Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Regular List
Serial No. 52
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
CM Nos. 7617/2023, 5076/2023 & 5737/2024
Date of pronouncement : 27.01.2026
Uploaded on : 29.01.2026
Malika
….Petitioners
Through:-
Mr. Nitin Verma, Advocate.
V/s
UT of J&K & Ors
Through:-
…..Respondents
Ms. Monika Thakur, Assisting Counsel
vice Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG for R-1.
Mr. Karan Singh, Advocate vice
Mr. Vipan Gandotra, Adv for R-2.
Mr. Rajat Gupta, Advocate for R Nos. 3
& 4.
\
CORAM: HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(ORDER)
01.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present
petition, has laid challenge to the select list of primary
teachers issued by respondents No. 3 and 4 in July, 2023.
She has also sought a direction upon respondents No. 2 and 3
to allow her to continue as Primary Teacher (hereinafter to be
referred to as „PRT‟) and not to replace her with another
contractual teacher.
02.
As per case of the petitioner, she had joined
respondent-Maharaja
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
Hari
Singh
DAV
Centenary
Public
School, Akhnoor (hereinafter to be referred to as “respondentSchool”) on 04.04.2014 as PRT. It has been submitted that
the petitioner has to her credit nine years of continuous
service and there has never been any complaint against her
regarding her performance. In March, 2023, respondent No. 4
is stated to have issued an advertisement for the post of PRT to
which the petitioner responded.
She joined her service in
April, 2023 but in July, 2023, a fresh advertisement notice
was issued by respondent No. 4 for the session 2023-2024.
03.
According to the petitioner, she appeared in the
interview before the selection committee but to her utter
surprise, her name did not figure in the select list and she was
kept in waiting list. It has been contended that most of the
candidates in the select list do not possess the requisite
qualification and they have not undergone B.Ed course and
they are not CTET qualified.
The petitioner is stated to have
made a representation to the respondent No. 3 voicing her
grievance about her arbitrary rejection but without any
success.
04.
Respondent No. 1-UT of J&K and respondent No. 2-
Chairman, CBSE have filed their separate replies. Both these
respondents have contended that they are not concerned with
the selection process. They have also contended that the writ
petition against the respondent-School is not maintainable.
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
05.
Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 have filed a joint reply in
which they have raised a preliminary objection with regard to
maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that
relationship between the employees and the administration of
DAV School is contractual in nature and as such, the same
falls within the realm of private law.
Relying upon the
judgment of this Court in the case of Shivali Sharma and Ors
Vs. Army Public School and Ors [WP(C) No. 533/2024]
decided on 22.10.2024, respondents No. 3 and 4 have
submitted
that
that
the
instant
writ
petition
is
not
maintainable.
06.
On merits, respondents’ No. 3 and 4 have submitted
that the petitioner was working on contractual basis with the
respondent-School and her contractual tenure was complete.
It has been submitted that it is the prerogative of the selection
committee to appoint or reject a candidate on the basis of
his/her performance/merit.
Since the petitioner could not
satisfy the selection committee, as such, she was not selected.
It has also been submitted that the petitioner has worked for
nine years but her contractual appointment was never
extended from time to time. In fact, she had applied at the end
of each session and was appointed afresh on contractual
period for each session.
07.
It has been contended that the management has a
right to appoint or reject any candidate and in the absence of
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
any malafides, the petitioner does not have a right to challenge
the selection process.
08.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the record of the case.
09.
Before going to the merits of the case, it would be
necessary to deal with preliminary objection raised by learned
counsel appearing for the respondents with regard to the
maintainability of the petition.
10.
According to the respondents, the respondent-
School is a private institution, which is being run by a Society
and the matters relating to appointment and selection of
staff/teachers is governed by the bye-laws of the Society. It
has been submitted that there is no public law element
involved in the present case, therefore the writ petition against
the respondent-school is not maintainable.
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, on the other
hand, has placed reliance upon the judgment of the Himachal
Pradesh High Court in the case of “Dharmender Kumar Vs.
State of H.P and Ors” (CWP No. 5830 of 2014 decided on
3rd May, 2017) to support his contention that the present writ
petition against the respondent-School is maintainable. It has
been submitted that in similar circumstances, the High Court
of Himachal Pradesh has entertained the writ petition against
DAV School Shimla.
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
12.
It is not in dispute that the relief that is being
sought by the petitioner is primarily against the respondents
No. 3 and 4, who happen to be the Chairman and Principal of
the respondent-School, which is admittedly a private body.
Keeping in view the language of Article 226 of the Constitution,
a private body/institution is also amenable to writ jurisdiction
of the High Court even when it is not State within the meaning
of Article 12.
Respondent-School may not be an authority
under Article 12 of the Constitution but the same is amenable
to writ jurisdiction of the High Court because of wide scope of
Article 226 of the Constitution.
The words “any person or
authority” used in Article 226 of the Constitution not only
includes the statutory authorities and instrumentalities of the
State but it also includes “any person or authority”
performing public duties.
Thus, an action of a person or
authority which falls within the domain of public duty is
amenable to writ jurisdiction of the High court.
13.
The Supreme Court in the case of Andi Mukta
Sadguru Shree Muktajee Vandas Swami Suvarna Jayanti
Mahotsav Smarak Trust Vs. V.R. Rudani, (1989) 2 SCC 691
has discussed the situations in which a writ of mandamus
would lie against a person or an authority which is neither a
State nor an instrumentality of the State in the following
manner:“15. If the rights are purely of a private character no
mandamus can issue. If the management of the college
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
is purely a private body with no public duty
mandamus will not lie. These are two exceptions to
Mandamus. But once these are absent and when the
party has no other equally convenient remedy,
mandamus cannot be denied. It has to be appreciated
that the appellants Trust was managing the affiliated
college to which public money is paid as Government
aid. Public money paid as Government aid plays a
major role in the control, maintenance and working of
educational institutions. The aided institutions like
Government institutions discharge public function by
way of imparting education to students. They are
subject to the rules and regulations of the affiliating
University. Their activities are closely supervised by
the University authorities. Employment in such
institutions, therefore, is not devoid of any public
character. So are the service conditions of the academic
staff. When the University takes a decision regarding
their pay scales, it will be binding on the management.
The service conditions of the academic staff are,
therefore, not purely of a private character. It has
super-added protection by University decisions
creating a legal right-duty relationship between the
staff and the management. When there is existence of
this relationship, mandamus cannot be refused to the
aggrieved party.
***
***
***
***
17. There, however, the prerogative writ of mandamus
is confined only to public authorities to compel
performance of public duty. The 'public authority' for
them means everybody which is created by statute-and whose powers and duties are defined by statue.
So, Government departments, local authorities, police
authorities,
and
statutory
undertakings
and
corporations, are all 'public authorities'. But there is no
such limitation for our High Courts to issue the writ 'in
the nature of mandamus'. Article 226 confers wide
powers on the High Courts to issue writs in the nature
of prerogative writs. This is a striking departure from
the English law. Under Article 226, writs can be
issued to "any person or authority". It can be issued
"for the enforcement of any of the fundamental rights
and for any other purpose.
***
***
***
***
20. The term "authority" used in Article 226, in the
context, must receive a liberal meaning unlike the term
in Article 12. Article 12 is relevant only for the
purpose of enforcement of fundamental rights
under Art. 32. Article 226 confers power on the High
Courts to issue writs for enforcement of the
fundamental rights as well as nonfundamental rights.
The words "Any person or authority" used in Article
226 are, therefore, not to be confined only to statutory
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
authorities and instrumentalities of the State. They
may cover any other person or body performing public
duty. The form of the body concerned is not very much
relevant. What is relevant is the nature of the duty
imposed on the body. The duty must be judged in the
light of positive obligation owed by the person or
authority to the affected party. No matter by what
means the duty is imposed. If a positive obligation
exists mandamus cannot be denied.”
14.
It is, thus, clear that in the aforesaid case, the
Supreme Court has carved out two exceptions to the issuance
of writ of mandamus against a person or body, which is not a
State or its instrumentalities, (i) if the rights are purely of a
private character (ii) if the management of the college is purely
a private body with no public duty, mandamus would not lie.
The guiding factor, therefore, is the nature of duty imposed
upon the person or body against whom writ is being sought.
Thus, if the nature of duty imposed on a body is public in
nature, it is amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226
but if the rights sought to be enforced are purely of a private
character, a writ cannot be issued against such body.
15.
The issue has again be considered by the Supreme
Court in the case of Binny Ltd. Vs. V. Sadasivan, (2005) 6
SCC 657.
Para 32 of the said judgment is relevant to the
context and the same is reproduced as under:
“32. Applying these principles, it can very well be
said that a writ of mandamus can be issued
against a private body which is not a State within
the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and
such body is amenable to the jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution and the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution can
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
exercise judicial review of the action challenged by
a party. But there must be a public law element
and it cannot be exercised to enforce purely private
contracts entered into between the parties.”
16.
Reference may also be made to the observations of
the Supreme Court in the case of K.K. Saksena Vs.
International Commission of Irrigation and Drainage and
Ors, (2015) 4 SCC 67. The same are reproduced as under:
“43. What follows from a minute and careful reading
of the aforesaid judgments of this Court is that if a
person or authority is a 'State' within the meaning
of Article 12 of the Constitution, admittedly a writ
petition under Article 226 would lie against such a
person or body. However, we may add that even in
such cases writ would not lie to enforce private law
rights. There are catena of judgments on this aspect
and it is not necessary to refer to those judgments as
that is the basic principle of judicial review of an
action under the administrative law. Reason is
obvious. Private law is that part of a legal system
which is a part of Common Law that involves
relationships between individuals, such as law of
contract or torts. Therefore, even if writ petition would
be maintainable against an authority, which is 'State'
under Article 12 of the Constitution, before issuing
any writ, particularly writ of mandamus, the Court
has to satisfy that action of such an authority, which
is challenged, is in the domain of public law as
distinguished from private law.”
17.
In St. Mary‟s Education Society and anr Vs.
Rajendra Prasad Bhargava & Ors 2022 SCC Online SC 109,
the Supreme Court while considering the question whether a
writ petition would be maintainable against a private school
affiliated to the Madhya Pradesh State Board observed as
under:
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
“27. The respondent No. 1 herein has laid much
emphasis on the fact that at the time of his
appointment in the school, the same was affiliated to
the Madhya Pradesh State Board. It is his case that at
the relevant point of time the school used to receive
the grant-in-aid from the State Government of Madhya
Pradesh. Later in point of time, the school came to be
affiliated to the CBSE. The argument of the
respondent No. 1 seems to be that as the school is
affiliated to the Central Board i.e. the CBSE, it falls
within the ambit of “State” under Article 12 of the
Constitution. The school is affiliated to the CBSE for
the purpose of imparting elementary education under
the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory
Education Act, 2009 (for short, “Act 2009”). As the
appellant No. 1 is engaged in imparting of education,
it could be said to be performing public functions. To
put it in other words, the appellant No. 1 could be said
to be performing public duty. Even if a body
performing public duty is amenable to the writ
jurisdiction, all its decisions are not subject to judicial
review. Only those decisions which have public
element therein can be judicially reviewed under the
writ jurisdiction. If the action challenged does not
have the public element, a writ of mandamus cannot
be issued as the action could be said to be essentially
of a private character.
***
***
***
***
61. Merely because a writ petition can be maintained
against the private individuals discharging the public
duties and/or public functions, the same should not
be entertained if the enforcement is sought to be
secured under the realm of a private law. It would not
be safe to say that the moment the private institution
is amenable to writ jurisdiction then every dispute
concerning the said private institution is amenable to
writ jurisdiction. It largely depends upon the nature of
the dispute and the enforcement of the right by an
individual against such institution. The right which
purely originates from a private law cannot be
enforced taking aid of the writ jurisdiction irrespective
of the fact that such institution is discharging the
public duties and/or public functions. The scope of the
mandamus is basically limited to an enforcement of
the public duty and, therefore, it is an ardent duty of
the court to find out whether the nature of the duty
comes within the peripheral of the public duty. There
must be a public law element in any action.”
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
18.
In the aforesaid case, the Supreme Court summed
up its conclusion in the following manner:
“68. We may sum up our final conclusions as under:
(a) An application under Article 226 of the Constitution
is maintainable against a person or a body discharging
public duties or public functions. The public duty cast
may be either statutory or otherwise and where it is
otherwise, the body or the person must be shown to owe
that duty or obligation to the public involving the public
law element. Similarly, for ascertaining the discharge of
public function, it must be established that the body or
the person was seeking to achieve the same for the
collective benefit of the public or a section of it and the
authority to do so must be accepted by the public.
(b) Even if it be assumed that an educational institution
is imparting public duty, the act complained of must have
a direct nexus with the discharge of public duty. It is
indisputably a public law action which confers a right
upon the aggrieved to invoke the extraordinary writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 for a prerogative writ.
Individual wrongs or breach of mutual contracts without
having any public element as its integral part cannot be
rectified through a writ petition under Article 226.
Wherever Courts have intervened in their exercise of
jurisdiction under Article 226, either the service
conditions were regulated by the statutory provisions or
the employer had the status of “State” within the
expansive definition under Article 12 or it was found
that the action complained of has public law element.
(c) It must be consequently held that while a body may be
discharging a public function or performing a public duty
and thus its actions becoming amenable to judicial
review by a Constitutional Court, its employees would
not have the right to invoke the powers of the High Court
conferred by Article 226 in respect of matter relating to
service where they are not governed or controlled by the
statutory provisions. An educational institution may
perform myriad functions touching various facets of
public life and in the societal sphere. While such of those
functions as would fall within the domain of a "public
function" or "public duty" be undisputedly open to
challenge and scrutiny under Article 226 of the
Constitution, the actions or decisions taken solely within
the confines of an ordinary contract of service, having no
statutory force or backing, cannot be recognised as being
amenable to challenge under Article 226 of the
Constitution. In the absence of the service conditions
being controlled or governed by statutory provisions, the
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
matter would remain in the realm of an ordinary contract
of service.
(d) Even if it be perceived that imparting education by
private unaided the school is a public duty within the
expanded expression of the term, an employee of a nonteaching staff engaged by the school for the purpose of
its administration or internal management is only an
agency created by it. It is immaterial whether “A” or “B”
is employed by school to discharge that duty. In any
case, the terms of employment of contract between a
school and nonteaching staff cannot and should not be
construed to be an inseparable part of the obligation to
impart education. This is particularly in respect to the
disciplinary proceedings that may be initiated against a
particular employee. It is only where the removal of an
employee of nonteaching staff is regulated by some
statutory provisions, its violation by the employer in
contravention of law may be interfered by the court. But
such interference will be on the ground of breach of law
and not on the basis of interference in discharge of public
duty.
(e) From the pleadings in the original writ petition, it is
apparent that no element of any public law is agitated or
otherwise made out. In other words, the action
challenged has no public element and writ of mandamus
cannot be issued as the action was essentially of a
private character.”
19.
From the foregoing analysis of the legal position, it
comes to the fore that while a private body like respondentSchool would be amenable to writ jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution but the judicial
review of its actions by the High court would be confined to
only those actions which have the element of public duty
whereas, its actions which have the character of private law
rights are not amenable to the writ jurisdiction of the High
court.
20.
In the light of the aforesaid legal position, let us
now analyse the facts of the present case.
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
21.
The petitioner is aggrieved of her non-selection as a
PRT and she is also seeking a writ of mandamus upon the
respondents No. 3 and 4 for her re-engagement as PRT. The
selection of teachers by a private unaided school results in
creating of a contract of service between the school and the
selected teacher. The same is a matter which falls within the
realm of private law. The rights arising in favour of candidates
participating in the selection process are private rights, which
cannot be enforced against an institution which is neither a
State nor an instrumentality of the State by way of a writ
petition.
22.
A coordinate bench of this Court in the case of
Showkat Ahmad Rather and ors Vs. Government of J&K
and Ors [WP(C) No. 2197/2021 decided on 11.10.2022) has
held that a writ petition for enforcement of private contract of
service is not maintainable. Similarly another Single Bench of
this Court in the case of Janak Raj Sharma Vs. D.A.V College
Managing
Committee
and
ors, [WP(C) No. 2747/2024
decided on 13.08.2025] has held that a writ petition against
D.A.V School for enforcement of service related rights is not
maintainable.
23.
In face of aforesaid binding precedents of this
Court, the ratio laid down by the High Court of Himachal
Pradesh in the judgment relied upon by the petitioner cannot
be followed.
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
24.
In the face of aforesaid discussion, the instant
petition is held to be not maintainable. The same is dismissed
accordingly leaving it open to the petitioner to work out
appropriate remedy.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
27.01.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
Naresh Kumar
2026.01.14 20:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
WP(C) No. 2193/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review