provisions of the
Eastern Institute for Integrated Learning in Management
University, Sikkim Act 2006 (hereinafter referred to as EIILM
University Act, 2006).
incorporation,
The Appellant No. 2-University, after
commenced
functioning
as
full-fledged
University located at Jorethang, South Sikkim as notified on
26.05.2006 by the Human Resource Development Department
(HRDD),
Government
Commission
(UGC)
of
Sikkim.
approved
the
The
University
academic
and
Grant
other
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
infrastructure of the Appellant No. 2, on inspection, vide letter
dated 22.07.2008.
4.
It is averred in the pleadings that a suo motu FIR
was lodged against officials of the Appellant No. 2-University
on the allegation of violation of the UGC and other statutory
norms,
on
01.09.2012,
under
provisions
of
Sections
406/420/467/120B/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in
short, IPC) by Sikkim Police at P.S. Jorethang.
The charge-
sheet filed thereon is pending consideration in the file of the
Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, South and West, at Namchi.
A second FIR, being FIR No.92 of 2013, was also registered on
the same grounds at Sadar Police Station against the officials
of the Appellant No.2, which was subsequently quashed on
04.06.2013 in Crl. Misc. Case No.12 of 2013 by the High Court.
The matter was referred to the Enforcement Directorate also
for further investigation and the case was registered under
Sections 420/467/120B of the IPC against the officials of the
Second Appellant and others.
5.
It has come on record that the bank accounts of the
Appellant No.2-University were attached in the process of
investigation. Under this prevailing confusion, it is stated that
a chaotic situation was created, followed by mass resignations
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
and disruption of academic activities. It is further averred that
facing acute financial crisis, the Petitioners/Appellants herein
made a representation to the Directorate of Higher Education,
HRDD,
Government
of
Sikkim
on
08.01.2015,
seeking
indulgence of the HRDD by taking over the University and
making it functional. It appears that several communications
were sent thereafter to the University as final reminder on
12.01.2015, calling upon the Appellant No.2-University to
conduct the examination in time. Subsequently, the Appellant
No. 2-University was served a notice under heading, “Request
for Conduct of Examination” on 29.01.2015, wherein it was
stated that activities of the University has been affected due to
maladministration,
mismanagement, indiscipline, failure in
accomplishment of the objects of the University and economic
hardships in the management of the University. The Appellant
No.2-University was called upon to safeguard the students’
interest and restore discipline in the University, failing which,
the Appellant No.2-University was informed that the State
Government would take necessary action as per Section 47(2)
of the EIILM University Act, 2006.
Responding to the said
communication, Mr. R. P. Sharma, Acting Vice Chancellor of
the University sent an e-mail to the Director, Higher Education
on 31.01.2015, stating that keeping in mind the interest of the
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
students, the University is agreeable for appointment of an
independent person or any person other than Mr. P. C. Rai to
get the examinations conducted.
6.
On 09.02.2015, the Trustee, Malvika Foundation
was called upon to submit details regarding functioning of the
Appellant No.2-University. On not receiving the satisfactory
response to the notice dated 29.01.2015 and further on
examination
of
details
of
requisition
by
the
HRDD
on
09.02.2015, after waiting for a reasonable period of almost
three months, the Cabinet took a decision on 28.04.2015 to
dissolve the Appellant No.2-Univerity, which resulted into
passing of the formal order on 08.05.2015. Calling in question
the legality and validity of the said Cabinet decision as well as
the consequential order dated 08.05.2015, the Writ Petition
was filed on 04.06.2015.
7.
The sole ground of challenge in the Writ Petition as
well as in the Appeal is that the order dated 08.05.2015 of the
Human Resource Development Department, Government of
Sikkim, dissolving the Appellant No. 2-University, is not in
accord with the due procedure prescribed under Section 47 of
the EIILM University Act, 2006.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
8.
The facts as projected by the Appellants are not in
dispute, except that communication dated 09.02.2015 does not
bear proper address for which there is no pleading and as
such,
we
proceed
to
examine
the
applicability
of
the
safeguards prescribed under Section 47 of the EIILM University
Act, 2006, before taking decision to wind up the University.
9.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Senior Government
Advocate appearing for the Respondents, in response, would
contend that the Appellants were noticed on several occasions
about
the
maladministration
University.
The
University
examination,
there
was
and
was
ill-functioning
unable to
indiscipline,
the
of
the
conduct
the
interest
of
the
students was in jeopardy and, as such, they were served a
notice on 29.01.2015 to hold the examination immediately
within fifteen days.
In failure, it was also stated that
necessary action would be taken under provisions of Section
47(2) of the EIILM University Act, 2006.
Moreover, the
Appellants have also not shown any prejudice caused to them.
The State authorities have, on passing the order dated
08.05.2015, admitted the students in other institutions. Prior
to this, the Appellants have also made a request to take over
the institution expressing its difficulty to make the University
functional
on
08.01.2015.
Taking
all
the
facts
into
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
consideration, the Cabinet took the decision to dissolve the
University, which resulted into passing of the order dated
08.05.2015 and there is no prejudice as the Appellants had
sufficient notice.
The Appellants have failed to improve the
administration and conduct examination in time as advised by
the State Government, which necessitated dissolution of the
University in the interest of students’ education.
10.
The question that arises for our considerations is as
to whether the notice dated 29.01.2015 was the show-cause
notice as contemplated under proviso to sub-section 3 of
Section 47 of the EIILM University Act, 2006? If not, whether
non-issuance of notice can be a ground to set aside the
impugned order when no prejudice whatsoever was pleaded to
have been caused to the Appellants/ Writ Petitioners.
11.
To appreciate the lis in its proper perspective, it is
apposite to extract relevant provisions of the EIILM University
Act, 2006 –
“47. (1)
If the Sponsor proposes dissolution of the
University in accordance with the law
governing its constitution or incorporation, it
shall give at least 12 (twelve) months notice in
writing to the State government and it shall
ensure that no new admissions to the
University are accepted during the notice
period.
(2)
On identification of mismanagement, maladministration, in-discipline, failure in the
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
accomplishment of the objects of University
and economic hardships in the management
systems of University, the State Government
would issue directions to the management
system of University. If the directions are not
followed within such time as may be
prescribed, the right to take decision for
winding up of the University would vest in the
State Government.
(3)
The manner of winding up of the University
would be such as may be prescribed by the
State Government in this behalf:
Provided that no such action will be initiated without
affording a reasonable opportunity to show cause to
the Sponsor.
………………………………………………………………………”
12.
On studied examination, it is manifest that Section
47 of the EIILM University Act, 2006 contemplates dissolution
of the University. Sub-Section (2) provides for identification of
mismanagement, maladministration, in-discipline, failure in the
accomplishment of the objects of University and economic
hardships in the management systems of University.
This
provision further contemplates issuance of directions to the
management of the University prescribing the timeline to
rectify the deficiencies before taking a decision for winding up
the University. Proviso to Sub-Section (3) prescribes that no
such
action
be
initiated
without
affording
a
reasonable
opportunity to show cause to the Sponsor. Indisputably, in the
case on hand, the First Respondent is a Sponsor of the
Appellant No.2-University.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
13.
In the case on hand, the Appellants were sent a
communication on 12.01.2015, under caption “final reminder
for conduct of examination”, to conduct the examination
immediately to protect interest of the students as they were
facing a lot of confusion and apprehension about their future.
On bare reading of the communication, it is manifest that the
University was informed earlier by telephonic calls and e-mail
communications to conduct the examinations.
At this stage,
it is apt to refer the representation dated 08.01.2015 made by
the
Appellant
No.2-University
to
the
Director,
Higher
Education, stating clearly that the University is not in a position
to function properly due to financial crisis and also desertion by
the staff. Thus, the Government was requested to take over
the institution in the interest of the society, at large and in the
interest of the students to make it functional.
Eventually, a
notice was issued on 29.01.2015. On careful consideration, it
is evident that the notice indicates the reasons that there is
maladministration, mismanagement, in-discipline, failure in
accomplishment of the objects of the University and economic
hardships in the management and as such, the University was
called upon to conduct the examinations within fifteen days to
safeguard the interest of the students. It is also clearly stated
that in failure or non-compliance, the State Government would
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
take necessary action as per Section 47 of the EIILM University
Act, 2006. This notice is in accord with to the requirements of
Section 47 read with proviso, as it clearly indicates that in
failure, the State Government would take action under Section
47(2) of the EIILM University Act, 2006, i.e. wind up the
University.
14.
Section
mandates
identification
of
mismanagement, maladministration, in-discipline, failure in the
accomplishment of the objects of the University and economic
hardships in the management system of the University.
Thereafter, direction is to be issued to the University to
improve the situation before taking a decision to wind up the
University. It is prescribed under proviso that no such action
be initiated without affording a reasonable opportunity to show
cause.
Notice is well-understood, it means communication
to a person for the purpose of informing something.
Show-
cause, which is contemplated under proviso, means to show
cause a person on stating reasons as to why a particular action
may not be taken against him.
15.
It is well established as a general rule that when a
statute provides for exercise of power in a particular manner
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
then the power has to be exercised only in the said manner.
The Supreme Court in Captain Sube Singh and others v. Lt.
Governor of Delhi and others1 considered this aspect and
held as under: xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 29. In CIT v. Anjum M.H. Ghaswala (2002) 1 SCC 633 a
Constitution Bench of this Court reaffirmed the general rule
that when a statute vests certain power in an authority to
be exercised in a particular manner then the said authority
has to exercise it only in the manner provided in the
statute itself. (See also in this connection Dhanajaya Reddy
v. State of Karnataka (2001) 4 SCC 9) The statute in
question requires the authority to act in accordance with
the rules for variation of the conditions attached to the
permit. In our view, it is not permissible to the State
Government to purport to alter these conditions by issuing
a notification under Section 67(1)(d) read with sub-clause
(i) thereof.”
xxx
16.
xxx
xxx
xxx
On several occasions, the principle of natural justice
was deliberated in many cases by the Supreme Court.
The
Supreme Court laid down broad features to observe principle of
natural justice.
17.
In S. L. Kapoor v. Jagmohan and others2, relied
on by Mr. Shakeel Ahmed, learned Counsel for the Appellants,
the Supreme Court has examined the issue of failure to
observe rules of natural justice and held as under:xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 17. Linked with this question is the question whether the
failure to observe natural justice does at all matter if the
observance of natural justice would have made no
(2004) 6 SCC 440
(1980) 4 SCC 379
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
difference, the admitted or indisputable facts speaking for
themselves. Where on the admitted or indisputable facts
only one conclusion is possible and under the law only one
penalty is permissible, the court may not issue its writ to
compel the observance of natural justice, not because it
approves the non-observance of natural justice but because
courts do not issue futile writs. But it will be a pernicious
principle to apply in other situations where conclusions are
controversial, however, slightly, and penalties are
discretionary.”
xxx
18.
xxx
xxx
xxx
In Olga Tellis and others v. Bombay Municipal
Corporation and others3, cited by Mr. Shakeel Ahmed,
learned Counsel for the Appellants,
the Supreme Court
observed as under:xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 45. It must further be presumed that, while vesting in
the Commissioner the power to act without notice, the
legislature intended that the power should be exercised
sparingly and in cases of urgency which brook no delay. In
all other cases, no departure from the audi alteram partem
rule (“Hear the other side”) could be presumed to have
been intended. Section 314 is so designed as to exclude
the principles of natural justice by way of exception and not
as a general rule. There are situations which demand the
exclusion of the rules of natural justice by reason of diverse
factors like time, place, the apprehended danger and so on.
The ordinary rule which regulates all procedure is that
persons who are likely to be affected by the proposed
action must be afforded an opportunity of being heard as to
why that action should not be taken. The hearing may be
given individually or collectively, depending upon the facts
of each situation. …………………………………………………………”
xxx
19.
xxx
xxx
xxx
Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Senior Government
Advocate for the Respondents, has referred and relied on
observations of Supreme Court in Aligarh Muslim University
(1985) 3 SCC 545
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
and others v.
Mansoor Ali Khan4, wherein it was held as
under:xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 22. In M.C. Mehta [(1999) 6 SCC 237] it was pointed out
that at one time, it was held in Ridge v. Baldwin [1964 AC
40 : (1963) 2 All ER 66 (HL)] that breach of principles of
natural justice was in itself treated as prejudice and that no
other “de facto” prejudice needed to be proved. But, since
then the rigour of the rule has been relaxed not only in
England
but
also
in
our
country.
In S.L.
Kapoor v. Jagmohan[(1980) 4 SCC 379] Chinnappa Reddy,
J. followed Ridge v. Baldwin [1964 AC 40 : (1963) 2 All ER
66 (HL)] and set aside the order of supersession of the New
Delhi Metropolitan Committee rejecting the argument that
there was no prejudice though notice was not given. The
proceedings were quashed on the ground of violation of
principles of natural justice. But even in that case certain
exceptions were laid down to which we shall presently
refer.
23. Chinnappa Reddy, J. in S.L. Kapoor case [(1980) 4
SCC 379] laid down two exceptions (at SCC p. 395)
namely, if upon admitted or indisputable facts only one
conclusion was possible, then in such a case, the principle
that breach of natural justice was in itself prejudice, would
not apply. In other words if no other conclusion was
possible on admitted or indisputable facts, it is not
necessary to quash the order which was passed in violation
of natural justice. Of course, this being an exception, great
care must be taken in applying this exception.
24. The principle that in addition to breach of natural
justice, prejudice must also be proved has been developed
in several cases. In K.L. Tripathi v. State Bank of
India[(1984) 1 SCC 43 : 1984 SCC (L&S) 62] Sabyasachi
Mukharji, J. (as he then was) also laid down the principle
that not mere violation of natural justice but de facto
prejudice (other than non-issue of notice) had to be
proved. It was observed, quoting Wade's Administrative
Law (5th Edn., pp. 472-75), as follows: (SCC p. 58, para
31)
“[I]t is not possible to lay down rigid rules as
to when the principles of natural justice are to apply,
nor as to their scope and extent. … There must also
have been some real prejudice to the complainant;
there is no such thing as a merely technical
infringement of natural justice. The requirements of
natural justice must depend on the facts and
(2000) 7 SCC 529
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
circumstances of the case, the nature of the inquiry,
the rules under which the tribunal is acting, the
subject-matter to be dealt with, and so forth.”
Since then, this Court has consistently applied the principle
of prejudice in several cases. The above ruling and various
other rulings taking the same view have been exhaustively
referred to in State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma [(1996)
3 SCC 364 : 1996 SCC (L&S) 717] . In that case, the
principle of “prejudice” has been further elaborated. The
same principle has been reiterated again in Rajendra
Singh v. State of M.P. [(1996) 5 SCC 460]
25. The “useless formality” theory, it must be noted, is
an exception. Apart from the class of cases of “admitted or
indisputable facts leading only to one conclusion” referred
to above, there has been considerable debate on the
application of that theory in other cases. The divergent
views expressed in regard to this theory have been
elaborately considered by this Court in M.C. Mehta [(1999)
6 SCC 237] referred to above. This Court surveyed the
views expressed in various judgments in England by Lord
Reid, Lord Wilberforce, Lord Woolf, Lord Bingham, Megarry,
J. and Straughton, L.J. etc. in various cases and also views
expressed by leading writers like Profs. Garner, Craig, de
Smith, Wade, D.H. Clark etc. Some of them have said that
orders passed in violation must always be quashed for
otherwise the court will be prejudging the issue. Some
others have said that there is no such absolute rule and
prejudice must be shown. Yet, some others have applied
via media rules. We do not think it necessary in this case to
go deeper into these issues. In the ultimate analysis, it
may depend on the facts of a particular case.”
xxx
20.
xxx
xxx
xxx
While considering scope and ambit of Regulations
6(18) and 6(21) of the Canara Bank Officer Employees’
(Conduct) Regulations, 1976, the Supreme Court in Canara
Bank and others v. Shri Debasis Das and others5
observed as under :xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 12. Residual and crucial question that remains to be
adjudicated is whether principles of natural justice have
AIR 2003 SC 2041
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
been violated; and if so, to what extent any prejudice has
been caused. It may be noted at this juncture that in some
cases it has been observed that where grant of opportunity
in terms of principles of natural justice does not improve
the situation, “useless formality theory” can be pressed into
service.
13. Natural justice is another name for common-sense
justice. Rules of natural justice are not codified canons. But
they are principles ingrained into the conscience of man.
Natural justice is the administration of justice in a
common-sense liberal way. Justice is based substantially on
natural ideals and human values. The administration of
justice is to be freed from the narrow and restricted
considerations which are usually associated with a
formulated law involving linguistic technicalities and
grammatical niceties. It is the substance of justice which
has to determine its form.
14. The expressions “natural justice” and “legal justice”
do not present a watertight classification. It is the
substance of justice which is to be secured by both, and
whenever legal justice fails to achieve this solemn purpose,
natural justice is called in aid of legal justice. Natural
justice relieves legal justice from unnecessary technicality,
grammatical pedantry or logical prevarication. It supplies
the omissions of a formulated law. As Lord Buckmaster
said, no form or procedure should ever be permitted to
exclude the presentation of a litigant's defence.
15. The adherence to principles of natural justice as
recognized by all civilized States is of supreme importance
when a quasi-judicial body embarks on determining
disputes between the parties, or any administrative action
involving civil consequences is in issue. These principles are
well settled. ………………………”
xxx
21.
xxx
xxx
xxx
In P.D. Agrawal v. State Bank of India and
others6, the Supreme Court held as under:xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 30. The principles of natural justice cannot be put in a
straitjacket formula. It must be seen in circumstantial
flexibility. It has separate facets. It has in recent time also
undergone a sea change.
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
(2006) 8 SCC 776
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
39. Decision of this Court in S. L. Kapoor v. Jagmohan
[(1980) 4 SCC 379] whereupon Mr Rao placed strong
reliance to contend that non-observance of principle of
natural justice itself causes prejudice or the same should
not be read “as it causes difficulty of prejudice”, cannot be
said to be applicable in the instant case. The principles of
natural justice, as noticed hereinbefore, have undergone a
sea change. In view of the decisions of this Court in State
Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma [(1996) 3 SCC 364 : 1996
SCC
(L&S)
717]
and Rajendra
Singh v. State
of
M.P. [(1996) 5 SCC 460] the principle of law is that some
real prejudice must have been caused to the complainant.
The Court has shifted from its earlier concept that even a
small violation shall result in the order being rendered a
nullity. To the principle/doctrine of audi alteram partem, a
clear distinction has been laid down between the cases
where there was no hearing at all and the cases where
there was mere technical infringement of the principle. The
Court applies the principles of natural justice having regard
to the fact situation obtaining in each case. It is not applied
in a vacuum without reference to the relevant facts and
circumstances of the case. It is no unruly horse. It cannot
be put in a straitjacket formula. (See Viveka Nand
Sethi v. Chairman, J&K Bank Ltd.[(2005) 5 SCC 337 : 2005
SCC
(L&S)
689]
and State
of
U.P. v. Neeraj
Awasthi [(2006) 1 SCC 667 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 190 : JT
(2006) 1 SC 19] . See also Mohd. Sartaj v. State of
U.P. [(2006) 2 SCC 315 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 295 : (2006) 1
Scale 265] )”
xxx
22.
xxx
xxx
xxx
In A. S. Motors Private Limited v. Union of
India and others7, the Supreme Court further examined the
ambit of rules of natural justice and held as under:xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
“ 8. Rules of natural justice, it is by now fairly well
settled, are not rigid, immutable or embodied rules that
may be capable of being put in straitjacket nor have the
same been so evolved as to apply universally to all kind of
domestic tribunals and enquiries. What the courts in
essence look for in every case where violation of the
principles of natural justice is alleged is whether the
affected party was given reasonable opportunity to present
its case and whether the administrative authority had acted
fairly, impartially and reasonably. The doctrine of audi
alteram partem is thus aimed at striking at arbitrariness
(2013) 100 SCC 114
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
and want of fair play. Judicial pronouncements on the
subject have, therefore, recognised that the demands of
natural justice may be different in different situations
depending upon not only the facts and circumstances of
each case but also on the powers and composition of the
tribunal and the rules and regulations under which it
functions. A court examining a complaint based on violation
of rules of natural justice is entitled to see whether the
aggrieved party had indeed suffered any prejudice on
account of such violation. To that extent there has been a
shift from the earlier thought that even a technical
infringement of the rules is sufficient to vitiate the action.
Judicial pronouncements on the subject are legion. We may
refer to only some of the decisions on the subject which
should in our opinion suffice.”
xxx
23.
Mr.
Shakeel
xxx
xxx
Ahmed,
learned
xxx
Counsel
for
the
Appellants, has referred to a Judgment dated 16.07.2015
rendered by learned Single Judge of the High Court of
Meghalaya
in
CMJ Foundation and Ors.
v. State of
Meghalaya and Ors. [WP (C) No.177/2014], wherein the
High Court, on examination, came to the conclusion that the
State Government has not followed the provisions of CMJ
University Act, 2009; the Meghalaya Private Universities
(Regulation of Establishment and Maintenance of Standards)
Act, 2012, strictly and directed to act fairly in the interest of
justice following principles of natural justice, whereagainst a
Special Leave Petition being SLP (C) No(s). 28831/2016 was
filed by the State Government before the Supreme Court of
India and the same was dismissed on 21.10.2016. The facts
involved therein are not identical to the facts of the instant
case.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
24.
A common thread running through the aforestated
enunciation of law on principles of natural justice, propounds
that Rules of Natural Justice are not codified cannons, which
may be put in a straight jacket. While examining, it is required
to be seen as to whether any prejudice is caused to the party
concerned. The alleged prejudice is needed to be pleaded
specifically. The requirement of natural justice is dependent on
the facts and circumstances of the case. The useless formality
theory be also examined in the facts of the case. In the case
on hand, the appellants have not pleaded any prejudice either
before the writ court or in the appeal. Moreover, the Appellant
No.2-University had sufficient notice and also reasonable time
after 29.01.2015 till a decision was taken by Cabinet on
28.04.2015, to rectify the deficiencies in the administration
and also by conducting the examination. The Appellant No.2University was clearly warned in the show-cause notice dated
29.01.2015 that in failure, the State Government may take a
decision under Section 47(2) of the EIILM University Act, 2006,
i.e. the dissolution or winding up of the University.
25.
On anxious and careful examination of the facts and
legal provisions, we are of the considered view that the
impugned Judgment and Order rendered by learned Single
Judge is just and proper, warranting no interference.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
W.A. No. 01/2016
Malvika Foundation & Anr. vs. Human Resource Development Department & Anr.
26.
Accordingly, the Appeal is dismissed.
27.
No order as to costs.
………………………… CJ.
(Satish K Agnihotri)
…………………………… J.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
May 25, 2018
pm
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review