Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 19
R
DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.100101 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
MALAPPA
S/O. MARITAMMAPPA AMARSHETTY,
AGE. 80 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. AMMINABHAVI,
TQ. AND DIST. DHARWAD-580 201.
… PETITIONER
(BY SRI. ABHISHEK KALLED, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
M/S. ALLIED BUILDERS,
DIAMOND CORNER,
DESHPANDE NAGAR,
HUBBALLI-580 020,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNER,
MUKHESH HARIJIVANDAS PATADIA,
R/O. ADARSH NAGAR,
HUBBALLI-580 035.
2.
JAKKAVVA W/O. BASAVANEPPA KAMPLI,
AGED ABOUT: 64 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. SANGATIKOPPA, TQ: KALAGHATAGI,
DIST: DHARWAD-581 204.
3.
SAVAKKA W/O. CHANNABASAPPA SULLAD,
AGED ABOUT: 60 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. GANESHPETH, TQ: HUBLI,
DIST: DHARWAD-580 020.
Digitally
signed by
PRAMILA G V
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
-2-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
4.
DYAMAVVA
W/O. BASAVANNEPPA SATYAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 62 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. PUDAKALAKATTI,
TQ. AND DIST: DHARWAD-581 206.
5.
NEELAVVA W/O. BASAPPA BENNI,
AGED ABOUT: 62 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. AKKI ONI, TQ: SAVADATTI,
DIST: BELAGAVI-591 126.
6.
SEEMA W/O. SANJEEV PUJAR,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. MAYUR PARK, YALAKKI SHETTAR ONI,
DHARWAD-580 004.
7.
SANJEEV S/O. HANUMANTHAPPA PUJAR,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC: ADVOCATE,
R/O. MAYUR PARK, YALAKKI SHETTAR ONI,
DHARWAD-580 004.
8.
SHILPA D/O. CHANNABASAPPA SULLAD,
AGE: 41 YEARS, OCC: PRIVATE JOB,
PRESENTLY R/O. SULLAD COMPOUND,
LAMINGTON ROAD, HUBLI-580 020.
9.
SIDDARAMAPPA
S/O. CHANNABASAPPA SULLAD,
AGED ABOUT: 35 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,
PRESENTLY R/O. SULLAD COMPOUND,
LAMINGTON ROAD, HUBLI-580 020.
10. BASAVARAJ S/O. CHANNABASAPPA SULLAD,
AGED ABOUT: 35 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
PRESENTLY R/O. SULLAD COMPOUND,
LAMINGTON ROAD, HUBLI-580 020.
11. ARUN S/O. LAXMANRAO NEELOPANT,
-3-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
AGE: 67 YEARS, OCC: ADVOCATE,
R/O. SRI NIKETANA, 1ST MAIN JAYANAGARA,
DHARWAD-580 001.
… RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ASHOK HARANALLI, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. AMRUTH V. JOIS, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. MALLIKARJUNASWAMY B. HIREMATH,ADVOCATE FOR
R4 AND R5;
SRI. ROSHAN SAHEB CHABBI, ADVOCATE FOR R2, R3,
R6 TO R10;
SMT. KAVITA S. JADHAV, ADVOCATE FOR R11)
THIS CRP IS FILED UNDER SECTION 115 OF THE CODE
OF
CIVIL
PROCEDURE,
PRAYING
TO
SET
ASIDE
THE
IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 22.09.2025 PASSED ON I.A. NO.4
BY THE TRIAL COURT AND CONSEQUENTLY ALLOW THE I.A.
NO.4 IN O.S. NO.319/2025 BY REJECTING THE PLAINT
PENDING ON THE FILE OF II ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL
JUDGE
AND
JMFC,
HUBBALLI
AS
PER
ANNEXURE-F
BY
ALLOWING THE PETITION AND ETC.
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ADMISSION ON 12TH DECEMBER 2025 AND COMING ON
FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED
THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE
-4-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
CAV ORDER
The petitioner is assailing the order rejecting the
application filed under Order VII Rule 11(d) of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (Code). The petitioner contends that the
suit filed before the Senior Civil Judge is not maintainable and
urges that only the Commercial Court constituted under the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (the Act, 2015) is competent to
try the suit.
2.
a)
Put briefly, the suit is:
To declare that the decree dated 23.04.2019 in O.S. No.
2/2009 before the I Additional Senior Civil Judge,
Dharwad is not binding on the plaintiff-firm.
b)
To declare that the transactions, viz., Gift Deeds and
Sale Deeds said to have taken place between defendants
No. 1 to 11 in respect of the suit item No. 1 property,
are not binding upon the plaintiff-firm and the suit
properties.
-5-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
c)
For
Specific
Performance
of
the
contract
dated
05.05.2007 and to direct defendant No. 1 to execute the
registered sale deed in respect of the suit property.
d)
In the alternative, for a refund of the earnest money
along with interest.
e)
In the alternative, to direct the defendants to hand over
possession of the suit properties to the plaintiff-firm for
the development and sale of the suit properties as per
the terms and conditions of the Registered Agreement
for Development and Sale dated 29.03.2008 and the
registered General Power of Attorney dated 28.03.2008.
f)
And for a permanent perpetual injunction against the
defendants, or any person claiming through or under
them, restraining them from changing the nature of the
suit properties in any manner whatsoever.
3.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/
defendant No.1 raised the following contentions:
-6-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
(i)
The plaint refers to an alleged development and sale
agreement between defendant No. 1 and the plaintiff
dated 29.03.2008, which replaced an earlier agreement
for sale dated 05.05.2007 between the parties. One of
the alternative reliefs is to enforce the development and
sale agreement; as such, the dispute is a commercial
dispute.
(ii)
The
registered
28.03.2008
General
enables
Power
the
of
Attorney
power
of
dated
attorney
holder/plaintiff to sell the developed property in terms of
the registered agreement dated 29.03.2008. Since the
transaction is a commercial transaction relating to
construction and development, the suit can be tried only
by the Commercial Court.
4.
Elaborating on the submission, the learned counsel
for the petitioner invited the attention of the Court to Section
2(1)(c), sub-clauses (vi), (vii), and (xi), and the explanation
to the said Section 2(1)(c) of the Act, 2015.
-7-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
5.
In support of the contention, the learned counsel
for the petitioner also relied on the following judgments:
[1]
M/s. Kiran Builders, Bengaluru v. M. Surya
Babu1,
[2]
Sri R.J. Dayananda v. Smt. Narasamma and
others2,.
[3]
Blue Nile Developers Private Limited v. Movva
Chandra Sekhar and Others3.
[4]
Blue Nile Developers Private Limited v. Movva Chandra
Sekhar and Others,4.
[5] Sushil Kumar Agarwal v. Meenakshi Sadhu and Others5,
[6] Aase Ram v. Amit Kumar6,.
6.
The learned Senior counsel appearing for the
contesting respondent defended the impugned order and
submitted that:
2024 (2) KCCR 1256
W.P. No. 28536/2024 (Karnataka High Court)
2021 SCC OnLine AP 3964 (Andhra Pradesh High Court DB)
SLP(C) No. 3819/2022 (Supreme Court of India)
(2019) 2 SCC 241.
Civil Appeal No. 9481/2005 (Supreme Court of India), decided
on 14.07.2025
-8-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
(i)
The dispute raised before the Trial Court does not attract
the provisions of the Act, 2015.
(ii)
The “construction and infrastructure” contracts referred
to in Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015 do not include
agreements of the nature referred to in the suit before
the Trial Court, and the said document cannot be
construed as a construction and infrastructure contract.
(iii)
The suit is one for specific performance of a contract to
enforce the agreement to sell dated 05.05.2007 and not
to enforce the construction and development agreement
dated 29.03.2008, as the relief sought with respect to
the construction and development agreement dated
29.03.2008 is sought in the alternative, and the said
alternative relief is only for possession of the property
and nothing more.
7.
The Court has considered the contentions raised at
the Bar and perused the records.
8.
The Act, 2015 provides for the adjudication of
commercial disputes by a Commercial Court. The expression
-9-
CRP No.100101 of 2025
“commercial dispute” is defined in Section 2(1)(c) of the Act,
2015.
9.
The Trial Court held that the plaintiff sought for
specific performance of contract and alternative relief is only
the relief of possession of the suit schedule property as per
the terms and conditions of the registered agreement for
development and sale dated 29.03.2008 and the General
Power of Attorney dated 28.03.2008. It further held that there
is no dispute as to the agreement dated 29.03.2008 and
consequently rejected the application.
10. The Trial Court is of the view that the plaintiff-firm
has not made any assertion regarding compliance or noncompliance with the terms of the development agreement and
has also not complained of any breach in respect of the terms
and conditions stipulated in the development agreement dated
29.03.2008. The Trial Court observed that any commercial
dispute would commence only if the development agreement
is put into execution.
- 10 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
11. The relevant portion of the alternative relief sought
by the plaintiff reads as under:
“e) .....the Hon'ble Court be pleased to direct the
defendants to hand over the possession of the suit
properties to the plaintiff firm for development
and sale of the suit properties as per terms
and conditions of the Registered Agreement
for Development and Sale dated 29.03.2008
registered vide Doc No. HBL-1-00024-2008-09
stored in CD No. HBLD95 dated 04.04.2008 and
the registered General Power of Attorney dated
28.03.2008 registered vide document No. HBL-400002-2008-09 stored in CD No. HBLD95 dated
01.04.2008.”
(Emphasis supplied)
12.
Thus, the prayer is to direct the defendants to
hand over possession of the suit properties to the plaintiff-firm
for the development and sale of the suit properties as per the
terms
and
conditions
of
the
registered
agreement
for
development and sale dated 29.03.2008 and the registered
General Power of Attorney dated 28.03.2008.
- 11 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
13.
In paragraph No. 11 of the plaint, the plaintiff
extracted Clauses (a) to (p) of the terms and conditions of the
agreement dated 29.03.2008. Said clauses in the agreement,
read with the clauses in the General Power of Attorney, clearly
demonstrate that the plaintiff-firm is enabled to construct a
commercial/residential complex on the property covered
by the said agreement. The plaintiff is also enabled to sell the
developed property after construction, except for a 10,000
square foot built-up area on the 3rd floor. Said 10,000 square
feet, in terms of the agreement dated 29.03.2008, which is
said to be the share of defendant No. 1.
14.
Thus, if the alternative relief is granted, it would
enable the plaintiff to put up construction and develop the
property into a residential/commercial complex and the
plaintiff-firm would be competent to sell the same, except for
the 10,000 square foot built-up area on the 3rd floor.
15.
This being the position, the Court is of the view
that the Trial Court erred in holding that the relief sought by
the plaintiff is only for specific performance of contract and for
possession in the alternative
and does not attract the
- 12 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
provisions of the Act, 2015. The Trial Court did not notice that
the alternative relief of possession is not merely a relief of
possession but a relief to put the plaintiff in possession
pursuant to a registered development and sale agreement,
which enables the plaintiff to develop the property and build a
commercial and residential complex.
16.
The
next
question
is
whether
the
registered
development and sale agreement dated 29.03.2008, read with
the registered General Power of Attorney dated 28.03.2008,
would
fall
under
the
category
of
“construction
and
infrastructure contracts, including tenders,” as defined
under Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015.
17.
The learned Senior counsel appearing for the
respondent/plaintiff urged that the agreement in question
cannot be construed as an “construction and infrastructure
agreement” but is only a construction agreement. It is urged
that to attract Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015, the
agreement must be for the construction and development of
infrastructure.
Since
the
agreement
does
not
fulfil
the
- 13 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
aforementioned requirement, it is urged that the dispute
cannot be termed a commercial dispute.
18.
It is noted that the expressions “construction and
infrastructure,” “construction,” or “infrastructure” are not
defined under the Act, 2015.
19.
forum
The object of the Act, 2015 is to provide a separate
for
the
speedy
adjudication
and
resolution
of
“commercial disputes.” Section 2(1)(c) of the Act, 2015, which
defines
the
expression
“commercial
disputes,”
refers
to
several commercial transactions and contracts. Since the
expression “construction and infrastructure contracts” is not
defined in the Act, 2015, as a normal rule, one must refer to
the dictionary meanings of the terms “construction” and
“infrastructure.”
20.
As per the Oxford Learner's Dictionary the word
“construction” is described as under:
"the process or method of building or making
something, especially roads, buildings, bridges, etc."
- 14 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
21.
As per the Cambridge Dictionary “construction” is
described as under:
"the work of building or making something,
especially buildings, bridges, etc."
22.
As per the Oxford Learner's Dictionary the word
“infrastructure” is described as under:
"the
basic
systems
and
services
that
are
necessary for a country or an organization to run
smoothly, for example buildings, transport and water
and power supplies."
23.
As per the Cambridge Dictionary “infrastructure” is
described as under:
"the
basic
systems
and
services,
such
as
transport and power supplies, that a country or
organization uses in order to work effectively".
24.
It is also relevant to notice in the definition under
Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015, the Parliament has not
used
the
expression
as
"construction
of
infrastructure
contracts, including tenders" but has used the expression as
"construction and infrastructure contracts, including tenders".
- 15 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
Thus, it is evident that the Parliament intended to include the
contracts relating to construction as well as infrastructure.
25.
The contention on behalf of the plaintiff is that the
“construction and infrastructure” contracts referred to in
Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015 should be understood as a
single
expression,
and
the
contract
must
include
both
construction and infrastructure activities to fall under Section
2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015.
26.
The Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High
Court in Blue Nile Developers Private Limited (supra) held
(in paragraph No. 20) that if the expression “construction and
infrastructure” is read as one, it would exclude exclusive
“construction contracts” or “infrastructure contracts” from the
purview of Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015. The Division
Bench held that such an interpretation is not permissible.
27.
The object of the Act, 2015 is to ensure the speedy
resolution of disputes involving commercial transactions. That
being the position, the Court is of the view that if the
expression “construction and infrastructure contracts,
- 16 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
including tenders” in Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015
were considered a single conjunctive expression—meaning the
contract must be for both construction and infrastructure—it
would defeat the object of the Act, 2015.
28.
The Court is of the view that the expression
“construction and infrastructure contracts including tenders””
in Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015 need not necessarily be
read conjunctively; it can also be read disjunctively. In other
words,
the
expression
“construction
and
infrastructure
contracts, including tenders” in Section 2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act,
2015 includes construction contracts, infrastructure contracts,
combined
construction
and
infrastructure
contracts,
and
tenders for either.
29.
As per the terms of the contract dated 29.03.2008,
the developer is enabled to demolish the old building and
construct a commercial/residential complex.
30.
Though the agreement under scrutiny does not
specifically use the word “infrastructure,” for the reasons
discussed above, the Court is of the view that the contract
- 17 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
dated
29.03.2008
for
the
construction
of
a
commercial/residential complex—enabling the developer to
construct and sell the property—does fall under Section
2(1)(c)(vi) of the Act, 2015.
31.
It is noticed that application I.A. No. IV was filed to
reject the plaint by invoking Order VII Rule 11(d) of the Code.
Merely because a suit is filed before the wrong forum, it is not
a ground to reject the plaint. The proper course is to return
the plaint, even though the prayer was for rejection under
Order VII Rule 11.
32.
For the aforementioned reasons, the impugned
order must be set aside.
33.
Hence the following:
ORDER
(i)
The petition is allowed in part.
(ii)
The impugned order dated 22.09.2025 on
the file of II Additional Senior Civil Judge,
Hubballi in I.A.No.IV in O.S.No.319/2025 is
set aside.
- 18 -
CRP No.100101 of 2025
(iii)
The plaint is ordered to be returned to the
plaintiff with a direction to present the
same before the jurisdictional Commercial
Court.
(iv)
The Court fee already paid if sufficient, shall
be
treated as Court fee paid before the
Commercial Court in case the plaint is
presented before the Commercial Court.
(v)
If
the
suit
Commercial
is
presented
Court,
the
before
plaintiff
is
the
also
permitted to make necessary changes in
the new plaint to meet the requirements of
the pleadings in the commercial suit. The
plaint returned to the plaintiff shall be
annexed to the plaint in commercial suit,
for reference.
(vi)
The interim order if any granted by the
Senior Civil Judge will be in force for 20
days from today.
Sd/(ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE)
JUDGE
GVP/CHS.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review