Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 16th JUNE, 2016
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------D.B. : HON’BLE M R. JUSTICE SUNIL KUM AR SINHA, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE M RS. JUSTICE M EENAKSHI M ADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
M at.App. No.01 of 2015
Appellant
:
Smt. Mala Rai,
W/o Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala,
R/o Chalamt hang,
Pakyong,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala,
S/o Dadhiram Dhamala,
R/o Amba Busty,
Pakyong,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 19(1) of
the Family Courts Act, 1984
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. B. K. Gupta, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) for the Appellant.
Appellant in person.
Mr. Umesh Ranpal and Ms. Kesang Choden Tamang, Advocates
for the Respondent.
Respondent in person.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
J U D GM EN T
M eenakshi M adan Rai, J.
1.
In the instant Appeal, t he Appellant assails the Judgment
and Decree dated 18-04-2015 of t he Learned Judge, Family Court, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, in Family Court (Civil) Case No.83 of 2014, ordering
dissolution of the marriage bet ween the Appellant and t he Respondent
under Section 13(1)(i) of t he Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (for short “ the
Hindu Marriage Act” ).
2.
Advancing his arguments before this Court, Learned
Counsel for t he Appellant put forth the grounds t hat t here are no
independent witnesses to t he alleged adultery claimed to have been
witnessed by t he Respondent and his elder brother, which t hey failed to
either photograph or videograph. That, according to the Respondent,
he was informed by P.W.3, a well-wisher, that he had seen t he Appellant
entering her house along wit h one man at around 10.30 p.m., but the
evidence of this witness is not reliable as before the Learned Family
Court, P.W.3, deposed that earlier he had illicit relations wit h the
Appellant. If such be the case, it cannot be fathomed as to how he
could be the well-wisher of the Respondent. In t he next leg of his
argument, emphasising on the provisions of Order I Rule 10 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “ CPC” ), it was contended that D.W.3,
alleged to be in an adulterous relationship with the Appellant, is a
necessary and proper party to the proceedings, but was not impleaded
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
as a party on which ground alone, the impugned Judgment and Decree
of t he Learned Family Court is liable to be set aside. To fortify t his
submission, reliance was placed on the decision of the Hon’ble High
Court of Andhra Pradesh in Smt. Ch. Padmavathi vs. Ch. Sai Babu, F.C.A.
No.21 of 2009 dated 12-09-2012, wherein it was, int er alia, held t hat, the
alleged adulterer will be a proper party to a proceeding under Section
13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act.
3.
It was urged that t he Learned Family Court had also
wrongly observed that
there are sat isfactory and convincing
circumstantial evidence as well as direct evidence of the Appellant
having extra marital relations with ot her persons and indulging in illicit
sexual relationship with them, when to the contrary, t he Respondent
lives in adultery with anot her lady. That, t he Respondent had earlier
filed a Petition for Divorce on grounds of “ Cruelty” , but as the matter
was dismissed on 26-03-2013, the instant matter was filed subsequently
reflecting an ulterior motive and mala fide intention. It is prayed that
the impugned Judgment and the resultant Decree, dated 18-04-2015 be
set aside.
4.
Per cont ra, the arguments put forth by Learned counsel for
the Respondent is that, in the first instance there is no shortcoming in
the impugned Judgment of the Learned Family Court which has made
its decision after analysing the evidence on record. In the next limb of
his argument, it was expostulated that although Order I Rule 10 of the
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
CPC requires that the Court at any stage of the proceedings may strike
out or add any person as a Plaintiff or Defendant to effectually and
completely adjudicate the matter but one cannot lose sight of t he
mandatory provision of Order I Rule 13 of t he CPC, which requires that
all objections on grounds of non-joinder or misjoinder of parties shall be
taken at t he earliest possible opportunity. The Appellant cannot be
heard to say belatedly, at t he stage of Appeal, that the alleged adulterer
ought to have been added as a necessary party. That, therefore, in view
of the lack of substance in the Appeal, the same be dismissed.
5.
We have heard the rival arguments of Learned Counsel at
lengt h and given due and anxious consideration to the same. We have
also carefully perused all relevant documents on record including the
evidence and the impugned Judgment.
6.
In order to assess the matter in its correct perspective, it
would be necessary to first consider the averments made by the parties
before the Learned Family Court. According to the Respondent, he was
married to the Appellant in the year 1999, according to customs
prevalent amongst t he Nepali Hindu Community and from the wedlock,
they have two children, i.e., one son aged about 11 years and one
daughter aged about 8 years.
The parties lived together at Pakyong,
East Sikkim, in the Respondent’s house after their marriage, where he
was working as a Range Officer in the Forest Department. For some
time they had good matrimonial relations, but with the passage of time,
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
the Appellant started picking up quarrels on trivial issues and harassing
him mentally as well as physically. Admittedly a Petition for Divorce on
grounds of ‘Cruelty’ was filed previously but was dismissed on failure to
establish cruelty.
After such dismissal, the Appellant’s behaviour
towards him deteriorated and the Appellant started indulging in illicit
relations wit h other men, of which, he alleges, was one man from
Rhenock. That apart, she was missing from their home from 03-07-2014
when he was on dut y, which he learnt of on 11-07-2014 and come to
know that she was out with another person wit h whom she had illicit
relations and returned on 14-07-2014. Following this incident, on 17-072014 when the Respondent had gone for dinner to the house of his
Superior Officer in Pakyong, he was informed by P.W.3, that the
Appellant was seen entering her house wit h one man at around 10.30
p.m. The Respondent immediately called his brot her P.W.2, who resides
at Amba Busty, Pakyong and both of t hem reached the Respondent’s
home at around 11.40 p.m., where they saw t he Appellant and D.W.3 in a
room inside the house of the Appellant, having sexual intercourse. On
repeated knocking, the Appellant opened the door after 10 minutes,
where D.W.3 was hiding in a corner of the room. It was alleged that
both admit ted their illicit relations and t he act of adultery. That, in view
of the said act, t he marriage has broken down irretrievably and hence,
the prayer for divorce.
7.
The Appellant to the contrary, int er alia, averred that on 17-
07-2004, the Respondent, his brother and sister-in-law came to their
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
matrimonial house at around 10 p.m. and suddenly started assaulting
her wit h kicks and blows in front of her visitors. Her contention is t hat
D.W.3 is a neighbour and a distant brother from her mot her’s side and
on the relevant day after parking his vehicle at around 9.30 p.m., in the
common compound, he had sought shelter her house as it was raining
heavily. She denies that such an incident, as alleged, ever occurred with
D.W.3 and that photographs allegedly taken in her house have been
manufactured by the Respondent.
She denied all allegations of
adultery.
8.
The Learned Family Court after hearing the parties, framed
the following issues;
(i)
Whether after t he solemnization of their marriage,
the respondent had voluntarily (sic, volunt ary)
sexual intercourse with any persons other t han her
spouse.
(ii)
Whether the Petitioner is entit led to a decree of
divorce.
9.
After the parties led evidence, the Learned Family Court on
analysing the same decided both issues in favour of t he Respondent and
decreed the marriage between the Appellant and the Respondent as
dissolved.
10.
The question that arises for determination before this
Court is whet her t he Learned Family Court was correct in granting the
divorce to the Appellant based on the evidence placed before it.
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
11.
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
In this regard, we may go t hrough t he relevant provisions
of Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, which reads as follows:“13. Divorce.— (1) Any marriage solemnized, whether
before or after the commencement of this Act, may, on a
petition presented by either the husband or the wife, be
dissolved by a decree of divorce on the ground that the other
party—
(i)
has, after the solemnisation of the marriage,
had voluntary sexual intercourse with any
person other than his or her spouse; or
…………………………………………………..”
Therefore, for divorce t o be granted under Section 13(1)(i) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, voluntary intercourse by the spouse with a third
person has to be proved by the person seeking the relief.
12.
However, in const ruing t he provisions of Sect ion 13 of t he
Hindu Marriage Act one has t o remember t hat divorce is not generally
favoured or encouraged by t he Court s and is permit t ed only for very
serious and grave reasons. [ See Swarajya Lakshmi vs. Dr. G. G. Padma Rao : (1974) 1
SCC 58]
While at t he same time it must be borne in mind that in
allegations of adultery law does not postulate direct proof of adultery,
the assumption of which is to be drawn from t he conduct of the parties
and the evidence on record.
Therefore, the accepted rule is that
circumstantial evidence can normally be expected in proof of the
allegation, the general rule being that t he circumstances should be such
as would lead a reasonable and just man to the conclusion of adultery.
It is also essential t o mention here that such proof does not extend to
one which is beyond reasonable doubt, but is sufficient if there is a
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
preponderance of probability. [ Vide Dr. N. G. Dast ane vs. Mrs. S. Dast ane : AIR
1975 SC1534 and Subbarama Reddiar vs. Saraswat hi Ammal : AIR 1967 Madras 85]
13.
On the anvil of the principles enumerated above, we now
turn to analyse as t o whether the evidence on record proves that t he
Appellant had indulged in adultery.
14.
While going through the evidence of D.W.1, the Appellant,
she has specifically denied having any relation with D.W.3. On t he ot her
hand, the evidence of P.W.1, the Respondent, is to the effect t hat on 1707-2014, while he was having dinner with his Senior Officer at Pakyong,
he received a telephonic call from P.W.3 informing him t hat, he had seen
the Appellant entering her home with one man at around 10.30 p.m.
The Respondent informed his elder brother P.W.2, who accompanied
him to the house where they both witnessed the Appellant engaged in
sexual intercourse wit h D.W.3.
He also added that the Appellant
accepted and admitted the act of adultery and having illicit relations
with D.W.3.
His evidence has not been demolished under cross-
examination, but is duly supported by the evidence of P.W.2, his elder
brother, who is a Teacher by profession at Takshang Government
Primary School, East Sikkim. According to him, on 17-03-2014 at around
10.30 p.m. he received a telephonic call from t he Respondent. He
accompanied his brother to the Respondent’s house where they found
the room was locked from inside and from the ventilation they saw the
Appellant and D.W.3 engaged in sexual intercourse. P.W.3 is the person
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
who admits to having previously had extra marital relations with the
Appellant when she was married to the Respondent and admits that
they had physical relationship. According t o him, the Appellant also had
relations wit h another person after him. This witness is the one who
saw D.W.3 entering the home of the Respondent on 17-07-2014 on which
he informed the Respondent immediately, t his evidence has withstood
the cross-examination. On this aspect, it was pointed out by Counsel for
the Appellant that in such circumstances it would be impossible to
agree that P.W.3 was a well-wisher of the Respondent. We do not find
any force in this argument since it is for Respondent to decide who his
well-wisher is.
D.W.3 is the alleged adulterer who states that as he
shares a common compound wit h the Appellant, he parked his vehicle
and went into t he house of the Appellant due to the heavy rain along
with a friend of his. Inside the house, when they were about to settle
down, all of a sudden P.W.1 and P.W.2 as well as the sister-in-law of
P.W.1, entered the house and assaulted the Appellant in their presence.
Alt hough he stated that he had entered the house of the Appellant wit h
“ one friend” , neither t he identity of t he person has been disclosed nor
has the Appellant herself stated that any ot her person had entered her
house along wit h D.W.3. Both P.W.1 and P.W.2 have made no mention
of a third person, therefore, this statement of D.W.3 has to be taken
with a pinch of salt. Also what is incongruous is, admittedly he shared a
common compound with the Appellant t hen the question arises as to
why he would take refuge from t he rain in the house of the Appellant
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
instead of going into his own house, after parking his car.
The
contention of the Appellant that D.W.3 is a distant brother of the
Appellant can also be safely ruled out being improbable as D.W.3
himself has deposed that he has known the Appellant only for the last
10-12 years apart from which he is unable to name t he parents or
brothers of D.W.1.
15.
On traversing the law points of the matter, Order I Rule 10
of the CPC clothes t he Court with power to add any person as a party at
any stage of the proceedings to enable t he Court to effectively and
completely adjudicate upon all issues involved. Thus, all necessary and
proper parties can be added by the Court at any stage of the
proceedings. The spirit behind impleading an adulterer as a party is to
allow him an opportunity to defend himself against the allegations
levelled and to vindicate himself. In the instant matter, the person who
is alleged to have commit ted the adultery, i.e., D.W.3, has already been
examined as a witness giving him sufficient opportunity to extenuate
himself against the allegations foisted upon him. However, he has not
been able to demolish the case of the Respondent, despite sufficient
opportunity extended to him during his deposition. In such a situation,
we are of t he considered opinion that it would serve no purpose to
implead him as a party to the proceeding. The involvement of a second
person also as an adulterer was not st rongly pressed by the Respondent
and, therefore, we find that it is not essential to implead him. That
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
apart, we may set out the provisions of Order I Rule 13 of the CPC which
mandates as follows;
“I. Who may be joined as Plaintiffs.− ……..
……………………………………………….…
13.
Objections
as
to
non-joinder
or
misjoinder.−All objections on the ground of non-joinder
or misjoinder of parties shall be taken at the earliest
possible opportunity and, in all cases where issues are
settled, at or before such settlement, unless the ground
of objection has subsequently arisen, and any such
objection not so taken shall be deemed to have been
waived.”
16.
On this point, it has to be stated that the prayer for
impleadment is indeed belated, and it is not the Appellant’s case that
she was unable to agitate the point of impleadment as the ground arose
subsequently, in which event even the provisions supra cuts some slack.
17.
In view of the evidence on record which has been
discussed hereinabove, there is no reason t o doubt t hat the Appellant
was in an adulterous relationship with D.W.3. It is t hus apparent t hat
the findings of the Learned Family Court warrant no interference.
18.
In the result, the Appeal is dismissed. Decree be drawn
accordingly.
19.
Copy of this Judgment and Decree be sent to t he Learned
Family Court for information.
20.
fort hwit h.
Records of the Learned Family Court be remitted
Mat.App. No.01 of 2015
Smt. M ala Rai
vs.
( M eenakshi M adan Rai )
Judge
16-06-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
Shri Bal Krishna Dhamala
( Sunil Kumar Sinha )
Chief Justice
16-06-2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review