Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 19
TH
DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 16.01.2015 IN W.P.(C)NO.25037
OF 2013 OF THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS 2 TO 4 IN W.P.(C):
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT, ERANHIPALAM P.O.,
KOZHIKODE-673006
COMMISSIONER
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD, ERANHIPALAM P.O., KOZHIKODE673006.
ASSISTANT COMMISSINONER
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD, ERANHIPALAM P.O., KOZHIKODE673006.
BY ADV SRI.R.LAKSHMI NARAYAN
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS AND RESPONDENTS 1,5 AND 6 IN W.P.(C):
K.P.KESAVAN NAMBEESHAN, AGED 36,
S/O.KESAVA NAMBEESHAN, KIZHAKKE PUSHPAGATHU,
TRIKKALANGODU P.O., MANJERI, MALAPPURAM, PIN-676123
V. KIRATHADASAN, AGED 52,
GOPIKA, S/O.V.KRISHNAN, TRIKKALANGODU P.O., MANJERI,
MALAPPURAM, PIN-676123
N. RAMESH EMBRANTHIRI
S/O.SUBRAMANIAN EMBRANTHIRI, THOTTAKKAD MADOM P.O.,
PULPPATTA - 676126
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
UMADEVI BRAHMANIAMMA
W/O.KESAVAN NAMBEESAN, KIZHAKKE PUSHPAGATHU,
TRIKKALANGODU P.O., MANJERI, MALAPPURAM, PIN-676123
V. VIJAYALAKSHMIAMMA,
D/O.C.MADHAVAN NAIR, MARATHODI VEEDU, TRIKKALANGODU
P.O., MANJERI, MALAPPURAM, PIN-676123
K.P. DEVAKI BRAHMANIAMMA
D/O.KESAVA NAMBEESHAN, KIZHAKKE PUSHPAGATHU,
TRIKKALANGODU P.O., MANJERI, MALAPPURAM, PIN-676123
SHANKARAN EMBRANTHIRI
S/O.P.KRISHNAN EMBRANTHIRI, KADATHAMANA (H),
THRIKKALANGODE P.O.,MANJERI, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN676123.
STATE OF KERALA
REP. BY ITS SECRETARY, REVENUE (DEVASWOM),
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN-695001.
THE TRUSTEE
SREE TRIKKALANGODE DEVASWOM, TRIKKALANGODE P.O.,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-676127, REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHAIRMAN.
EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SREE TRIKKALANGODE DEVASWOM, TRIKKALANGODE P.O.,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-676127.
BY ADVS.
J.JULIAN XAVIER
M.P.SREEKRISHNAN
OTHER PRESENT:
SMT. RANJANIE, SC, MDB
SMT. VINITHA B, SR. GP
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 19.03.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
Respondents 2 to 4 in W.P.(C)No.25037 of 2013 have filed
this writ appeal, invoking the provisions under Section 5(i) of the
Kerala High Court Act, 1958, challenging the judgment of the
learned Single Judge dated 16.01.2015 in that writ petition. The
said writ petition was one filed by respondents 1 to 7 herein, who
are the temple employees of Sree Meledath Siva Temple, a
controlled institution under the Malabar Devaswom Board, in
respect of which the 9th respondent herein is the hereditary trustee
and the 10th respondent is the Executive Officer. The petitioners
have filed that writ petition, invoking the writ jurisdiction of this
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking a writ
of mandamus commanding respondents 1 to 4, namely, the State
of Kerala; the Malabar Devaswom Board; the Commissioner,
Malabar Devaswom Board; and the Assistant Commissioner,
Kozhikode to forthwith disburse the arrears of salary as evidenced
by Ext.P6 statement dated nil. They have also sought for a writ of
mandamus commanding the respondents to disburse their full
salary on the day fixed for disbursement of salary. The
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
respondents in that writ petition, i.e., appellants and respondents
8 to 10, have not chosen to file any counter affidavit.
2.
The learned Single Judge, by the impugned judgment
dated 16.01.2015, disposed of the writ petition by directing
respondents 1 to 4 to disburse to the petitioners the arrears of
salary as computed by them, within a period of two months from
the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment and further to
disburse their full salary. Paragraphs 3 to 7 and also the last
paragraph of that judgment read thus;
“3. The facts involved in the writ petition would disclose that
by way of Ext.P3 dated 28.02.2009, the Government has
taken a decision to approve the pay scale of various
categories of employees. It is inter alia contended that the
proposal
of
the
Board
has
been
accepted
by
the
Government in that regard. A circular had been issued by
the 3rd respondent on 18.03.2009 by way of Ext.P4 thereby
indicating that the scale of pay has been fixed with effect
from 01.03.2009.
4. It is stated that on the basis of Ext.P3, the 6th respondent
revised the scale of pay of the petitioners, as evidenced by
Exts.P1 and P2, with effect from 01.03.2009. Petitioners
had submitted a representation before the 2nd respondent,
who, after conducting a study on the matter, took a decision
on
20.09.2012
recommending
the
sub-shrines
as
independent temples in order to get the support of the
management fund. The 3rd respondent had forwarded the
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
recommendation dated 26.09.2012 by way of Ext.P5 to the
1st respondent. According to the petitioner, Ext.P6 evidences
the balance amount due to the petitioners on the basis of
fixation of the pay scale as above mentioned. But so far no
action has been taken by the respondents to effect
payments.
5. Though sufficient opportunity had been granted to the
respondents to file a counter affidavit, no steps had been
taken to file a counter affidavit.
6. Having regard to the factual statement as narrated in the
writ petition and in the absence of any counter affidavit in
this regard, it is clear that the averments in the writ petition
are treated to be admitted. Learned counsel appearing for
respondents 5 and 6 supports the stand taken by the
petitioners.
7. Having regard to the aforesaid submissions and the
factual statement as narrated, it is clear that the petitioners
are entitled to fixation of pay scale and payment of salary
in terms with Exts.P3 and P4, which are liable to be paid.
In the said circumstances, the petitioners are entitled to the
reliefs claimed and accordingly there will be a direction to
respondents 1 to 4 to disburse to the petitioners, the arrears
of the salary as computed by them within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment
and further to disburse the full salary to the petitioners.”
3.
Feeling aggrieved, the Malabar Devaswom Board and
its officials - respondents 2 to 4 in the writ petition are before this
Court in this writ appeal by contending that in view of the
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
Government orders and circulars governing the field respondents
1 to 7 - writ petitioners are not legally entitled to a direction
against the Malabar Devaswom Board for payment of their salary
from the Management Fund maintained by the Board.
4.
This writ appeal is one filed along with C.M.Appl.
No.587 of 2015 for condonation of delay, which was condoned by
the order dated 26.06.2015. The writ appeal was admitted on file.
Respondents 1 to 7 - writ petitioners entered appearance through
counsel and the learned Government Pleader took notice for the
8th respondent. Respondents 9 and 10 entered appearance
through the learned counsel.
5.
On 14.10.2015, when this writ appeal came up for
consideration, the Division Bench noticed the submission made by
the learned Government Pleader that he had instructions to say
that a separate appeal was being filed by the Government. After
recording the said submission, the Division Bench adjourned the
matter, for further consideration of the request of the Malabar
Devaswom Board for a stay of operation of the directions
contained in the impugned judgment.
6.
On 30.10.2015, when this writ appeal came up for
consideration, the Division Bench passed the following order;
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
“1. Received the memo to file.
2. For the time being, the directions contained in the
impugned
judgment
shall
be
complied
with
by
the
Government and the Malabar Devaswom Board. It is clarified
that MDB may proceed to comply with the judgment, even
without waiting for further funds earmarked to satisfy the
impugned judgment. All these will be provisional and subject
to further orders in the writ appeal. In the meanwhile, the
Government is directed to bring the issues raised in this writ
appeal as well to the notice of the Committee constituted as
per G.O.(Rt) No.3483/15/RD dated 23.07.2015. We may also
mention that it will be worthwhile for that Committee to
consider as to whether the grouping and classification of
temples by the Malabar Devaswom Board, as is stated to
have been done, is with due authority. Further, it also needs
to be considered as to whether it is appropriate to have the
classification based on temples as institutions rather than
trustees as the identifying criteria; particular regard being
had to the judgment and different orders referred to in
W.P.(C)No.1763 of 2015.
Two months granted for compliance.”
7.
The order dated 30.10.2015 was followed by the order
dated 24.02.2016, which reads thus;
“The Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board shall file an
affidavit on or before 08.03.2016 after releasing of whole
amounts covered by the impugned judgment and the order
dated 30.10.2015 issued in this writ appeal. Failing that, it
may be noted that this Court may be constrained to pass an
order that no Members of the Malabar Devaswom Board and
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
other
authorities,
including
the
employees
2025:KER:25025
from
Commissioner downwards, would be permitted to draw the
salaries from the month of March, 2016 onwards.”
8.
Heard the learned Standing Counsel for Malabar
Devaswom Board for the appellants, the learned counsel for
respondents 1 to 7 - writ petitioners, the learned Senior
Government Pleader for the 8th respondent and the learned
counsel for respondents 9 and 10.
9.
The issue that requires consideration in this writ appeal
is as to whether any interference is warranted in the impugned
judgment dated 16.01.2015 of the learned Single Judge in
W.P.(C)No.25037 of 2013.
10.
The writ petitioners are the temple employees of Sree
Meledath Siva Temple, which is a C-grade temple, and Sree
Valliyankavu Temple, which is a D-grade temple, which are
controlled
institutions
under
the
management
of
Malabar
Devaswom Board. They have filed the writ petition, seeking the
aforesaid reliefs, mainly relying on Ext.P5 communication dated
26.09.2012 made by the Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom
Board, which is one issued based on Decision No.83 taken by the
Malabar Devaswom Board in its meeting held on 20.09.2012.
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
11.
2025:KER:25025
During the course of arguments, the learned Standing
Counsel for the Malabar Devaswom Board would place reliance on
the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Malabar
Devaswom Board and others v. C. Narayanan Namboothiri
and others [2024:KER:10614].
12.
In Malabar Devaswom Board [2024:KER:10614]
the question raised before a Division Bench of this Court was with
regard to the payment of salary to employees of temples which
are controlled institutions under the Malabar Devaswom Board,
without reference to the income limits as provided in the relevant
Government orders. In the impugned judgment, the learned
Single Judge held that the Government is bound to provide funds
for payment of salary found due to the employees of such temples,
even if the income has exceeded the limits provided in the
Government orders. The Division Bench noticed that the prayer in
the writ petitions was for clearing the salary dues of the temple
employees and also to quash the income limit provided in the
Government orders, including the Government order dated
03.09.2019. Having considered the contentions advanced at the
Bar, the Division Bench found that no grounds have been made
out to justify the challenge raised to the income limit provided in
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
the Government order. The Division Bench noticed that the
commitment
of
the
Government
to
meet
the
financial
requirements for paying the salary of the employees in the
temples which are controlled institutions under the Malabar
Devaswom Board stands substantially met by the provisions made
for establishing a welfare fund and for making payments
therefrom. At least in the case of temples which have income
exceeding
the
prescribed
limit,
it
would
be
the
primary
responsibility of the individual trustees to meet the payments
towards salary of temple employees.
13.
During the course of arguments, it is not in serious
dispute that the payment made by the Malabar Devaswom Board
to the hereditary trustee or trustee board of a temple, which is a
controlled institution under the Board, is subject to the financial
limit fixed by the Government orders, which were in force during
the relevant period. None of such Government orders enable the
writ petitioners in W.P.(C)No.25037 of 2013, who are the temple
employees of Sree Meledath Siva Temple, in which the 9th
respondent is the hereditary trustee and the 10th respondent is
the Executive Officer, to seek a direction against the Malabar
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
Devaswom Board to disburse their arrears of salary shown in
Ext.P6 statement.
14.
In Bihar Eastern Gangetic Fishermen Cooperative
Society Ltd. v. Sipahi Singh [(1977) 4 SCC 145], a ThreeJudge Bench of the Apex Court held that a writ of mandamus can
be granted only in a case where there is a statutory duty imposed
upon the officer concerned and there is a failure on the part of
that officer to discharge the statutory obligation. The chief
function of a writ is to compel performance of public duties
prescribed by statute and to keep subordinate tribunals and
officers exercising public functions within the limit of their
jurisdiction.
15.
In Oriental Bank of Commerce v. Sunder Lal Jain
[(2008) 2 SCC 280] the Apex Court held that in order that a writ
of mandamus may be issued, there must be a legal right with the
party asking for the writ to compel the performance of some
statutory duty cast upon the authorities. In the said decision, the
Apex Court noticed that the principles on which a writ of
mandamus can be issued have been stated in 'The Law of
Extraordinary Legal Remedies' by F. G. Ferris and F. G. Ferris, Jr.
that, mandamus is, subject to the exercise of a sound judicial
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
discretion, the appropriate remedy to enforce a plain, positive,
specific and ministerial duty presently existing and imposed by law
upon officers and others who refuse or neglect to perform such
duty, when there is no other adequate and specific legal remedy
and without which there would be a failure of justice.
16.
In State of U.P. v. Harish Chandra [(1996) 9 SCC
309] the Apex Court held that under the Constitution a
mandamus can be issued by the Court when the applicant
establishes that he has a legal right to performance of legal duty
by the party against whom the mandamus is sought and said right
was subsisting on the date of the petition. The duty that may be
enjoined by mandamus may be one imposed by the Constitution
or a Statute or by Rules or orders having the force of law. But no
mandamus can be issued to direct the Government to refrain from
enforcing the provisions of law or to do something which is
contrary to law.
17.
Viewed in the light of the law laid down in the decisions
referred to supra, in the absence of a legal right with the writ
petitioners to compel the performance of any statutory duty by
the Malabar Devaswom Board, for disbursement of their salary as
per Ext.P6 statement, the writ of mandamus issued by the learned
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
Single Judge commanding respondents 2 to 4, i.e., the Malabar
Devaswom Board and its officials, the appellants herein, or even
the 1st respondent State, the 8th respondent herein, to disburse to
the writ petitioners the arrears of salary as computed by them in
Ext.P6 statement, cannot be sustained in law.
In such circumstances, this writ appeal is allowed by setting
aside the impugned judgment dated 16.01.2015 of the learned
Single Judge in W.P.(C)No.25037 of 2013 and the said writ petition
is dismissed. We make it clear that the payment made by the
Malabar Devaswom Board in terms of the directions contained in
the orders of this Court dated 30.10.2015 and 24.02.2016 in this
writ appeal, in excess of the entitlement of the 9th respondent
hereditary trustee for financial assistance to the temple from the
Malabar Devaswom Employees Management Fund for the relevant
period, in terms of the Government orders governing the field,
shall be repaid by the 9th respondent hereditary trustee through
the 10th respondent Executive Officer. For that purpose, the
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board shall make a demand,
after quantifying
the amount
that
has to
be
repaid, as
expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period of one month
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. In
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
case of any default in repaying the said amount, the Board shall
initiate recovery proceedings, in accordance with law, against the
defaulter.
Sd/-
ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
MIN
W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
2025:KER:25025
APPENDIX OF W.A.NO.1102 OF 2015
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
ANNEXURE A-1
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER
NO.J4-1456/20212/MDB/(1)DATED
6.3.2012
ANNEXURE A-2
A TRUE COPY OF THE
GO(RT)NO.4894/2013/RD DATED
4.9.2013
ANNEXURE A-3
A PHOTOCOPY OF THE LETTER
DATED 28.12.2015
A COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
06.01.2016
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
30.07.2015 IN HRMP
NO.7765/2014/MPM&7501/14 MPM
TRUE COPY OF THE INFORMATION
RECEIVED UNDER RIGHT TO
INFORMATION ACT DATED 2.7.2015
THE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER
DATED 3.3.2016 ISSUED BY THE
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER,
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD,
KOZHIKODE
ANNEXURE A-4
ANNEXURE R(1)(A)
ANNEXURE R(1)(B)
ANNEXURE A-5
ANNEXURE A-6
THE PHOTOCOPY OF THE LETTER
DATED 3.3.2016 ISSUED BY THE
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER,
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD,
KOZHIKODE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review